More Jobs Added, Past Months Revised Up

The economy added 165,000 jobs last month and the estimate for the previous two months were revised up:

WASHINGTON — U.S. employers added 165,000 jobs in April, and hiring was much stronger in the previous two months than the government first estimated. The job increases helped reduce the unemployment rate from 7.6 percent to a four-year low of 7.5 percent.

The report Friday from the Labor Department was a reassuring sign that the U.S. job market is improving despite higher taxes and government spending cuts that took effect this year.

The only sectors of the economy that cut jobs last month were construction and government

The government revised up its estimate of job gains in February and March by a combined 114,000. It now says employers added 332,000 jobs in February and 138,000 in March. The economy has created an average of 208,000 jobs a month from November through April — above the 138,000 added in the previous six months.

An additional 210,000 people started looking for work in April, and many of them found jobs.

Well, good. Now all we need to do is keep it up at that pace every single month over the period of the next ten years.

4 comments

The Changing Video Landscape

Without looking it up, which company is the leader in the video rental business? The best answer may be that nobody really knows.

It’s possible that Redbox, which puts kiosks from which customers can rent DVDs in grocery stores and malls, may be the leader. Redbox has something like 42 million customers. In 2012 it had revenues of about $2 billion and net income of around $100 million. And they said that DVDs were dead.

By comparison NetFlix, the clear leader in streaming, has 32 million customers and had 2012 revenues of $3.6 billion with net income of $17 million.

Other players in the streaming business include Amazon, Hulu.com (3 million customers, revenues just under $700 million, net income ?). No one outside of Amazon knows for sure how much income the company is generating through video streaming and Amazon isn’t telling. Amazon Prime probably has 10 million customers in its subscription service.

Hulu.com is a joint venture, owned in roughly equal shares by Disney (ABC), News Corp. (Fox), and Comcast (NBC). Comcast has about 24 million cable customers with about $62.5 billion in revenue and net income of $6 billion. It has its own streaming service, Xfinity. Yes, Comcast is in competition with itself.

As of May 3 more than 1,700 movies and television programs from the archives of Warner Brothers, MGM, and Universal will be removed from NetFlix’s streaming service. Warners now has its own “Instant Warner Archive”, a subscription service, and, presumably, the content no longer available from NetFlix will eventually become available there. But it isn’t now. My reading of the site may be wrong but there presently appear to be under 300 titles there. There’s a price point at which their service might be attractive. Ten bucks a month ain’t it. If they were to offer the entire archive, say, from 1920 to 1960, I might consider it but I won’t subscribe at that price point for the opportunity to watch Temple Houston. Not a chance.

The video landscape that’s now emerging is one of the media giants belatedly getting into the streaming business and trying to make life hard for the streaming industry leader and the Internet retail giant. I doubt that they will be successful. ABC, NBC, Fox, and so on are unaccustomed to selling directly to end users or, indeed, in operating in a competitive market. Until relatively recently Hulu.com’s user interface was pathetically bad and its reliability iffy.

There’s more to attracting customers and keeping them than just having the content. You’ve got to make the process of shopping easy and appealing to use and that’s something the media giants have little experience with, and, judging by Hulu.com, don’t care very much about. They may succeed in discouraging NetFlix users with NetFlix’s dwindling streaming library but that won’t necessarily attract those customers to their own competing services.

5 comments

My Cluttered Video Environment

While preparing a post on what I see emerging in the video marketplace, it occurred to me that I’ve never really described my amazingly cluttered video environment and how that might be relevant.

I don’t know whether our video environment here at Chez Schuler is typical, exceedingly simple, absurdly complicated, cutting edge, behind the times, or all of the above in varying degrees. At one time or another we view each of the following: cable, cable on demand, Internet live streaming, Internet streaming on demand, DVD, videotape, video from device (camera, flash drive, etc.). The only time we view actual broadcast television is when we’re somewhere other than at home.

Several years back we put an addition on the house. Every room (other than the bathrooms) in the addition has both coax connections and wired network connections. We have a single wired network connection on the old side of the house plus wireless connectivity everywhere, both from our own wireless network and from the phone company’s wireless network.

We have three televisions, all LCD, all capable of high definition (two at 1080p, one at 720p). Two of the televisions have cable connections, the third does not. All three televisions have DVD players connected to them, one has a VCR connected to it, and one has a BluRay player. The BluRay player provides Internet connectivity and supports NetFlix, Amazon Instant Video, Hulu, and a few others. The other two televisions have Roku boxes connected to them which provide all of those channels plus many more.

One television has a Wii connected to it. Another has a Wii-U connected to it. Both provide Internet connectivity. Neither browser supports flash. The Wii-U supports Netflix, Hulu Plus, Amazon Instant Video, and YouTube.

In addition to our televisions we can also stream video on two personal computers, two notebook computers (more, actually: only two are presently commissioned), two tablets (one Android, one iPad), and two smartphones (both Android). When you include the game console of the Wii-U that means that at least in principle twelve people could watch different things at the same time here. More if they brought their own viewing devices.

We subscribe to cable, NetFlix, Amazon Prime, Hulu, and Acorn Television.

I also have a Plex Media Server installed on one of our personal computers. In theory it allows us to view anything that’s online from any site that has a Plex channel via our Rokus or BluRay player. In practice it’s not appropriate for anybody who’s not very tech-savvy, it’s extremely rough around the edges, and frustrating in a way that things that aren’t ready for primetime can be frustrating. But when it works it’s wonderful.

2 comments

The Country

Somewhere there is a country that has two factions. One of the factions is large, comprising most of the people. The other faction is small. The positions of the larger faction are based on facts, reason, and compassion. Every belief of the smaller faction is motivated by gain, politics, and outright hatred. The smaller faction holds undue power, illegally and immorally.

The larger faction loves the chief executive because of the content of his character. The smaller faction hates him because of the color of his skin. Their hatred is so great that they will even oppose things that they’ve supported simply because the chief executive likes them.

Somewhere there is such a country. This is not that country. I do believe, however, that this is the country of Paul Krugman’s and his supporters’ imagination and it is that imagination that Clive Crook criticizes in his recent column:

A line has been crossed when the principal spokesmen for contending opinions have no curiosity whatsoever about their opponents’ ideas and radiate cold, steady contempt for each other. That’s dangerous. Civil society depends on a minimum threshold of tolerance and mutual respect. Fall too far below it, and the seething paralysis you see in Washington could soon be the least of your concerns. This is America’s biggest political problem — and Krugman’s not part of the solution.

Meanwhile, for the side that thinks it has the better arguments, naked contempt for dissenters is plain bad tactics. That isn’t how you change people’s minds. Better to fire up the base with a little demagoguery (such as calling conservatives racist, as Krugman is wont to do) than reach out to the uncommitted? I don’t think so. The enthusiasm you inspire on your side is canceled out by an equal and opposite reaction on the other. Krugman stirs up the right in much the same way that Rush Limbaugh, for instance, inflames the left. Granted, if you’re going to have a spokesman, better a Nobel laureate than a talk-radio clown. The fact remains that Krugman’s weary disdain for roughly half the country is self-defeating.

Really, I just wish he’d meet a wider range of people. It’s true that the modern Republican Party includes a growing number of extremists who have no interest in the kind of discussion I’m recommending. In their case, attempts at outreach would be so much wasted breath. But if Krugman got out of his bubble a bit more, he’d find that the other half of the country contains no more than its fair share of knaves, fools and lunatics — and a lot of thoughtful, public-spirited Americans whose views on the proper scale and scope of government are different from his, yet worthy of respect.

Let me give just two examples of that view of the country in operation: the ARRA fiscal stimulus package and the recent gun control legislation that failed in the Congress.

According to that view a large enough stimulus package would have jolted the country out of the economic doldrums in which we’ve settled, Democrats championed a much larger fiscal stimulus, a larger stimulus wasn’t enacted solely because Republicans opposed it, Republicans opposed it solely because they hate Barack Obama, and they hate Barack Obama solely because he’s black.

That view assumes far too much, is empirically suspect, and drastically over-simplified.

There are good theoretical reasons to think that all other things being equal a fiscal stimulus with the right size, timing, and construction could have that effect. Unfortunately, in the real world things are never equal and, especially in a liberal democracy, no bill enacted into law ever has or will have the right size, timing, or construction. That includes the ARRA. The empirical evidence that the stimulus packages that actually get enacted into law have the desired effect is to say the least ambiguous.

Democrats never championed a larger stimulus package. That is a lie. You will search in vain for any public statement by a White House official that they did. They may have privately supported one, it might have been talked about casually among the president’s White House economic advisors, but, at least according to the best evidence we have, such a bill was never seriously entertained. The largest bill that Democrats would pass was the one that got enacted into law. Any reasonable reading of the actual bill suggests it was not properly timed, its implementation spread out over too long a period, and too much of it consisted of projects that were too much a Democratic political wishlist, payoffs to constituencies, contributors, bundlers, and so on.

It might be true that every single Republican hated Barack Obama and voted against the ARRA for that reason alone. I doubt it but I can’t read their hearts or minds. The Greeks had a word for it. Frene, I think.

With respect to the recent gun control legislation, its advocates proclaim that 90% of the American people supported it and the Republicans prevented it from passing nonetheless, presumably because of their hatred of Barack Obama or their love of the NRA. There is some evidence that 90% of Americans support universal background checks for purchasing firearms. It’s possible that was just a snapshot. I know of no evidence that even a simple majority of Americans supported everything that was in the actual bill that failed to be enacted.

It might also be true that every single Congressional Republicans continues to hate Barack Obama and refused to vote for the bill solely for that reason. Again, I can’t read their hearts or minds. I don’t think you need to resort to that explanation. Constituent service is probably enough.

I think the real United States is actually quite a bit different from that imaginary country. It has two major political parties consisting of many, many more factions than just two but for simplicity let’s say the country has three approximately equal-sized factions. One of the those factions consists of yellow dog Democrats who will vote for anybody with a D next to their name, another Republican equivalent of that group, and a third faction whose members may lean one way or another but have no permanent loyalty to either side.

Either Democrats or Republicans will leap on science and evidence that supports their preconceived views and reject the science or evidence that contradicts those views.

Both Democratic and Republican politicians have one overwhelming, dominating priority: election or re-election. They may have other values as well but their hierarchy of values is such that those are lost in the drive to achieve and retain office.

I doubt that either Democrats or Republicans know or care much about President Obama’s character. I think they’re both acutely aware of his race which I find rather sad. I wish that the president, his advisors, and supporters did not feel the need to go out of their way to alienate those who disagree with them. Like Mr. Crook, I don’t think it’s healthy for a liberal democracy or productive of the sorts of agreements we need to reach for our society to work.

26 comments

The Alternative Law School Rankings

For some years now law school prof Glenn Reynolds has been banging the drum on the disconnect among law school enrollments, the cost of attending law school, and the prospects for actually getting a job as a lawyer once you’ve graduated. At Above the Law (hat tip: Glenn Reynolds) they have produced an interesting ranking of the top 50 law schools based, rather than on the inputs to the law school, e.g. entering LSATs, GPAs, etc., the outputs of the law school, e.g. jobs in law, alumni satisfaction, etc. There are some overlaps between the conventional published law school rankings and some interesting deviations.

If you don’t graduate from one of their top three law schools (Yale, Stanford, Harvard), prospects for getting a job in law drop sharply. Prospects for working the law dwindle through the next ten schools (#13 is Northwestern) and drop sharply again. If you graduate from #14 (University of Texas at Austin), your prospects for getting a job as a lawyer drop to only 60.67%. It’s downhill from there through the remainder of the top 50 schools in their rankings. The prospects for getting a job as a lawyer if you graduate from at their 50th-ranked school, the Sandra Day O’Connor School of Law the Arizona State, is only 36.83%.

Now, I suppose it could be maintained that a law school education is useful for all sorts of other things, for example, as a preparation for a career in business or finance. Pretty expensive way of preparing for a career in business or finance. It’s even more expensive if the best you can expect is shouting out of a loudspeaker mounted in a clown’s mouth.

5 comments

Planting Seeds

Last weekend we planted seeds in our garden and in trays that will be transplanted to our garden when they sprout, something we haven’t done in a very long time.

I don’t grow vegetables. They take too much care, they attract vermin. I grow herbs. At one point I had more than 50 varieties of herbs in my backyard garden but they finally succumbed to the successive onslaughts of dogs and home remodeling. We’ve now got a little fenced-in dog-free area and we’re growing herbs in it.

Last year we planted seedlings: sage, basil, lovage, tarragon, marjoram, oregano, rosemary, thyme, lemon thyme, sorrel, a few others. The sage, lovage, sorrel, oregano, thyme, and lemon thyme survived the winter well. We have been able to treat ourselves to one of the great joys of spring: soupe santé, essentially leek and potato soup with sorrel, flavored with our own fresh sorrel and thyme. The tender perennials, rosemary, tarragon, and marjoram, didn’t fare as well.

We’ve planted seeds for the following: marjoram, chervil, and basil. When we purchased our seeds the vendor also threw in a packet of seeds for Parisienne carrots, short, stubby little things. We planted those, too, along with nasturtiums.

If all of our seeds take hold, we’ll end up with bushels of marjoram, chervil, and basil. I’ll also plant some tarragon and rosemary seedlings. This year I’m determined to harvest and preserve them properly. We’ll see. I’ll post pictures as things develop.

9 comments

No Inside Job

Scott Sumner takes note of a paper that contradicts the “Inside Job” theory of the housing/finance crisis. Here’s the twelve bullet point summary:

Fact 1: Resets of adjustable rate mortgages did not cause the foreclosure crisis.

Fact 2: No mortgage was “designed to fail.”

Fact 3: There was little innovation in mortgage markets in the 2000s.

Fact 4: Government policy toward the mortgage market did not change much from 1990 to 2005.

Fact 5: The originate-to-distribute model was not new.

Fact 6: MBSs, CDOs, and other “complex financial products” had been widely used for decades.

Fact 7: Mortgage investors had lots of information.

Fact 8: Investors understood the risks.

Fact 9: Investors were optimistic about home prices.

Fact 10: Mortgage market insiders were the biggest losers.

Fact 11: Mortgage market outsiders were the biggest winners.

Fact 12: Top-rated bonds backed by mortgages did not turn out to be “toxic.” Top-rated bonds in collateralized debt obligations (CDOs) did.

Read the whole thing. I don’t know what caused the housing/finance crisis. I’m actually more interested in why prices rose so high so fast than in why they fell and came pretty close to taking the whole economy with them. The fall was implicit in the rise.

14 comments

Regional Recessions

Quite a few people are crowing about the most recent Case-Shiller index of housing prices. Areas that had taken quite a hit in housing prices when the housing bubble burst like San Diego, Las Vegas, Phoenix, and Tampa have all shown strong 9% year-on-year increases. That’s good. Certainly better than if they had gone down.

What’s not being said is that on average people in those markets who bought their homes after the middle of 2003, a full ten years ago, will take a loss if they sell now. People like making profits but they really dislike taking losses. Most people will go to irrationally great lengths to avoid taking losses. That’s understandable. One of the hardest things to learn when buying and selling things is when it’s time to take a loss. Is it any wonder the supply of homes for sale is so scanty?

In Chicago the situation is somewhat worse. On average people in Chicago who purchased homes since the beginning of 2001, more than a decade ago, will take a loss if they sold now. Since the typical American family changes homes about every 12 years, that’s certainly the greater number of home owners and probably includes most peoeple.

Consider the Chicago Purchasing Manager’s Index, illustrated above. I think it’s pretty clear that the region is drifting towards recession. Spirits may be pretty buoyant in New York and Washington, DC. They should be with the amount of money the Federal Reserve and the federal government have lavished on those areas over the last half dozen years. Just as there is an oil-driven boom going on in the upper Midwest there may be regional recessions going on all over the country, largely unfelt and unreported in the national news outlets, concentrated as those are so heavily in New York, Washington, and Los Angeles.

3 comments

Clemens Right Again

As Sam Clemens said, the difference between a man and a dog is that, if you feed a dog and make it prosperous, it won’t bite you.

0 comments

The United States Isn’t Bankrupt, Either

My point of departure for this post is this complaint from Jonathan Kay:

Are we witnessing the end of the “American age”? It depends whom you ask. But one thing is certain: Thanks to the near-bankruptcy of the American welfare state, Washington is losing both the means and desire to project power across the world. Inevitably, nations with deeper pockets — China, most notably — will fill the void.

There are so many things wrong with just those few words it’s hard to know where to start. China’s military is mostly useful for internal use. Our military has the ability to project power without peer in the world today. So much so that it promotes overconfidence in our allies, stealth in our prospective adversaries, and alarm in those sitting on the fence. It should. We spend enough on it.

The most egregiously wrong thing with it is this: if we elected to do so, we could pay the public debt with the stroke of a pen or, more accurately, with electronic credits to accounts held on computers. That, too, would have consequences but it’s possible.

The United States isn’t bankrupt. In practical terms it can’t go bankrupt. It’s just profligate which is a somewhat different proposition.

15 comments