Watching the Watchers

There’s a paragraph in today’s Wall Street Journal editorial that summarizes neatly my views on the IRS’s singling conservative and libertarian organizations out for excessive scrutiny:

All IGs appear before Congress, but they are really answerable to the President who is responsible for what goes on in the IRS and what the agency actually does. If the IRS is not operating in a way that treats taxpayers evenhandedly and in accordance with its guidelines and mission, it is up to him to change the personnel and make any other corrections so that the taxing power of the federal government is legal and fair. If that isn’t the case, voters deserve to know exactly who is accountable for the decisions of the agency that takes a healthy fraction of their income every year.

I don’t blame the president, specifically, although I do take the point that’s been made by his opponents seriously. He didn’t need to give the “rogue IRS officials” directions. They undoubtedly thought they were doing his bidding.

If it could be proven definitely that he had been informed of the situation some time ago, my evaluation might be different.

Whether he’s known about the situation for some time, he knows now and just being outraged is an inadequate response. Clearly, he should ask for Lois Lerner’s resignation. If she declines, he might want to assign her to the IRS’s Anchorage office.

The WSJ is outraged about the lack of responsibility and accountability. I think that the IRS’s procedures need changing. It’s remarkable to me that the whole thing wasn’t obvious long, long ago and dealt with appropriate. Exactly how much discretion are low-level IRS officials allowed?

Even if the whole snafu turns out to have been the work of just a handful of IRS officials (a story that already seems to be falling apart) quite literally hundreds more must have known. I find it dismaying that it didn’t strike any of them as wrong.

I’ve been complaining for years around here that the moral education of most Americans seems to stop at about age 7. Our system really depends on the honesty, decency, and good sense of ordinary Americans. If that can no longer be depended on, the system that will necessarily replace our present system will look a lot more like Warsaw Pact East Germany than it does like the America I want it to be.

64 comments

“Most Loathsome Person in American Political Life”

Far be it from me to disagree with Dave Zirin of The Nation’s assessment of Chicago’s Mayor Rahm Emanuel:

It all starts with the person who seems committed to win the current spirited competition as the most loathsome person in American political life: Mayor Rahm Emanuel. The same Mayor overseeing the closing of fifty-four schools and six community mental health clinics under the justification of a “budgetary crisis” has announced that the city will be handing over more than $100 million to DePaul University for a new basketball arena. This is part of a mammoth redevelopment project on South Lakeshore Drive consisting of a convention center anchored by an arena for a non-descript basketball team that has gone 47-111 over the last five years. It’s also miles away from DePaul’s campus. These aren’t the actions of a mayor. They’re the actions of a mad king.

I’ve thought so since he was a spokesman for the Clinton Administration. What excites Mr. Zirin’s ire? The mayor’s support for a basketball stadium for DePaul University, to be built in the vicinity of McCormick Place. That’s the arena that was characterized by stadium expert Marc Ganis as “lunacy”, “sheer folly”, and “no economic sense whatsoever”.

Mr. Zirin’s going out of his way to mention that DePaul is a Catholic university makes me mildly uncomfortable (he notes it twice in the column). That it is a private institution would be enough to make the point. Is its being Catholic somehow relevant?

The school closings were a done deal as soon as raises for Chicago Public School teachers were agreed upon. The money has to come from somewhere and there are no good ready candidates. Raising sales taxes or property taxes are more likely to drive retail and investment from the city than they are to increase tax dollars at this point. There is simply no more tax blood in the Chicago turnip. Maybe a payoff for past contributions.

Is there some major political donor, local or out-of-state, who would benefit by such a deal? I’m guessing that the DePaul arena deal has more to do with drumming up contributions than it does to anything else.

3 comments

Point of Information: Scrutiny

Has anyone noticed that there hasn’t been a torrent of progressive, liberal, etc. organizations coming forward to say that they received excessive scrutiny, too? Why is that? Because they didn’t receive such scrutiny? Because they don’t mind? Because they didn’t file to receive 501(c)(4) status? All of the above? Something else?

3 comments

Senators Outraged at Laws They Enacted

Michigan Senator Carl Levin is making the news in his outrage about Apple’s exploiting the tax code to reduce its income tax liability:

Mr. Levin is outraged that Apple subsidiaries in Ireland pay little or no corporate income tax on profits generated from Apple’s international sales. Ireland has a laudably low corporate tax rate of 12.5% to attract jobs and capital, but it turns out that for certain corporations controlled by entities outside Ireland, the deal gets better.

The Apple units are based in Ireland, so U.S. law does not consider them to be U.S. corporations subject to U.S. corporate tax. But since they are managed and controlled by Apple in the U.S., Irish law doesn’t consider them Irish companies and thus they are also not subject to the 12.5% Irish corporate tax. This isn’t alchemy; it’s accountancy.

Carl Levin has been a U. S. Senator since 1979. That means that he held office when most of the laws governing income taxes, individual or corporate, were enacted into law. What was he, an innocent bystander? The problem is, of course, that Apple has strong incentives to do what they can within the law to reduce its tax burden and Apple’s accountants and tax lawyers are smarter than Sen. Levin. Or Sen. Levin, all of his colleagues, and their staffs put together. That will always be the case.

There’s plenty of room for outrage. The WSJ is outraged over the high corporate income tax that incentivizes companies to implement such tax avoidance schemes.

Have you noticed how many of the stories of the day ultimately revolve around the corporate income tax? The IRS singling out conservative and libertarian organizations for scrutiny, Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission, stories about lobbying. They all come down to the corporate income tax.

5 comments

Genes, Patents, and Theft

Ruth Marcus brings up a subject in which I have some interest:

As the sequencing of the human genome has expanded the ability to test for such genetic susceptibilities, is the discovery of the gene itself a patentable invention?

The practical consequences are enormous. Would allowing companies that identify such genes to hold patents on them provide an incentive for useful discoveries? Or would it have the perverse effect of impeding research by allowing one patent-holder to lock up work on the gene, and, simultaneously, hurting consumers by driving up costs and availability?

As it happens, the Supreme Court is poised to decide this issue in a case involving a Utah company, Myriad Genetics, and its patents on the BRCA1 and BRCA2 mutations. As is true of many of the cases that make their way to the high court, this is not the easiest of legal questions — except that this one also calls for an advanced degree in biology.

I do not believe that animals, plants, or genes that occur in nature should be patentable. That’s completely consistent with the history of patent law. You cannot patent electricity, gravity, or the Third Law of Motion although you can patent devices that make use of these naturally occurring physical phenomena. Certainly there are gray areas, for example, when a completely new gene is created. But in my view granting patents on naturally occurring genes is theft, plain and simple.

Pointing to the good that can be done by granting such patents is specious. I could do an enormous amount of good with the money I got from robbing a bank.

8 comments

Criminalizing Reporting

Dana Milbank explains why the conjoined twin scandals, the subpoenaing of AP reporters’ phone records and the arrest of James Milbank for espionage, matter:

But here’s why you should care — and why this case, along with the administration’s broad snooping into Associated Press phone records, is more serious than the other supposed Obama administration scandals regarding Benghazi and the Internal Revenue Service. The Rosen affair is as flagrant an assault on civil liberties as anything done by George W. Bush’s administration, and it uses technology to silence critics in a way Richard Nixon could only have dreamed of.

To treat a reporter as a criminal for doing his job — seeking out information the government doesn’t want made public — deprives Americans of the First Amendment freedom on which all other constitutional rights are based. Guns? Privacy? Due process? Equal protection? If you can’t speak out, you can’t defend those rights, either.

Beyond that, the administration’s actions shatter the president’s credibility and discourage allies who would otherwise defend the administration against bogus accusations such as those involving the Benghazi “talking points.” If the administration is spying on reporters and accusing them of criminality just for asking questions — well, who knows what else this crowd is capable of doing?

We only have the Administration’s word for the underlying offense in either one of these cases. For all we know the real offense may be lèse-majesté. And the harm has already been done. To the extent that real reporting on the federal government has been done in the past in the future reporters who think about reporting on the federal government will be looking over their shoulders.

George Santayana once defined a fanatic as someone who redoubles his efforts when he has forgotten his goal. By that definition although I’m ardent about freedom of the press I’m no fanatic. I know what my goals are: honest government in the context of maximizing individual freedom. What are the Administration’s goals in these two cases? Are they to make us more secure or them?

10 comments

In a Galaxy Far, Far Away

Europe, to be exact. Just when you think the world couldn’t possibly get any more bizarre, the Eurovision Song Contest comes alone to remind you just how wrong you were. Check out the photo montage. Beats the heck out of listening to it.

1 comment

Out of Sight, Out of Mind

For Californians who are happy with how their state has solved the potential problems of homes that can’t stand up to the elements with zoning requirements, California has more than 5,000 trailer parks with something like 1 million residents. Indeed, there are 13 in Marin County alone.

3 comments

Juxtaposition

Yesterday this comment was left in the comment thread of one of my posts:

It is easier to attack than defend since the attackers can say anything. Truth doesnt matter. They can forge emails and forget to mention that they knew about the IRS investigation because they instigated the IG audit.

I think that makes an interesting juxtaposition with this:

It has long been part of the Washington game for officials to discredit a news story by playing up errors in a relatively small part of it. Pfeiffer gives the impression that GOP operatives deliberately tried to “smear the president” with false, doctored e-mails.

But the reporters involved have indicated they were told by their sources that these were summaries, taken from notes of e-mails that could not be kept. The fact that slightly different versions of the e-mails were reported by different journalists suggests there were different note-takers as well.

Indeed, Republicans would have been foolish to seriously doctor e-mails that the White House at any moment could have released (and eventually did). Clearly, of course, Republicans would put their own spin on what the e-mails meant, as they did in the House report. Given that the e-mails were almost certain to leak once they were sent to Capitol Hill, it’s a wonder the White House did not proactively release them earlier.

The burden of proof lies with the accuser. Despite Pfeiffer’s claim of political skullduggery, we see little evidence that much was at play here besides imprecise wordsmithing or editing errors by journalists.

or, said another way, it is the White House that is lying. The remarks of IRS official Lois Lerner, too, have been riddled with lies:

In some ways, this is just scratching the surface of Lerner’s misstatements and weasely wording when the revelations about the IRS’s activities first came to light on May 10. But, taken together, it’s certainly enough to earn her four Pinocchios.

It is possible to tell a lie with good intentions and it is possible to tell the truth with less than pure intentions. That doesn’t make it any the less important to distinguish between the truth and lies.

If your yardstick for heroes and villains is truth-telling, you’ll find precious little heroism these days.

3 comments

Not Foreign Policy

Today at OTB I’ve written a few words on the disaster that struck Moore, Oklahoma yesterday:

Before

0 comments