One Man’s Obstruction

The topic of the day seems to be GOP obstruction of Obama appointments, no doubt spurred by the president’s remarks yesterday. This morning the Washington Post present two conflicting views.

Greg Sargent wonders if the president isn’t right in his claim that Republicans are being obstructionist with respect to his apointments:

It is not easy to conclusively determine whether GOP obstructionism is unprecedented. But there are some data points we can look at.

For instance, Dr. Sheldon Goldman, a professor of political science at the University of Massachusetts who focuses on judicial nominations, has developed what he calls an “Index of Obstruction and Delay” designed to measure levels of obstructionism. In research that will be released in a July article he co-authored for Judicature Journal, he has calculated that the level of obstruction of Obama circuit court nominees during the last Congress was unprecedented.

Goldman calculates his Index of Obstruction and Delay by adding together the number of unconfirmed nominations, plus the number of nominations that took more than 180 days to confirm (not including nominations towards the end of a given Congress) and dividing that by the total number of nominations. During the last Congress, Goldman calculates, the Index of Obstruction and Delay for Obama circuit court nominations was 0.9524.

“That’s the highest that’s ever been recorded,” he tells me. “In this last Congress it approached total obstruction or delay.”

By contrast, during the 108th Congress, from 2003-2004 – which is the most comparable, because George W. Bush was president and Republican controlled the Senate, meaning Dems had to use procedural tactics available to the minority to block nominations — the Index of Obstruction and Delay for Bush circuit court nominations was far lower, at 0.6176.

I wonder whether Dr. Goldman distinguished between nominees weren’t scheduled for hearings before the Senate Judiciary Committee which would, presumably, be Democratic obstruction from delays in confirmation instigated by Republicans which would, of course, be Republican obstruction. Unfortunately, Dr. Goldman’s paper is paywalled and I’m not going to pay to examine his methodology.

Ed Rogers, on the other hand, argues that the president has gone out of his way to antagonize Republicans and what would you expect them to do under the circumstances?

Instead of presenting us with an enthusiastic, robust case for his nominees, the president gave us a convoluted, hard-to-follow set of statistics and a detailed, tedious explanation of how he believes Republicans have held up previous judicial nominees. Does the president still believe he can get things passed in Congress by taunting Republicans? I thought David Plouffe and Obama White House aides were freelancing in the last few days in their engagement with Congressman Darrell Issa (R-Calif.). But it appears that taunting Republicans is a strategy that’s coming directly from the top. Not that it matters, but you get your nominees confirmed by dealing strategically with the Senate — by packaging confirmations with other confirmations or items that the opposition does want to pass. No one in the Senate thinks there is any consequence to opposing Obama, so when the president lashes out at Republicans, it gets him nowhere.

The last time I examined differences in judicial appointment confirmation rates among Clinton, Bush, and Obama President Obama’s confirmation rate was lower than his predecessors but not dramatically so. What was dramatically different was how slow President Obama was filling empty seats. Perhaps that’s changed in the year or so since I last considered the issue.

Back when Democrats were obstructing President Bush, something they have apparently forgotten, I criticized it and, equally, I don’t think that Republicans should obstruct President Obama’s appointments, either. Presidents should generally get their way in the appointments they make. It’s one of the perks of the job. Additionally, as I said back then, although there will always be a majority party and a minority party I don’t think an opposition party, that largely defines itself by what it’s against (the other party) is good for American politics. I’d much rather see Republicans making their case for what they support rather than just blocking President Obama at every turn, by whatever means comes to hand.

Similarly, I’d also like a president who had more appetite for cultivating support from the party out of power but, alas, the American people have decided that was not to be.

0 comments

Downgraded Again

After the cowardly failure of the Illinois legislature to address the problem the state faces in paying its public pensions in its regular legislative session, Illinois, already the state with the lowest credit rating, has had its credit rating lowered again:

One of the three major ratings agencies has downgraded the value of Illinois state government credit.

Fitch Ratings said Monday it would drop the Illinois rating from “A” to “A-” based on lawmakers’ failure to enact a solution to the state’s public-employee pension crisis.

Illinois already has the lowest rating in the nation. Lower ratings mean paying higher interest rates on borrowed money.

A lower credit rating means higher operating expenses for the state—the state relies very heavily on short term borrowing. For a good backgrounder on Illinois’s finances see here. That means that not only have Illinois’s legislators failed to face the state’s most serious fiscal problem they’ve actually compounded it.

When will the voters of Illinois realize that sending the same people who dreated the problems in the first place back to Springfield year after year, term after term, where they can refuse to cope with the problems again and again? Never, is my guess.

4 comments

Robert Fletcher, 1911-2013

Most of you probably haven’t heard of Bob Fletcher. Heroism comes in many forms. In Mr. Fletcher’s case it took the form of preserving the farms of his Japanese-American neighbors who had been interned during World War II:

In the face of deep anti-Japanese sentiment — Fletcher was taunted as a “Jap lover” and nearly hit by a bullet fired at a barn — he stepped in to save the farms of the Nitta, Okamoto and Tsukamoto families.

He worked 90 acres of California table grapes, paid the mortgages and taxes, and took half the profits. He turned over the rest — along with the farms — to the three families when they returned to Sacramento in 1945.

“I did know a few of them pretty well and never agreed with the evacuation,” Fletcher told the Sacramento Bee in 2010. “They were the same as anybody else. It was obvious they had nothing to do with Pearl Harbor.”

During the war many interned Japanese-Americans lost their land due to unpaid mortgages, unpaid taxes, or thieves. Mr. Fletcher’s actions saved his neighbors’ land for them. If there had been many more like him, California after the war would have been a very different place. Juster, I think.

Who, in your opinion, was a neighbor to the Japanese-Americans interned during World War II?

0 comments

Bored

I haven’t found the heart to post anything for the last several days because, frankly, I’m bored with the stories that are out there.

I’ve pretty much said my piece on the scandals that are out there. I think they’re all scandals of various different degrees of severity and that none of them will touch the president himself although I think that Eric Holder has become a liability for the administration. The real question guiding whether Mr. Holder remains Attorney General is whether he’s a net liability and the jury is still out on that. As I’ve said elsewhere every administration needs a lightning rod and for the Obama Administration that’s Eric Holder. As long as he can satisfy that function, shielding the president, from the White House’s standpoint he remains a net asset and he’ll stay.

Even Benghazi is a scandal although it’s in a different class from the others. As far as I know nobody’s alleging any actual wrongdoing in the matter—just boneheadedness, recklessness, and a feckless and quickly untenable week-long attempt at diverting attention from what actually happened. It’s essentially a policy disagreement. Should Benghazi even have had a consulate? IMO Libya is barely a country at all at this point. We don’t generally send diplomats to cities but to countries and especially not to cities teetering on the brink of chaos.

Most American just don’t care what happens in Libya, even to American diplomats so I doubt the matter will go much of anywhere. It’s just an irritation.

The IRS affair, the Rosen thing, and the AP thing are still festering. We’ll know whether anything becomes of them in the fullness of time.

I think the economy is slowly stalling but today everybody has their own facts and can try and make their case that everything’s hunky-dory. I don’t see how that case can be made without at least a twinge of shame as long as so many people remain unemployed or underemployed.

Syria may expand into a regional war. Since we’re not going to back Assad (which would be the surest way to end the violence), we’re not going to do much there. Sad as it is our best course is probably to maintain a low profile.

The EU’s economic policy is, apparently, to muddle along. They don’t know what else to do. Nothing they can do as long as Germany has all the marbles.

Maybe Japan’s experiment in reviving its slow economy will work. I doubt that those who’ve been cheering Abenomics along will be at all embarrassed if it flops.

I wonder what Kim Jong-un is up to. No good, probably.

25 comments

Oldest Torah

The oldest complete Torah, the first five books of the Hebrew Bible, has been found in the library of the University of Bologna. It is believed to be more than 800 years old:

The University of Bologna in Italy has found what it says may be the oldest complete scroll of Judaism’s most important text, the Torah.

The scroll was in the university library but had been mislabelled, a professor at the university says.

It was previously thought the scroll was no more that a few hundred years old.

However, after carbon dating tests, the university has said the text may have been written more than 850 years ago.

The university’s Professor of Hebrew Mauro Perani says this would make it the oldest complete text of the Torah known to exist, and an object of extraordinary worth.

Texts that old almost invariably have minor variations from the standard texts used today. It will be interesting to see what’s found in this one.

One thought that this brings to mind is that we really don’t know just what’s sitting around, gathering dust, in the libraries and museums of the world. There are still lots of exciting finds being made in the field but the most exciting archaeological find ever made might be sitting in some collection somewhere, unidentified, uncatalogued, and unknown.

Another thing this brings to mind is a subject I’ve returned to from time to time here. Most people don’t realize how very few manuscripts we have from antiquity. Most of what we know about the ancient world is from medieval manuscripts of sketchy provenance. I wonder what the provenance of the Torah manuscript they’ve found might be. My guess is that they have no idea.

0 comments

Mess Over Genetically Modified Wheat

The discovery of genetically modified herbicide-resistant wheat growing in a field in Oregon has produced a backlash:

Commercial farming of genetically modified wheat is banned in the United States. The practice is primarily not allowed because about half of America’s wheat is sold overseas and many foreign countries prohibit the import of genetically modified foods.

So when modified wheat was discovered recently on a small farm in Oregon, the response from U.S. trading partners was fierce. Japan, the number one buyer of U.S. wheat, suspended some imports, as did South Korea.

Korean scientists are testing their U.S. wheat for signs of genetic modification and the European Union is also urging its 27 member nations to test American wheat.

It’s not known how the modified wheat got into the Oregon field. Genetically it’s the same wheat that Monsanto tested for possible commercial use in 16 states including Oregon a decade ago.

Monsanto has a patent on this “Roundup Ready” wheat (I should have the little trademark thingy after that but I’m too lazy to look it up). Since it may not be grown legally in the U. S. and they’re the patent-holder, off-hand I’d guess that they have an affirmative responsibility to prevent its cultivation. I will be very surprised if we don’t see a class action suit by U. S. wheat farmers against Monsanto, suing for damages from loss of export sales.

7 comments

The Cowardly Illinois Legislature Fails Again

Although more attention will be given to the Illinois legislature’s declining to legalize homosexual marriage in the state of Illinois, that wasn’t yesterday’s main legislative story. Despite promises to the contrary, despite Illinois’s having the lowest credit rating of any state, despite the likelihood of failing to deal with the state’s problems being very likely to push the state’s credit rating even lower and, consequently, increase the state’s costs, and despite Illinois’s problems in finding enough money to spend on its urgent priorities even without a higher cost of borrowing, the Illinois legislature did not muster the courage to face Illinois’s problems with its public pensions:

“The biggest supermajorities in modern history, the biggest issue facing the people of Illinois in a generation and you failed to deliver,” said Sen. Matt Murphy, a Palatine Republican. “… The governor is going to bring Squeezy out again tomorrow because you guys couldn’t figure out how to communicate with a supermajority of the same party on the other side of the building.”

Lawmakers spent the final days of session approving medical marijuana; a deal on hydraulic fracturing, or “fracking;” a method for legalizing the carrying of concealed guns; and a historic expansion of Medicaid, a key part of President Barack Obama’s health care law.

They also sent Quinn a new $35.4 billion general revenue fund budget that avoids cuts to education for the first time in several years. But they had nothing to show for on pensions, legalizing gay marriage or expanding gambling.

The explanation for the failure to act is, first and foremost, that the Democratic supermajorities in control of the legislature are cowards, there is no pain-free solution to the problem so, consequently, they’re looking for someone else to blame.

For those of you who aren’t familiar with the peculiarities of Illinois’s legislative process, from when the legislature convenes in January of each year until the end of May is considered “regular session”. During the regular session, bills are enacted by a simple majority of each house of the legislature. In the fall the legislature reconvenes for a two-week “veto session” during which the legislature considers the governor’s vetoes of its legislation including the peculiar “amendatory vetoes” (in which the governor actually re-writes portions of legislation) or other urgent legislation which can be passed during the veto session with less debate but must be passed by a two-thirds vote.

Illinois legislators frequently wait until the veto session to pass controversial laws. The effective result of doing that is to forgo passing legislation by a simple majority but over a three-day period in favor of a two-thirds majority in a single day.

Illinois has pension problems for two reasons. First, under the incompetent leadership of now-impeached Gov. Rod Blagojevich, presently serving a term in prison, the state didn’t make its contributions to the various pension funds preferring instead to buy votes by expanding and liberalizing Medicaid, giving more benefits to the elderly, etc. They made the assumption that the state could always rely on rapidly rising revenues, something that hasn’t proven to be the case. Second, the state has overly-generous public pensions with funds that depend on wildly optimistic investment returns—8% per year compared with the closer to 1% realized last year.

I’m guessing that they’re calculating that they can hide behind Gov. Quinn (who, presumably, won’t be re-elected regardless of what he does) and/or blame the Republican majority minority for their ongoing failure to pass pension reform. Win-win!

4 comments

The News on Social Security and Medicare

The Social Security Trustees’ report for 2013 became available today. The media reports are emphasizing that the insolvency date for the Social Security Trust Fund is unchanged at 2033 while the insolvency date for the Medicare Trust Fund has been pushed back a couple of years until 2026.

When I read mystery stories I don’t skip to the end to see whodunnit but when I read the Trustees’ report I always do because that’s where the Statement of Actuarial Opinion is. Here’s the important part:

In past reports, and again this year, the Board of Trustees has emphasized the strong likelihood that actual Part B expenditures will exceed the projections under current law due to further legislative action to avoid substantial reductions in the Medicare physician fee schedule. While the Part B projections in this report are reasonable in their portrayal of future costs under current law, they are not reasonable as an indication of actual future costs. Current law would require a physician fee reduction of an estimated 24.7 percent on January 1, 2014—an implausible expectation. Further, while the Affordable Care Act makes important changes to the Medicare program and substantially improves its financial outlook, there is a strong likelihood that certain of these changes will not be viable in the long range. Specifically, the annual price updates for most categories of non-physician health services will be adjusted downward each year by the growth in economy-wide productivity. The best available evidence indicates that most health care providers cannot improve their productivity to this degree for a prolonged period as a result of the labor-intensive nature of these services.

Without unprecedented changes in health care delivery systems and payment mechanisms, the prices paid by Medicare for health services are very likely to fall increasingly short of the costs of providing these services. By the end of the long-range projection period, Medicare prices for hospital, skilled nursing facility, home health, hospice, ambulatory surgical center, diagnostic laboratory, and many other services would be less than half of their level without consideration of the productivity price reductions. Medicare prices would be considerably below the current relative level of Medicaid prices, which have already led to access problems for Medicaid enrollees, and far below the levels paid by private health insurance. Well before that point, Congress would have to intervene to prevent the withdrawal of providers from the Medicare market and the severe problems with beneficiary access to care that would result. Overriding the productivity adjustments, as Congress has done repeatedly in the case of physician payment rates, would lead to substantially higher costs for Medicare in the long range than those projected under current law.

For these reasons, the financial projections shown in this report for Medicare do not represent a reasonable expectation for actual program operations in either the short range (as a result of the unsustainable reductions in physician payment rates) or the long range (because of the strong likelihood that the statutory reductions in price updates for most categories of Medicare provider services will not be viable).

or, said another way, the Chief Actuary is saying “pay no attention to the little trustees behind the curtain. Medicare will go broke long before 2026.”

11 comments

How to Close Guantanamo

As the years go by I find myself ever more bewildered by the country I’ve lived in nearly all my life. I simply don’t understand why people are doing and saying the things they are. Take Guantanamo (please ba-dum-bump). The president can close Guantanamo any time he cares to by executive order. He can pardon all of its present inmates and order that they be returned to their home countries.

That would, of course, have consequences. So does leaving Guantanamo in operation. I didn’t run for president on closing Guantanamo—Barack Obama did. Now he doesn’t like the implications of closing it. A bit late. And he keeps repeating it.

As I’ve said before, President Obama’s problem in closing Guantanamo is identical to the problem that President Bush had and has been the cardinal problem with the place since it was first used for warehousing prisoners in the War on Terror: they don’t know what else to do.

The other cardinal problem is that it’s not Guantanamo that’s the problem at all. The problem is indefinite incarceration.

5 comments

Assuming the Worst

They say that even a blind pig finds an acorn once in a while and the editors of the Washington Post have realized that the discrepancies in the various accounts of how an FBI agent shot and killed a man being questioned in connection with the Boston Marathon bombing is, if not a scandal, at least a story:

Even if the world weren’t watching, the case would warrant exceptional attention. Mr. Todashev had had run-ins with law enforcement before last week, and his possible involvement in a gruesome triple murder is chilling. FBI agents may very well have had reason to worry about him. But if so, did they really leave a samurai sword in the room during questioning? Did they really leave only one person with Mr. Todashev? If neither of those accounts holds up, how else could the shooting be justified?

The FBI said that it takes the incident “very seriously,” that it is reviewing the events internally with its “time-tested” procedures and that it is doing so “expeditiously.” But the curious circumstances and conflicting, anonymous explanations suggest that standard procedure might not be sufficient.

The worst case scenario is that FBI special agents executed the man being questioned. That conclusion is already being drawn overseas where it’s being said that today’s United States is no better than Soviet Russia. In that sense the harm has already been done. As far as I can tell the best case scenario is that proper procedures were not followed leading to a man’s death.

The FBI really needs to get out in front of this story. A true, authoritative, and convincing account must be reported with all due haste and discipline must be exerted to reduce speculation. Even if it’s embarrassing. Even if it’s damaging.

This is yet another story that feeds the narrative of an out-of-control federal government. Now it’s a trigger-happy out-of-control federal government.

Update

Conor Friedersdorf echoes my prescription above:

It also seems clear to me that the FBI should assign someone trustworthy to set forth what it knows to be true on the record, in order to reduce misinformation as much as possible.

We may need to open a new can of trustworthy individuals. We’re starting to run short.

3 comments