Fallback Position on Immigration Reform

Mickey Kaus outlines an alternative immigration reform plan, less ambitious than the “Gang of 8” plan but possibly more likely to pass:

Immigration reform doesn’t have to be all or nothing. The obvious mini-deal, that would give something (but not everything) to several important constituencies would involve a) mandating the “E-Verify” system for checking new employees for their immigration status b) in exchange for formalization of the “DREAM Act” mini-amnesty for immigrants brought into the country as minors and c) some measured liberalization of high-tech and agricultural visas to please business interests.

People that wouldn’t satisfy at all:

  • Democrats who want a club to beat over the heads of Republicans.
  • Republican Know Nothings who want to end immigration full stop.
  • Activists for whom nothing less than amnesty now with potential citizenship later is acceptable.

I’ve already expressed my views on immigrations reform. Legislate in haste, repent at leisure.

0 comments

Deviating from the Narrative on Unemployment

From the department of “even a blind pig finds an acorn every so often”, the New York Times has lurched uncontrollably onto the reality that not only is the employment situation in the United States not what it should be but other developed countries are doing a lot better in that regard than we are:

The American economy may be the world’s biggest, but when it comes to job creation since the recession hit at the end of 2007, it is far from a leader.

Indeed, contrary to the widespread view that the United States is an island of relative prosperity in a global sea of economic torpor, employment in several other nations has bounced back more quickly, according to a new analysis by the Bureau of Labor Statistics.

The government reported Friday that the nation added 175,000 jobs in May, continuing a 32-month run of job gains. The unemployment rate moved up slightly to 7.6 percent, from 7.5 percent in April.

But overall employment in the United States remained 2.1 percent below where it was at the end of 2007, according to the statistics bureau. By comparison, over the same period, between December 2007 and March 2013, the number of jobs was up 8.1 percent in Australia; Germany, the biggest economy in the troubled euro zone, has managed a 5.8 percent gain in employment.

It’s not just Germany and Australia. Canada (7.1%) is doing better than we are. Mexico (5%) is doing better. Brazil (5.8%) is doing better than we are. Russia (5.6%) is doing better than we are.

Certainly, there are countries in worse shape than we are:

While several European countries have fared worse, Canada, Sweden and even Britain, which is trapped in yet another recession, have enjoyed healthier job gains than the United States. In fact, of the nine countries surveyed by the Bureau of Labor Statistics, only perennially-troubled Italy and Japan performed worse.

Do we really aspire to being clumped with Italy, Greece, and Spain? We must be doing something wrong.

8 comments

I Agree With Paul Krugman

Mark it down on your calendar. In his remarks in the roundtable portion of ABC’s This Week program I agreed with almost everything Paul Krugman had to say.

First, on the issue of the NSA’s data collection and mining, Dr. Krugman, paraphrasing Jack Balkin, noted that technology made some level of surveillance state inevitable. The surveillance state could be democratic, gather as little data as was practicable, and be open about what it was gathering. Alternatively, it could be authoritarian, gathering as much data as it could, and be as closed as possible about it. We’re closer to the authoritarian model than the democratic one.

Second, with respect to Friday’s jobs report, after pointing out that the economy had entered a sort of “sour equilibrium”, made very nearly all of the points I made in my post on the subject. Essentially, it was not a good jobs report and characterizing it as such is an act of desperation.

Later in the roundtable he wandered off into the weeds a bit but on the two issues mentioned above he and I are in accord to a remarkable degree.

0 comments

May Jobs Report Not Nearly Good Enough

Yesterday the Bureau of Labor Statistics released its employment situation report for May:

The Labor Department announced Friday that the U.S. economy added 175,000 jobs in May and that the unemployment rate ticked up to 7.6 percent, from 7.5 percent in April.

Despite the pleased tone from Alan Krueger, chairman of the White House Council of Economic Advisers,

While more work remains to be done, today’s employment report provides further confirmation that the U.S. economy is continuing to recover from the worst downturn since the Great Depression. . . .

that’s not remotely good enough and I’ll try to explain why.

In my view the most that can be said is that it’s better than if the number of jobs had decreased. It is not true that it illustrates a good trend. 175,000 jobs is the average of the last three months. That’s not an upwards trend; it’s a constant trend. The number of jobs needed to account for the “natural increase” is about 150,000 per month. That leaves a net of 25,000 jobs. At that rate it would take 100 months, more than 8 years, to bring the people who lost their jobs during the downturn starting in 2007 back to work. That in turn would mean that some people would have been out of work for fourteen years. Putting more people to work at a faster rate is a moral necessity and it’s a scandal and an outrage that it’s not a political necessity.

Delving deeper into the report adds insult to injury. The bottom line is that the jobs being added are part-time or temp jobs that pay below the average wage. Hailing the May jobs report as a sign that we’re out of the woods is objectively lauding not enough people not being paid enough as a good thing.

I wish people would stop giving political cover to the White House and to the Congress. It is not as though there weren’t plenty of things that could be done from WPA-style federal jobs programs to subsidies for hiring people who have been out of work for an extended period to reducing payroll taxes, corporate income taxes, and regulatory barriers. Don’t just stand there; do something.

7 comments

Weasels

Peter Suderman presents a list of ways in which the panicked denials by top management of Google, Facebook, and Yahoo can be reconciled with the Washington Post story claiming that the NSA is “directly tapping into the central servers” of the companies. The potential explanations he lists are:

  1. The statements the companies have released so far are technically accurate—but the companies are involved anyway.
  2. The tech companies are involved in an NSA data gathering program, but only a very small number of people in each company knows about the involvement.
  3. The tech companies are not telling the truth.
  4. The NSA is accessing tech company servers without the knowledge of those companies.

The first explanation is what immediately occurred to me. The second, plausible deniability, sounds equally likely. I guess it’s also possible that the Post’s sources are mistaken or lying but my sense is that those explanations are less plausible than one or more of the others. I don’t think that Mark Zuckerberg has given us any particular reason to trust him or that we should believe that Larry Page wouldn’t bend over backwards to cooperate with government authorities (any government) if it maintained or improved Google’s position with them.

5 comments

Esther Williams, 1921-2013

Wet, she was a star. Esther Williams, famous for extravagant water-borne movie musicals of the 1940s and 50s, has died:

The water, Esther Williams once quipped, was her favorite costar.

With her beauty, sunny personality and background as a champion swimmer, Williams shot to stardom in the 1940s in the “aqua musical,” an odd sub-genre of films that became an enormous hit with the moviegoing mainstream, fanned popular interest in synchronized swimming and turned Williams into Hollywood’s Million Dollar Mermaid.

The MGM bathing beauty, whose underwater extravaganzas made her one of the most popular actresses of the era, an idol in competitive swimming and a fashion force, died in her sleep early Thursday in Beverly Hills, said her publicist, Harlan Boll. She was 91.

My wife tells me that her autobiography is very frank.

My dad used to say she was his favorite movie star. I think he admired her beauty, figure, and athleticism. There’s a wonderful, glamorous picture of her at the Entertainment Weekly site that should give you the general idea. She probably did more to popularize synchronized swimming than anybody including Annette Kellerman who first popularized it in 1907 and whom Ms. Williams portrayed in Million Dollar Mermaid. I doubt we’ll ever see anyone like her or her movies again.

2 comments

Is This What Obsession Looks Like?

The political blogosphere and the opinion sections of media sites are buzzing with a discussion of the federal government’s datamining of, well, just about everything you do online, by phone, or with a credit card. All of the ferment was spurred, no doubt, by Glenn Greenwald’s revelation of the use of phone call records. Walter Russell Mead’s remarks are as good as any:

As if the Tea Party/IRS mess isn’t enough, the White House has been shaken to its foundations by a series of dramatic and devastating revelations about the unsuspected reach of the government’s surveillance of the telephone records, email and other activities of US citizens without their knowledge. The President’s liberal base is stunned and appalled, with the New York Times editorial board hanging out the black crepe of official mourning. Al Gore twittered his disappointment and fear.

Republicans are divided. Jeffersonians and libertarians wave the flag of civil liberty, ready to join the liberal left in an attack on an administration that would have loved the Alien and Sedition Acts. Security focused Republicans are saying little; more concerned about the terror threat than some, they don’t want to see tools that may be necessary hastily stripped from the executive—though they have little reason to help President Obama out of his worst political scrape since Jeremiah Wright went under the bus.

The revelations could hardly have come at a worse time; when public trust in the good intentions of the federal government are ebbing is a difficult time to recommend that we’ll just have to trust the federal government to use the information it’s gathered properly.

I’m reading quite a few opinions to the effect that we should blame the growth of the security state on Americans’ obsession with terrorism and perfect security. Is this what obsession looks like?

That’s a graph, courtesy of the Gallup organization, of how many Americans list terrorism as their most important priority.

I don’t for a second believe that the growth of the “security state” is a matter of national security so much as job security. Elected officials are minimizing downside risk by determining how far they can push the envelope.

If I had any confidence that the vast and elaborate structures that have been erected over the last ten years were really necessary and sufficient to deter terrorist attack I might feel a bit better about the situation but I don’t. All of this acquiring of data is done in the name of making us more secure but is it really suitable to that task? Not being able to identify apparent Lone Wolves like Nidal Hasan is one thing. Not being able to identify active conspiracies, like the Boston Marathon Bombing, is another. The argument would be made, presumably, that the data are necessary but not sufficient.

What is sufficient? If no amount of data would be sufficient is acquiring that much data even necessary? Are they just gathering data in the hope that someday they might have the tools to make it useful? Is that an acceptable purpose? Sheer volume of data might be a barrier to its effective use.

Assurances that anything they sweep up in their search for usable information are nice but IMO it’s a reasonable assumption that if it can be misused then, ultimately, it will be misused. Just as there’s no perfect protection against terrorism, there’s no perfect protection against the misuse of information.

And then there’s the niggling suspicion that all of this, whether orchestrated by the Bush Administration or the Obama Administration, is far more about job security than about national security. As me auld mither used to say “It’s easier to ask for forgiveness than permission.”

27 comments

No Experience Necessary

Is Ralph Peters being overly harsh in his assessment of President Obama’s new foreign policy team?

Rice has the weakest credentials of any national security adviser in the history of the office, but she has the president’s ear as his old pal. And she’ll work in the White House: Proximity to POTUS is trumps in DC. Kerry’s desk in Foggy Bottom might as well be a hundred miles from the Oval Office.

However incompetent, Rice may become the most influential national security adviser since Henry Kissinger eclipsed the entire State Department. Which means that Obama’s foreign policy, already disastrous, is now going to get worse.

As for the earnest Ms. Power, she has zero qualifications to serve as our UN ambassador. She’s a left–wing militant who has yet to show the least interest in defending America, rather than merely using our might as her tool. Her cause is human rights abroad, and that’s her only cause. And while respect for human rights should be a major factor in our foreign policy, it can’t be the only factor.

Both Power and Rice consistently advocate using our military to protect the human rights of often-hostile foreign populations. Of course there are, indeed, times when measured intervention is strategically wise and morally imperative — but our military’s fundamental purpose is national defense, not mercy missions to those who spit in our faces.

My reaction to Ms. Power’s nomination as UN ambassador was that she’d fit right in. What I’ve heard of her views more closely resemble those of the typical UN delegate than they do those of the typical American.

I think it’s increasingly clear that the president values loyalty very highly and the primary qualifications that his most recent appointments possess is that they’re loyal and part of his close-knit group of friends and advisors.

4 comments

The Resurrection of Arrested Development

It’s being variously called a “reboot”, a “revival”, or just a fourth season but IMO one of the more interesting show business stories is Netflix’s resurrection of the Fox television series, Arrested Development. Seven years ago Fox cancelled AD after just three seasons and, frankly, the series struggled to get that far. It averaged about 6 million viewers per episode in the first season, 4 million in the second, and three and a half in its final season. Since the cancellation there have been rumors of the show being reborn elsewhere, a movie, etc.

Then about a year ago Netflix announced that it had ordered a fourth season of Arrested Development. The results became available on May 26 and the whole season was made available at once. Here’s how it was reported:

Fox’s early cancellation of “Arrested Development” played out like a rock star dying in his prime: It catapulted the show into cult-favorite status, leaving fans wondering what could have been.

Netflix tried to answer that question with a revival of the series, but critics and investors aren’t thrilled.

Netflix (NFLX) released all 15 episodes of season four on Sunday, and unlike the rest of Netflix’s foray into original programming — completely new series like Kevin Spacey’s “House of Cards” and Ricky Gervais’ “Derek” — the “Arrested Development” reboot came with a built-in fan base of millions.

The company is betting a lot on original series, and “Arrested Development” is one of the brightest stars in its lineup. But shares of Netflix were down as much as 6% in midday trade Tuesday, the first trading day after the episodes were posted online.

This may be just a “sell the news” reaction after Netflix’s months of marketing the revival, which included pop-up banana stands (a series in-joke) in cities across the globe.

That appears to have been the case. Netflix’s stock has recovered much of the ground it lost over the last couple of years since it announced the development last year and, after a brief dip immediately following the release of the fourth season of AD, it appears to be holding its own.

I’ve never watched Arrested Development, broadcast, on DVD, or streaming, but I do find the phenomenon of its coming back from the dead interesting. Increasingly, I’m wondering whether we’re going to be seeing a lot more original programming being bankrolled by the streaming services. As mentioned in the squib above, Netflix has several more originals (none of which I’ve watched, Hulu has some originals, and Amazon has announced its own original programming.

I suspect that the example of Arrested Development, a television series originally broadcast finding new life with first run programming via streaming, is likely to be rare. For such a thing to make any sense the series in question needs to have been cancelled before it ran its course, it needs an ardent following of (I’d say) at least three million people, and the producers and cast need to be open to the idea. I can only think of one other prospective candidate for such a treatment and it strikes me as a very long shot.

9 comments

The Stories I’ll Never Know

One of the things you learn when you poke through the possessions of a person after they’ve died is the vast number of stories they contain. That’s certainly what I learned when I organized, catalogued, and dispersed my mom’s things after she died.

Some of the stories I’d known all of my life. I knew that my mom had registered for the china and silver when she and my dad got married, that some of it she’d received as wedding presents, some my dad had given her over the years, and some I’d given her. I’d been there when she bought most of the furniture in the house and the rest I knew the stories behind, at least a little. I also knew about the Bohemian glass bowl she’d been bequested by her high school voice teacher in her will, the oriental rugs that had been bought at auction by my grandmother seventy years ago or more, the old, cheap, dime store glass that had belonged to my great-grandmother, and the vast amount of handpainted china another great-grandmother had won playing euchre.

I learned new details of stories, especially when I was going through the old check stubs, paid bills, correspondence, and income tax returns. I learned that my parents had scrupulously deducted witholding and Social Security from the pay they’d given their household help and submitted it all to Uncle Sam. I learned that one of the women they’d hired when I was very small and whom I had loved and called “Ivy” was actually “I. V.”.

I learned some family secrets I’ll take to my grave, some of them things I don’t believe my mom had even known.

And then there are the stories I’ll never know. For example, tucked in the bottom of a little jewelry case that was on the top of my mom’s dresser for as long as I can remember, was a little torn-off piece of a red and white checked handkerchief. Tied in the piece of handkerchief was a single, old, silver quarter. Obviously, there’s a story there. It was kept by somebody for a reason I’ll never know now.

While rehabbing the house my mom had lived in for fifty years, one of my siblings found another story: the painting of a naked lady that hung behind the bar in my grandparents’ saloon. Rolled up, creased, and damaged and stuck in the rafters between the first and second floors of the house. I can only speculate that my dad could neither bear seeing it nor throwing it away. So it lay ignored, forgotten, and ultimately lost until it was found again quite by chance.

0 comments