In a contest of personalities between Illinois Gov. Pat Quinn and dynasty scion Bill Daley who would win? I’m thinking the Trib’s right: the Republicans.

In a contest of personalities between Illinois Gov. Pat Quinn and dynasty scion Bill Daley who would win? I’m thinking the Trib’s right: the Republicans.
If you haven’t already concluded it from my writings, I am predisposed to see things as being connected. Not too long ago I believe I identified one of those connecting threads in my own thoughts and writing.
I do not think that politics is a science or engineering. I am strongly opposed to technocracy which on its face is that belief. I think that politics, like sales with which politics has much in common, is an art of relationships. In my view that, indeed, is where our politics is weakest today. The relationships aren’t healthy and that makes the politics unhealthy.
The editors of the Wall Street Journal wonder what city or town will be the next to be compelled to seek municipal bankruptcy?
While few municipalities are as economically depressed or dilapidated as Detroit, many have borrowed heavily, raised taxes and hollowed out services to pay retirement and debt obligations. Some like Detroit may soon decide that clipping bondholders and pensioners is a better option than to keep whacking taxpayers.
Take Oakland, which is Detroit’s doppelganger on the West Coast. The run-down Bay Area city, which has the highest crime rate in California, recently laid off more than 100 police to fund retirement benefits and pension-obligation bonds. Murders and robberies shot up by nearly 25% last year. To avert steeper cuts, the city borrowed an additional $210 million to finance pensions.
Philadelphia and Chicago have been less scrupulous about financing pensions and are now having to make balloon payments to prevent their retirement funds from going broke. Philadelphia is spending about 20% of its budget on pensions to make up for years of short-changing the system. In 1999, it issued $1.3 billion in bonds to invest in the pension fund, but it has paid more in interest than it has earned on its pension investments.
The city has recently raised sales, property and business taxes. The city council is now discussing using revenues from a one-percentage-point sales tax hike in 2009 intended for schools to finance pensions. Its sale tax rate is now 8%, the limit under state law.
Chicago is also fast approaching a day of reckoning. Chicago Public Schools last week announced 2,100 layoffs, which Mayor Rahm Emanuel blamed on a $400 million spike in pension payments. “The pension crisis is no longer around the corner,” he said. “It has arrived at our schools.”
If you can reconcile Chicago’s settling the teachers’ strike last year by offering the Chicago Teachers Union a whopping pay increase with the city’s weak fiscal condition on a strictly policy basis, I would welcome your explanation. Try as I might I can’t figure it out. At least not on the basis of sound policy.
Detroit has almost three times as many public employees per capita as Chicago. Not only Detroit’s system of government and taxation but the whole state of Michigan’s system has a dominant, prosperous auto industry baked into the cake. At least that’s how I explain Michigan’s high tax on capital investment.
I think those are the factors behind Detroit’s problem as well as Oakland’s and Chicago’s. City government is an instrument for providing service rather than providing public sector jobs. A strong public sector is predicated on a strong private sector. An effective and efficient public sector can facilitate the growth of the private sector and may even be necessary for a strong private sector but it can’t substitute for it.
And cities, like individuals, must change with the times. The prevailing winds of today are not blowing in Detroit’s direction. The recovery plan that appears to be in place for Michigan’s largest city appears to my outsider’s eye to be more in keeping with producing a Motown theme park, restoring a semblance of life to an otherwise dead city than it is to facilitating a viable core.
Like pruning a tree, Detroit needs pruning back to a vital and viable core. Unlike a tree, a city is composed of people and the pruning process must be done with an eye to reducing the suffering of the people affected as much as is practicable.
Chicago’s problems are somewhat different than Detroit’s. There’s much more viable here. We’re not as dependent on a single industry as Detroit has been. But Chicago must change with the times, too. And just as some of Detroit’s change must necessarily be executed in Lansing much of Chicago’s change must be executed in Springfield. Springfield’s one-party gridlock doesn’t give me a great deal of hope.
I want to draw your attention to an op-ed at the Wall Street Journal from Andrew Puzder, CEO of the food service company that operates the Carl’s, Jr. and Hardee’s fast food chains. In the op-ed Mr. Puzder explains some of the reasons why the ACA may not function as expected. It’s closely reasoned and difficult to excerpt so you may want to read the whole thing.
I read Mr. Puzder’s op-ed as more of a lament than a diatribe. If I had to provide a rough summary, it might be that the incentives provided in the plan are those that would appeal more to well-to-do middle-aged or elderly white guys than to the young and healthy.
Just as a trip down memory lane, I should repeat that my objections to Obamacare, as I still feel uncomfortable in calling it, were that the United States frequently goes a long time between drinks at the healthcare reform bar and even if it were completely successful the plan does not effect the changes we need.
Sadly, contra Mr. Puzder, a “bipartisan, market-driven approach that might actually work” was never on the table. The Powers-That-Be hate each other and love their ideologies more than they care for the American people and their well-being.
I never went to a commercial summer camp as a kid, as I gather that many East Coast middle class and upper middle class kids did. There are no fond memories of Camp Sissimanoonoo from my childhood. Or horrific ones, for that matter.
I do have memories of summer day camp. My first experience of any summer camp was day camp. I couldn’t have been more than five or six and my recollections from that far back are pretty vague. I can’t tell you what the activities were, how long it ran, or how many years I attended. I remember riding on a yellow school bus to a local high school or, possibly, college campus. I have fuzzy memories of stringing beads. They may have shown us film strips or 8mm versions of cartoons or old movie serials. I have memories of sitting in the shade of a large, old tree with a bunch of other unruly kids and having stories read to us.
I suspect I went there for two consecutive years, once by myself and once with my next younger sibling. I’ve compared notes with that sibling who remembers day camp, riding on a bus, and hordes of unruly kids but not much else.
Maybe a year or so later the whole family went to stay for a week at Bunker Hill, at that time under the auspices of the Missouri State Teachers Association. You’ll recall that my mom was a public school teacher. Judging by the pictures in the gallery it’s been spruced up a bit over the decades but otherwise it hasn’t changed much. I remember catching a fish right from the shore in the third picture in the gallery and having it served to me that night in the mess hall. During the day we swam, canoed, fished, or just walked through the woods. At night there were square dances and, if memory serves, they showed 16mm prints of reasonably recent movie releases. Either they were mostly westerns and musicals or that’s what my parents took us to. I remember Athena and Seven Brides for Seven Brothers. I’m sure there were others. I also remember large (in every dimension) loud women with Ozark accents.
A bit later, from about the time I was 10 to about 13, there was Scout camp. I loved Scout camp. For a week we would camp in tents with cots, eat our meals in the mess hall, march around, engage in various competitions, swim, canoe, hike, and engage in all sort of other scouting activities. No plumbing. Just outhouses and gravity showers. My dad, who was the president of the troop’s board, usually joined us for the last couple of days.
At night the troop whould sit around a huge campfire, sing songs, tell stories, and recite poems. I can still recite “The Cremation of Sam McGee” from memory.
There are strange things done in the midnight sun
by the men who moil for gold
And the arctic trails have their secret tales
That would make your blood run cold
And the Northern Lights have seen queer sights
But the queerest they ever did see
Was that night on the marge of Lake LeBarge
I cremated Sam McGee.
One night during the week all of the troops in the camp would play “Capture the Flag”. Imagine 500 boys aged 10 to 13 running in the woods in the pitch dark shrieking at the top of their lungs and it will give you the general idea. It’s a miracle that more of us weren’t injured.
The camp was Irondale, deep in the Ozarks, and it was wonderful. In addition to the mess hall, an Olympic-sized swimming pool, and several lakes, it had a climbing tower, lots of woods, and open fields. My last year there I was inducted into the Order of the Arrow. Irondale closed a few years after my time but I understand there’s a movement to revive it.
And those are my memories of summer camp.
Here’s an example of going beyond what we actually know, as I pointed out in this post. Donald Sensing remarks:
What happened that night in Sanford is awful. Martin’s death was tragic even though his slayer, George Zimmerman, was found to have acted in justifiable self defense according to Florida law.
But only one man broke the law that night, and it was not George Zimmerman. I have written that much, if not all of the moral culpability for Martin’s death rests upon Zimmerman, but moral culpability and legal transgression are not the same thing.
As they say, everyone is entitled to his own opinion, but not his own facts. And the inconvenient fact of the night that Barack Obama ignored, along with all the others on the Left working feverishly to make Martin a national cause, is that Trayvon Martin committed a felony immediately before he died.
Zimmerman never attacked Martin. It was Martin who committed felony assault and battery when he violently attacked Zimmerman, pinned him to the ground and began pounding his head into the sidewalk.
With all due respect to Rev. Sensing we don’t actually know that. All we really know is that George Zimmerman shot and killed Trayvon Martin and that he was acquitted of murdering him on the grounds of self defense. It’s a reasonable inference, based on a single person’s eyewitness testimony and forensic evidence, i.e. just slightly beyond what we actually know, that Trayvon Martin “pinned him to the ground and began pounding his head into the sidewalk”.
But we don’t know that Trayvon Martin committed a felony because we don’t know the antecedent events any more than we know that George Zimmerman racially profiled Trayvon Martin or that Trayvon Martin was just walking back from the store.
It might well be that, had charges been brought against him, Trayvon Martin would have been acquitted of assault. Or not. We just don’t know. Thinking that we do know, as I said in that earlier post, is in our heads.
The Chicago Public Schools is laying off more than 2,000 people including more than 500 tenured teachers:
Citing a $1 billion budget deficit, Chicago Public Schools will lay off more than 2,000 employees, more than 1,000 of them teachers, the district said Thursday night.
About half of the 1,036 teachers being let go are tenured. The latest layoffs, which also include 1,077 school staff members, are in addition to 855 employees — including 420 teachers — who were laid off last month as a result of the district’s decision to close 49 elementary schools and a high school program.
This is exactly what I predicted when the strike was settled. It was baked into the settlement that included substantial pay increases. I can’t believe that the CTU could possibly have believed anything else. The situation was summarized succintly by the representative from the CPS:
CPS spokeswoman Becky Carroll said the district was “scraping the bottom” of reserves to provide financial relief and had made cuts in other spending before making layoffs.
“We’re not going to be able to cut our way out of this crisis,” Carroll said. “Our revenues are simply not keeping in line with our spending increases.”
That’s the modern day equivalent of Mr. Micawber’s famous lament:
Annual income twenty pounds, annual expenditure nineteen pounds nineteen and six, result happiness. Annual income twenty pounds, annual expenditure twenty pounds nought and six, result misery.
The situation in Chicago is manifestly unjust. Illinois’s contribution to public education, despite the mandate in the state’s constitution, is far too low. Illinois is 50th among the 50 states in the proportion of its contribution to education. Its contribution is about 20%—half that in most states. Chicagoans not only pay for the educations of Chicago’s children, the rest of the state’s children, and the pensions of retired Chicago public school teachers but the pensions of Illinois teachers outside of Chicago as well. People living in Barrington just pay for their own kids’ educations and part of the retirements of their kids’ teachers.
Steve Rattner pleads that Detroit must be saved:
America is just as much about aiding those less fortunate as it is about personal responsibility. Government does this in so many ways; why shouldn’t it help Detroit rebuild itself?
Many call for scaling back the city to fit realistic population projections. While logical, the potential for downsizing Detroit is limited because the city’s population didn’t flee from just one neighborhood; the departures were scattered, requiring Detroit to deliver services across a geographic area the size of Philadelphia, with less than half the population. Further cuts will surely come, but in some key areas, like public safety and blight removal, Detroit needs to spend more, not less.
That necessitates large-scale reductions in its liabilities, which total as much as $18 billion. By comparison, the country’s second largest municipal bankruptcy — that of Jefferson County, Ala., which is slightly smaller than Detroit in population — involves $4 billion of liabilities.
Detroit faces greater challenges than the automakers because the structure of its obligations is quite different from those of General Motors and Chrysler.
Detroit owes approximately $5.3 billion on debt that has first call on all water and sewer revenues, which means the holders of that debt have to the right to take as much of the water and sewer fees (after operating expenses) as are needed to service the debt.
The bulk of its obligations are to the grossly underfunded pension plans and for retiree health care costs — nearly half of the city’s total liabilities. The city has suggested that it cut these by 90 percent. Although retirees don’t have a lot of legal rights in the bankruptcy process, it is difficult to imagine — on either a human or a political level — an exit from bankruptcy that would include reductions of this magnitude.
The first duty to help lies with the state: Gov. Rick Snyder has made clear that Detroit’s success is key to Michigan’s success.
I’m not from Detroit. I didn’t grow up in Detroit. I don’t know a great deal about the city’s history. My plan would be very different from Mr. Rattner’s. It would be based on three principles:
The very first thing that needs to happen is that both the city of Detroit and the state of Michigan and citizens’ groups in both places need to stop trying to save Detroit. Reduce Detroit’s operating costs by redrawing Detroit’s city borders, condemning large portions through eminent domain, and razing the present structures in the large abandoned portions. Give unemployed Detroit residents jobs doing the work. What I have in mind is a Detroit that’s half to a third its present size. I couldn’t begin to draw the map. I think that should be left to people from Detroit and Michigan.
Sow the condemned area with native plants. Return most of it to green space.
Provide assistance to the people in the condemned areas so they’ll have somewhere to go and the wherewithal to go there.
Reduce the city’s workforce to be commensurate with a city of 700,000 people.
Convert the pension plan of the present public employees to a defined contribution plan. Make the contributions even if that requires state help.
Cap present public pensions. Pick a nice, round number, say, $100,000. That wouldn’t affect many people but it would be a start. Pick a number.
Reduce the pension benefits for current city retirees according to a formula that takes into account age, length of service, how much they are receiving, and whether they’re eligible for Social Security. It should be kept in mind that most retired public school teachers aren’t eligible for Social Security. Cutting a 70 year old retired teacher’s pension by 90% will throw him or her into penury. That’s not justice nor will it be a learning experience.
Mr. Rattner is wrong in completely absolving city workers from blame. They voted for years of fraud, corruption, and mismanagement and they should bear at least some of the costs of that. But let’s temper justice with mercy.
That’s a quick hipshot outline. I’m sure that more knowledgeable people can come up with a better, more detailed plan. But think about the premises of any rescue plan. Are we saving an outline on a map or people?
Yesterday President Obama gave a much commented on speech, spurred by the “Not Guilty” verdict the jury found in the case against George Zimmerman for the killing of Trayvon Martin. The Wall Street Journal was impressed:
Six days after a Florida jury acquitted a Hispanic man in the shooting death of an African-American teen, President Barack Obama made his first extensive comments on the case, speaking in personal terms about his own experience of being black in America.
” Trayvon Martin could have been me 35 years ago,” the president said in the remarks, made Friday during a surprise appearance in the White House press room. Mr. Martin, a 17-year-old African-American, was shot and killed in Florida last year in a case that riveted millions of Americans and sparked debate over the state of race relations in the country.
[ ]
But he tried to explain the lens through which black Americans may see the case, saying that their own experiences and the country’s history with race inform how many view what happened to Mr. Martin.
“There are very few African-American men who haven’t had the experience of walking across the street and hearing the locks click on the doors of cars,” Mr. Obama said. “That happens to me—at least before I was a senator.”
[ ]
On Friday, Mr. Obama noted that African-Americans are disproportionately victims as well as perpetrators of violence. And while he called for soul-searching on matters of race, he said he sees signs of improvement.
“Each successive generation seems to be making progress in changing attitudes when it comes to race,” he said. “It doesn’t mean that we’re in a postracial society. It doesn’t mean that racism is eliminated. But you know, when I talk to [daughters] Malia and Sasha and I listen to their friends and I see them interact, they’re better than we are.”
Chicago Tribune columnist John Kass wasn’t nearly so impressed:
Could Obama have been Trayvon Martin 35 years ago?
Perhaps. If so, then any of us could have been Trayvon Martin. And I could have been Trayvon Martin. Racial motives weren’t established at trial. And reportedly, the FBI still hasn’t found racial motives in George Zimmerman, who is Hispanic.
Race was established by the president of the United States, and by other political and media actors. It’s a cynical business, about money and power, about keeping divisions between American tribes. There are the black tribes that see Martin in the context of the old civil rights struggles and leverage, and white tribes that see Martin being used to pummel them with racial guilt.
The algebra of all of this is as old as some musty textbook in your uncle’s garage. We’ve seen it before. We’ve heard the lines, the formulations, the slogans, and some of us recite them the way we recite phrases from television commercials. We’re given just enough evidence and we’re told we must choose a side.
[ ]
By saying he could have been Trayvon Martin, President Obama bypassed the evidence and established his own motive. Only a maestro could accomplish this.
“I think it’s going to be important for all of us to do some soul searching,” Obama said, and I hope he included himself in the search.
“There has been talk about should we convene a conversation on race,” he continued. “I haven’t seen that to be particularly productive. When politicians try to organize conversations they end up being stilted and politicized, when folks are locked into the positions they already have.”
They get locked into positions with help from those who would ostensibly lead them away from ignorance and anger and fear. No one wins the game of tribes but the leaders.
To understand where I’m coming from I’ll need to pass on some anecdotes. The first is a conversation I had with a friend more than twenty years ago. We had invited a young couple for dinner at our home. They were, perhaps, the handsomest couple I’ve ever seen in terms of sheer physical beauty. He was black. She was Native American and Hispanic. I don’t remember the precise context but at one point my black friend said something that’s stuck with me. “What happens to you when you get on a bus? The exact same things may happen to you as happen to me but we won’t have the same experience.”
I suspect that every black kid in the country has had an experience with racism, whether actual dyed-in-the-wool racism, soft racism, or merely their own putting a racist spin on experiences I wouldn’t have interpreted through the lens of race. “She doesn’t want me because I’m black”. “They don’t like me because I’m black”. “I would have gotten a better grade if I hadn’t been black”. “I would have a job if I weren’t black”. From the standpoint of internalized experience does it make a difference whether those interpretations are true or not? I don’t think so.
Do I think that racism exists in the United States today? There’s no question of that in my mind. Do I think that every instance perceived as racism is actually racism? Absolutely not.
Here’s the second anecdote. My mom spent a good part of her life teaching poor black kids. Something she frequently said: “They believe the lie”.
Finally, one of my best friends in college was Hawaiian. When I was in grad school we roomed together for a while (more accurately: I slept on his couch for a month or so until I found an apartment of my own). Through him I met and befriended quite a number of Hawaiian kids at my alma mater. My friend had attended high school at Kamehameha and was, of course, native Hawaiian. Another friend, Lloyd, had attended Punahou, the school that would later be attended by the young Barry Obama. Lloyd was Japanese-American and his family was quite well-off.
In 1980 fewer than 1% of Hawaiian household had even one black member. There were very few African Americans in Hawaii, there was no black community there, Hawaii is extremely racially diverse, and Hawaii has no history of anti-black racism. I don’t believe that any of my Hawaiian friends had so much as seen an African American in person until they came to the mainland.
In Hawaii, Barack Obama was just one mixed race kid in a place where being of mixed race was not at all unusual. If he experienced racism, it was either when he came to the mainland or it was in his own head.
But that means that Barack Obama couldn’t have been the Trayvon Martin he’s imagining or, at least, he couldn’t have been in a sense different than I could have been.
I could never have been George Zimmerman. By the time I was George Zimmerman’s age I had taught judo and self defense for well over a decade and, not only was I strong in mind and body, defending myself by reading and avoiding trouble was ingrained in me as much as breathing. I have never felt the need to carry a firearm because I can defend myself with weapons that can’t be taken away from me.
But by the same token I could never have been Trayvon Martin. I would never have confronted George Zimmerman but even if I had once he was down I would have run away as fast as I could.
The facts as we know them of the Zimmerman-Martin case are that George Zimmerman shot and killed Trayvon Martin and that a jury acquitted him of any crime on the basis of self defense. Everything else is speculation. It’s the racism in our own minds and hearts.
The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.
The post announcing the results at the Watcher’s site is here