Why Have Healthcare Cost Increases Slowed?


That’s the question Robert Samuelson asks in his most recent Washington Post column:

In today’s contentious political climate, when hardly anyone agrees on anything, here’s a rare subject of consensus: Health spending is slowing, and almost everyone thinks that’s a good thing. Aside from relieving pressures on federal and state budgets, it could help reverse stagnant wages by moderating the cost of employer-paid insurance. Compensation would shift from insurance to wages. What the experts don’t agree on is who (or what) caused the slowdown and whether it will continue.

First, the basic figures. In each of 2009, 2010 and 2011, U.S. health spending increased a modest 3.9 percent, virtually identical with the slow growth of the economy (gross domestic product, or GDP). So health spending remained steady at 17.9 percent of GDP after years of increases. Almost no one predicted this.

There are practically as many answers to this question as there are people answering it. The Obama Administration and its staunch supporters, as you might expect, say that, of course, it’s ObamaCare. Others, like Samuelson, are skeptical. Explanations that have been offered include the recession and “structural changes”, e.g. use of less-expensive generic drugs, higher patient co-payments and deductibles, and lower administrative costs in doctors’ offices and hospitals.

I would also suggest that very slow increases in the Medicare reimbursement rate, the recession, and the higher patient co-pays and deductibles work synergistically to reduce the ability of providers to pass cost increases along which in turn incentivizes a search for ways to lower administrative costs, etc.

Some of the slowing may merely be a mathematical artifact. Healthcare spending continues to rise but as healthcare becomes a larger proportion of the economy the gap between the general rate of inflation and the rate of increase in healthcare costs narrows. With healthcare spending at 100% of the economy the two would be identical by definition.

In the final analysis Mr. Samuelson offers no answer in which we can have any confidence. Nobody knows. I do think it’s too early to declare victory.

12 comments

Meeting With Putin

It’s being reported that President Obama has cancelled bilateral talks between Russia and the United States scheduled for next month over Russia’s granting temporary asylum to Edward Snowden:

The Kremlin says it is “disappointed” the US cancelled bilateral talks in September, after Russia granted asylum to intelligence leaker Edward Snowden.

Russian President Vladimir Putin’s foreign affairs adviser said the move showed the US could not develop ties with Russia on an “equal basis”.

A White House aide said Mr Snowden’s asylum had deepened the pre-existing tension between the two counties.

I wanted to share a few thoughts on this move and ask a question:

  • The most important bilateral relationship in the world today is that between Russia and the United States.
  • Great powers cannot be bullied, shamed, or manipulated into acting against what is perceived as their national interests.
  • Russia is a great power.
  • For the last two decades American presidents have systematically miscalculated in their management of the U. S.-Russian relationship.
  • Russia has interests of its own. Just as the United States does.
  • Russia and the United States have more interests in common than we have conflicts.

Russia’s granting temporary asylum to Snowden makes complete sense in the context of European politics and in the context of domestic Russian politics. Now here’s my question.

Why does the president’s decision make sense?

21 comments

Foreign Policy Blogging at OTB

I’ve just published a foreign policy-related post at Outside the Beltway:

Crazy Pants, the Embassy Closings, and Star Wars Reboots

Passing on a McClatchy article I found amusing. IMO the embassy closings are due to some combination of prudence, over-reaction, and political calculation. We just don’t know enough to conjecture about the proportions.

1 comment

Rich and Fat

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention have issued a report finding that the obesity rate among American pre-schoolers has declined since 2008:

In recent years there have been small but significant decreases in childhood obesity. The finding that 19 states/territories experienced a decrease in obesity among low-income preschoolers, a vulnerable population, adds to recent findings from local data of low-income preschoolers (10,11) and studies observing decreases among children with higher socioeconomic status (SES) (12). The specific factors that might have contributed to the differential changes in obesity prevalence by state could not be readily identified. States likely differ by cultural and other factors that affect diet, activity, and weight as well as the implementation of policy and environmental interventions used to improve nutrition and physical activity. For example, reductions in obesity prevalence might reflect a combination of contributing factors, such as local and state initiatives that focus on the implementation of nutrition and physical activity standards for early care and education (ECE) programs (13) and efforts to improve healthier food options and physical activity offerings in communities (14). Federal policy changes such as the alignment of the WIC package of nutritious foods with the Dietary Guidelines for Americans (15) might have led to improved diets among low-income preschool children and their families. Population-level changes in behavior such as increases in breastfeeding (16) also might have contributed to declines in obesity.

The children included in the report are limited to those from low income families who participated in federal nutrition programs, it only included states who consistently reported PedNSS (Pediatric Nutrition Surveillance Program) data, and the families of those participating in such programs were demographically somewhat different from those prior to 2008. Specifically, the children tended to be older, a smaller proportion were non-Hispanic whites, and a larger proportion were non-Hispanic blacks. No mention is made of the relative proportions of Hispanic kids between the pre-2008 and later cohorts.

I find this report interesting and suggestive but certainly not dispositive. I’m skeptical of their explanations for the differences and can’t help but wonder if demographics and changes in the perception as well as the actuality of income and economic conditions aren’t more important than the factors they suggest. We have good reason to believe, for example, that racial and ethnic differences in obesity persist after controlling for differences in family income, that there are differences in obesity rates among whites, blacks, and Hispanics, and that income is negatively correlated with obesity in white adults, weakly correlated with obesity in Hispanic and black female adults, and positively correlated with obesity in black male adults.

I can’t help but wonder if changes in behavior unrelated to education or other government programs aren’t more important in whatever change has occurred. Has uncertainty about the future made people more cautious about spending money than they were prior to the recession? Have the reported demographic changes also had some effect?

7 comments

A World Without Locks

When I was a kid leaving your house or car doors unlocked was a commonplace. That’s one of the many things that have changed, forever and not for better, over the years. Imagine a world in which there are, in effect, no locks because they just don’t function any more. This article explains why mechanical locks may soon be rendered ineffective:

“If we show that mechanical locks are vulnerable to key duplication just by having a handful of numbers you can download off the internet, hopefully they ‘ll be phased out more quickly… Either that or make 3D printers illegal,” warns Eric Van Albert, a 21-year-old engineering student at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) in an interview with Forbes, following his keynote at Def Con 21.

Along with fellow student and researcher David Lawrence, Mr. Van Albert showed off a software tool that used scans from a flatbed scanner of a highly advanced “secure” key design to create a 3D model of the key and then duplicate it via online printing services Shapeways (nylon; $5 USD) and i.Materialise (titanium: $150 USD).

Meanwhile, electronic high-security locks have long been known to be easily defeatable:

Toby Bluzmanis and Matt Fiddler are at it again.

The three, who have made numerous headlines for bumping and picking Medeco high-security locks and other brands, have now succeeded to crack state-of-the-art, CLIQ technology electro-mechanical high-security locks.

They showed Threat Level how they could easily bypass the electronic portion of the locks and thwart audit logs that track who opens a lock and when. They provided the demonstration in advance of a presentation they’re giving at the DefCon hacker conference here on Sunday, with the caveat that Threat Level not disclose certain details about how they defeated the locks. (View edited video on Tobias’ web site.)

The hacks are low-tech and don’t involve attacking the actual electronic component of the lock. Instead, they use standard techniques for opening mechanical locks, similar to bumping — where an attacker places a specially-designed key in the keyway and “bumps” it repeatedly with a device until the lock releases.

“These [locks] are used in some high-security facilities,” Tobias said. “And the makers tout the fact that this is the ultimate in security. And they shouldn’t be saying that.”

The locks cost between $600 and $800 apiece, with keys costing about $95 each.

They’re used in government buildings, banks, and critical infrastructures, such as power and water plants and transportation facilities. The Swiss Federal Railway System uses them as does the Ottawa International Airport in Canada.

Ah, brave new world! When the technology of lock-breaking proceeds faster than the technology of new locks, locks have become ineffective.

1 comment

Does Redistribution Slow Economic Growth?

I disagree with what is apparently the thesis of a book reviewed at City Journal, that food stamps, unemployment benefits, and other federal, state, and local support programs have resulted in less economic activity than might otherwise have been the case:

But as University of Chicago professor Casey Mulligan’s shocking book, The Redistribution Recession, makes clear, going on food stamps is hardly unusual any more. With their loosened eligibility requirements and expanded benefits, food stamps and a host of other federal and state programs are undermining traditional incentive structures—and keeping the nation’s unemployment rate stubbornly high. A preeminent labor-market economist, Mulligan presents extensive research into these labor-market “distortions”—the way that policy interposes itself between prospective employers and employees—since 2008. Ordinarily, such heavily quantitative research is the province of economics journals. In this case, the findings deserve a broader audience.

That’s not to say that I don’t think that policy is producing distortions that reduce economic policy. We’re redistributing from young to old in the form of Social Security benefits and Medicare, from just about every other sector to the healthcare sector via Medicare, Medicaid, and other healthcare subsidies, from every other sector to the defense sector through defense spending, and from savers to borrowers (not to mention the banking industry) through the measures adopted during the financial crisis that sparked off the Great Recession. That’s just a few of the ways in which we’re redistributing and IMO their sheer volume dwarfs any economic distortions produced by food stamps.

Indeed, I see the history of our economy over the last several decades very, very differently from what’s being implied in the post. I think that what we’ve seen is that sectors that are subsidized or protected survive while sectors that aren’t similarly favored decline or stall. I don’t think that unemployment insurance is causing the percentage of people employed to shrink—just look at the large number of long-term unemployed, mostly ineligible for unemployment insurance payments at this point (although some of those have now gone on to Social Security Disability). I think that a slack job market is mostly the cause rather than the effect and that we’ve got a buyer’s market in employment due to trade, monetary, immigration, and social policy decisions that have been made over the period of the last forty years.

Those are some headwinds.

9 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The announcement post at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments

Will Chicago Be Next?

The New York Times takes note of Chicago very serious public pension problems:

Among the nation’s five largest cities, Chicago has put aside the smallest portion of its looming pension obligations, according to a study issued this year by the Pew Charitable Trusts. Its plans were funded at 36 percent by the end of 2012, city documents say. Federal regulators would step in if a corporate pension fund sank to that level, but they have no authority over public pensions.

Chicago’s troubles, experts say, were years in the making. They are the result of city contributions under a state-authorized formula that failed to accumulate nearly enough money, two economic downturns in the 2000s that led to heavy investment losses, and an impasse in the State Capitol despite urgent calls to cut costs of the state’s own pension system. Illinois, which has the most underfunded state pension system in the nation, controls Chicago’s benefit and funding levels.

In Springfield, which, like Chicago, is controlled by Democrats, leaders have clashed over how best to cut costs of the plans — a notion that pits the lawmakers against labor unions, which have traditionally been allies.

This particular article highlights a number of the important issues behind Chicago’s pension woes. It’s easy to remain politically popular when you deliver services without asking that people pay for them. When you offer deferred compensation to public employees in the form of pensions and retiree healthcare benefits and similarly defer paying into the funds from which those benefits will be paid, everybody’s happy. For a while. But eventually that money will need to be paid back and that’s where Chicago is today. Eventually is now.

Neither Chicago’s nor Illinois’s problems can be laid at the feet of the evil Republicans who haven’t controlled the state’s government in well over a decade or the city’s in generations. There’s no political gain to be had for Democrats here. Meanwhile, the Democrats in the state legislature have fecklessly maximized Republican power by continually deferring the hard decisions on public pensions until the veto session.

The article repeatedly holds out the option of “raising taxes”. Raising tax rates and raising tax revenues are two different things. Chicago does not have the power to levy an income tax. It could raise the sales tax rate, already the highest in the country, but recent experience suggests that won’t actually raise any revenue. Lower sales taxes are just a short drive away. Or a mouse click.

The city has just about tapped out its ability to increase property tax rates without direct popular approval and getting that approval at the ballot box is not guaranteed.

The revenue-based solution for Chicago depends on the state paying much more of the freight, particularly in education where Illinois is 50th among the 50 states in the state’s contribution to education. Chicago has carried more than its fair share for decades while downstate Democrats have steadfastly refused to change. Presumably, they’re in fear of their own jobs.

Cutting pensions or retirement benefits is prohibited by the state’s constitution. The avenue that leaves open is reducing the compensation of present employees and, as you might expect, they’re not happy about it, viz. Chicago’s teachers’ strike last year. I suppose the converse of G. B. Shaw’s wisecrack that “when you rob Peter to pay Paul you can always depend on the support of Paul” is that Peter won’t think much of it but that pretty well summarizes the present state of affairs here.

Although Chicago isn’t in the dire, rundown condition that Detroit is, it’s possible that municipal bankruptcy may be Chicago’s best alternative. Better sooner than later.

12 comments

No Strategic Victory

I disagree with much of what’s in Bret Stephens’s column this morning but I agree with this:

Specifically: Mr. Obama believed that killing Osama bin Laden was a strategic victory. In fact, it was mainly a symbolic one (further undercut by his use of it as a political prop). He thought that ending the war in Iraq would help refocus U.S. efforts on Afghanistan. In fact, it showcased America’s lack of staying power and gave the Taliban additional motivation to hold out during the president’s halfhearted Afghan surge. He thought that substituting the Bush administration’s approach to detainees with an approach heavy on drones would earn America renewed goodwill on the Arab street. In fact, there was no goodwill to renew in the first place, and the U.S. is more unpopular in Pakistan and Egypt today than it was six years ago.

One of the weaknesses of our system of government is that nearly every administration comes into the White House as amateurs. Nowhere is that so obvious as in foreign policy.

Our weakness does have a compensating strength: ineffective grand strategies need not be permanent and an opportunity for change is always right around the corner.

If only our presidents would learn by their predecessors’ failures rather than insisting on recapitulating them!

6 comments

Infrastructure “Investment”

History profs Larry Schweikart and Burton Folsom make an interesting point: infrastructure spending is a lagging indicator of private capital investment rather than a leading one. I think it’s probably both. The interstate highway system may have been the political response to decades of private investment in automobiles and automobile production capacity but it also spurred lots of new private capital investment, this time in real estate.

My complaint about government investment is that it is so often a device for picking winners and losers and, mirabile dictu, the winners are very often political allies, donors, and rainmakers.

As for our infrastructure needs, IMO we’re enormously over-built as it is. Every city with a population over 100,000 is already served by an interstate and building until we serve every town with a population over 50,000 will bring practically no economic benefit. The same is true of building yet another bridge across the Mississippi. There are already more than 150 of them.

What we have now is a maintenance problem gravely aggravated by the over-building. Before we plow more billions into infrastructure we might want to think about what we actually want and need. And spend a moment thinking what we would need if we weren’t subsidizing the use of all of that infrastructure.

13 comments