Disapproval

President Obama’s approval rating, based on the RCP average of polls has declined almost consistently since December of last year and is nearing its lowest ebb since he took office in 2009. I don’t know whether this means that he’s due for a recovery or, if he follows the pattern of most presidents, whether it will continue to decline. His disapproval rating is greater than 50% and that’s significant.

The polls most supportive of him are a month old. If they’re replaced by newer polls less favorable to him, as has been the pattern, his approval rating will decline even farther over the next several weeks.

1 comment

The Incentives

I have some nitpicks with Jeffrey Dorfman’s op-ed at RealClearMarkets but I think the basic message is on target. Let me summarize it in one sentence. The “mortgage meltdown” of 2008 was caused by all parties acting in a way consistent with the incentives they had.

Unfortunately, the incentives in the mortgage market are designed in such a way as to create exactly the type of mortgage market meltdown we recently experienced.

When you apply for a mortgage you deal with a mortgage broker. Even at most banks, the person you deal with has multiple sources of funds. Each source has provided the mortgage broker with an amount of money to lend, a set of rules to qualify for a mortgage, and interest rates to charge based on credit worthiness. The mortgage broker hopefully pairs you with the best mortgage deal given your circumstances. When the loan is approved and closes, the mortgage broker gets paid a commission.

That means the broker’s incentive is to close the deal and collect the commission. Whether the borrower makes payments on the mortgage is irrelevant to the mortgage broker. This was not lost on the mortgage brokers who stretched and bent rules in some cases in order to get deals done.

It wasn’t just the mortgage brokers. It was the ratings agencies, the banks, the mortgage bankers, the buyers, the sellers, the borrowers, the lenders, the local, state, and federal governments. Everyone was doing the prudent thing based on the incentives that were in place.

The incentives haven’t changed. That’s been my gripe for the last five years. I think that at the very least one of the ratings companies needed to be executed to encourage the others. Why we have private rating agencies at all is something that eludes me.

4 comments

Origins of Ross-Loos

Ross-Loos is a group medical practice founded in 1929 in Los Angeles by two physicians, Donald E. Ross and H. Clifford Loos, older brother of writer Anita Loos. From Wikipedia:

The founders believed that health care could be improved by combining prepayment of services, eliminating the financial barriers faced by patients at the time of needed care, with the sharing of medical records and the ease of consultation in a medical group. The focus was on the improvement of medical care quality, rather than financial success, and many of the concepts in these plans built on a public health approach that encouraged prevention. These plans included prenatal care, well-baby visits, and immunizations in standard benefit packages, with small or no copayments, in an era when even the hospital costs of maternity stays were often excluded from traditional insurance.

Whatever happened to that idea?

6 comments

Cruel Or Unusual Punishment

There’s a wisecrack that’s apparently making the rounds in Russia that I thought was so good I had to pass it on. For his crimes against the American state, the Americans have sentenced Edward Snowden to the worst punishment they could think of: living in Russia.

Very Russian.

Hat tip: Snoopy

2 comments

The Post’s Lament

Like many of the Washington Post’s columnists, Robert Samuelson certainly sounds as though he’s in a complete panic over Amazon.com’s founder Jeff Bezos’s purchasing of the venerable DC paper, announced last week. He writes:

For years, The Post enjoyed a quasi-monopoly of largely captive readers and advertisers. Now it faces the Internet’s Darwinian hyper-competition. In text and video come torrents of news, information, analysis, advocacy, comedy and criticism. People do not lack for things to read, but the quality is spotty and often unreliable. Good journalism, though hardly perfect, strives to discredit misinformation and half-truths. Papers such as The Post contribute to a free society by undertaking the expensive reporting that others won’t — and which informs us of who we are.

But it’s not free. It rests on editorial independence — the ability to pursue stories no matter how inconvenient — and commercial success. Someone has to pay the bills. Bezos’s task is to respect editorial independence and restore its economic base. He has defied naysayers before. Maybe he will again. Good luck.

He’s right. Good reporting isn’t free. Even bad reporting isn’t free and, sadly, what we’ve been getting for decades is increasingly bad reporting.

Since UPI started pulling in its horns thirty years ago, the Associated Press, whose syndicated articles contain much of the reporting that’s done by a U. S.-based organization, has become complacent. More press releases from interested organizations are being published as news articles. That’s not reporting. It’s dictation.

The Internet, broadly, is no threat to major newspapers and in giving the back of their hands to it, newspapers have targeted the wrong enemy. Blogs aren’t the enemies of reporting. What blogs have done is demonstrated that good writing is not the exclusive province of major newspapers and that, in turn, is a broadside against syndicated columnists rather than reporters. Just about all you’ve needed to become a syndicated columnist is a bachelors degree from Harvard. Contrary to their apparent beliefs, not all smart people went to Harvard and not all people who went to Harvard are smart.

The real threat to the newspapers is not the Internet or blogs or Facebook. It’s Craigslist. If professional journalism wants to attack something, that’s what they should attack. There is no doubt in my mind that Craigslist is vulnerable to attack and a good reporter would be on it like a tick on a dog’s butt.

But rather than looking for external enemies whether the Internet or blogosphere or Jeff Bezos or Craigslist, why not do a little self-examination? I think there are some questions that people in the field should be asking themselves.

What’s the proper relationship between a reporter and a “highly-placed source”? At what point do papers stop “afflicting the comfortable” and start licking their butts?

Is there really a role for a national daily journal of opinion? I don’t believe there is but all of the major contestants seem to be vying for the title.

Why is U. S. professional journalism so flaccid? That’s obvious to anybody who reads foreign newspapers.

What is the role of leveraged buyouts in the decline of big news dailies? I think it’s major. Local weeklies don’t appear to be in the same state of decline as the big dailies are and one of the major differences between the two is that the big dailies have been bought up by news conglomerates and saddled with the debt incurred in the purchase. That and that local weeklies don’t big salaries to reporters, columnists, editors, or publishers. The weeklies of which I have direct knowledge are largely staffed by what are to some degree volunteers.

Would greater diversity of opinion among the reporters, columnists, editors, and staff of newspapers actually produce better news reporting? Today’s newspapers are notoriously monocultural. Remember that newspapers shape the news not merely by what is reported but by what is not reported and that in turn is influenced by the views of the people who work there from the top on down. I don’t just mean Republicans and Democrats. Why aren’t there open avowed socialists? Libertarians? Islamists? Because it would be indiscreet and make people uncomfortable? What the heck kind of journalism is that?

13 comments

You Call That Dangerous?

When I read this list of the most dangerous roads I could only think that obviously the folk who compiled the list had never driven the Dan Ryan after midnight.

5 comments

Pick Your Delusion

The editors at Bloomgberg, explaining why public pensions are “everybody’s problem”:

The pension liabilities that helped bankrupt Detroit have cast a harsh light on similar problems in Chicago and other large American cities, adding urgency to the question of who should close the shortfall. This is a challenge that public-sector workers and retirees shouldn’t bear on their own.

almost immediately get off on the wrong foot with this prescription:

First, governments need to stop lying to themselves. Money that’s slated to cover annual pension and health-care fund contributions but is instead siphoned away to cover other costs won’t magically reappear in later budgets. In the future, states and cities should agree only to benefit packages that are based on reasonable rates of return and annual contributions they can actually make — and then make them.

which is itself delusional. Telling governments or politicians to start by not lying is like telling a major league pitcher that the way to improve his game is to cut off his arms. They depend on lying. Promising to put a chicken in every pot is as old as the republic if not as old as The Republic. That’s how politicians are elected to office and stay there.

I don’t disagree entirely with their second prescription:

No matter how gracefully such changes can be accomplished, it won’t be fair to expect workers and retirees to be the only ones to sacrifice. After all, they are not the people who set the unaffordable policies in the first place.

Some jurisdictions will have to help meet their pension obligations by cutting spending elsewhere, finding new revenue or both. Those steps won’t be popular, but this is a shortfall too large to close easily or cheaply.

but that doesn’t seem to be the question right now. At least in Illinois and in Michigan the question is whether public employees should sacrifice at all.

I think that pragmatically states must be involved. Municipalities are not sovereign and without action from their states they won’t be able to escape the obligations they’ve undertaken however foolishly that was done. The real question is how will the “shared sacrifice” be apportioned?

If I were king, the accounting would be, in descending order of responsibility, the elected officials who agreed to the non-deliverable promises in the first place, public employees, the voters and taxpayers of the cities with the problems, the voters and taxpayers of the states containing those cities, and, finally, all of us.

That’s my delusion. Those most accountable will never be held to account.

7 comments

Why I Don’t Think That Comparisons With Europe Are Helpful

This post is a quick explanation of why I don’t think that using European models of immigration policy are particularly useful in thinking about our own circumstances. The graphic above illustrates GNI per capita in constant dollars for Mexico, Turkey, and Egypt. Click on the graphic for a larger version. It doesn’t constitute cherry-picking—whichever growth model you might use tells very much the same story: growth in Mexico has proceeded considerably faster than growth in Turkey or Egypt although since 2000 Turkey has grown considerably.

Most U. S. immigration comes from Mexico. Most European immigration doesn’t. Their natural sources for immigration are mostly Africa, the Middle East, and, to some extent particularly in the United Kingdom, West and South Asia.

Now, consider a few facts. No European country shares a 1,500 mile border with a country with a median per capita income a third of its own. Our last experience with a “path to citizenship”, admittedly 30 years ago, was that only a minority of Mexican citizens in the United States made eligible to become American citizens did so. International travel and communication has become easier over the years and that includes between Mexico and the United States. Mexico is much wealthier than it used to be and its economy is growing robustly. Finally, the demographics of Latin America and the Caribbean, including Mexico, suggests that Mexico no longer has as large a surplus of young workers as it used to.

The story I would tell about Mexican immigration to the United States goes something like this. For many years, as much as a century or longer, there has been considerable immigration from Mexico to the United States, mostly in the form of migrant workers and depending on economic conditions in both countries. It’s been a way of life. From the point of view of both Mexican workers and U. S. employers, the border might just as well not have existed. People came; they returned home.

The tighter we made border security, the higher it increased the costs to the workers of crossing the border, the more likely it became that they would stay here rather than returning home regularly. That’s essentially the explanation given by Princeton scholar Doug Massey. Far from putting down roots here I suspect that a lot of Mexican workers are maintaining closer ties with the family back home in Mexico than ever before. The exceptions to this are probably individuals brought here as children by their parents, the so-called “DREAM-ers”. Improving economic conditions in Mexico make returning to Mexico more attractive.

Contrast that with the situation in Europe. The demographics and economics of the Middle East, North Africa, sub-Saharan AFrica, and West Asia are completely different from the conditions in Mexico. There’s practically no reason for those who’ve made it to the vastly better conditions in Europe to return home once they’ve arrived.

1 comment

Sure They Can

Hussein Ibish, senior fellow of the American Task Force on Palestine, makes the argument at The National that Arabs can’t blame America for everything:

Anti-Americanism, a ubiquitous feature of contemporary Arab political culture, arises from an insidious and deeply- ingrained concept: the myth of American omnipotence.

Thus the will of the United States becomes the default explanation for everything that happens in the Middle East, particularly when people don’t like it.

Can’t blame the U. S. for everything? Sure they can.

Dr. Ibish attributes the present condition of reflexive anti-Americanism to traditional antipathy to the “Christian West”, and “disillusionment and perceived betrayal by an ideal, combined with a wild overestimation of US power”. I think he leaves out an important component: misdirection.

Over the last millennium Arabs have been colonized by other Arabs, Turks, the French, the Spanish, the Italians, the British, and Israelis. They have never been colonized by the United States or, at least, any definition by which Americans can reasonably be said to have colonized Arabs would also apply to the Russians, Chinese, and just about any other country that trades or has any other contact with Arab countries.

This is not to say that we haven’t had colonies. We colonized the Philippines, Hawaii, Haiti, Cuba, and other U. S. possessions in the Caribbean and Pacific. It’s also arguable that the United States west of the Mississippi was colonized by the United States. Just no Arab countries. How, then, can the ire be explained?

I would attribute it to two factors. First, I think there has been a conscious strategy of associating the United States with the “Christian West” by elites in Arab countries to distract attention away from themselves and maintain their own power and by people in the United States for reasons that aren’t entirely clear to me. We’ve taken up the “white man’s burden”. God knows why.

Second, I think that the U. S.’s version of Realpolitik, which includes, for example, our support of Saddam Hussein in Iraq’s war with Iran, has tended to support Arab autocrats for the last seventy or so years. And we’ve supported Israel for the last forty or so years. I don’t think we have been well-served by Realpolitik. I don’t think we’re good at it. We are too conflicted. Every so often a little glimmer of idealism breaks through, reflecting the diverse views within the United States, and that tends to make others see us as insincere and hypocritical.

5 comments

O Brave New World!

You know the world must really be a fascinating place for people who refuse to accept evidence, experience, history, incentives, or logic to explain what goes on here. Alternately surprising and frightening.

Just for the record I don’t think that evidence, experience, history, incentives, or logic are dispositive but I do think they are highly suggestive. History doesn’t repeat itself but it does rhyme.

0 comments