Winning vs. Governing

Here are the percentages of the popular vote won by the victorious presidential candidate in the post-war period:

Election year Percent
2012 51.1%
2008 52.9%
2004 50.7%
2000 47.9%
1996 49.2%
1992 43.0%
1988 53.4%
1984 58.8%
1980 50.8%
1976 50.1%
1972 60.7%
1968 43.4%
1964 61.1%
1960 49.7%
1956 57.4%
1952 55.2%
1948 49.6%

Under our electoral system to become president a candidate must receive a majority of the electoral votes and, occasionally, that can result in a candidate who wins less than half of the popular vote being elected president. I’ve highlighted those cases in red. As you can see, George W. Bush, Bill Clinton, Richard Nixon, John Kennedy, and Harry Truman were all elected by minorities of the popular vote. Clinton never won a majority of the popular vote.

Based on popular vote percentage Lyndon Johnson was the most popular president of the post-war period. That he is an unperson now is at least partially based on his lack of popularity among Baby Boomers, many of whom were single issue non-voters when he was elected. He’s followed in popular vote percentage by Richard Nixon then Ronald Reagan. Only Eisenhower and Reagan won two elections by increasing majorities of the popular vote. Obviously, popular vote percentage is only one of the factors behind how fractious a term can be.

Popular vote percentage may not determine who wins or loses but it does influence the freedom of action of a sitting president, what the president can do without attracting significant opposition. Lyndon Johnson had considerable freedom of action and he used it to pass the voting rights act, Medicare and Medicaid, the other Great Society programs, and to wage the Vietnam War. Bill Clinton, on the other hand, had difficulty in passing significant legislation and was ultimately impeached (but not removed from office).

Just as a reminder: I think that the president is the president of all of the people and not just of those who voted for him or her. When elected presidents receive the mandate to obey and enforce the law. To think otherwise is to agree with Nixon: if the president does it, it’s not against the law.

I also think that it is prudent for presidents to temper their actions in a way consistent with the percentage of the popular vote they receive. To do otherwise is to court not merely opposition from the Congress but impeachment.

3 comments

If There’s So Much Unemployment Why Are There So Many “Help Wanted” Ads?

In an op-ed in the Washington Month Peter Orszag, former Obama Director of the Office of Management and the Budget, ponders how with so much continuing unemployment the number of advertised job opening has risen by 50% while actual hiring has only increased by 5%? He suggests four reasons:

  1. Mismatch between the work that companies need done and the skills that workers have.
  2. Employers are offering jobs at wages that are too low to attract good applicants.
  3. The gap between job advertising and new hires reflects the growing use of companies’ “internal” labor markets.
  4. Companies have reduced their “recruiting intensity.” They advertise jobs but don’t have much interest in filling them.

I think his analysis is good and well worth reading and I suspect that all of those factors are at work to some degree. However, there are two more factors that Dr. Orszag might consider.

It may be the case that companies are unwilling to hire the long-term unemployed. The number of long-term unemployed admitted to by the Bureau of Labor Statistics is nearly 40% of the unemployed. Once you’ve taken into account the large number of long-term unemployed who have given up looking the actual percentage is undoubtedly larger.

It also might be the case that companies are fishing. In my field it used to be common practice both for employers and workers to put out feelers. Employers would advertise jobs with unrealistically high requirements and unrealistically low compensation to see what they’d get. Workers would apply for jobs making absurdly high wage demands to see what was out there.

In a buyer’s market or even what’s assumed to be a buyer’s market employers may be putting out feelers of this kind to see what’s out there, to test the wages they’re offering, and maybe get somebody who’s better for less money. By doing this they’re also bolstering their case that they need to import foreign workers because nobody in the domestic job market has the skills they need.

12 comments

Imagine

Over at RealClearPolitics Sean Trende poses an interesting question—what if Republicans aren’t that out-of-step ideologically?

It’s almost taken as a given that the Republicans are out of step with public opinion on a wide range of issues. The party is certainly out of step with elite Washington opinion — both Republican and Democratic elites, for that matter — but it isn’t clear that this holds true nationally (at least in terms of perception). More importantly, it isn’t clear that the issues that inside-the-Beltway types and high-information pundits obsess about matter much to the American people.

To really get at public opinion as it relates to elections, it probably isn’t best to isolate a few issues. Rather, let’s look at some omnibus measurements of the parties. For this, I will borrow from two excellent articles from political scientist John Sides. As Sides notes, YouGov asked respondents throughout 2012 to rate themselves ideologically, and to rate the candidates ideologically as well.

He proceeds to present a considerable amount of evidence that Americans don’t see the views of Republicans as being as extreme and divergent from their own as they do those of Democrats.

I think there’s more than one way to interpret the data and I’m in no position to determine which of them is correct. It could, indeed, be that Republicans’ views are more consistent with those of most Americans’ than Democrats’ are. Or it could be that the Republicans have done a much better sales job than the Democrats to convince people that they’re not wild-eyed fanatics. Or that Democrats have done a poor job of convincing people either that the Republicans are wild-eyed fanatics or that they aren’t. Or, for some inexplicable reason, it could be the case that Democrats are trying to convince people that the Democrats’ views aren’t consistent with those of most Americans.

However heinous you think the Republicans are I think it’s a valuable exercise to imagine the opposite. It might be you who’s out-of-step.

29 comments

Executive Overreach

The Obama Administration has been handed another setback, the latest in a long list:

In a major rebuke on Tuesday, the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals issued an unusual writ of mandamus, which is a direct judicial order compelling the government to fulfill a legal obligation. This “extraordinary remedy” is nominally about nuclear waste, writes Judge Brett Kavanaugh for the 2-1 majority, yet the case “raises significant questions about the scope of the Executive’s authority to disregard federal statutes.”

In re: Aiken County is another episode in the political soap opera about spent-fuel storage at Nevada’s Yucca Mountain, an Energy Department project that requires the approval of the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission. The Nuclear Waste Policy Act of 1983 requires that the NRC “shall consider” the license application for the repository and “shall issue a final decision approving or disapproving” it within three years of submission.

Yucca has since been infamously stop-and-go amid opposition from the green lobby and not-in-my-backyard Nevadans and Californians. This particular application was submitted to the NRC in June 2008.

Mr. Obama promised to kill Yucca as a candidate and the Energy Department tried to yank the license application after his election. But an NRC safety board made up of administrative judges ruled unanimously that this was illegal unless Congress passed a law authorizing it. Mr. Obama then teamed up with Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid of Nevada to stack the NRC with anti-Yucca appointees.

Although Congress appropriated money to conduct the review, the NRC flat-out refused, in violation of the three-year statutory deadline. “By its own admission, the Commission has no current intention of complying with the law,” writes Judge Kavanaugh, despite a 2011 ruling from a separate D.C. Circuit panel instructing the NRC to follow through. The ruling also invited Congress “to clarify this issue if it wished to do so.”

The problem is not a partisan or even an ideological one. The Obama Administration has experienced an abnormally large number of 9-0 Supreme Court decisions against it during its tenure.

The problem is one of executive overreach. Being elected president does not convey a mandate to do whatever you see fit. It conveys a mandate to enforce the law. And obey it.

2 comments

The Problem With Discretion

Wall Street Journal columnist Kimberley Strassel has been on the trail of the sole exemption from the mandate for refineries to purchase federal ethanol “credits” awarded this year. She’s identified the refinery:

The dispensation amounts to a significant financial favor to one lucky player, as I wrote in the Journal on Friday. Further reporting has revealed that the refinery is Alon USA Energy’s ALJ -0.49% Krotz Springs facility in Louisiana. There’s reason to wonder
why Krotz Springs alone got a deal.

The EPA maintains a program that allows “small refineries”—those with an average capacity of less than 155,000 barrels of crude daily—to apply for a hardship exemption from the mandate. Krotz Springs was one of four refineries that applied for 2013. The other three—Hunt Refining in Alabama, Kern Oil & Refining in California and Placid Refining in Louisiana—are small, privately held concerns. The biggest, Placid, has a capacity of about 57,000 barrels a day, according to January statistics from the federal Energy Information Administration.

Krotz Springs has a capacity of 80,000 barrels, so it meets the definition. Then again, Krotz Springs is just one of Alon’s five refineries, which are located in Louisiana, Texas and California, and have a combined capacity of about 215,000 barrels. A New York Stock Exchange-listed company, Alon isn’t exactly a mom-and-pop outfit.

As it turns out Alon, alone among the companies that applied for exemptions, was able to hire professional lobbyists to work the halls of power:

Lobbying disclosure records show Alon paid $60,000 in the second quarter of 2013 to the Manatt, Phelps & Phillips firm. This was the same quarter when Alon filed for its exemption. The records show that Manatt lobbied in the House and in the Senate for Alon on the sole issue of “renewable fuel standards.” Alon didn’t report any appreciable lobbying expenses for the year preceding the quarter. The records also did not turn up similar lobbying efforts by other refineries applying for an exemption.

If you are going to have such mandates and you determine to grant exemptions from them, the exemptions should be based on objective criteria. Not on discretion.

The company with the deepest pockets will inevitably be able to pay more to get their exemptions. That’s one of the reasons that corporate power is becoming so centralized. Natural economies of scale have less to do with it than the political advantages that scale confers.

Under the circumstances discretion is just another word for corruption.

0 comments

The Art of Crisis Maintenance

Felix Salmon, writing on Lawrence Summers as a candidate for chairman of the Federal Reserve:

In other words, when there’s a crisis, it really doesn’t matter whether you’re Ben Bernanke or Mervyn King or Jean-Claude Trichet — or Janet Yellen or Larry Summers or pretty much anybody else bar Rand Paul. The central banker’s crisis playbook is a thin document, and easy enough for anyone to master. It’s what central bankers do when there isn’t a crisis that matters, since they’re all going to do exactly the same thing when there is one.

More importantly, financial crises aren’t things which just happen, like asteroids or earthquakes. They have causes — which means that they can also be prevented. Crisis management is an important skill, and it’s one where Larry Summers has a lot of experience. But crisis prevention is the thing which really matters. Summers has demonstrated essentially zero crisis-prevention skills: his deregulatory instincts helped make the financial crisis more likely and more severe when it happened. Mark Carney, to take one obvious example, is a better central banker than Larry Summers will ever be, because he did something vastly more praiseworthy than managing a crisis: he prevented a crisis from ever happening in the first place.

As a result, Obama should be bending over backwards to appoint not the candidate who can best manage a financial crisis, but rather the candidate who is most likely to stop a crisis from happening in the first place. That candidate is Janet Yellen. (Or maybe Mark Carney, but he’s taken.)

Does Dr. Summers have what it takes to maintain a future state of crisis (which by nearly any reckoning he would have had a role in fomenting) for as long as possible? I think he does.

1 comment

Ripples from Umbrellas

For the first time in almost fifty years the other night I watched an hour or so of Jacques Demy and Michel Legrand’s jazz opera, The Umbrellas of Cherbourg. I found that all of the things I liked about it then I still liked and almost everything I disliked I still disliked.

It features an astonishingly beautiful young cast. At 20 Catherine Deneuve as Geneviève hadn’t metamorphosed into the rapturously gorgeous Catherine Deneuve she was to become and has remained but she was nonetheless a very pretty young girl. Nino Castelnuovo as Guy and Marc Michel as Roland, her two suitors, were equally pretty. I couldn’t believe that Anne Vernon as Madame Emery, Geneviève’s mother, was pushing 40. She looked to be scarcely out of her twenties herself and the role was a marked departure from the femmes fatales that were her staple roles in the 40s and 50s.

The movie has what was a very original and creative look and style. There’s not a spoken word of dialogue—all is recitative. The cartoon sets, bright, strong colors of sets and costumes, and beautiful cast remind me a bit of the romance newspaper comic strips of the time.

On the other hand the principal cast can’t sing, the score is repetitious, there’s a conflict between the highly naturalistic action and the movie’s style. Sort of like French New Wave meets Mary Worth.

I won’t spoil the ending for you by telling you the details of the plot. The slightly transgressive drivers of the action were handled immeasurably better in Fanny.

One thing I noticed and was somewhat surprised by was how indebted Baz Luhrmann was to Umbrellas. The semi-singing but beautiful cast, the surreal look, and the operatic character that are typical features of his movies, e.g. Moulin Rouge!, are all right there in Umbrellas. I guess there’s nothing new under the sun.

0 comments

A Very Brief History of Immunization

If you learned in school as I did that Edward Jenner invented immunization, you learned wrong. If you use an extremely narrow definition he probably invented vaccination but I’ll get back to that later.

Immunization by exposure to diseased persons or disease “material” goes back at least a millennium and is probably much older. There are attestations that the Chinese practiced “variolation”, a process by which smallpox scabs were blown up the noses of persons to prevent them from contracting the disease from at least as early as 1000 AD. By the 16th century the practice was widespread in the Far East, in India, throughout the Ottoman Empire, and in adjacent parts of Africa. Only Europe and the New World’s European colonies lagged behind and there is evidence that African slaves practiced variolation before their American masters did.

In 1717 Lady Mary Wortley Montagu, the wife of Edward Wortley Montagu, the British Ambassador to the Ottoman Empire, learned of the practice in Constantinople. When there was an outbreak of smallpox in London in 1721 Lady Montagu and the Princess of Wales engaged in an experiment in which they inserted smallpox “material”, i.e. scabs or pus, under the skin of prisoners and abandoned children and then exposed them to individuals with the disease. None contracted smallpox so it was deemed safe. It sometimes seems that medicine progresses one atrocity at a time.

In reality the fatality rate from variolation was about 3% compared with a fatality rate from smallpox contracted naturally of from 14% to 30%.

Edward Jenner was himself variolated and suffered from health repercussions from the treatment for the rest of his life. Jenner, apprenticed to a surgeon at 13, had noticed that milkmaids rarely contracted smallpox but frequently presented themselves for treatment for a similar but milder disease called “cowpox”. Farmers told him that cowpox prevented smallpox. In 1796 he inserted pus taken from a milkmaid’s cowpox lesion under the skin of his gardener’s young son and then exposed him to smallpox. He did not contract the disease. The material was called “vaccine” and the process by which it was administered “vaccination”, ultimately from the Latin, vacca, “cow”.

Vaccination proved so successful that it quickly spread through Europe and its colonies. In 1840 the British government banned variolation which had itself been known to produce smallpox outbreaks and made vaccination mandatory and free of charge.

In the 1870s Louis Pasteur, in working on chicken cholera, discovered that weakened versions of the pathogens worked as well as the fresh, live ones in producing immunization. Nowadays “killed” vaccines are much common than live ones. Pasteur developed vaccines for chicken cholera, rabies, and anthrax, just to name a few. He earned the enmity of physicians by a) being a chemist a b) urging them to wash their hands, something that remains a problem today.

Jonas Salk famously developed a vaccine for polio in 1954.

Today there are vaccines for hundreds of different diseases. When I was a kid vaccinations for diphtheria, tetanus, pertussis, and smallpox were compulsory. When I was in school the polio vaccine, too, became compulsory. I knew kids who had polio, something not nearly so common today and there’s little doubt that the successful vaccine is the explanation.

In Illinois today not only are the vaccines I was required to take required but also vaccines that weren’t available when I was a kid—measles, rubella, mumps, haemophilus influenzae type b, hepatitis type b, and chicken pox—are compulsory.

Immunization has never been without risks and has always been the subject of controversy. Recently, opposition to vaccination, popularized by celebrities, has probably resulted in new outbreaks of pertussis. I attribute it to ignorance of history, science and, particularly, statistics.

Note: in doing the research for this post I learned that in the 15th century medical treatises occasionally took the form of epic poems. Those were the days!

12 comments

The Homeopathic Theory of Healthcare Reform

In homeopathy any of a variety of animal, plant, or mineral substances are diluted in alcohol or distilled water and vigorously shaken. The process is repeated to extreme dilutions, sometimes until not even a single molecule of the original substance may remain in the final preparation. Those who believe that such extreme dilutions remain potent posit a mechanism known as “water memory” by which the water “remembers” the original substance. No scientific study to date has unambiguously shown any individual homeopathic preparation to be more effective than placebo.

A story is now making the rounds as reported here by The Hill that the Obama Administration has quietly delayed the provision of the PPACA that would limit out-of-pocket insurance costs for consumers until 2015:

The Obama administration has delayed a key provision in President Obama’s healthcare reform law that would limit out-of-pocket insurance costs for consumers until 2015.

The cap, which includes deductibles and co-payments, was supposed to limit consumer costs to $6,350 for an individual and $12,700 for a family. But administration officials have quietly delayed the requirement for some insurers, allowing them to set their own limits starting in 2014.

The delay has been outlined on the Labor Department’s website since February, but went largely unnoticed.

Writing at Forbes Avik Roy notes:

First, there was the delay of Obamacare’s Medicare cuts until after the election. Then there was the delay of the law’s employer mandate. Then there was the announcement, buried in the Federal Register, that the administration would delay enforcement of a number of key eligibility requirements for the law’s health insurance subsidies, relying on the “honor system” instead. Now comes word that another costly provision of the health law—its caps on out-of-pocket insurance costs—will be delayed for one more year.

To that I would add that more than 1,200 companies have received waivers from various aspects of ObamaCare’s provisions, some on quite questionable grounds.

The Administration’s various moves have been criticized on a wide variety of grounds including whether the president actually has the authority to adjust the law as he has without the agreement of Congress, whether the reasons for the various moves are more political than pragmatic, and so on.

My question is somewhat different. Isn’t there some level of dilution of healthcare reform beyond which it is no longer effective? Or at which cost control vanishes? Is there some kind of homeopathic theory under which the law will retain its potency regardless of how it’s delayed, waived, or modified via some sort of legislative memory?

10 comments

CSI: Florence

Italian researchers are applying the tools of modern forensic science in an attempt at solving an ancient mystery—the identity of the woman painted by Leonardo Da Vinci in his famous “Mona Lisa”, also known as “La Gioconda”:

The remains of del Giocondo, his son by Gheradini — Piero — and Gheradini’s stepson Bartolomeo have been uncovered in their family crypt, the authority of Florence has announced.

A team led by Silvano Vinceti accessed the remains beneath the Chapel of the Holy Martyrs, in Florence on August 6, it said in a statement.

Last year, Vinceti’s team exhumed the remains of eight women from the ruins of a Franciscan convent in Florence where old city records said Gheradini had been buried.

A laboratory at the University of Bologna had established that three of the skeletons at the St. Ursula convent were consistent with the age at which Gheradini had died, the statement said.

Further carbon testing to establish which of those skeletons dated from the 16th century — when Gheradini died — was being carried out at the University of Salento, it quoted Vinceti as saying.

If DNA taken from the del Giocondo family remains matched one of the skeletons found in the convent ruins, the skeleton could be confirmed as Gheradini’s, he said.

Scientists could then reconstruct Gheradini’s face and compare it to da Vinci’s mysterious portrait.

1 comment