They Don’t Get It

The editors of the Chicago Tribune just don’t understand the administration’s actions with respect to ObamaCare:

Democrats strong-armed Obamacare into law three years ago. Now they’re busy flouting it.

The mandate that employers provide insurance next year or pay a penalty, as the law requires? Delayed for at least a year.

The law’s dictate that people applying for federal subsidies to buy insurance provide proof that they’re eligible for the government aid? Scaled back.

Sharp limits on Americans’ out-of-pocket costs for health care? Suspended for a year.

Providing members of Congress and more than 10,000 staff members with federal health care subsidies that the law does not allow? Done, via a deal brokered by President Barack Obama.

And on and on.

As I’ve said before the administration clearly has a very different view of law than the Trib’s editors do. The law is merely the raw material of the policy. It will be reshaped and reworked by regulation, executive diktat, and selective enforcement to make the unworkable work. I think that was always the plan.

5 comments

Foreign Policy Blogging at OTB

I’ve just published a couple of foreign policy-related posts at Outside the Beltway:

Baby, Come Back

Do we really want to return Americans troops to the meatgrinder in Iraq?

Congrega Ut Regnes

The habit of world leaders who are actually showing leadership.

0 comments

What’s the Harm?

Writing at Balkinization, Frank Pasquale outlines the harm that can come from the systematic massive surveillance being carried on in the name of security:

To make this more concrete: note that the US’s intelligence apparatus has already extensively monitored libertarians and peace activists. According to the Partnership for Civil Justice Fund, “from its inception, the FBI treated the Occupy movement as a potential criminal and terrorist threat.” During Occupy Wall Street, investigative journalists uncovered command centers advised by federal and local officials and banks. Skeptics wondered whether banks’ lucrative “private detail pay” and donations for police helped motivate multiple, brutal crackdowns on peaceful (if unorthodox) protesters. Homeland security officials may have advised local police on containment of the hundreds of “Occupy” encampments that arose in the fall of 2011. And in terms of selective enforcement: one has to wonder why police decided to care about a six-year-old open container violation at the homes of activists one day before May Day protests.

The post is highly documented, thoughtful, realistic, and non-hysterical.

To his remarks I would add that if you gave me access to the information that’s apparently being collected I have a high degree of confidence that I could predict your day-to-day movements and only slightly less confidence that I could predict what you’d do when you got there. That such information could have considerable value in a business intelligence context is not paranoia it’s obvious. The information could prove useful to criminals, bosses, spouses and who knows how many other individuals and organizations. It is equally obvious that if value can be extracted from something it will be.

The difference between government officials collecting such data and big businesses retaining such data as they collect it in the course of business is recourse. Due to the civil service shield laws there is no recourse when information is misused by the government and because of the absence of such recourse the disincentives to misuse the data are small. If those protections were removed it would go a long way towards assuaging my concerns.

Update

Some other things that might be considered on why we should be concerned about the federal government retaining and using information that large companies, too, are retaining and using. First, the parallel is in no way exculpatory of government action. Second, there are no trillion dollar companies.

14 comments

Foreign Policy Blogging at OTB

I’ve just published a foreign policy-related post at Outside the Beltway:

Sauds Side With Egypt’s Military

The king of Saudi Arabia has issued a statement expressing solidarity with Egypt’s struggle against terrorists. Egypt = Military Government. Terrorists = Muslim Brotherhood. There’s some basis for that characterization.

1 comment

Of Course They’d Never Do Anything Illegal

We now know that the NSA’s communications surveillance programs have operated illegally for years. The scale of the violations, mostly accidental, is such that it suggests that the agency is unable to monitor or control its own operations.

Can someone make a good case for me that the NSA, despite its inability to prevent tens of thousands of violations in its own operations, will be able to prevent the information it’s gathering from from being used to harm ordinary Americans?

17 comments

Duck-Footed

Interesting story at RapidReadyTech.com of how Buttercup the Duck received a 3D-printed prosthetic foot:

In January 2013, a local high school student contacted Garey in search of a home for Buttercup, a domestic duck she had inherited from a high school science class. Buttercup was born with a malformed foot, and for two and a half months the student had hand-raised him, but was no longer able to. Garey agreed to take in the duck, but quickly realized two things. First, that Buttercup did not know he was a duck due to his lack of feathered socialization; and second, that Buttercup was unable to effectively socialize because his foot caused him extreme discomfort in the yard.

With Buttercup’s first steps in front of Garey, Buttercup’s malformed foot started to bleed. Garey wondered if preserving the foot made sense, so he consulted a veterinarian and confirmed that amputating would improve Buttercup’s mobility. “I’d seen plenty of birds get around well on a peg leg, but as I started to think about it, I wondered if it would help Buttercup’s sociability if he had a foot,” Garey said. “These birds are so smart and have such great personalities, so I thought that if it were in my power to improve Buttercup’s quality of life, I should do that.” Garey liked the idea of 3D printing because it seemed like the perfect answer to the question of how to fashion a precise, custom part to his exact specifications without trading time for complexity, or vice versa. Garey started researching his available options for 3D file creation and 3D printing, and came across NovaCopy, a Tennessee supplier of 3D printers and 3D printing solutions. The compassion and positivity of Garey’s aim immediately compelled NovaCopy to agree to help with printing. If Garey could provide a 3D file, NovaCopy could run it through one of their machines, no problem. By taking multiple pictures of another duck’s foot from all angles, Gary used 3D imaging software to create a 3D model. Then, with CAD software and NovaCopy’s feedback, Garey tweaked and modified the data into a prosthetic foot design. Garey sent off the final design for NovaCopy to print, and NovaCopy selected one of its 3D Systems machines for the task – the ProJet HD 3000Plus – due to the machine’s high-resolution capabilities.

I think it’s pretty clear that we’re only scratching the surface of what 3D printing will be able to accomplish. I also suspect that its veterinary uses will outstrip its medical uses if only because of how much more highly regulated medical applications are.

It will not only be a technological revolution; it will be a social and economic one.

2 comments

Life in a Dog Pack: Old Age

When you live in a dog pack, eventually, if you are very lucky, you will experience life with an old dog. Tally, at 15 years four months, is the oldest dog it has been our good fortune to share our lives with.

Living with a geriatric dog means that every day is a new adventure. Not only are there the regular routine activities of meals, potty breaks, and medications, we try to remain sensitive to Tally’s limitations, adapting to them as new challenges arise, so that we can ensure that she is as happy and comfortable as we can keep her.

We’ve placed cheap runners and area rugs strategically so that Tally can move about without being forced to navigate bare wood floors. As she’s gotten weaker over the years her ability to manage bare floors has diminished and we’ve changed to take that into account.

Tally no longer sleeps with us. She gave up climbing stairs several years ago and since then we’ve left her on her own recognizance on the first floor. Generally, she’s just fine there—she’s always preferred her own company—but, occasionally, we’ll hear a yelp and rush downstairs to find she’s trapped herself beneath a chair, slipped off the rugs we’ve placed for her convenience and safety, or walked into a corner and is too befuddled to make her way out without assistance.

On rare occasions she’s had nighttime “accidents”. That’s just the cost of doing business. She’s always very embarrassed about it.

Walks have become increasingly rare. She wants to walk and sometimes demands a walk but we understand that she really doesn’t have as much ability to handle a long walk as she thinks she does. I’m not prepared to carry a tired fifty pound dog home in my arms so we limit her walks to three or four blocks, sometimes just a block depending on how she feels that particular day.

She wants to play ball but, sadly, her vision is failing so, if you throw the ball more than a few feet away from her, she won’t be able to find it. My wife is better at playing ball with Tally these days than I am.

Every night we have the same ritual. I’ll let her out the back door for her final nightly elimination and she won’t come back in until I’ve chased her one slow circumnavigation around our backyard, then helped her up the two stairs into the house. The joy in her eyes during these low speed chases is a delight to see. I’ve taken to calling her “the White Bronco”.

Last night we had something of a scare. When she rose from a nap she began a series of odd, hopping bounds. She wouldn’t stop. It was quite alarming.

We moved the other dogs elsewhere in the house and let her outside. She continued the hopping. My wife thought it was some sort of neurological malfunction. I thought she’d awoken with a stitch in her leg and, like an athlete with a leg cramp, was trying to run it out. She was unable to put weight on her left foreleg but wasn’t strong enough to maintain her balance and stand in one place. Hence the odd, forward-moving, hopping bound.

After a while she stopped and, although she was still hobbling a bit, she was behaving much more normally. I gave her an extra half Rimadyl before we went to sleep and this morning she’s shown no signs of a return to her previous condition.

It was, however, a reminder that Tally won’t be with us a great deal longer and we must savor every moment we have with her. We are resolved that Tally will enjoy her life as long as she lives. So far, so good.

The other dogs show Tally considerable deference, each in their own way. Will is extremely fond of her. Nola gives her a wide berth (although she’s not above stealing some of Tally’s food when she has the chance—stolen food always tastes better). Smidge, with typical Australian Shepherd temperament, is worried about her. She herds her, blocks her from moving into spaces she thinks are too dangerous for her (Smidge and Tally have different views on this subject), and sleeps curled up with her. It’s like having her own personal sheep.

I don’t know how our pack dynamics will change when Tally is no longer with us. It’s not something I look forward to. Although she’s always been highly independent, she and Jenny made us into a pack. Tally taught us all to howl.

6 comments

In Re: Jesse Jackson, Jr.

As you presumably know, Jesse Jackson, Jr. was sentenced to 30 months in a low security federal prison for stealing $750,000 from his campaign fund.

That means he’ll be available to run for the House in 2016. Any bets on whether he’d win?

9 comments

Just Google “Train Wreck”

I don’t think that the various machinations in the implementation of ObamaCare suggest that the law is a “train wreck”. That the claim is being made is easy enough to find so I won’t bother to link to any of them here. Just Google “train wreck”. At the top of the list of results will be posts, articles, etc. either claiming or denying that it’s a train wreck.

What I do think they reflect is a very different view of law and government than I’m comfortable with. Essentially, it’s “how to sculpt a statue of a rabbit” as applied to government. Take a block of stone (the law as enacted) and then cut away anything that doesn’t contribute to a general impression of rabbititity (exercise executive discretion).

18 comments

Who Killed Cock Robin?

From the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco:

While our estimates show that fiscal policy has held back the recovery slightly to date, the effect over the next three years looks much bigger. The CBO projects that the federal deficit as a share of GDP will drop 1.4 percentage points per year over the next three years. This projection would ease slightly to 1.2 percentage points per year if sequestration spending cuts were reversed. By contrast, our calculation of the historical-norm deficit decline through 2015 is 0.4 percentage point per year based on the CBO’s output gap projections. This implies that the excess drag from the rapidly shrinking deficit would reduce real GDP growth annually by between 0.8 and 1.0 percentage point, depending on whether sequestration is reversed. Thus, with or without sequestration, fiscal policy is expected to be a much greater drag on economic growth over the next three years than it has been so far.

Surprisingly, despite all the attention federal spending cuts and sequestration have received, our calculations suggest they are not the main contributors to this projected drag. The excess fiscal drag on the horizon comes almost entirely from rising taxes. Specifically, we calculate that nine-tenths of that projected 1 percentage point excess fiscal drag comes from tax revenue rising faster than normal as a share of the economy. As Panel B shows, at the end of 2012, taxes as a share of GDP were below both their historical norm in relation to the business cycle and their long-run average of about 18%. However, over the next three years, they are projected to rise much faster than our estimate of the usual cyclical pattern would indicate. The CBO points to several factors underlying this “super-cyclical” rise, including higher income tax rates for high-income households, the recent expiration of temporary Social Security payroll tax cuts, and new taxes associated with the Obama Administration’s health-care legislation.

The emphasis is mine. You cannot be simultaneously in favor of economic growth and the fiscal policy on which we’ve embarked and, of spending cuts forced by sequestration and tax increases, tax increases are enormously more significant.

My main gripe about the tax increases have been the form that they’ve taken. Restoring the payroll tax is horribly regressive. People who complain about income inequality and then move to increase payroll taxes make me ill.

The three most important things that we could do to foster a reduction in income inequality are a) more jobs; b) eliminating payroll taxes; and c) reducing the subsidies paid to the top 10% of income earners. Those subsidies include both direct payments and tax expenditures like the home mortgage deduction, most of which goes to the highest income earners.

5 comments