What’s Our Grand Strategy?

Walter Russell Mead’s WSJ op-ed on President Obama’s “failed Mideast policy” is getting quite a bit of comment, in the blogosphere and beyond. James Joyner has a nice post on it. Much of the blogospheric commentary has taken the form of ad hominems, the rhetorical equivalent of “Oh, yeah?”

Dr. Mead jumbles strategy and grand strategy a bit in the op-ed. As I read the op-ed he sees the president’s grand strategy was to make the Middle East more democratic using the strategy of working with moderate Islamist groups. That’s the same grand strategy as President Bush had; the difference is in strategy rather than grand strategy.

Every American grand strategy that has been attempted with a top-down approach has foundered. In President Obama’s case it’s because the strategy was a contradiction in terms. President Bush’s strategy had that problem and more—not only did it have internal contradictions (not everyone aspires to democracy) but it lacked the support of substantial portions of the American people.

In the United States grand strategy is an emergent phenomenon. As much as our elites wish they were 19th century British aristocrats, they aren’t. Any successful American grand strategy will come from the bottom up rather than the top down.

What is the American grand strategy for the Middle East? Do we have one? Should we?

14 comments

Back to School Special

I’ve continued thinking about the president’s plan for making college more affordable and, honestly, on reflection it’s not as loopy as it sounded at first. I think it makes all of the sense in the world if you buy the president’s assumptions about higher education. I don’t which explains my initial, puzzled reaction.

For example, I don’t think that college education for everyone is possible and, consequently, I can’t see it as a desireable goal. 50% is about the limit for any country and we’re approaching that now. The main effect of college education beyond about 30% of the people is mostly positional rather than educational. Is that really something we should be pursuing and financing?

I also don’t think that the president believes that supply and demand play any role in pricing at all. If you believe that supply and demand play some role in pricing, you recognize that if you hold the supply constant and pour more money into something, its cost will rise. At some level the people who point to the tremendous increase in the role of the federal government in financing higher education as being a basic reason for the rising cost of education are right. We can’t make it cheaper by spending more on it.

Consider the primary mechanism of the president’s plan, the rating system and tying federal loan money to the rating system. IMO the bad secondary effects of such a system outweigh the benign intended effects. Pell grant money just isn’t that important for elite schools. For most of them fewer than 30% of their students qualify and the general rule is that the more elite the school the lower the percentage of Pell grant recipients. So, for example, only about 12% of students that go to Princeton, the #1 ranked school, are recipients. That represents an extremely small proportion of revenues.

IMO the main effect of the plan will be to aggravate the partitioning of the higher educational system into elite schools whose students go on to lucrative careers and non-elite schools whose students go on to jobs that used to be done by people without college degrees but for which college degrees are now required. Those non-elite students will be both dissatisfied because of their unrealizeable expectations and burdened with educational debt.

Also, if you believe that our signal economic problem is excessive household debt, the “balance sheet recession” hypothesis, I don’t see how you can be happy about what’s been happening over the last decade or so. Over the period of just the last eight years the volume of educational debt has increased five-fold. Now look at total household debt. As you can see, we started to deleverage and have plateaued at what is obviously too high a level of debt. The only plausible explanation for that is educational debt.

It’s understandable that banks would turn to financing educational debt. It’s unsecured but it’s not dischargeable in bankruptcy. For a risk-averse institution that’s practically perfect. No pesky assets to seize or dispose of, possibly at a loss, and the unlucky defaulter can’t escape.

0 comments

Ballmer Isn’t Microsoft’s Only Problem

Microsoft CEO Steve Balmer announced that he would be leaving the company he helped found within a year:

Microsoft’s CEO Steve Ballmer shocked the technology world on Friday by announcing he would step down within 12 months, punctuating a tenure marked by the software giant’s declining dominance and struggles to keep pace with its competitors.

In a statement, Microsoft said Ballmer would retire “upon the completion of a process to choose his successor. In the meantime, Ballmer will continue as CEO and will lead Microsoft through the next steps of its transformation to a devices and services company that empowers people for the activities they value most.”

Market scrutiny will now likely shift to who will be tapped to succeed Ballmer. Despite that uncertainty, investors applauded the news by sending Microsoft’s shares surging by more than 7 percent — adding a whopping $24 billion to the software company’s market capitalization from Thursday’s close.

The business pages are now full of articles on how and why Ballmer failed. I think that most of these articles are too short-sighted.

IMO Microsoft’s problems go far beyond Steve Ballmer and started much earlier than 2000. I think they go back to the hiring of Dave Cutler and other members of the VAX VMS development team back in 1988 and the mindset that made that look like the right move for Microsoft. It goes back to the roots of Microsoft’s hegemony on the desktop.

Microsoft began as part of the small computer revolution, a revolution that wanted to put computing power in the hands of everybody. The decision to ally itself with corporate IT departments and put the real power there not only lead to Microsoft’s becoming the biggest software company in the world. It made the company constitutionally incapable of seeing the developments that would, ultimately, put it into its present zombie state.

It missed the Internet but was quickly able to make what might well be the most complete course correction in the history of American business. Since then its domination of the desktop has lead directly to the worldwide mass adoption of smartphones and tablet computers not to mention the transmogrification of malware from a minor and avoidable nuisance into a multi-billion dollar industry.

Microsoft’s latest grand vision for computing, as embodied in Windows 8, seems to be to impose all of the shortcomings of smartphone and tablet computing on desktops and notebooks. Suiting computing experience to use has never been one of Microsoft’s strong points. Diversity is a strength rather than a weakness but it is difficult to get a man or a company to understand something when his salary or its business plan depend upon their not understanding it.

1 comment

The Vital Importance of Work

I just want to make one observation on the murder of Australian ball player Chris Lane by three bored, black teenagers in Oklahoma last week. Sadly but I guess to be expected, people are making all sorts of hay out of this terrible incident. Some are using it to point out the hypocrisy they see in the media’s coverage of violent crime. Others point to the need for gun control. To each his own hobbyhorse.

Searching for meaning in their lives is a human necessity. Some find meaning in parenthood. When you ask a young woman without economic prospects why she had a baby out of wedlock as often as not it’s not because she didn’t know about effective birth control but she wanted to give meaning to her life.

Others find meaning in their lives by affiliation. It’s one of the reasons that young men join gangs.

For centuries, possibly for all of our history as a species, people have found meaning and identity in their work and their work relationships. I don’t know whether this is something that is learned or something that is innate but I know that it is true. It is not something that will be easily changed or replaced and, as the murder of Chris Lane suggests, there is no guarantee that the substitutes for work that people use to give meaning to their lives and establish identities will be benign.

8 comments

Julie Harris, 1925-2013

Julie Harris, actress, has died:

Julie Harris, the unprepossessing anti-diva who, in the guises of Joan of Arc, Mary Todd Lincoln, Emily Dickinson and many other characters both fictional and real, became the most decorated performer in the history of Broadway, died on Saturday at her home in Chatham, Mass.

She was 87. The cause was not immediately known, said Francesca James, a longtime friend who was with her when she died.

She excelled on the stage, on the big screen, and on television. Most people probably remember her for her portrayals of Lilimae Clements on the television program Knots Landing, Abra in the movie East of Eden, or for supply the voice for Mary Chestnut in Ken Burns’s documentary, The Civil War but it was on Broadway that she ruled. She is the only performer to have been awarded six Tonies for her performances. The list of her great Broadway performances include

It’s a Gift
King Henry IV, Part II
Oedipus Rex
The Playboy of the Western World
Alice in Wonderland
Macbeth
Sundown Beach
The Young and Fair
Magnolia Alley
Montserrat
The Member of the Wedding (her breakout role)
I Am a Camera (the basis for the musical Caberet)
Mademoiselle Colombe
The Lark
The Country Wife
The Warm Peninsula
Little Moon of Alban
A Shot in the Dark

and that just takes us from 1945 to 1962. She was on the Broadway stage almost continuously from 1945 to 1966. Other unforgettable performances include Forty Carats, And Miss Reardon Drinks a Little, The Last of Mrs. Lincoln, her signature one-woman inhabiting of Emily Dickinson, The Belle of Amherst, that has inspired so many young actresses, and her last performance in The Gin Game.

Of her the playwright John Van Druten, who adapted Christopher Isherwood’s Berlin Stories into I Am a Camera said “You pour in red wine, the pitcher looks red; pour in crème de menthe, it is green. When she’s by herself, Julie’s almost transparent, almost nonexistent.” It’s called “acting”. That’s a quality she shared with others of the greats like Alec Guinness and few performers have shown the depth and breadth she did in her performances.

2 comments

‘Splain Me

I’m with Tyler Cowne about President Obama’s plan to reduce the cost of education:

I would find it helpful if this proposal would outline the core, underlying theory of market failure in higher education, and then how these ideas would fix it. It is difficult for me to put that argument together in my mind. I do get the intuitive reason why “aid should be tied to outcomes.” But presumably students, who already have by far the most at stake in choosing a college, already allocate their own dollars and aid dollars on the basis of outcomes. If that process isn’t broken, this plan seems to address a pseudo-problem. If that process is broken (misguided students?), we need to know whether this plan really will fix the kink in the system. For instance if students cannot right now choose the schools offering the best expected outcomes for them, this plan seems to work mighty hard to get the schools to do the choosing for them, but in reality only ends up putting the students into tougher and less appropriate institutions. Can you spell “remedial”? In any case, under these assumptions, it would seem to be the students who need the fixing, not the schools.

[…]

Overall the ideas here strike me as underdeveloped in terms of logic.

Is the idea behind the rating system to frighten schools into lowering their prices? I really don’t get it. Other than at the margins how will this plan lower the cost of higher education? Please explain it to me.

Lord knows I have no objection to higher education costing less but it seems to me that the problem of college costing too much has a simple solution and one I’ve proposed before: a high quality, accredited online program, free of charge or at least inexpensive, available to anyone who’ll do the work.

Of course, if our actual problems are that the top schools are the top schools because they’re selective, select students who have high earning potential when they walk in the door, and expensive or that our educational system’s greatest problem isn’t the outputs (students with degrees) but the inputs (the capabilities of the students when they enter college) or that we aren’t producing enough jobs for people with any level of education, even that won’t help much.

46 comments

Marian McPartland, 1918-2013

Marian McPartland, jazz musician, composer, educator, broadcaster, and keeper of the flame, has died:

Marian McPartland, a jazz pianist and composer whose radio show “Marian McPartland’s Piano Jazz” was National Public Radio’s longest running and most widely carried jazz program, has died. She was 95.

McPartland died of natural causes Tuesday night at her home in Port Washington, N.Y., NPR reported.

One of the jazz world’s most visible female instrumentalists, McPartland’s highly personal style was rich with colorful harmonies and briskly swinging rhythms, enhanced by a love of bebop, while adapting smoothly to the many stylistic changes taking place in jazz over the course of a career spanning more than half a century.

“Marian McPartland is a harmonic genius,” pianist Bill Charlap said. “Her singular musical voice encompasses the past, present and the future of jazz.”

NPR also has a lovely obit.

In the historic semi-impromptu photograph “A Great Day in Harlem”, pictured above, possibly the greatest assemblage of jazz musicians ever, taken in 1958, she’s standing in the first row.

Marian McPartland is a great favorite around here. We must have a dozen of her recordings. And we were enthusiastic listeners to her radio program, Piano Jazz, for many years.

One of my favorite memories is of Marian McPartland. One Sunday afternoon, many years ago, we drove up to hear a workshop conducted by her at one of the small theaters at Ravinia, summer home of the CSO and the location of the oldest music festival in the United States. As we stood in line, waiting for the “first come, first served” tickets, the heavens opened and the throng of hardy fans were drenched with, perhaps, two inches of summer showers. Under the circumstances we were allowed into the theater a bit early.

When Ms. McPartland and the other members of her trio showed up on stage, she looked out at the dripping, bedraggled audience and said “I don’t know what a ‘workshop’ is. What would you like me to play?” Someone in the audience shouted “Here’s That Rainy Day!”, the Jimmy Van-Heusen-Johnny Burke standard. She played a lovely rendition. The next two hours were filled with her giving tips to a few young musicians who’d been signed up for the event, stories, and her unmatchable playing. It was grand.

0 comments

Chicago

Hog Butcher for the World,
Tool Maker, Stacker of Wheat,
Player with Railroads and the Nation’s Freight Handler;
Stormy, husky, brawling,
City of the Big Shoulders:

They tell me you are wicked and I believe them, for I have seen your painted women under the gas lamps luring the farm boys.
And they tell me you are crooked and I answer: Yes, it is true I have seen the gunman kill and go free to kill again.
And they tell me you are brutal and my reply is: On the faces of women and children I have seen the marks of wanton hunger.
And having answered so I turn once more to those who sneer at this my city, and I give them back the sneer and say to them:
Come and show me another city with lifted head singing so proud to be alive and coarse and strong and cunning.
Flinging magnetic curses amid the toil of piling job on job, here is a tall bold slugger set vivid against the little soft cities;
Fierce as a dog with tongue lapping for action, cunning as a savage pitted against the wilderness,
Bareheaded,
Shoveling,
Wrecking,
Planning,
Building, breaking, rebuilding,
Under the smoke, dust all over his mouth, laughing with white teeth,
Under the terrible burden of destiny laughing as a young man laughs,
Laughing even as an ignorant fighter laughs who has never lost a battle,
Bragging and laughing that under his wrist is the pulse, and under his ribs the heart of the people,
Laughing!
Laughing the stormy, husky, brawling laughter of Youth, half-naked, sweating, proud to be Hog Butcher, Tool Maker, Stacker of Wheat, Player with Railroads and Freight Handler to the Nation.

Carl Sandburg, 1916

Without the jobs in meatpacking, steel, light manufacturing, transport, or those associated with being the center of retail empires, Chicago is still wicked, crooked, and brutal but it is no longer proud, no longer strong. There is no future for Chicago as a place where the pale and slender young men and women flit from bistro to boutique. Or even the fashionably sun-kissed ones.

There are two possible reactions to this. We can either surrender to the fate that decay brings and be willing to become Nineveh on Lake Michigan, crumbling and forgotten, or we can make Illinois a welcoming place for making things, wresting things from the soil, industry, and commerce. And deal tirelessly with the problems those things bring along with them.

There’s a choice and we should make it and commit to it. We don’t have the choice of sun-drenched beaches, mountain vistas, and benign climate. That’s California. We aren’t California.

37 comments

Sideways

It’s not my imagination. The economy in Illinois really is crummy:

The dismal news reported Monday by the U.S. Department of Labor: Illinois still has the second-highest unemployment rate in the nation. Only economically hobbled Nevada has a worse job picture.

This state’s jobless rate ticked up 0.1 percent to 9.2 percent in July as the state added a modest 7,100 private-sector jobs last month. The national jobless rate is 7.4 percent, which looks pretty grim … except when it’s compared with Illinois’.

We are not creating many jobs here. We are not competing. We are being left behind.

The Trib editorial quoted above goes on to suggest that workmen’s comp laws in Illinois need further reform to bring them into line with those of the surrounding states.

When you look at the long-term trend it certainly looks as though Illinois, unlike the country as a whole, is just moving sideways:

Given the headwinds that the state is facing, it’s amazing the state is doing so well. Unemployment, as noted above, is the 2nd highest in the nation. We’re basically where we were at the end of 2010. The state legislature has steadfastly refused to deal with the state’s most pressing fiscal problem, public pensions. The state’s GDP is rising more slowly than that of nearby states or the country as a whole. Government corruption is so bad we’ve become a national laughingstock. State lawmakers have accomplished none of the things they promised when they enacted the whopping increase in the state’s personal income tax, which expires in 2015. The new strategy for increasing revenue in the face of economic doldrums is a graduated income tax, unlikely to encourage income earners to come here or stay here.

We’ve become California without the mountains, the ocean, the desert, the climate, or Silicon Valley. We’re Bakersfield all the way from the Wisconsin border to the Ohio River.

WE need to do more. We need to attract and foster businesses rather than driving them away.

21 comments

Say “Cheese”!

Last week I embarked on a great experiment. I made my first successful batch of ricotta cheese. I’d made yogurt cheese in the past (just filling a cheesecloth bag with yogurt, suspending it, and letting the whey drain out) but I had never been successful in any of my other cheesemaking experiments.

I used my ricotta to make lemon-ricotta pancakes and then, later in the week, to make a batch of manicotti. Both were fabulous. Now my appetite is whetted, both literally and figuratively. My next, somewhat more complex project will be to make a batch of mozzarella. That may prove to be a bridge too far.

I’m enrolled in a two-day cheesemaking workshop in early September. The first day we cover soft, fresh cheeses (the sort I’m experimenting with now). The second day is devoted to making hard cheeses. I’ll be reporting back with my progress.

2 comments