Why Income Inequality?

Writing at the Wall Street Journal, economist John B. Taylor rejects the argument that increasing income inequality in the United States is a consequence of tax policy:

Weak economic growth today, according to the middle-out view, is the consequence of a wider distribution, or dispersion, of income (more at the upper end). This growth in inequality, the argument goes, is the consequence of tax cuts since the 1980s, a trend toward deregulation (that actually began under the Carter administration), and fewer targeted federal programs.

The key causal factor of the middle-out view is that a wider income distribution slows economic growth by lowering consumption demand. Saving rates rise and consumption falls if the share of income shifts toward the top, according to middle-out reasoning, because people with higher incomes tend to save more than those with lower incomes.

The data for the recovery since mid-2009 do not support this view. The 5.4% overall savings rate during this recovery is not high compared with the 8.4% average since 1960. It is relatively low compared to past recoveries, such as the 9.3% savings rate during a comparable period during the recovery in the early 1980s.

Moreover, data do not support the view that tax cuts in the past 30 years are responsible for the widening income distribution. According to the Congressional Budget Office, the distribution of market income before taxes widened in the 1980s and ’90s by about as much as the distribution of income after taxes.

with which I agree and asserts that what’s promoting income inequality is education:

What caused the differential income growth in the 1980s and 1990s? Research shows that the returns to education started increasing in the 1980s. For example, the wage premium for going to college compared to high school increased. But the supply of educated students did not respond to the increase in returns. High-school graduation rates were declining in the 1980s and ’90s and have moved very little since then. Test scores of American students fell in international rankings. With little supply response, the returns to those with the education rose more quickly, causing the income distribution to widen.

with which I don’t.

Contrary to Dr. Taylor, the history of the last thirty years tells us that what we protect and subsidize prospers disproportionately and what we don’t doesn’t. If we had protected and subsidized auto industry jobs the way we protect and subsidize healthcare providers, we’d have at least as many of them as we did thirty years ago (rather than the fraction we do now) and we’d have the most expensive automobiles in the world.

In the starkest terms, we can either pick winners and losers or not. If we elect to pick winners and losers, it’s insane to be surprised when the winners win and the losers lose.

5 comments

Moving Beyond Aggression

Fortunately, events are moving beyond the administration’s proposals. The Syrian government has approved the proposal enunciated by Russian Foreign Minister Lavrov. The details of the plan are expected today but they’re anticipated to include Syria’s turning over its stocks of chemical weapons, committing not to manufacture more, and joining the international convention banning their use.

That’s a good outcome and I don’t much care who gets credit for it. However, if the actual desired outcome of attacking Syria were regime change, don’t expect such an agreement to satisfy its advocates. Or the rebels. With this agreement in place and adhered to, the civil war will continue for the foreseeable future.

36 comments

The Syria Red Herring

Almost no one other than, possibly, the president himself believes his address tonight will move public opinion much. The national argument over attacking Syria continues with its proponents emphasizing, like Secretary of State John Kerry, how inconsequential the attacks will be, which hardly seem to me to be a selling point.

I’m baffled that people are persisting in dragging the red herring of hypothetical proposals across the trail when we have two actual proposals in written form. The first, which I’ve linked to before, is the administration’s request for authorization. It’s unlimited in duration, means, target, or objective. It could potentially include land troops, it could include bombing Iran. It’s discretionary.

The second is the authorization approved by the Senate Foreign Relations Committee. The Foreign Relations Committee’s authorization narrows the timeframe of the authorization, retains its broad discretionary character, and expands the objective of attacks to “changing the momentum on the battlefield in Syria”, strengthening the rebels’ hand to force the Alawite regime to the bargaining table.

IMO the Obama Administration, prudently cognizant that once it has initiated hostilities against Syria its ability to control the outcome is quite limited, has requested maximum discretion. The proponents of attacking Syria need to defend what the administration has requested or what the Senate committee has approved. The administration could have requested an approval much more consistent with what it’s been saying but it elected not to do so. It’s what’s actually been requested that should be the subject of discussion rather than what we wish had been requested.

0 comments

It Must Have Been “Moonglow”

Over at TCM they’ve been playing a short portion of the scene in the video above and it was sufficiently nostalgic for me I thought I’d pass along a few thoughts. If you’re not familiar with it, it’s the famous “Moonglow” scene from Joshua Logan’s screen adaptation of William Inge’s stage play, Picnic. Yes, I saw this at the drive-in and that’s a much better venue for it than the small screen.

A couple of thoughts. First, that mash-up of the 1934 standard, “Moonglow”, with the “Love Theme from Picnic” is so effective that it’s hard to think of “Moonglow” without thinking of it as an ostinato for the movie theme. A great rendition. Wish I knew who the musicians were. It’s as good an example of “cool jazz” as you’ll run across.

Second, the play. If you’ve never seen it on stage, you’ve never seen it. It’s a very affecting piece of drama. The movie is solid but nothing as good as a good stage performance. A good stage performance is riveting.

I’ve heard that William Inge hated the way the director of the play made him re-write his original ending. As the play originally ended, Hal leaves and Madge stays. She becomes an embittered old maid.

William Holden. Josh Logan managed to wrench one of his best performances out of Holden but the truth is that Holden was not really suited to the part. He was too old. Hal is supposed to be in his late twenties, not his late thirties. It’s not as though there weren’t a perfect alternative available: Paul Newman. Newman would have been brilliant on screen as Hal. That’s the character he played on screen for the next thirty years. He’d played Alan, Hal’s college roommate, on stage, the part played in the film version by Cliff Robertson.

Kim Novak is young and lovely, of course, in Picnic and it’s one of the few movies in which she doesn’t look like she wished she were somewhere else. Hitchcock actually capitalized on that in Vertigo. In Hitchcock’s movie her character is really uncomfortable with the role she’s being forced to play and her genuine lack of comfort became an asset rather than a liability. Have you ever wondered why she retired from the movies so young? She wanted to be somewhere else.

The more I learn about the making of the movie, the more reservations I have about it. Logan’s passion for verisimilitude lead to too many injuries among the cast. IMO that’s one of the marks of a reckless director.

Even if you’re not interested in watching the whole movie, just listen to the soaring music, watch some great movie stars when they were young and beautiful and didn’t all look like plastic dolls and when “Hollywood ending” didn’t mean explosions.

0 comments

Guns vs. Butter

There’s a comment from a thread over at OTB that caught my attention:

The country itself needs a strategic review of our place in the world. We can no longer afford to be the only world policeman as the infrastructure of this country disintegrates and more and more people are in poverty. Off course that’s not going to happen.

Ironically, since I’m pretty sympathetic with the core claim in that comment, I was struck that I could find at least three logical fallacies in it. That’s a pretty high number for so short a comment.

Do you see them, too?

4 comments

Another Chink in the Simple Thermodynamics Model

I wonder how you’d go about reconciling the simple thermodynamics model of weight gain with this finding:

The trillions of bacteria that live in the gut — helping digest foods, making some vitamins, making amino acids — may help determine if a person is fat or thin.

The evidence is from a novel experiment involving mice and humans that is part of a growing fascination with gut bacteria and their role in health and diseases like irritable bowel syndrome and Crohn’s disease. In this case, the focus was on obesity. Researchers found pairs of human twins in which one was obese and the other lean. They transferred gut bacteria from these twins into mice and watched what happened. The mice with bacteria from fat twins grew fat; those that got bacteria from lean twins stayed lean.

The study, published online Thursday by the journal Science, is “pretty striking,” said Dr. Jeffrey S. Flier, an obesity researcher and the dean of the Harvard Medical School, who was not involved with the study. “It’s a very powerful set of experiments.”

What I’m referring to as the “simple thermodynamics model of weight gain” is the frequently assert belief that weight gain or loss can be determined based solely on calories consumed as food and calories expended as exercise. Despite the piles of evidence against it, the theory is remarkably persistent.

One of the things that strikes me about the experiment above is that it provides an alternative explanation for why we’ve been getting fatter as a society. It might not be due simply to eating too much and exercising too little even if that does play a role. The use of antibiotics, known to affect the intestinal flora, might play a role, too.

Maybe someday we won’t treat being fat as a character flaw and will start treating it as an actual, possibly communicable disease.

Hat tip: Glenn Reynolds

15 comments

Is It To Be Isolationists vs. Militarists?

Bill Keller presents a false and vicious dichotomy. Although he’s a bit sheepish about it, he’s ultimately arguing that, if we are to be engaged with the world, it must be at the point of a gun:

But can we dial down the fears and defeatist slogans of knee-jerk isolationism and conduct a serious discussion of our interests and our alternatives in Syria and the tumultuous region around it?

The event that ultimately swept the earlier isolationists off the board was, of course, Pearl Harbor. But even before the Japanese attack the public reluctance was gradually giving way, allowing the delivery of destroyers to the British, the Lend-Lease program, a precautionary weapons buildup and the beginning of military conscription.

One factor that moved public opinion toward intervention was the brazenness of Hitler’s menace; Americans who had never given a thought to the Sudetenland were stunned to see Nazis parading into Paris.

I see barely a smidgeon of isolationism in contemporary America. There are millions of Americans living and working overseas, we import a huge proportion of our consumer goods and a lot of our food from abroad, and we have a higher proportion of immigrants presently living in the United States than at at all but a very few times in our history.

Who is he, Hideki Tojo? Is the only form of engagement with the world military engagement? That’s militarism.

He’s calling for robust dialogue about our role in the world without recognizing that nobody’s arguing for complete disengagement from it. Even if we were to completely stop bombing and killing people overseas, we would remain tremendously far from isolationist. Think about what real isolationism would imply for a while.

Branding anyone who believes that a little less military intervention wouldn’t be such a bad thing an “isolationist” doesn’t promote dialogue. It’s an attempt at stifling it.

6 comments

The Guilt of Bashar al-Assad

Is Bashar al-Assad’s personal guilt over the use of chemical weapons against the people of Syria important? If so, we might consider that the tide of evidence that contradicts that appears to be rising:

President Bashar al-Assad did not personally order last month’s chemical weapons attack near Damascus that has triggered calls for US military intervention, and blocked numerous requests from his military commanders to use chemical weapons against regime opponents in recent months, a German newspaper has reported , citing unidentified, high-level national security sources.

The intelligence findings were based on phone calls intercepted by a German surveillance ship operated by the BND, the German intelligence service, and deployed off the Syrian coast, Bild am Sonntag said. The intercepted communications suggested Assad, who is accused of war crimes by the west, including foreign secretary William Hague, was not himself involved in last month’s attack or in other instances when government forces have allegedly used chemical weapons.

Assad sought to exonerate himself from the August attack in which hundreds died. “There has been no evidence that I used chemical weapons against my own people,” he said in an interview with CBS.

But the intercepts tended to add weight to the claims of the Obama administration and Britain and France that elements of the Assad regime, and not renegade rebel groups, were responsible for the attack in the suburb of Ghouta, Bild said.

Doesn’t that argue that regime change rather than “degrading” Assad’s capabilities, the strategy being argued by Secretary of State Kerry, is really the required outcome?

Just as a reminder, I think it’s likely that chemical weapons have been used in Syria, I don’t know the nature of the chemical weapons that have been used, and I don’t know who used them, whether at Bashar al-Assad’s specific command, by other members of the regime, by some low-ranking Syrian military officer, or by the rebels. I don’t honestly think that anybody else does, either.

The questions I’m raising are what level of proof should be required before we use military force, what should be its objective, and what kind of authorization should be necessary for its use? IMO that’s a discussion worth having.

1 comment

The Incoherence

You know, I honestly can’t see how one can oppose the invasion of Iraq in 2003 and support attacking Syria today while retaining any semblance of coherence. Every argument being made about Bashar al-Assad could be made in spades against the other Ba’athist dictator, Saddam Hussein. Kept a minority in power at the expense of the majority of the people? Check. Ruthless dictator? Check. Invaded neighbors? Check. Used chemical weapons against his own people? Check.

In addition there’s a huge bill of particulars against Saddam Hussein, all supporting getting rid of him. He didn’t pay any special price for using chemical weapons against his own people, something he did to an enormously greater extent than Assad (assuming that Assad is, indeed, responsible). We were maintaining a “No Fly” zone and imposing sanctions before we even knew about it. Unless, that is, you think the justification for the invasion was his use of chemical weapons.

Doesn’t that mean that either Barack Obama was wrong in 2003, he’s wrong now, he was wrong on both, or he’s incoherent? That makes me uncomfortable. Please defend the president’s present position without attacking his position back in 2003. I’m having a hard time getting my mind around that.

12 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The post at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments