Nothing Succeeds Like Success

One of my favorite definitions of our class structure is that the children of the members of the upper class will not be allowed to fail. Paul Krugman appears to be surprised that the upper crust continue to prosper when we won’t allow them to fail:

A few days ago, The Times published a report on a society that is being undermined by extreme inequality. This society claims to reward the best and brightest regardless of family background. In practice, however, the children of the wealthy benefit from opportunities and connections unavailable to children of the middle and working classes. And it was clear from the article that the gap between the society’s meritocratic ideology and its increasingly oligarchic reality is having a deeply demoralizing effect.

The report illustrated in a nutshell why extreme inequality is destructive, why claims ring hollow that inequality of outcomes doesn’t matter as long as there is equality of opportunity. If the rich are so much richer than the rest that they live in a different social and material universe, that fact in itself makes nonsense of any notion of equal opportunity.

He continues with what seems to me to be a non sequitur but which ties in with my earlier post this morning about education, Bill Blasio’s proposal for universal pre-kindergarten education in New York City. The evidence of efficacy for that is mixed but here’s a good defense.

In the final analysis, so long as we won’t allow those at the top of the heap to fail and won’t (or can’t) ensure that those of us in the lower orders will succeed, anything we do to promote egalitarianism is moot. And that, indeed, is the history of the last six years. Regardless of manifest failures of governance, the big banks have not been allowed to fail and those responsible for the bad governance, up to and including criminal malfeasance, remain in charge. Their confederates both in business and in government won’t allow them to fail.

10 comments

Learning About Learning

There’s a Jesuit maxim: “Give me the child until he is seven and I’ll show you the man.” That’s probably why, despite the weak empirical evidence for many educational practices, they’re defended with such fervor. Here’s an interesting article on what we’re learning about learning. Many common beliefs are either unsupported with empirical evidence or just plain wrong.

I suspect that there are some people who will learn despite the method, many people who learn according to traditional methods (it’s why they became traditional methods), and some people who have difficulty learning regardless of the method. Maybe the more interesting question is what is the objective of formal education?

1 comment

The Lack of Moral Outrage

Richard Cohen laments the absence of moral outrage among “liberals” about the horrible things going on in Syria:

The inescapable truth is that the world needs a policeman. The inescapable truth is that only the United States can play cop. We have the wherewithal. A further inescapable truth is that evil exists and needs to be fought. We should always proceed cautiously and prudently, aware of mission creep, complexity and our own limitations. I have always thought, maybe naively, that these were values embedded in the very soul of American liberalism. It seems I am wrong.

Yes, he’s wrong and in more than one way. The few remaining liberals are white-haired and feeble, in their final years. Hubert Humphrey has been dead for 35 years. Their successors, calling themselves “progressives”, are not about morality but about gain, about securing advantage.

The protests of the Aughts were not anti-war. They were anti-Bush. Now that George W. Bush is gone and there’s a Democrat in the White House, there’s nothing to protest, even when he does very much the same things that his Republican predecessor did. I’m reminded of William F. Buckley’s half-hearted defense of Richard Nixon’s obviously wrong-headed wage and price controls: “Well, at least he imposed them reluctantly.”

The president also is under the handicaps that he’s making an incoherent argument in a particularly passionless way. It is incoherent to argue for immediacy but be willing to delay action, first for Congressional deliberations, then for diplomatic negotiations. It is incoherent to argue for the moral necessity of “unbelievably small” actions.

What is it about chemical weapons? It is that they are technological, impersonal, indiscriminate, and used from afar. So are drone strikes. We may not see it that way but most of the world does. It is incoherent to argue that killing children and other civilians with chemical weapons is immoral while killing children and other civilians with drone strikes is moral. The decision isn’t a moral one; it’s a pragmatic one. And the pragmatic decision when there is no acceptable strategy for producing the outcome you wish, as is the case in Syria, is to do nothing.

It is an imperfect world and no one in it is morally pure. We’re damned if we do and damned if we don’t.

7 comments

Remember Libya?

Remember Libya? In the two years since Moammar Qaddafi was overthrown there, abetted by American, British, and French forces, the country has fallen under the control of criminal gangs (they call them “militias”) and its economy is in collapse. Qaddafi’s arms made their way into the hands of Islamists who used them to inflict who knows how much death and destruction in Mali and destabilized the government there. The Washington Post editors have a prescription—nation building:

What Libya needs from Washington is not a special forces raid but much more help in building a state. In a letter to Secretary of State John F. Kerry released this week, 28 experts, including former American diplomats, scholars and businessmen, urged a more active policy that would expand beyond seeking justice for the Benghazi attack. They urged U.S. technical support for the drafting of a new constitution that safeguards human rights, help in developing a long-term strategy to create an independent judiciary and training programs for security forces.

After helping to liberate Libya, the Obama administration and its European allies were too quick to walk away, leaving a shattered country to find its own way. If they wish to avoid another Arab state descending into chaos, they need to come back.

Have we learned nothing over the last decade? We’re just not very good at nation-building. They might have thought of that before kicking over the apple cart. Nation-building was never on the agenda for Libya and, if it had been viewed as a prerequisite for action, I strongly suspect that Qaddafi would have been left in charge.

Neat, plausible, and wrong.

Here’s my modest proposal: let the British, French, and Italians take responsibility for the nation-building. They did need us to get rid of Qaddafi but they don’t need us for that.

11 comments

The Minimum Wage Red Herring

In the first item that caught my eye this morning Robert Samuelson writes about the movement to increase the minimum wage. After noting that the poor, by and large, are unemployed and, consequently, their situation can’t be improved by increasing the minimum wage, a sizeable proportion of those earning the minimum wage don’t live in poor families, and the consequences of increasing the minimum wage on jobs is hard to measure, he concludes:

In the short run, even sizable increases in mandated wages may have moderate effects on employment, because businesses won’t abandon their investments in existing operations. But companies that think themselves condemned to losses or meager profits won’t expand. Not surprisingly, a study by two economists at Texas A&M finds that the minimum wage’s biggest adverse effects are on future job growth, not current employment. To this defect must be added another: An excessively high minimum will attract more skilled workers, denying the less skilled an entry point to work and on-the-job training.

The minimum wage seems a shortcut to social justice. It isn’t.

The intended beneficial effect of increasing the minimum wage is ensuring that everyone who works full time can earn a living wage. The prospective unintended secondary effects of increasing the minimum wage include:

  • It may reduce the number of jobs. But it may not. The results are obscure.
  • It will probably reduce the rate of job growth.
  • It will incentivize a black market in sub-minimum wage jobs.
  • It may grant a raise to individuals already working for more than minimum wage but working under minimum wage multiple contracts, proliferating the secondary effects of increasing the minimum wage far beyond entry level jobs.

and, as noted by Samuelson, it won’t solve the problems of the poor. There are other solutions, some of which would help the poor, including:

  • A negative income tax.
  • Subsidized employment programs.
  • Reducing the barriers to entry for a wide variety of businesses.
  • Reducing the subsidies being granted to the largest businesses.

These, of course, would have unintended secondary effects of their own.

In the final analysis IMO the discussion of an increase in the minimum wage is a red herring. We aren’t producing enough jobs at any rate of compensation and to the extent that increasing the minimum wage would reduce the rate of job growth it would actually be counter-productive. Focus on more jobs.

19 comments

Neat, Plausible, and Wrong

The theme for today might well be H. L. Mencken’s wisecrack: “there is always a well-known solution to every human problem — neat, plausible, and wrong.” Eliminate poverty? Increase the minimum wage! Save the Libyan people from slaughter? Remove Qaddafi! Stop Syrian kids from being gassed? Remove Bashar al-Assad!

That each of these solutions will have unintended secondary effects and those secondary effects may overwhelm the intended result never seems to occur to their advocates. That the advocates have no intention of hanging around to deal with the horrible secondary effects of their well-intentioned actions is a lagniappe.

4 comments

Twelve Years After

As of today twelve years have passed since the attacks on September 11, 2001. I’ll leave it to others to provide remembrances of the events of the day.

Instead, I’ll repeat something I began saying shortly after those events and have repeated often: we haven’t prevented any of the critical success factors that lead to the attacks and, consequently, similar attacks are just as likely as they were on September 10, 2001.

A “critical success factor” for a process is a process without which the process would not take place. Most processes have critical success factors. For the process of buying a house, for example, one of the critical success factors is having money and/or the financing to make the purchase. In addition to critical success factors some processes depend on interrelated clusters of factors, none of them critical by themselves but critical in combination.

Judging by the federal government’s actions over the last twelve years, federal officials believe that the critical success factors behind the attacks included inadequate security theater at airports, Taliban rule in Afghanistan, inadequate gathering of information, and Osama bin Laden. Essentially, I think that’s hooey. I don’t believe that any of those were critical success factors for the attacks.

I’ve avoided delineating what I see as the critical success factors behind the attacks but I’ll give you an example. Once aliens enter the United States we don’t monitor their activities or movements. We lose track of them. I think we’re understandably reluctant to change that but if you consider the events of leading up to the attacks it’s obvious that was a factor critical to their success. As supporting evidence (and evidence refuting that inadequate information gathering was a critical success factor) I would submit the Boston Marathon Bombing of last year. Strict monitoring of the movements and activities of resident aliens would have made that impossible.

One of the things about critical success factors is that inhibiting any of them ends the process. I think it’s arguable that one of the critical success factors behind the 9/11 attacks was the stationing of U. S. troops in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. If that’s the case we have already done everything we need to do to prevent a future 9/11 and everything else we’ve done over the last twelve years to that end has been waste motion.

These are things that I think are worth debating so that, at the very least, we understood the trade-offs we’re making. I completely understand why we’re reluctant to intercept any of the critical factors that leave us vulnerable to attack. Sadly, we’ve decided to do things which have very little to do with avoiding other attacks similar to those we experienced on that day. That almost 70% of Americans believe that another attack is at least somewhat likely suggests that many people have an intuitive understanding of the shortcomings of what we’ve done.

12 comments

Did the President Make His Case?

As I was betwixt and between I heard an interesting analysis of the president’s speech on Syria featuring comments by Marc Lynch (Abu Aardvark) and George Lakoff. Lakoff did some phrase by phrase linguistic analysis of the speech, concluding that the president’s diction probably did more to un-sell his case than to sell it.

You can listen to the program here:

0 comments

Why Is the WSJ Pro-War?

Historically, the Wall Street Journal has been the house organ for Hamiltonians, i.e. mercantile foreign policy optimistic realists. Is there a buck to be made from attacking Syria? Are there no downside risks to trade from such an attack?

When did the WSJ become the mouthpiece of “National Greatness” interventionists? You know, the people who never met a military intervention they didn’t like. Is it all about defense spending?

7 comments

The President’s Address on Syria

I didn’t watch President Obama’s address on Syria last night. I did this morning through the magic of Youtube. I seriously doubt that it changed anyone’s mind. I haven’t been able to locate an overnight tracking poll yet but I suspect that relatively few people saw the address, those who did learned nothing new, and they’ve already made up their minds.

A distinct question is whether President Obama helped his own approval rating with the address. Right now it’s hovering around the lowest level of his presidency. If he decides to attack Syria, it will be with the full recognition of that and in the knowledge that 2/3s of the American people disagree with him.

My opinion is what it has been for some time: that the U. S. should makes its case to the Security Council before taking any action, that the Congress should authorize the use of force before the president takes action, and that what control we have over events is limited to whether we attack Syria or not rather than over what happens afterwards.

I have hopes for Russian Foreign Minister Lavrov’s proposal for ending Syria’s chemical weapons use and, presumably, its program but on that we’ll need to wait and see the details as they emerge.

8 comments