The IMF Random Number Generator

Get a load of these growth rate predictions from the IMF. This is the sort of thing that gives economics a bad name.

4 comments

The Third Mandate

I see that Scott Sumner has recognized something I’ve been saying for years, including on this blog:

The Fed now has a triple mandate:

1. Low inflation.

2. High employment.

3. Minimizing the number of sarcastic comments from Wall Street that might make their lives more embarrassing at cocktail parties with rich people.

However, they’re in the wrong order. #3 is obviously the most important. And it’s not limited to the Federal Reserve.

4 comments

Why Did the CBO Change Its Mortality Projections?

Buried in a footnote to his post on the possibility of using Social Security reforms as a lever for breaking the impasse over the budget (and the debt ceiling), Bruce Krasting makes an interesting observation:

The “Non Partisan” CBO did not have to make dramatic changes to its mortality assumptions in September of 2013. The 5/13 SS Report to Congress did not have changes in its mortality rates, but CBO did. Why?

That’s an excellent question. Mr. Krasting suggests political motivations. I’d be interested in some alternative but none occurs to me. I’m not even sure how I’d go about finding out.

Here’s the CBO’s explanation. Does that actually answers the question. Why now?

2 comments

She Didn’t Do It!

Over at Smithsonian.com there’s a good write-up on the Chicago Fire. Today is the 142nd anniverary of the disaster. If you’re not aware of it, Mrs. O’Leary was very belatedly exonerated for starting the fire.

If somebody asked me (which nobody has), I’d say the real causes of the fire were too many wooden buildings, bad city layout, inadequate city services, and the weather. Without those, working synergistically, the fire which destroyed 2,000 acres of Chicago, would have been contained easily.

5 comments

Nothing Will Come of Nothing

Writing at Forbes Gordon Chang has a post that I wish that more people would read. In it he analyzes what would happen if China suddenly sold its U. S. Treasuries. His answer is simple but, sadly, eludes most people: nothing.

4 comments

Fred Allen of the Day

I’m frequently reminded of a wisecrack of Fred Allen’s: a committee is a group of people who individually can do nothing but as a group decide that nothing can be done. It’s certainly convenient. I think it was Aristotle who described human beings as rational animals. Maybe “rationalizing animals” probably would have been closer to the mark.

1 comment

Software Takes Time

There’s an interesting article at the WP’s Wonkblog, presenting one informed technician’s thoughts on the problems being encountered by users trying to access the PPACA’s portal, healthcare.gov. He makes a number of interesting observations but the two I found most interesting were this:

SK: The Obama administration has said that all these problems are happening because of overwhelming traffic. How good of an explanation is that?

JB: That seems like not a very good excuse to me. In sites like these there’s a very standard approach to capacity planning. You start with some basic math. Like, in this case, you look at all the federal states and how many uninsured people they have. Out of those you think, maybe 10 percent would log in in the first day. But you model for the worst case, and that’s how you come up with your peak of how many people could try to do the same thing at the same time.

and this:

SK: What would you be doing right now if you were running healthcare.gov?

JB: First I would put some really good instrumentation in place. The problem is if you’re fighting a fire, and it’s dark, you don’t know what’s going on. In other words, you can’t manage what you can’t measure. So first I would put something in place so you can measure what’s happening.

The second thing I’d do is I’d start building a very good load testing environment, so everything could be simulated in a load test, and move faster. Really everything is about speed right now, how quickly can you find problems and fix them. Ninety percent of the effort is really finding what to fix. Making the coding changes is only about 10 percent.

Neither of those two observations is particularly profound. Just ordinary good practice.

They’d better hope that the problems can be solved by throwing additional hardware at the site. That’s an easy solution and inexpensive to implement both in elapsed time and labor. Changing the architecture at this point could be disastrous. It’s probably out of the question.

My experience is that software developers are strongly predisposed to continue doing what they’re accustomed to doing. Getting someone from the outside to audit the code is probably a good idea but it will take time.

10 comments

Roots of the Shutdown

Frequent commenter Andy drew my attention to this WP article on the roots of the shutdown. It touched on a number of topics near and dear to my heart. For example:

Today, there is almost no overlap between the voting behavior of the most conservative Democrats in the House and the most liberal Republicans. That’s in part because there are few moderate-to-conservative Democrats and ­moderate-to-liberal Republicans left in the chamber.

It also is a reflection of the fact that members from districts that are more evenly balanced ideologically now vote the way their colleagues from highly ideological districts vote. In other words, there is a big difference in the way Republicans and Democrats represent relatively neutral districts.

Today the Congress is more polarized than it has ever been. More polarized than during Reconstruction.

And here:

The absence of a center in today’s politics significantly complicates coalition building. “How do you build a coalition from the center out when there’s no one in the middle?” Abramowitz asked. “Reaching across the aisle means reaching pretty far.”

I think there’s a possibility on which more reflection is due: that today’s federal government shutdown was “baked in” when the Pelosi-Reid Congress enacted the PPACA. Major social programs have historically been enacted with bipartisan support. The metaphor frequently used is that the parties join hands and jump. That is extremely difficult in today’s highly polarized climate.

But it’s not impossible. Wyden-Bennett had bipartisan support. It wasn’t rejected by Republicans; it was dismissed by the Democratic leadership. Why? I think it’s because the “Healthy Americans Act” didn’t satisfy enough of the items on their checklist and they felt they deserved a victory and they wanted to continue to be able to run on the issue. They didn’t want to “join hands” with the Republicans to construct a plan with bipartisan support.

Pointing to the adoption in the PPACA of an approach that was first proposed more than a decade previously is begging the question. Today’s Republican Party is on the “all politics all the time” path that New Gingrich put them on. It’s not that Republican Party. The approach selected doesn’t suggest they were looking for Republican support; it just points out how the conversation has changed over the years. And the notion that Democrats were trying to gain bipartisan support by courting Olympia Snowe is even more outlandish. As voted Olympia Snowe so voted Olympia Snowe. She was the last holdout of a cadre of Northeastern Republican moderates. For good or ille she had practically no influence in today’s Republican Party.

48 comments

The Team Name Flap

I agree with the president. The name of DC’s professional football team is offensive and should be changed. They should change their name to the “Landover Redskins”.

4 comments

Connections Are Everything

A new theory is emerging that Albert Einstein’s extraordinary intelligence was due to a highly developed corpus callosum, the “interface” between the brain’s hemisphere’s:

A new analysis technique that compared Albert Einstein’s brain to others of the period shows the left and right cerebral hemispheres of the famous scientist’s brain were unusually well connected to each other. This connectivity may have contributed to his brilliance, according to Florida State University evolutionary anthropologist Dean Falk.

Falk was part of a research team that investigated Einstein’s corpus callosum, the large bundle of fibers that connects the two cerebral hemispheres and facilitates interhemispheric communication in the brain. The findings appear, appropriately, in the journal Brain.

IMO this study leans too heavily on the “hardware” of the brain, its morphology, and too little on the “software” of the brain, the connections that develop over time. In my view in all likelihood intelligence is a consequence of a compicated interplay between hardware and software. The old “nature vs. nurture” discussion although I’d phrase it a bit differently. I suspect that extremely high intelligence will be very hard to nail down.

However, there’s no need to speculate. If Einstein’s brilliance was a consequence of the congenital structure of his brain, then genetic testing should be able to shed light on the discussion. I strongly suspect it’s a line of inquiry that will not bear fruit.

5 comments