Unaffordable Healthcare

While many Americans are distracted by the melodrama surrounding the rollout of the healthcare exchanges, the real story is that healthcare spending is rising, continuing to increase, is unaffordable, and the PPACA doesn’t do a lot about it.

Total U. S. healthcare spending was $2.5 trillion in 2009. In 2012 it had risen to $3 trillion—an increase of 20% in just three years. That’s during a period of very low inflation.

However you want to rationalize it, whether in terms of total real healthcare spending or total real per capita healthcare spending, healthcare spending is increasing at an unacceptably fast rate. That’s killing state and local governments and stunting job growth.

0 comments

A Measly 25 Years, Then Pffft!

After a measly twenty-five years of service our old Kenmore dryer has given up the ghost. The other night we smelled a burning smell coming from it. As befits a daughter of a family of firefighters my wife immediately disconnected it from the outlet. We then checked it for heat. Nothing was apparent. When we moved it away from the wall we noticed an oil leak.

Our equally old Kenmore washing machine has been limping along at a minimally acceptable level of functionality for years (if you want hot water, you’ve got to run it in with a hose). So we’ve decided to replace both our washer and dryer.

Yesterday and the day before we researched the subject both in our old issues of Consumer Reports and online and did a bit of online shopping. My wife went to Abt, our appliance store of choice, on Thursday and I went there yesterday. Now we’ve bought a new washer and dryer which will be delivered and installed on Thursday.

Our new washer and dryer are feature-laden and heavy on electronics which does not particularly comfort me. They’re more expensive than my first car and I’m resigned to the reality that they will not be nearly as reliable or durable as our old ones were. I’ll install some sort of power conditioning to protect the most fragile parts of the gadgets, unquestionably the electronic circuit boards.

9 comments

M. Scott Carpenter, 1925-2013

Scott Carpenter, the second man to orbit the earth, has died:

M. Scott Carpenter, a college dropout and local ne’er-do-well who became the second American to orbit Earth, wasn’t proud of the way his teen years took off.

“The local papers that say I was just a normal boy are trying to think of something not bad to say,” he told Life magazine in May 1962, a few days before his historic flight in the Aurora 7 space capsule that made him the second American to orbit Earth. “I didn’t study hard and I quit high school football because I couldn’t devote myself to learning the plays. I stole things from stores and I was just drifting through, sort of a no-good.”

After twice flunking out of the University of Colorado and getting into a serious accident driving home from a party, he had an epiphany in his hospital bed. He returned to college and studied hard. Three years later, he was a Navy pilot. A decade afterward, he was one of America’s seven original Project Mercury astronauts.

Briefly feared lost after orbiting Earth three times and plunging into the Atlantic far from his target, he returned to parades and plaudits.

Carpenter, who in 1965 made history again with his experiments in an undersea research capsule, died Thursday morning at a Denver hospice, said his wife, Patty Carpenter, after having a stroke about three weeks ago. He was 88.

His passing leaves John Glenn as the last surviving Mercury astronaut.

0 comments

Exchanges Off to a Slow Start

The Daily Mail is reporting a story that should be some cause of concern. The enrollment for the health insurance exchanges under the PPACA has been quite small:

Just 51,000 people completed Obamacare applications during the first week the Healthcare.gov website was online, according to two sources inside the Department of Health and Human Services who gave MailOnline an exclusive look at the earliest enrollment numbers.

The career civil servants, who process data inside the agency, confirmed independently that just 6,200 Americans applied for health insurance through the problem-plagued website on October 1, the day it first opened to the public.

Neither HHS nor the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services would comment on the record about the numbers. Enroll America, the president’s organization of health care ‘navigators’ who are charged with helping Americans sign up, didn’t reply to a request for information about its level of success so far.

The White House also did not respond to emails seeking comment.

But several administration officials have claimed this month that they didn’t have access to the kinds of raw figures MailOnline obtained from the people who work for them. And the anemic totals suggest a far lower level of interest in coverage through the Affordable Care Act than the Obama administration has hoped to see.

That’s consistent with the results being reported anecdotally by the individual states.

The open enrollment period for the exchanges is six months. If enrollments continue at the present rate, the total enrollment, including for the state-run exchanges, would be roughly 2 million people.

My experience with open enrollments conducted by my clients is that they typically follow a pattern. There’s substantial inquiry and interest at first which simmers down to a much lower level and then there’s a final flurry of enrollments at the end. Pretty much as you might expect. All the more reason for a much smoother rollout than has actually been experienced.

Don’t confuse me with someone who wants the PPACA to fail. Quite the contrary. I want it to succeed to whatever degree it will succeed as quickly as possible so that we can recognize the scope of the problem and turn to addressing the problems with our healthcare system that are in such desperate need of resolution and which, sadly, the PPACA mostly just kicks down the road.

Perhaps the problems with the web site can be corrected by throwing hardware at it and bug resolution. That woud be a best case scenario. If the problems are more basic, resolving them while the site is up and running could be quite difficult. Imagine conducting brain surgery while the patient is playing a game of tennis.

20 comments

My Dad’s Birthday, 2013

Today would have been my Dad’s 99th birthday. I’ve posted a number of pictures of him in prior posts and it’s starting to become difficult to find good pictures of him I haven’t already posted—he generally preferred to be behind the camera rather than in front of it. The nude figure studies probably wouldn’t be the best choice. I don’t know that I’ll ever forget the expression on the face of a dear friend of ours when she stumbled across them, thumbing through one of our old photo albums.

I’m not entirely sure of the story behind this photo. I suspect he took it himself, probably trying out the timer feature on his camera. I would say he’s in his late twenties or early thirties here. His expression is a bit goofy. He had very poor vision and I can only speculate that he removed his glasses to avoid the reflection from the flash that would otherwise have been apparent.

I don’t know that I’ve really conveyed my Dad’s personality in my posts about him. One of his most notable characteristics was enthusiasm. He approached everything with enormous energy, drive, and joy.

He was an avid and skilled amateur photographer. He belonged to a photography club and was an early experimenter with color photography.

He was also what’s called an “early adopter” of technology. He was the first lawyer in St. Louis to use a dictaphone or xerography and not too many years before his death he was starting to write articles about technology in the practice of law.

I’m quite sure he would have been thrilled with digital photography and would have owned a top-of-the-line professional camera.

7 comments

This Is the Way the Shutdown Ends

Writing at Fiscal Times, Eric Pianin and Josh Boak present three different ways the shutdown might end. They are

  • Pass a stopgap measure that’s tied to budget talks.
  • The President bends on the PPACA.
  • Implement the Portman plan, a sort of “grand bargain” including a one-year continuing resolution, substantial entitlement cuts, tightening qualifications for subsidies under the PPACA, and tax code reform.

To me only the first of these sounds anything but far-fetched. This despite my impression that the best thing that could happen to the PPACA might be a brief delay. Any of these ways of ending the shutdown presumes that the two sides are actually interested in arriving at an agreement.

In a world in which everyone has their own facts and each side may believe that it’s winning that really doesn’t appear to be the case.

11 comments

Plans and Posturing

There’s frequently a pretty big discrepancy between what people believe and what they say. There can also be quite a difference between what people believe and what they’d like to think they believe and, even more so, what they’d like you to think they believe.

In the case of the present House of Representatives, fortunately, we have a record of what they believe. Not only do we have the continuing resolution they’ve passed but we also have the 2014 budget they passed.

Budgets are, among other things, statements of intent. In no case has the House passed any form of budget that limits expenditures to revenues. Now, I could do all sorts of analyses of these two pieces of legislation but there’s one thing that’s beyond doubt: the House intends to raise the debt limit. Since they’ve already signalled their willingness to raise the debt limit by passing a budget, refusing to raise the debt limit at this point isn’t even an effective bargaining ploy. It’s just posturing.

4 comments

“Clean CR”

I really wish that John Boehner would allow a “clean CR”, i.e. a continuing resolution that funds the PPACA, to come to the floor of the House. If it passes, the will of the people is done. If it doesn’t pass, it removes that talking point from the discussion.

The ideal way for that to happen is if House Democrats could force it to the floor through parliamentary means but I’m skeptical they can bring that about.

4 comments

Bad Language

I also think there’s an enormous amount of untoward language about the federal government shutdown. Democrats including the president routinely refer to the House Republicans’ actions as “blackmail”, “extortion”, “terrorism”, “arson”, or some variation of one of those. I think the expression they’re looking for is “hard bargaining”. The basic difference is that all of the insults refer to acts that are illegal while what the House is doing is ill-mannered but not illegal.

If what the Republicans in the House are doing were illegal, the president would all but certainly be seeking relief in the courts. That he is not doing so suggests that he recognizes that the House Republicans are engaging in hard bargaining and he’s responding with stump speeches, presumably intended either to sway the public (which does not appear to be working) or prepare the battleground for the 2014 midterm elections.

To the extent that the president’s objections are well-founded the problem is in the structure of our government. Congresses have very little ability to compel future Congresses other than via multi-year appropriations, trust funds, and the like. That’s why bipartisan agreement on major new programs is so vital. The House, Senate, and the president together enact laws but the House identifies the spending priorities. The House has no legal obligation to fund things enacted into law by prior Congresses. What obligations it has in that regard are those of tradition, convention, and civility.

I wish the House weren’t behaving the way it is but I also wish that there were more collegiality and civility in our present public sphere. I very rarely get what I want.

38 comments

What Does “Default” Mean?

The news media are full of warnings of default. The New York Times proclaims:

Wall Street is showing few signs so far that it is fearing the financial panic it has been predicting should the government default on its debt.

The fiscal impasse in Washington continued to weigh on stock prices on Monday, as the market’s “fear gauge,” the C.B.O.E. volatility index, jumped 15.95 percent to its highest level since June. Nonetheless, the market reaction to date has been muted compared with past crises.

“We all tell ourselves, ‘This is something that is not going to happen,’ ” said David Coard, the head of fixed-income trading at the Williams Capital Group. “This would be like a black swan event — it’s not something that you would have thought that the U.S. could do in a million years.”

But the relative calm on Wall Street is worrying some investors, who fear the markets will not signal to politicians the true danger of hitting the debt ceiling until it is too late.

“The markets are sending this complacent message, and I think the politicians are interpreting it incorrectly and they have no sense of urgency,” said Douglas Kass, the owner of the hedge fund firm Seabreeze Partners Management.

A lot of people are throwing the word “default” around. What does it mean?

In legal terms any omission or failure to do what is expected is a default. From that point of view the United States government is already in default since it’s not open for ordinary business, public employees aren’t being paid for work done after October 1, and other (what we used to regard as) normal, expected operations.

In financial terms default means the failure to make timely payment of interest or principal on a debt security or to otherwise comply with the provisions of a bond indenture. Under that understanding the United States can only default if income does not meet interest obligations which is tens or even hundreds of billions of dollars from the truth or it consciously decides not to make its interest payments on time. That is the case with Argentina, recounted here. Argentina has just refused to pay interest on its debts.

Yet another view of default is that even bringing up the subject is unhinged. The federal government can issue new credit to make any interest payments. Alternatively, the Federal Reserve can buy any new bonds the Treasury might issue that aren’t being bought by anybody else. It amounts to the same thing. Note that foreign governments or companies that obtain dollars in trade don’t have a lot they can do with them other than a) buy bonds, b) buy other U. S. assets, c) buy U. S. goods or d) sell their dollars to someone else.

IMO some of the hysteria surrounding the “debt ceiling” is caused by confusion among these various notions of default. Fiscal superhawks probably thought that the United States defaulted as soon as spending more than was taken in became commonplace. To federal employees what’s going on must now must certainly feel like default. However, technical financial default has not yet occurred and won’t as long as the federal government continues to make interest payments which it can easily do.

That’s not to say the federal government can’t voluntarily decide not to make its interest payments. It’s happened before: once in 1790 and again in 1933.

20 comments