Although I think that much of the analysis in this article at The Economist, on the president’s dwindling approval rating following the feeble debut of Healthcare.gov and the various NSA revelations, is quite correct, I think the slug, “Barack Obama’s supporters are worried that he is a terrible manager”. When you look at the evidence more closely, there’s very little to support the claim. Not that he’s a terrible manager. At this point that’s pretty obvious. I mean that his supporters are worried.
Consider this observation from Charlie Cook at The National Journal:
For the week of Oct. 21 to Oct. 27, Gallup polling found that Obama’s job approval was 80 percent among Democrats, just a touch above his September average of 79 percent; among Republicans, it was 10 percent, somewhat lower than the 12 percent in September. Among liberals, Obama’s approval rating was 74 percent, slightly above his 71 percent for September; among conservatives, it was 22 percent, just below the 23 percent last month. None of these numbers are particularly remarkable.
It’s always more interesting to watch the numbers among independents and moderates, because their views are much less anchored in partisanship or ideology. Among independents, Obama’s job-approval rating was 36 percent, about the same as the 37 percent for September; among moderates, it was 47 percent, a little bit below the 50 percent for September. While it would certainly be reasonable to expect Obama’s numbers to dip a little among partisans and ideologues in reaction to recent events, those numbers aren’t likely to move as much as those from the independents and moderates.
In other words the president’s supporters are holding firm but most of the country are either opponents (Republicans) or their approval is contingent upon performance. It’s among these latter two groups that the president’s approval is declining.
In comments over at OTB there was a remark to the effect that American politics isn’t à la carte but table d’hôte. You must take the policies of each party in their entirety. I think that’s almost completely wrong.
Some Americans are solid partisans. They’ll continue to support the elected officials of their own party regardless of what they say or do. However, for a plurality of Americans support is contingent on performance. They’ll support elected officials only within certain bounds. Execution matters. Policies matter.







