Peter Suderman (Mr. Megan McArdle) reviews the worst case, hard landing scenario for the PPACA:
Over the weekend, several reports suggested that, despite continued assurances that Healthcare.gov, the problem-plagued online insurance enrollment portal run by the federal government, would be running smoothly for most users by the end of the month, it increasingly looks likely that the deadline will be missed.
Insurance industry consultant Robert Laszewski, who, thanks to his contacts with his insurers, has been a critical and frequently prophetic source of information about the law’s rollout, opened a blog post this weekend with the following assessment: “It is now becoming clear that the Obama administration will not have Health.care.gov fixed by December 1 so hundreds of thousands, or perhaps millions, of people will be able to smoothly enroll by January 1.†Laszewski says that months, not weeks, of work remain.
The dates he lists are important, and not only because of the administration’s self-imposed deadline of November 30. Anyone who wants to purchase insurance that kicks in at the beginning of next year must complete enrollment by December 15. If the system isn’t working smoothly at least a couple weeks prior to that rapidly approaching date, then large numbers of people simply won’t have a chance to sign up.
The quick summary is that millions of people would lose their healthcare insurance and suffer a discontinuity of insurance of unknown duration. The Obama Administration would have caused it and there would be nothing they could do about it.
He does propose one interesting stop-gap solution:
So the insurers have suggested a temporary measure: Let the insurers estimate the subsidies on their own. Any estimates that are too low would be reimbursable, and any estimates that are too high, the insurers would get to keep. In other words, the federal government, backed by taxpayers, would be on the hook for their bad estimates.
He thinks that’s pretty unlikely and I do, too.
His worst case scenario reminds me of the scene in Crocodile Dundee in which Mick, visiting New York, is confronted by a mugger armed with a switchblade knife:
Sue Charlton: [guardedly] Mick, give him your wallet.
Michael J. “Crocodile” Dundee: [amused] What for?
Sue Charlton: [cautiously] He’s got a knife.
Michael J. “Crocodile” Dundee: [chuckles] That’s not a knife.
[he pulls out a large bowie knife]
Michael J. “Crocodile” Dundee: THAT’s a knife.
What Mr. Suderman describes is no worst case scenario. IMO the worst case scenario is the above plus the contingency that most of the hardy few successfully enrolling for healthcare insurance under the exchanges are either a) Medicaid enrollees who qualified under the pre-PPACA rules or b) old and sick with pre-existing conditions.
The former condition would impose an intolerable fiscal strain on state governments. Medicaid enrollees who qualified for Medicaid under the pre-PPACA rules but for some reason weren’t enrolled in Medicaid don’t qualify for reimbursement by the federal government. Their entire tabs would be picked up by the states, many of which, like Illinois, are already teetering on the brink of fiscal disaster with no clear way to save themselves.
The latter condition would induce what’s been known as the “death spiral” in which insurers raise their rates and the PPACA’s costs soar in deadly embrace.
And that doesn’t even take what could happen in the group insurance market into account. We could be seeing millions of people formerly covered by their employers thrown into the exchanges.
I’m not predicting any of these scenarios. We’ll know in due course. All could be roses and lollipops.