James Taranto takes Michigan media functionary Jen Eyer to task for her guidelines on how not to discuss racial issues in the comments of her organization’s site. The things to avoid include:
- Overt racism
- Accusations of racism
- Generalizations
- Thread-jacking
- False equivalence
- Racial descriptions
- Crime statistics
Now if there were an automatic filter that could screen out the first six in that list plus “guilt by association” I am convinced that it would reduce the number of web comments by 90% or more. Not to mention blog posts.
After addressing the shortcomings of her formulations of 1—6, Mr. Taranto devotes substantial column space to a consideration of her aversion for crime statistics in discussions of race. If you’re interested in Mr. Taranto’s views, I urge you to read his column in full. I’d like to make a few remarks about the FBI crime statistics.
First, facts are not themselves racist and, when you find that facts make you uncomfortable, it’s probably time to reconsider your assumptions.
Second, sometimes it’s hard to identify when facts actually are facts. Not all statistics represent facts. Sometimes it takes a bit of digging through methodology do determine how factual the statistics actually are. However, in the case of the FBI crime statistics, my confidence that they do represent facts is pretty fair.
Third, I’ve examined the FBI crime statistics and have reached a different conclusion than Ms. Eyer has. It is incontrovertible that there is a strong racial differential in the commission of violent crimes and that the rates per 100,000 population are much higher among blacks than among whites or Hispanics. However, while race is a factor the facts do not support the view that it’s the only factor and I don’t believe that violent crime can be reduced to poverty or even race plus poverty.
Rural blacks are not notably more violent or criminal than rural whites. But the incidence of crime among urban blacks is much higher than among urban whites. My conclusion from this is that the problem is gangs and that the problems presented by gangs are particularly virulent among blacks.
We’ll never be able to cope with the problems of violent crime, problems that fall particularly heavy on blacks who form most of the victims of crimes perpetrated by blacks, without facing the facts squarely and unflinchingly. First, figure out what they are. Look at all of the facts. Then comes the hard part: doing something about it.