Ex Uno Plus

Every once in a while somebody proposes splitting one state or another into two or more states but it’s nearly always a fantasy—it will never go anywhere. A smarty-pants Silicon Valley venture capitalist has come up with a plan to split California into six states, pictured above, and there’s actually an outside chance it could happen:

Draper’s plan is controversial, but he’s got permission from Secretary of State Debra Bowen to start collecting petition signatures to qualify for a ballot. A total of 807, 615 registered voters need to sign Draper’s Six Californias plan in 150 days before it can be put on the next state election.

Article IV Section 3 of the U. S. Constitution prohibits states being carved out of other states other than under limited conditions:

New states may be admitted by the Congress into this union; but no new states shall be formed or erected within the jurisdiction of any other state; nor any state be formed by the junction of two or more states, or parts of states, without the consent of the legislatures of the states concerned as well as of the Congress.

California’s initiative system (they call them referendums but they’re initiatives) is quite robust and I strongly suspect that a well-written initiative could pass and would force the state’s legislature to approve the division. Whether the Congress would approve such an act is anybody’s guess.

However, let’s ignore whether it will happen for a second and consider the implications of its happening for a bit.

I think that dividing the state along the lines shown above would be good for “Jefferson”, “North California”, “Silicon Valley”, and, possibly, “West California” and a disaster for “Central California” and “South California”. The new state of “Silicon Valley” would have the highest per capita income of any state; “Central California” would have the lowest. “South California” would be starved for water. The bulk of its water comes from three sources: the Colorado River via the Colorado River Aqueduct, the State Water Project, and the Owens Valley. “South California” would have control of none of these.

Politically, by my reckoning the division would probably increase the Democrats’ margin in the Senate by two—”Jefferson” and “Central California” would probably elect Republicans, while the other four new states would elect Democrats. I don’t know what effect the new map would have on the House—it might well result in no change at all.

If the constitutions of the new states followed California’s, I’m skeptical that the new division would be stable. Once it had been shown to be possible I think the temptation to further divide the new states would be irresistible.

19 comments

Krauthammer’s Take on Climate Change

Somewhat to my surprise I find myself largely in agreement with Charles Krauthammer on climate change. He writes:

I repeat: I’m not a global warming believer. I’m not a global warming denier. I’ve long believed that it cannot be good for humanity to be spewing tons of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere. I also believe that those scientists who pretend to know exactly what this will cause in 20, 30 or 50 years are white-coated propagandists.

As I said yesterday I would have a lot more confidence in the claims of the advocates if there weren’t so many snake oil schemes. As the old rabbinic saying goes, “If a woman comes from a far country and tells you she’s divorced, believe her.”

The balance of his column is about the fatuousness of “settled science”.

14 comments

Letting the Side Down on Venezuela

I find the developments in Venezuela interesting and, likely, significant. Sadly, I don’t have the knowledge or background to comment on the situation with any real confidence. Am I breaking the code of the blogosphere?

14 comments

“Rahm the Impaler”

Esquire has an article on Rahm Emanuel. Overall, it’s favorable. Remarkably so, under the circumstances.

I think it’s about even money that the mayor will not seek re-election in 2015. Will he really have time to be the mayor of Chicago in 2015 and 2016? I think there will be pressing needs for his talents elsewhere.

0 comments

Will the Democrats Hold the Senate?

You might want to read Sean Trende’s analysis of the Democrats’ chances of retaining control of the Senate in the midterm elections. After all the hemming and hawing, he basically comes down where I am: they’ll hold it but it will be close. Barring some cataclysm, it’s really pretty unlikely that the Democrats will pick up seats in the Senate. My guess is that the Democratic Powers-That-Be recognize that and it’s the reason behind all the mau-mauing about Ruth Bader Ginsburg that’s been gonig on lately.

0 comments

Bickering About the Minimum Wage

The bickering about increasing the minimum wage continues, stirred up by the CBO report I mentioned yesterday. See here and here, for a taste of the discussion.

If anything, the CBO’s report convinces me that a 40% increase in the minimum wage would be problematic. The report rather clearly states that a 24% increase would destroy significantly fewer jobs than a 40% increase would. And a close reading of the report suggests that much of the benefit of a minimum wage increase would be realized by white teenagers living at home with Mommie and Daddy in reasonably prosperous circumstances while the pain would be born by black teenagers. I don’t find that an acceptable outcome.

I pointed out some of the shortcomings in the CBO report yesterday. There’s one thing that puzzles me. The 500,000 jobs lost figure for a 40% increase in the minimum wage seems to be a brute force, split-the-difference figure between zero jobs lost and a million jobs lost. Does the CBO really believe that all of the probabilities from zero to a million are equally likely?

Update

Alexis Simendinger read it the same way I do. If there’s an increase in the minimum wage, it might well be to $9.00 rather than to $10.10.

3 comments

Thoughts on Climate Change

Since the brouhaha over Secretary Kerry’s remarks about climate change is continuing, viz. here, I thought I’d repeat my views on the subject.

First, I think there are pressing geopolitical reasons for the United States to reduce its oil consumption. I have thought that for more than 30 years and the reasons for it today are, if anything, more pressing than they were decades ago. Even if all of the other reasons we might want to reduce our carbon emissions turned out to be balloon juice, those geopolitical reasons would constitute enough reason for us to consume less oil. A good place to start might be to trim our subsidies for oil consumption. I’m not a big fan of carbon trading schemes—too much opportunity for gaming the system which, presumably, is why they’re so highly favored in some political circles. After trimming subsidies a good, stiff tax on gasoline consumption would be my second alternative.

The earth as we know it has been around for, what, a billion years or so? (I know that the age of the planet is about 4.5 billion years; it wasn’t much like the earth we know then.) The climate has been changing all of that time and it will continue to change regardless of what we do.

Climate change, regardless of its cause, presents a problem for us. It’s not just the dire conditions under which the planet becomes inhospitable to human life that we need to worry about. 10,000 years ago when the climate changed, people just picked up and moved. That’s a lot harder than it used to be. There are a lot more of us, just about every place already has people in it, and over the last millennium or so we’ve developed something called “robust property rights” that makes it even harder to pick up and move than it was ten or twenty thousand years ago.

Robust property rights are Good Things. They’ve produced more prosperity, happiness, and well-being than just about anything else I can think of. They’re worth preserving. So, climate change, preserving the lives of millions (or billions) of people, robust property rights. You can’t have all three.

My preference for coping with climate change (whatever its cause) would be technological solutions. I’ve posted on any number of them over the years. For one thing, you don’t need every other country in the world’s cooperation to put them into effect.

I don’t think the models of climate change due to human-produced emission of greenhouse gases are robust enough to make detailed predictions of the sort that warmist alarmists are trying to make. See the linked op-ed above for more on that. And, as Glenn Reynolds has pointed out any number of times, it would be a lot easier to take their predictions seriously if they were behaving as though their predictions were true.

The notion that every country and every place in every country should have exactly the same energy needs, ways, and means is baffling to me.

I think that the failure to build more nuclear generators to produce power, a decision made 40 years ago, was an enormous error. I thought so then, too. I have great hopes for very small scale nuclear power generation, especially small scale power generation using thorium as fuel. Note that most of the electrical power that I use was generated by a nuclear power plant. California, however, is a lousy place for nuclear power plants. California is a lousy place for a large population but that’s a completely different subject.

I’m a lot more worried about ocean acidification than I am about climate change.

I’ve rambled on long enough. That should be something to chew on.

23 comments

It Ain’t Just the 1% vs. the 99%

Richard Reeves suggests that rather than thinking about the 1% vs. the 99% it would be more productive to think about three groups—the affluent, the “squeezed”, and the entrenched poor:

At the very least, recent economic and social trends suggest a trifurcation rather than bifurcation of society, with two consequent divides. At the top, we can see an elite doing well in a labor market offering big returns to human capital. This is perhaps not the just the top 1% (much though politics might be easier if that were so) but, say, the top decile, or 10%, of the income distribution.

This stratum is not only prospering economically. For the people on this top rung, education levels are high and rising. Families are planned, marriages strong, neighborhoods safe and rich in social capital, networks plentiful, BMIs low and savings rates high.

Below this affluent class is a broad swath sometimes dubbed the ‘squeezed middle.’ This group have decent labor market participation rates, but wages that are rising slowly. In many cases, two wages are needed to support the family. They own a home, but are not otherwise wealthy. Savings exist for emergencies or one-off expenditures, but run out fast if the households has a serious downward shock to income. Private schooling is rarely an option, financially. (This is a group that might benefit from one of the schemes of wage insurances currently being discussed, most recently by Prof Miles Corak).

At the bottom of the social scale are those whose poverty is entrenched. Labor market attachment is weak, with many people in long-term unemployment. Teen pregnancy is still heard of, unlike in most communities today. Poverty is felt in most domains of life – crime, health, education, parenting, drug addiction and housing. The growing economic segregation of neighborhoods further isolates this group from chances of work, better schooling or valuable social networks. Upward intergenerational mobility rates are low.

Color me “squeezed”, marginally attached to the labor force as I am now. I think there might actually be four groups—I’d divide the poor into “entrenched poverty” and “imported poverty”. See here for some statistics on the demographics of poverty in the United States. About a third of the poor are black; a majority of the increase in the poor since 1972 are Hispanic.

I’m not really clear on the theory for importing more poverty into the United States when we already have poverty that’s becoming increasingly entrenched.

8 comments

Again With the Tiger Repellent

I see that in Ruth Marcus’s defense for the substantive success of the ARRA, nowhere does she present actual evidence of its efficacy. She does assert that fiscal stimulus is “a classic, and sensible, Keynesian response to recession”, something with which I agree.

The problem is that to be effective fiscal stimulus must be of an appropriate size, timed properly, and structured correctly. None of those was the case.

I think that several things were necessary for an effective stimulus. All of it should have been spent as quickly as possible rather than dribbling it out over several years. If it had been as effective as it should have been, political support for it would have grown rather than weakened as it manifestly did. The only way to spend so large a stimulus quickly is through the tax system (remember the president’s rueful remark that he learned there were no shovel-ready projects?). My preference would have been a payroll tax holiday, a complete suspension of both sides of the payroll tax.

2 comments

The CBO Weighs In

There really isn’t much in the CBO’s projection on the effects of increasing the minimum wage that you wouldn’t expect. It would help some people. It would hurt others. It would reduce employment.

Reactions to the report, too, are much what you’d expect, i.e. where you stand depends on where you sit. I do notice that few are mentioning the substantial difference the CBO finds between increasing the minimum wage to $9.00 (24%) as opposed to $10.10 (40%)—the larger increase would throw five times as many people out of work.

There are other things that aren’t mentioned. For example, the CBO doesn’t essay a projection into the effect that any increase would have on future job growth. Or on what sectors and populations the deleterious effects of an increase would fall heaviest or the beneficial effects help most. And they don’t appear to consider that increasing the minimum wage would incentivize a black market in labor.

Whatever the boosters or critics say there ain’t much new here.

1 comment