A Signalling Problem

Riddle me this. How does this reality of European defense spending:

At 1.9%, France last year fell short of the 2% that is supposed to be the technical requirement for membership. Mr. Rasmussen’s Denmark spent 1.4% of its GDP on defense, Angela Merkel’s Germany 1.3%, Italy 1.2%, and Spain 0.9%. This is what a country spends if it thinks its main security threat is Belgium.

constitute an argument for greater U. S. commitment to Europe? When you consider all of the NATO countries only four—Estonia, Greece, the United Kingdom, and the United States—spend more than the 2% of GDP guideline for membership in the alliance. Most, like Germany (1.3%), spend less. Some, like Luxembourg (.4%), Spain (.9%), and Canada (1%), spend much less. Some of the free riders, e.g. Luxembourg and Canada, cannot plead poverty. Luxembourg has the highest median household income in the world. The free riders mostly just have other priorities.

In aggregate the countries of Europe have a higher GDP than the United States but their aggregate defense spending is a fraction of ours. I attribute a good deal of the discrepancy to bad signalling on the part of the United States. Take the war in the Balkans as an example.

We had very few interests in the Balkans. Germany, on the other hand, had substantial financial interests, particularly in Croatia. The Germans had been courting the Croats for years prior to Croatia’s declaration of independence. Italy had substantial interests as well, particularly as the refugees of the conflict began streaming across their border. The carnage in Yugoslavia was a mostly European problem that should have been soluble by the Europeans.

When we joined the intervention in the Balkans it signalled to the Europeans that we would provide the military muscle to handle even purely European crises. We have repeated that signal again and again since then. Is it any wonder that our European allies have interpreted our actions as absolving them from any need for paying for their own defense let alone paying for more general European security. They preferred to spend the money on social welfare as who wouldn’t under the circumstances?

We’re in the position of the man who has an enormous pain in his head because he’s pounding his head into a brick wall. The first thing to do is stop.

15 comments

Do We Really Want to Maximize GDP?

At The American Sean Speer and Charles Lammam lay out the case that once the size of government has exceeded some fixed percentage of GDP that further increases in the size of government will be accompanied by declines in economic growth:

Di Matteo examines international data and finds that, after controlling for confounding factors, annual per capita GDP growth is maximized when government spending consumes 26 percent of the economy. Economic growth rates start to decline when relative government spending exceeds this level. In other words, there is a hump-shaped relationship between the size of government and economic growth (this relationship is often referred to as the Scully Curve, named after the economist Gerald Scully).

According to OECD data, the size of government in the United States was approximately 40 percent of GDP in 2012. While Di Matteo’s estimate of the tipping point is based on international data, it suggests that President Obama should reduce government to boost the U.S. economy. This conclusion is supported by a larger literature (see here, here, here, and here) that has also found that a smaller size of government than what currently exists in the United States would translate into higher annual economic growth.

While I’m open to the possibility that the assertion is correct, they don’t convince me that it is or that you can make that determination using the methods that are being employed. For one thing, I’m skeptical that all economies react the same way to big governments and most of the studies of the relation between government size and economic growth have been international.

I’m much more interested in ways and means for increasing production since I think that the particular problem of the U. S. economy is that we don’t produce enough of what we consume.

However, I’m suspicious about the premise as well. Do we really care about maximizing GDP? If we could add $10 trillion dollars to GDP and all of that $10 trillion would be put into the hands of one individual, would it be a policy we’d want to pursue? A hundred people? A thousand? Why?

10 comments

He’s a Card

I can only presume that this remark by Fred Hiatt at the Washington Post is intended as humor:

Even the now-ridiculed “reset” of U.S.-Russia relations was worth a try; no one knew for sure whether then-president Dmitry Medvedev might offer a viable alternative to Putinism.

Everyone knew. Except possibly Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama.

Don’t make the mistake of thinking that Putin and his policies are unpopular in Russia. He is significantly more popular there than President Obama is here. His actions in Ukraine have made him more popular.

On the meat of his column I both agree and disagree with Mr. Hiatt’s column. I agree with this:

There was no viable military option that could have discouraged Putin’s invasion of Ukraine, and there is no military option to reverse it.

and I disagree with this:

The president came into office believing that military assets were a 19th-century measure of power, of dwindling relevance in the 21st century. He believed that diplomacy could solve problems that George W. Bush had ignored, created or exacerbated; that the eventual abolition of nuclear weapons was perhaps the United States’ most important goal; that economic reconstruction at home had to take precedence over — and was a necessary prerequisite for — leadership abroad.

I think that President Obama believed that foreign leaders hated George Bush for the same reason that he did—because he was George Bush—rather than because he was president of the United States.

In the end I think that barring some catastrophe the idea that President Obama will reconsider his foreign policy as Mr. Hiatt suggests is far-fetched. I think he has entered the consolidation phase of his presidency rather than a reconsideration phase.

26 comments

Paying College Athletes

Yesterday on CBS’s Sunday Morning program they had a feature about whether college athletes should be paid. I don’t have a dog in this hunt but I don’t think the advocates really understand the argument they were making.

As I understood it they were arguing that due to the athletic scholarships they receive college athletes (not all college athletes are on scholarship) are already employees of the university and, consequently, the universities should shoulder the responsibilities of employers including paying their athletes cash wages.

To me the most obvious solution to the problem would be to end athletic scholarships.

I also suspect that the advocates don’t want to think about the fact that payments in kind are taxable and if athletes are employees then a Northwestern University athlete on scholarship owes on the order of $20,000 to the IRS but that’s a different subject.

3 comments

Chutzpah Award of the Day

I’m awarding the award of the day for chutzpah to Leonardo Agate, writing at tp24 Rubriche, Italy:

Obama, who has dragged European countries along, some unwillingly and to the detriment of themselves, suffers due to a remoteness from the European situation, and cannot overcome the obstacle of his lack of historical experience. The president of the most powerful nation on the planet supposes he can condition the development of international crisis by applying criteria that are too recent to be concretely actionable.

Pop quiz. What was the proximate cause of the Euromaidan demonstrations that began in November 2013 and ultimately lead to the present crisis?

8 comments

Refugee of the 60s

If you’d like a nice example of a point I’ve repeatedly around here, that the federal government is stuck in the past from a business processes standpoint, this description of the Office of Personnel Management should give you the general idea:

Here, inside the caverns of an old Pennsylvania limestone mine, there are 600 employees of the Office of Personnel Management. Their task is nothing top-secret. It is to process the retirement papers of the government’s own workers.

But that system has a spectacular flaw. It still must be done entirely by hand, and almost entirely on paper.

The employees here pass thousands of case files from cavern to cavern and then key in retirees’ personal data, one line at a time. They work underground not for secrecy but for space. The old mine’s tunnels have room for more than 28,000 file cabinets of paper records.

This odd place is an example of how hard it is to get a time-wasting bug out of a big bureaucratic system.

Held up by all that paper, work in the mine runs as slowly now as it did in 1977.

“The need for automation was clear — in 1981,” said James W. Morrison Jr., who oversaw the retirement-processing system under President Ronald Reagan. In a telephone interview this year, Morrison recalled his horror upon learning that the system was all run on paper: “After a year, I thought, ‘God, my reputation will be ruined if we don’t fix this,’ ” he said.

That approach had been obsolete for a decade or more when it was adopted. Yet another example of how the federal government does not handle technology well.

6 comments

The To-Do List

John Goodman has a to-do list for reforming the PPACA:

Getting rid of the mandates, letting people choose their own insurance benefits, and giving everyone the same universal tax credit for health insurance would be a good start. More easily accessible health savings accounts for people in high-deductible plans is another good idea.

Every provision in ObamaCare that encourages employers either not to hire people or to reduce their hours should go. Everything in the law that prevents employers from providing individually owned health insurance that travels from job to job should go. And everything that makes HealthCare.gov more complicated than eHealth (a 10-year-old
private online exchange) should go.

I presume that most of the things that make HealthCare.gov more complicated than eHealth are due to its need to interact with an alphabet soup of government agencies, each with its own mutually-incompatible, frustrating, and obsolete access method. Those are in desperate need of reform but, sadly, experience suggests that they’ll only be reformed when it’s absolutely, positively, ten years later than they should have been replaced and then they’ll be replaced with something just as maddeningly obscure as what they’re replacing. What probably should have been done was to have established a set of standards in the context of the PPACA and mandated that the various agencies conform to them. Water under the bridge.

Meanwhile, I wish someone could provide a good explanation on the merits of why we continue to subsidize big business at the expense of small ones. It’s one of life’s mysteries.

Sadly, Republicans are in permanent attack mode while Democrats are in permanent defense mode. That makes it darned hard to hold an adult conversation on how the PPACA should be reformed.

19 comments

Winning the Silver

I see that in the post from Nate Silver that is provoking squeals of outrage from Democratic partisans he is in essence predicting what I have for some time: a Senate that is even more closely divided than the present Senate. I think it’s likely to be 50-50. Mr. Silver apparently thinks it’s more likely to be 51-49 with Republicans gaining control of that house.

This might also be a good time to repeat my suggestion that President Obama’s pollsters are telling him the same thing. That’s why his rhetoric has gradually shifted from gaining control of both houses of the Congress to what he can do without Congressional support.

1 comment

Not in a Vacuum

There’s a post by Ta-Nehisi Coates at The Atlantic that I think deserves more attention than it will probably receive. I find it troubling and largely true. The post is part of an ongoing dialogue between Mr. Coates and Jonathan Chaits on the prevailing progressive view of the pathologies that afflict the black community, epitomized in the president’s “My Brothers Keeper” initiative. The core of Mr. Coates’s argument is that none of the so-called pathologies to which people point arose in a vacuum:

And we do not find an era free of white supremacy in our times either, when the rising number of arrests for marijuana are mostly borne by African-Americans; when segregation drives a foreclosure crisis that helped expand the wealth gap; when big banks busy themselves baiting black people with “wealth-building seminars” and instead offering “ghetto loans” for “mud people”; when studies find that black low-wage applicants with no criminal record “fared no better than a white applicant just released from prison”; when, even after controlling for neighborhoods and crime rates, my son finds himself more likely to be stopped and frisked. Chait’s theory of independent black cultural pathologies sounds reasonable. But it can’t actually be demonstrated in the American record, and thus has no applicability.

I think that’s just the tip of the iceberg. IMO AFDC destroyed the black family in ways that slavery never could. Oppression evokes resistance in a way that responding to incentives does not. Without taking a breath, I could probably produce a dozen different ways that anti-black racism is operative today, not just in the form of overt racism but in the actions of the very nicest people.

That’s not to say that I don’t think there are actual cultural problems in the black community. I do agree with Mr. Coates that these problems didn’t arise in a vacuum and the context needs to considered as well as the consequences. It isn’t simply poverty—there are distinctive problems in the black community that aren’t factors among other ethnic or racial communities that are equally poor.

Perhaps we can start some discussion on this subject. What do you think of Mr. Coates’s post? We don’t have a time machine. How do we solve these problems on a day-forward basis?

7 comments

Things to Think About Russia

I am more inclined to forgive Ross Douthat’s maunderings on Russia than I am Anne Applebaum’s or Zbigniew Brzezinski’s. I would expect that they, at least, should know what the heck they’re talking about. I don’t expect Mr. Douthat, on the other hand, to know anything about Russia but what he reads in the newspapers.

What I’ve been trying to explain to people, both here and at Outside the Beltway, are the realities of dealing with Russia. Let me summarize what I think people should recognize:

  1. Russia has interests and a foreign policy which are not ipso facto opposed to ours.
  2. One of those interests is access to its base at Sevastopol which from Russia’s point of view is not negotiable.
  3. Having hostile countries on its border is a persistent irritant to the Russians.
  4. The present Ukrainian government is an illiberal kleptocracy.
  5. If pressed hard enough, Russia will use nuclear weapons.
  6. The EU is unlikely to impose economic sanctions on Russia with any bite.

I do not support Russia or Putin but Russia is not the Soviet Union and does not present anything remotely like the threat to us that the Soviet Union did. The Soviet Union was not only run by violent thugs, from the 1920s to the 1950s those thugs had dreams of riding to victory on the wings of world revolution and they had some reason to believe that was possible.

Ukraine is not worth risking nuclear war over.

If you want to read something reasonably sensible about the Ukrainian situation this piece by Christopher Booker in the Torygraph is closer to the mark:

The EU knows it is powerless to prevent Mr Putin in due course absorbing Ukraine’s Russian-speaking industrial heartland, leaving the EU to look after what remains of that bankrupt country, like a dismembered corpse. But there is no sign that those impotent nonentities who pose as our leaders have yet realised that their ambition to take over Ukraine must now rank alongside the euro as the two leading examples of how their collective act of make-believe is finally hitting the brick wall of reality.

13 comments