What’s Wrong With GM’s Culture?

The reason that GM didn’t live up to its legal responsibilities and recall millions of vehicles years ago isn’t because of the CAFE standards, as suggested by its new CEO, Mary Barra:

Federal regulations essentially prevented Detroit from building the small cars more cheaply offshore. That’s because the auto makers still had to meet stringent fuel-efficiency averages for all the cars they produced domestically. So in order to keep building the big vehicles they could make profitably, they had to churn out lots of fuel-efficient vehicles and somehow make them cheap enough to compete with cars produced by non-union workers.

Is this why GM didn’t make much earlier what seems like a relatively inexpensive fix? Ms. Barra suggested as much this week. “In the past,” she said, “we had more of a cost culture, and now we have a customer culture that focuses on safety and quality.”

I find that excuse, as the WSJ concurs, to be pretty threadbare. There are all sorts of ways that GM could cut costs. For example, they could cut executive pay. CEO pay now stands at roughly $14 million. It is obvious, except possibly to GM executives, that there’s room for cost-cutting there. The pay of top management pulls up the pay of the next layer of managers which pulls up the next layer and so on. And there are so many layers. You’d think that GM’s near-death experience would have impelled cultural change but, sadly, not enough:

Keep in mind that GM’s culture would have been turned upside down and might no longer exist if the government hadn’t preserved it. In the throes of the financial panic and recession, Chrysler and GM could no longer be sustained without help from Washington. In December 2008 they began receiving money from the Troubled Asset Relief Program. More aid came in 2009 when the feds engineered bankruptcies.

There’s plenty of room for flattening GM’s organizational structure. Why haven’t they done it?

GM’s cover-up of its defective switches persisted during the federal government’s oversight of GM. Either that oversight was quite superficial with the single-minded objective of preserving the labor unions or the federal government was complicit in the cover-up.

The 12-step programs say that the first step on the road to recovery is acknowledging that you have a problem. GM doesn’t seem to have taken that first step yet and the federal government has abetted the company’s failure to adapt.

Last month GM sold about 1,500 Volts. I guess that makes it worth it.

20 comments

Marc Platt, 1913-2014

He was born Marcel LePlat in Pasadena. When he joined the Ballet Russe de Monte Carlo, its director, Leonid Massine, Russified his name to Marc Platoff. On Broadway and in Hollywood he was called Marc Platt.

He danced the “Dream Curly” in the original Broadway production of Oklahoma, was a lead in Hollywood musicals in the 1940s, and was the oldest dancing brother in the movie 7 Brides for 7 Brothers. He has died at the age of 100:

Platt, who celebrated his 100th birthday in December, died Saturday in a hospice facility in San Rafael, Calif. The cause was complications from pneumonia, said his daughter, Donna Platt.

He was born Marcel Emile Gaston LePlat in Pasadena on Dec. 2, 1913, the only child of a concert violinist and soprano singer. The family traveled a lot for performances and finally settled in Seattle. When his father died around the time of the move, his mother “got a job in Mary Ann Wells’ dancing school,” Platt said in a 1946 Hedda Hopper column that ran in the Los Angeles Times. “I wanted to help buy the bacon, so I got a job as an errand boy at the same school.”

But Wells saw his potential as a dancer, and after eight years of lessons, she arranged for him to audition for Ballet Russe when the company visited Seattle.

That was followed by Broadway and then by Hollywood. In later years he directed the ballet company at Radio City Music Hall, then ran a dancing school in Fort Myers, Florida. His last screen appearance was in a documentary in 2005. He just couldn’t get show business out of his blood.

He was an extraordinarily gifted performer.

0 comments

Some of the Animals Are More Equal Than Others

In re the announcement that the FBI is opening a criminal investigation of Citigroup, Jonathan Weil of Bloomberg remarks:

The big story of the morning comes from New York Times reporters Ben Protess and Michael Corkery, although it’s important to remember that, in the U.S. these days, criminal investigations of large banks don’t result in criminal prosecutions of large banks, because the Justice Department for all practical purposes has deemed them immune: “Federal authorities have opened a criminal investigation into a recent $400 million fraud involving Citigroup’s Mexican unit, according to people briefed on the matter, one of a handful of government inquiries looming over the giant bank. The investigation, overseen by the FBI and prosecutors from the United States attorney’s office in Manhattan, is focusing in part on whether holes in the bank’s internal controls contributed to the fraud in Mexico.” Here’s what I’d like to know: What was Corbat’s basis for certifying that Citigroup’s internal controls were effective when the company filed its 2013 annual report? Because, at least from the perspective of an outsider looking in, they sure don’t seem like they were effective in all material respects.

I think we’ll find that this is theatrics or, more precisely, battlespace preparation. How are you going to extract large political contributions (not to mention justifying that million dollar job after getting out of government) if you don’t have a nice club to wield?

1 comment

Tally At 16

Today is Tally’s 16th birthday. Happy Birthday, Tally!

Every day with her these days is a blessing and a new adventure. She has difficulty negotiating the three stairs from the house into the backyard so I carry her down the stairs. I just stabilize her a bit when she’s on her way back in. We need to coax her to eat. Recently, I’ve taken to tempting her by adding bacon grease or melted pork lard to her food which she likes very much. I’m sure her teeth hurt her but she’s frail enough there’s not much we can do about them.

Somewhat to our surprise we got the pressure sore, the equivalent of a bed sore, on her right hip under control. She’s a bit unkempt in this picture but she really doesn’t think very highly of grooming these days.

Tally is the oldest Samoyed we’ve ever had and, I think, the oldest Samoyed I’ve ever met. When people ask “how old do Samoyeds get?” the usual answer is 12 to 14 years. She’s outlived the actuarial tables.

She’s still eating, pooping, walking around, doing her stuff. She’s still happy. As long as that’s the case I’m willing to do what I can to keep her that way.

10 comments

Misleading Headlines

When I saw the caption “Tillis, Berger Issue Joint Statement on Newly Discovered, Alarming Evidence of Voter Error and Fraud”, I presume I should be forgiven for expecting evidence of voter error and fraud. I was disappointed. What was actually presented were warning flags. Here’s an example:

765 voters with an exact match of first and last name, DOB and last four digits of SSN were registered in N.C. and another state and voted in N.C. and the other state in the 2012 general election.

That’s not evidence of actual fraud. I do think it suggests that more investigation is warranted.

Some of the numbers presented were actually pretty alarming:

155,692 voters with the same first and last name, DOB and last four digits of SSN were registered in N.C. and another state – and the latest date of registration or voter activity did not take place within N.C.

765 votes would not be enough to swing North Carolina’s statewide elections in 2012. They might have been enough to influence the House elections.

However, 765 votes would have been enough to change the outcome of the Minnesota election for the U. S. Senate, for example, which could have made the difference between the PPACA’s being passed or not.

I honestly don’t understand why progressives pooh-pooh claims of widespread vote fraud. It’s not like Bigfoot. There have been enough convictions in the courts that its existence can’t reasonably be disputed and in very close elections a few votes one way or another can make a difference.

24 comments

Godzilla vs. King Ghidorah

In the wake of Charles Koch’s WSJ op-ed (for commentary see here) I’ve seen a lot of agonistic reactions. In response both to the Supreme Court’s McCutcheon decision and the op-ed, I’d like to take note of Open Secrets’s analysis of the comparative political contributions of George Soros, who contributes almost exclusively to left-leaning political organizations, with those of the Koch brothers, who contribute equally exclusively to right-leaning ones. Here’s their conclusion:

Given the difficultly in tracking donations to nonprofits and charitable organizations, it’s almost impossible to quantify whether the Koch brothers or Soros dominate this political realm. That said, both the Kochs and Soros have spent incredible riches in this area with no sign of stopping.

I see all of this in a somewhat different light. I think that like most sharp traders both Mr. Soros and Mssrs. Koch know a bargain when they see one. Starting in the 1990s Mr. Soros saw a distressed property—the Democratic Party—with potential and he made moves to get a controlling interest. Over the last half dozen years the Koch brothers have been doing the same with respect to the Republican Party.

The really depressing part of the whole thing is how easily the parties can be bought.

25 comments

I’m Just Not That Interested in McCutcheon

I can’t manage to work up much ardor about the recent Supreme Court decision governing individual political contributions one way or another. If you’re looking for commentary on it I found these remarks by Robert VerBruggen at RealClearPolicy as good as any.

I’m not particularly libertarian when it comes to political contributions, lobbying, and political influence, generally. If I were king, I’d restrict paid political advertising on television severely, limit individual political contributions, prohibit contributions by non-individuals, prohibit lobbying any representatives other than your own, and other measures with an eye towards de-professionalizing politics. I have no illusions that anybody but I support such an idea.

4 comments

Foreign Policy Blogging at OTB (Updated)

I’ve just published a couple of foreign policy-related posts at Outside the Beltway:

That’s a Good Question

Jeffrey Tayler asks President Obama ten questions about the Ukrainian situation. Foreign policy does tend to happen to presidents, willy-nilly. It’s how the job is defined.

No Meltdown But the End of 10% Economic Growth for China

In this post I excerpt and remark on a good column by Martin Wolf in The Financial Times.

5 comments

One Swallow Doth Not a Summer Make

The editors of Bloomberg enter the lists on reforming the PPACA:

Now that the rush of enrollment has passed, the challenge is to identify and respond to at least three kinds of concerns. The first involves relatively narrow problems with the law itself. For example, many state-run exchanges are poorly run; states such as Maryland and Massachusetts need help to fix them in time for the next open enrollment period, which starts in November. The law’s programs to cushion insurers from excess risk may also need reinforcement — if not enough young people sign up for insurance — to lessen any shocks to premiums next year.

That leads to the second kind of problem — with the health-care system generally. This includes persuading still more young people to sign up next time; getting more doctors and hospitals to coordinate care, making good on the promise to make medicine more affordable; and smoothing the transition from employer-based coverage for people who lose it.

I’ve mentioned before the stated objectives of the PPACA:

The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act will ensure that all Americans have access to quality, affordable health care and will create the transformation within the health care system necessary to contain costs.

It’s just about four years since the PPACA was enacted into law and neither of those objectives has been effected. Some say that other worthwhile objectives have been acconmplished and those were, in fact, the real objectives. To believe that you must believe that the president and Democratic Congressmen have been lying. I prefer to believe that they genuinely believed that insurance reform would effect the changes that were the stated objectives.

But that can only be true if care and insurance are identical. Not just congruent. Identical. And they most definitely aren’t. Care is limited by the resources available for care and those resources are limited by design. Roughly a third of doctors won’t accept new Medicaid patients. About 10% of doctors (and 57% of psychiatrists) don’t accept insurance at all and that trend is increasing rather than decreasing. Among primary care providers more than 30% plan to stop practicing within five years (more than 50% among physicians over 50). There is already a critical shortage and that’s before you factor in an increased number of people seeking care.

We’d better all hope that excessive care-seeking by the insured is a figment of our imaginations.

I think the prospects for reforming the PPACA in any substantial way are very slim for the foreseeable future. They’ll fight it out on this line if it takes all summer.

11 comments

What’s the Next Move?

the editors of the Chicago Tribune respond to Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel’s plan for addressing Chicago’s public pension problem:

Three years into his mayoral term — after campaigning on a promise to fix pensions — Rahm Emanuel finally is ready to file legislation that would reduce the city’s dangerously unfunded pension liabilities for municipal workers and laborers. Emanuel says he has a deal with those employees’ unions that would bring two of the city’s four funds for retirees closer to full funding. The agreement includes a mix of politically risky property tax increases and benefit cuts.

Note the operative word: two of the city’s pension funds. City Hall hasn’t come to terms with police and firefighters over the unfunded liabilities in their pension funds, or with teachers who work for Chicago Public Schools, a separate taxing body. Yet to stabilize just two of the funds, he already is proposing an increase in property taxes, to be phased in over five years.

Why has it taken the mayor so long? I can think of any number of reasons. He may have had the vain hope that the Illinois legislature would save the city. It’s far from a done deal that they will even approve his plan or whether once approved it would survive court challenge.

He may have hoped that an improving economy would render the question moot. That hasn’t happened.

He might have been too busy planning his next career move to formulate a plan.

Something that non-Illinoisans should keep in mind: the city is just one of dozens of independently taxing entities, all of whom will undoubtedly be increasing the property tax. Add to that the “temporary” increase in the personal state income tax which the governor has proposed be made permanent and the state’s persistent economic woes and we’re right on track to be the state with the highest taxes, the highest rate of unemployment, and the lowest state contribution to education.

For most people Illinois is only an attractive place to live when business in the state is good. Attracting blue chip businesses (which will only cut jobs going forward) with inducements in the favor of special tax treatment just puts the burden on companies and individuals who can’t get similar treatment is a lousy strategy. It appears to be the only strategy our state’s leaders have.

6 comments