Biting the Hand That Feeds You

I can’t help but wonder if this episode:

Senate Democrats ripped former CIA Director Michael Hayden on Monday for describing Sen. Dianne Feinstein as “emotional,” calling Hayden’s remarks both a “baseless smear” and condescending.

Hayden on Sunday said the Senate Intelligence chairwoman may have been motivated by a “deep, emotional feeling” in her move last week to declassify a five-year investigation into the Central Intelligence Agency’s detention and interrogation policies. He concluded the report may not be objective, though the report’s findings have not yet been been made public and Hayden said he hadn’t read it.

isn’t emblematic of a whole mindset in the military and CIA rather than just one of Republicans, as maintained by Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid. The reality is that Sen. Feinstein is the superior of both generals and the CIA and, even more importantly, their patron. If anybody’s going to be condescending, it should be the other way around.

You just don’t treat your patrons that way. It’s as though the CIA thinks that it has some sort of claim on the public purse without any sort of oversight. I can understand how they might think that since that’s more or less the way it’s been throughout the organization’s history but it ain’t necessarily so.

7 comments

The Golden Rule

In an op-ed at The Wall Street Journal, Daniel Mitchell makes an interesting proposal:

Rather than fixating on deficits and debt, I suggest another goal: Ensure that government spending, over time, grows more slowly than the private economy. Evidence from economies around the world shows this is the best path to bring down deficits and nurture prosperity.

He goes on to explain how it would work and cites the examples of how something like his proposal has worked in Canada, Sweden, and Germany, not exactly havens of anarcho-capitalism.

While I think his ideas have merit, I’m still skeptical as to their practicality. For one thing, I’m skeptical of any attempt at central planning. I don’t think they can ever be administered quite as well as their proponents believe.

Additionally, private sector growth is always an after-the-fact determination. How would he propose that the government deal with the inevitable miscalculations and is that politically possible?

Finally, how would his “Golden Rule” operate in cyclical downturns? He appears to want the operative words in his prescription to be “grows more slowly” but I think they’re actually “over time”. To me his proposal would require a very different balance between discretionary spending and entitlement spending than actually prevails.

I don’t think our most serious fiscal problem is that government grows during and immediately after recessions. I think it’s that government grows during and immediately after recessions, long after the recovery is well under way, while the recovery is peaking, and ever after.

I think there’s a name for all of this and it’s “time inconsistency”. What would motivate politicians to behave as he’d want them? Statesmanship? That’s a good one.

10 comments

What Are They So Afraid Of?

When I read this NYT op-ed, my immediate reaction, especially following hard on the heels of Paul Krugman’s spat with Nate Silver, was that the op-ed was more pushback against him. I recognize that it’s an op-ed and not an editorial but I also seriously doubt that the NYT publishes op-eds from any passing stranger. The selection of op-eds to run is as much a part of editorial policy as editorials are. Just as the news that they decide isn’t “fit to print” is.

Pretty obviously he’s got a lot of his former associates spooked. Why?

5 comments

Emanuel Interviewed

Check out this interview with Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel in The New Republic. As I have no doubt made clear I do not hold the mayor in high regard and this interview should give some idea why.

I have grave reservations about parleying an unquestionable skill as a Democratic Party fundraiser into riches and power.

Update

Apparently, it’s not just right-wingers and centrists who have problems with the mayor. digby remarks:

Please let this be his last job in politics. Then he can go back to Wall Street where he belongs.

I feel so much better know that I know I’m not alone. Now if we can only persuade the voters of Chicago…

5 comments

Mickey Rooney, 1920-2014

One of the last big stars of the Golden Age of Hollywood has died:

Mickey Rooney, a celebrated child actor who embodied the All-American boy in the “Andy Hardy” films of the 1930s and ’40s and became one of the era’s top box-office draws, has died. He was 93.

Rooney, whose roller-coaster show-business career was marked by an often-turbulent personal life, died Sunday at his home in Los Angeles. Los Angeles Police Commander Andrew Smith and the Los Angeles County coroner’s office confirmed his death.

Rooney’s daughter-in-law Charlene Rooney said the actor died of natural causes Sunday afternoon at the home he shared with her and her husband, Mark Rooney.

I can only think of a few remaining top box office stars from that period. Olivia de Havilland and Luise Rainer come to mind and, remarkably, they’re both older than The Mick.

Despite the Irish stage name he wasn’t an Irishman. He was a Scot—his dad was Scottish-born vaudevillean Joe Yule. According to my mom, who appeared in vaudeville at just about the same time as Mickey Rooney did, as a child actor Rooney started out doing impressions of his dad. I presume she was passing along her dad’s assessment.

I was never much of a fan of the Andy Hardy pictures or his musicals with Judy Garland. His performances were just too manic. He began to come into his own with National Velvet but by that time he was starting to put his ingenue roles behind him. Like many child performers his transition into adult roles was difficult.

IMO it wasn’t until his old age that his acting really shone in performances like that in Bill.

Like the trooper he was he worked right through to the end. There’s no better way for an old vaudevillean to go. We still have his performances from his heyday in the glow of our televisions in glorious black and white. Check out his performances as Puck in A Midsummer Night’s Dream, in Captain’s Courageous, and The Human Comedy. They’re some of his best.

0 comments

Blaming the Victims

Glenn Hubbard muses over why, despite the nonminal recovery, total employment is lagging so badly. He proposes a number of explanations, I think they’re all inadequate, and I’ll answer them in turn.

The Baby Boomers are retiring

Actually, the Baby Boomers are continuing to work in record numbers. They can’t afford to do otherwise:

“The fact of the matter is that this aging-but-not-yet-aged segment of the baby boomer class can’t afford to retire,” said David A. Rosenberg, the chief economist of Gluskin Sheff, a Canadian firm, noting that overall household net worth was 15 percent lower than at the prerecession peak. “Dreams of the 5,000-square-foot McMansion being a viable retirement asset have morphed into nightmares of a deflationary ball and chain.”

The accompanying charts show the percentage of various age groups with jobs since the end of 2006, when the overall percentage of people with jobs hit its cyclical peak. Each of the charts has a different range, but the same spread between the top and the bottom, so that a move of a given size represents the same gain or loss in percentage points.

For the first time since the government began keeping track of the numbers in 1981 — and probably the first time ever — one in nine American men over the age of 75 was working in April. About one in 20 women over that age have jobs.

Dr. Hubbard doesn’t believe that explanation, either:

A 2012 study by economists at the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago estimated that about one-quarter of the decline in labor-force participation since the start of the Great Recession can be traced to retirements. Other economists have attributed about half of the drop to the aging of baby boomers.

Baby boomers can’t be the whole story, though, since the participation rate has declined for younger workers too.

There are too many malingerers

That the number of people who are on Social Security Disability has grown enormously over the last half dozen years is indisputable. Dr. Hubbard presents no evidence that those who’ve enrolled are fraudulent. He merely assumes it.

Quite to the contrary I think a better explanation is that SSDI is the unemployment insurance of last resort. The long-term unemployed who no longer qualify for unemployment insurance payments and who qualify for it go on disability as a desperate means of bringing some money into the household. Rather than proving that there are a lot of malingerers out there, I think it proves that a lot of people who are tired and sick just keep working anyway.

Inadequate schooling and training

There is practically no evidence of this. Dr. Hubbard merely takes the assurances of the multi-billionaires who want to hammer down the wages of their skilled workers by importing workers from overseas who’ll work for less and over whom they have a hold into the country.

If this were actually the case, you’d expect to see rising wages in the technology sector. That hasn’t been the case for years.

It’s also unclear to me how much effect this will have when in our cities 50% of kids don’t graduate from high school. The one thing we can be confident it will do is boost the incomes of people in the educational sector. Since Dr. Hubbard is the Dean of the Columbia School of Business that may appear to him to be an unqualified good. Increasing incomes in the educational sector are only good for the country as a whole if the sector is actually producing more education and the evidence for that isn’t particularly good. There’s actually more evidence that education has reach the point of bureaucratic displacement and less education is being produced for every dollar spent.

Bad policies

In this Dr. Hubbard and I are in agreement. The stimulus was poorly timed and structured. But let’s not limit the list of bad policies to bad economic policies. We have bad security policies, bad healthcare policies, bad trade policies, bad immigration policies, and bad financial policies.

Workers are discouraged

They should be. There are too many long-term unemployed and not enough jobs for them.

Here are Dr. Hubbard’s prescriptions:

  1. Increase the Earned Income Tax Credit
  2. Tax reform
  3. Make it harder to receive disability payments
  4. Stop extending the duration of unemployment insurance
  5. Block grants to states to support training and educational development
  6. Eliminate the “retirement earnings test”

I agree with #1, #2, and #5 and disagree with #3 and #4, both of which assume that Americans are lazy layabouts. I don’t think that #5 will do much to boost employment but it might make life a little easier for seniors in the second and third income quintiles.

To Dr. Hubbard’s list I would add:

  1. Impose a duty on imports from countries who don’t have environmental and labor laws as strict as ours in the estimated amount of their cost to American businesses
  2. Encourage energy production in the United States
  3. Impose the commonsense reforms to immigration that I’ve mentioned around here any number of times.
  4. Healthcare reform

Our trade deficit is around a half billion dollars a year. As I’ve mentioned before that’s a drastic underestimate since it doesn’t take into account intracompany transfers, many of which are in fact imports. Producing more here would mean more jobs here.

Manufacturing demands energy and, frankly, renewables don’t produce enough energy to meet the needs of manufacturing. Rather than discouraging energy production here we need to encourage energy production. If you’re worried about carbon production, limit its production by raising the tax on gasoline to European levels. Limit road production. After transportation and energy, cement production is the largest producer of greenhouse gases.

We need healthcare reform that will lower the cost of employment.

We need measures that will actually incentivize job creation here. Americans aren’t lazy layabouts and policies that assume they are are misguided.

14 comments

Healthcare Costs Are Increasing

I didn’t want to let this get away without commenting on it and a hat tip to Megan McArdle at Bloomberg for the graph above, the data for which are from the Bureau of Economic Analysis. The graph depicts the quarter on quarter changes in real healthcare spending from 1999 to 2013.

You may have heard that the rate at which healthcare costs have been increasing has been going down. That’s illustrated in this graph by the general downward trend from 2001 to 2012 (when you average the changes over the year for 2011 the overall trend is still slightly downwards despite the slight spike). However, that trend may have ended as illustrated by the spike in the third quarter of 2013, the highest rate of increase since the second quarter of 2004.

I think there are several things to keep in mind.

  • As depicted these data are very noisy—there’s lots of up and down motion.
  • Since June of 2012 the rate of change in spending has increased fairly sharply.
  • This charge does not depict expenditures. It depicts the rate of change in real expenditures.
  • Real expenditures are going up and they have been going up for decades.
  • No one knows why expenditures have started going up again just as no one knows why they went down. No one knows if the recent increase in spending is a fluke or part of a trend.
  • The CBO, etc. found that the slowing in the rate of change in spending could not be attributed to the PPACA.
  • Real spending on healthcare is increasing, it’s increasing faster than incomes or non-healthcare spending, and that’s been going on for decades. That’s illustrated by the two quarters over the period of the last 14 years in which spending did not increase. That’s only two quarters out of more than 50.
  • I really wish the graph went back another thirty years. If it did, what you’d see is very sharp increases from 1965 to 1980 with the rate of increase moderating considerably after that, roughly to what it is now. You would also see that the pattern is cyclical, i.e. they go up for a while, then they slow, they they go up for a while, and the pattern repeats.

This graph reflects intentional behavior. By that I mean that it’s not like weather patterns, the tides, or the motions of the planets. It’s more like a fencing match. Incentives matter. Different people engage in different behaviors and the net effect is what you see in a graph like the one above. Healthcare providers respond to changes in government policy. Individuals respond to changes in costs. Policymakers respond to political pressure.

Update

Fron the President’s Council of Economic Advisors, also using data from the Bureau of Economic Analysis, here’s a graph illustrating the growth in healthcare spending with a longer time horizon:

The portion at the far right of the graph, roughly from the 2002 spike to the present, illustrates the same data as are in the graph at the top of the page. As you can see typical growth rates in healthcare spending over the period have been at around 6%, with slower growth since about 2006. Remember, both of these graphs depict the rate of increase rather than just plain old expenditures.

Note that this chart completely bears out the thumbnail analysis I made in the body of the post:

very sharp increases from 1965 to 1980 with the rate of increase moderating considerably after that, roughly to what it is now. You would also see that the pattern is cyclical

28 comments

Blow Me Down!

If this Gallup poll is correct, Illinois residents are much more discerning than I gave them credit for. Illinois residents are less trusting of their state government than those of any other state in the union:

PRINCETON, NJ — Illinois residents trust their state government to handle their state’s problems far less than residents in any other state. Twenty-eight percent of Illinois residents trust their state government “a great deal” or “a fair amount.” In contrast, at least 75% of North Dakota, Wyoming, and Utah residents trust their state governments.

What’s a ten letter word that begins with ‘P’ and means you think that everybody is against you? That’s right. Perceptive.

Too soon you get old. Too late you get smart.

For some reason that doesn’t seem to prevent Illinois voters from returning the same misfeasant, malfeasant, nonfeasant shnooks to office year after year after year. Among other things I’d attribute that to the difficulty in getting on to the ballot here. Everything is stacked in favor of incumbents.

3 comments

Foreign Policy Blogging at OTB

I’ve just published a foreign policy-related post at Outside the Beltway:

Who Needs Europe or the US?

Here I take note of an op-ed from Gazeta (in translation). Russia may just not be that into us.

1 comment

You Have Nothing to Lose But Your Chains!

If this is a fair characterization, I find it pretty disturbing:

After citing Jean-Jacques Rousseau’s (!) views on the shortcomings of representative democracy, Breyer quotes James Wilson, one of the Founding Fathers, who argued in a 1792 commentary that the First Amendment’s purpose was to establish a “chain of communication between the people, and those, to whom they have committed the exercise of the powers of government.” Again quoting Wilson, Breyer elaborates: “This ‘chain’ would establish the necessary ‘communion of interests and sympathy of sentiments’ between the people and their representatives, so that public opinion could be channeled into effective governmental action.”

And here’s how Breyer sums it all up: “Accordingly, the First Amendment advances not only the individual’s right to engage in political speech, but also the public’s interest in preserving a democratic order in which collective speech matters.”

The emphasis on “matters” is again Breyer’s. We’d have italicized “collective” as the key concept. As with the Second Amendment, he and the other dissenters assert a “collective” right, the establishment of which is purportedly the Constitution’s ultimate purpose, as a justification for curtailing an individual right.

from which I would infer that rather than the near-absolute protection on political speech that Justice Breyer believes the federal government has the legal power to groom political speech, nearly the inverse of what I would take as the First Amendment’s purpose.

Forget Justice Ginsburg. It may be time for Justice Breyer to retire.

I have repeatedly suggested fairly severe restrictions to various political activities like campaigning, fund-raising, lobbying, and so on. I recognize those would require constitutional amendment. Other liberal democratic countries, e.g. Germany, have such restrictions without having become a totalitarian hellhole. Germany is arguably more democratic than we are. Some of the measures I’ve suggested could also be implemented by reforms in Congressional standards of ethics, which I think is about as likely as cats foreswearing mice.

I find that deciding that the federal government already has those powers to be pretty remarkable.

1 comment