Where to Begin?

I could hardly let the recent Wall Street Journal article, “What’s the Matter With Illinois?”, pass without comment. I’ve taken the liberty of sampling the graphic above from that article. As you can see, Illinois has fared far worse in the recovery than its neighboring states.

The WSJ attributes Illinois’s problems, essentially, to Democrats:

Democrats say Illinois taxes aren’t all that high and have room to grow…

[…]

Democrats want to impose a progressive income tax because they don’t want to extend their “temporary” tax hikes on their low and middle income constituents…

[…]

The real reason Democrats want higher taxes is the state’s exploding government-employee pension costs…

[…]

Democrats in Springfield are also teeing up a bailout for Chicago’s pension funds…

[…]

Taxes and public union governance aren’t the only policy differences in these states, but they have been the most notable since 2010. Judging by the record so far, nothing would make the four Republican Governors of neighboring states happier than for Illinois to keep soaking its millionaires.

I think that concluding paragraph begins to get to the heart of the matter but let’s do a more detailed comparison of the five states.

State Population (in millions) Per capita GDP Population of largest city (000) State Gini Percent non-white population
Illinois 13.0 $45,302 2,695 .465 29.5
Michigan 9.9 38,798 707 .451 21.0
Wisconsin 5.7 43,561 599 .430 13.8
Indiana 6.5 42,415 .440 15.7
Ohio 11.5 44,295 787 .452 17.3

or, in summary, Illinois is larger, richer, less equal, has a larger urban population, and has a larger percentage of minority and poor people than its neighboring states. It really isn’t as similar to its neighboring states as one might expect. It also has a higher state minimum wage than its neighboring states. Indiana can become Indiana just by competing with Illinois, tempting businesses to move across the state line, but it’s a lot harder for Illinois to improve its economy by attracting business away from Indiana. The numbers just don’t favor it.

What does Illinois need to do? Illinois isn’t a destination state like California or Florida and it doesn’t depend on natural resources as Texas does oil. The decline of the coal industry, largely a result of environmental regulations, has hit Illinois hard. Not only have thousands of working people been thrown out of work, many of those people headed to Chicago searching for jobs that proved elusive. Chicago’s Uptown neighborhood is still full of them.

Illinois needs to be more friendly to business, slowly reform its tax system to become less regressive, weed out government corruption, learn to live within its means, and recognize that it’s only by producing more that the state can prosper. Without business and industry Illinois will inevitably decline.

19 comments

No Recovery for Millennials

The editors of the New York Times lament that the economic recovery has left Millennials, Americans aged 25 to 34, behind:

The Federal Reserve, increasingly optimistic about the economy, is dialing back its stimulus efforts. The International Monetary Fund has raised its forecast for growth in the United States. Congress has long since reduced aid to the economy, with many lawmakers, mostly Republicans, adamant that the economy is better off with less government involvement.

The official line is clear: The worst is over, and recovery has given way to expansion.

But that’s not the whole story. Economic gains so far have mostly benefited those at the top of the income and wealth ladder. Worse, future growth is likely to be lopsided, because the foundation for broad prosperity is arguably the weakest it has been since World War II.

Take, for example, Americans age 25 to 34, the leading edge of the so-called millennials, the generation born in the 1980s and 1990s. They are worse off than Gen Xers (born from the mid-1960s to the late-1970s) were at that age and the baby boomers before them by nearly every economic measure — employment, income, student loan indebtedness, mobility, homeownership and other hallmarks of “household formation,” like moving out on their own, getting married and having children.

The solution, obviously, is to tax the young and give the proceeds to the old. It hardly seems like a coincidence that a wave of closings is striking the retail sector and many of the stores closing cater to the young.

I don’t think the young are the only people who’ve been left behind in this recovery. Others include the poor, middle income people, and people who live in the middle of the country. Then there are the long-term unemployed.

In the worst circumstances of all are young, black men.

However, if you’re only concerned about averages, the economy is doing very well.

21 comments

Foreign Policy Blogging at OTB

I’ve just published a foreign policy-related post at Outside the Beltway:

Kaminski on Ukraine

I respond to Wall Street Journal editor Matthew Kaminski’s lament about the West’s failure to oppose Russia in Ukraine.

4 comments

Long-Term Unemployment

Robert Samuelson muses about long-term unemployment:

A study by Princeton economists Alan Krueger, Judd Cramer and David Cho is discouraging. Among the long-term unemployed from 2008 to 2012, only 36 percent had jobs 15 months later, the study found. As for the rest, 30 percent were unemployed, and 34 percent were not in the labor force. Even for workers with jobs, success was limited. A third had full-time jobs; the others had part-time or interrupted full-time work.

Disturbingly, the study also argues that labor markets may be tighter than they seem. We could be closer to an inflationary wage-price spiral than the relatively high unemployment rate (6.7 percent in March) suggests. With a lot of unemployed workers, competition for jobs should prevent an inflationary wage surge. But, says the study, the long-term unemployed are so much “on the margins” that they only weakly influence wages. More important is short-term unemployment of less than six months. If it’s low, wage pressures are high; surprisingly, it’s now close to its 20-year average of about 4 percent. This could cause the Federal Reserve to tighten credit to prevent labor bottlenecks.

Of course, that would be disastrous for the long-term unemployed, because it would probably slow hiring and make finding a job even harder. It’s also unnecessary. Other indicators portray a labor market that isn’t tight, notes David Stockton of the Peterson Institute, formerly a top Fed economist. Employee “quit rates” remain below pre-crisis levels, betraying workers’ fears of finding new jobs if they leave the ones they have. Business “hire rates” are similarly low, reflecting ingrained cautiousness. Involuntary part-time work is two-thirds higher than before the Great Recession. A broad unemployment measure, so-called U-6 (covering the officially unemployed plus involuntary part-time workers and “marginal workers”), is 12.7 percent.

None of this describes an economy close to its productive capacity.

Now consider the hot-button political issues of the day. Immigration reform that includes normalization and a “path to citizenship”. Increasing the minimum wage. Increasing the number of people with healthcare insurance. Balancing the budget. Ending global warming.

Whatever the merits of any or all of those issues, it’s hard for me to see how any or them or all of them will result in putting more people who’ve been unemployed for six months or more back to work.

14 comments

You Cahn’t Get The-ah from He-ah

Megan McArdle explains why the PPACA isn’t the first step in the process of getting to a single-payer system using Vermont as an example. Basically, it’s just too darned expensive. Our present basis for healthcare spending is just too high.

10 comments

Self-Flagellation

This weekend I’m engaging in my annual rite of penance and mortification. Somewhat like Prince Vronsky in Anna Karenina, I take the opportunity of the due date for my federal income taxes to re-examine and put the finishing touches on my books for the previous year.

As I think I’ve mentioned before, last year my income in real terms was the lowest it’s been in my adult life. The reasons for that are complicated. Mostly it boils down to my long-term clients having fallen on hard times, a result of the sluggish economy, changing conditions, and long-term mistakes (not my mistakes but theirs many of which I’ve been fighting for, literally, decades).

Now I’m rebuilding my client base. It’s something I should have been doing all along but, honestly, I got a bit lazy. My new clients haven’t produced much billing yet but I have hopes.

My wants are pretty limited. I need about $15,000 more business to stop being panicky and with about an additional $30,000 in net billing I’d have as much as I want or need. You’d think that would be doable but it’s proven elusive. Nominally I have some pretty desireable skills, I have extensive experience, and I’m very good at what I do. I rarely have problems closing once I’ve gotten my foot in the door.

Only my dear wife’s earnings prevent me from being desperate but it’s pretty humiliating. I really should be doing much better than I am.

I’m not a particularly desireable employee for a variety of reasons including my age and that I don’t want to be employed full-time. That’s why I’m looking for business rather than a job. If this goes on, I may be forced to look for a job, something I haven’t done in 35 years. The conditions are really terrible for that and, as I say, I’m not a particularly desireable employee.

A desireable employee is me, thirty-five or forty years ago. Somebody who’s young, unmarried, energetic, and ambitious who’ll work for half of what he’s worth and put in 60 hours a week doing it. Somebody who doesn’t have a life.

41 comments

Five Little Words

In the past I’ve mentioned my opinion that just because most of the members of the Congress are lawyers doesn’t mean that they’re good lawyers. I’m beginning to think I should extend that observation to members of the Supreme Court. Consider, for example, former Supreme Court Justice John Paul Stevens’s prescription for “fixing” the Second Amendment to the Constitution:

As a result of the rulings in Heller and McDonald, the Second Amendment, which was adopted to protect the states from federal interference with their power to ensure that their militias were “well regulated,” has given federal judges the ultimate power to determine the validity of state regulations of both civilian and militia-related uses of arms. That anomalous result can be avoided by adding five words to the text of the Second Amendment to make it unambiguously conform to the original intent of its draftsmen. As so amended, it would read:

“A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms when serving in the Militia shall not be infringed.”

Now, there’s a substantial body of scholarship from Second Amendment advocates specifically rejecting Justice Stevens’s interpretation of history and the law and I presume there will be an outpouring of opinion directly contradicting the justice’s interpretation. However, you don’t need to do that to vitiate the justice’s prescription. Consider Article XII Section 1 of the Illinois state constitution:

The State militia consists of all able-bodied persons residing in the State except those exempted by law.

In other words, I’m serving in the state militia as I write this post and have done for most of my adult life just as all other “able-bodied residing in the State except those exempted by law” do including South Side gangsters, North Shore matrons, and just about everybody in between. Were the Constitution of the United States to be amended according to the justice’s prescription before the ink was dry at least half of the states would have adopted similar language in their state constitutions, negating the amendment to the amendment.

I don’t believe that I can think of an amendment to the Constitution which in the unlikely event that it were enacted would be more likely to provoke violent rebellion than that. However, let’s leave that point aside.

Let me suggest five alternative words that would solve the problem the justice sees and that a lawyer more clever than he would have substantially more difficulty in eluding: “except as provided by law”. That’s the conventional formulation used by illiberal autocracies to appear to be liberal without being liberal. The constitution of Saddam Hussein’s Iraq had that formula applied to just about every guarantee of basic human rights from freedom of speech to freedom of the press or religion.

We could fix the First Amendment similarly:

Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances except as provided by law.

Do you see how handily that works out? Wouldn’t you feel freer if the Constitution were amended that way?

9 comments

Foreign Policy Blogging at OTB

I’ve just published a foreign policy-related post at Outside the Beltway:

What Else Did You Expect?

With respect to Ukraine, the Russians are behaving exactly as you would expect given their experience of the last twenty-odd years with the West. There are too many areas in which we need Russian cooperation to accomplish our own objectives to go out of our way to alienate the Russians with little hope of achieving anything productive by it.

6 comments

Interesting Choice of Words

I think I was passed by one of these on the Kennedy the other day:

A new paper from the Swansea University, College of Engineering team working on the BLOODHOUND SSC (Supersonic car) project has been published on the aerodynamic characteristics of travelling at 1,000mph. Simulations have looked at how the car will cope with the supersonic rolling ground, rotating wheels and resulting shock waves in close proximity to the test surface at the record attempt site in Hakskeen Pan, South Africa. Where, in 2015, it will make high speed test runs of up to 800mph, with the full 1,000mph attempt scheduled for 2016.

In order for a ground vehicle to travel at over 1,000mph (approximately Mach 1.3), the designers have created the most advanced fusion of space, aeronautical and Formula 1 engineering ever attempted. In the words of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, ‘the BLOODHOUND supersonic car (SSC) is the most exciting and dynamic engineering challenge going on today.’

I found that the title of the article was an interesting choice of words: “BLOODHOUND team predict the impact of the 1,000 mph supersonic car”. I imagine it would make quite an impact. I wouldn’t want to be hit by one while crossing the street, anyway.

9 comments

Something Different

There’s an interesting tidbit of information from Jonathan Bernstein at Bloomberg. Do you remember the opinion poll results that say that among those who say they disapprove of the PPACA because it’s “not liberal enough”? As it turns out very, very few them support a single-payer system or public option.

Here’s the nugget:

The majorities who have formed a negative impression of the law are real, even allowing for a low single-digit percentage who would prefer a single-payer system or a government-run public option.

Apparently, they mean something different than progressives do by “not liberal enough”.

3 comments