Examination of the chemical composition of the teeth of people interred in ancient Cahokia has determined that a considerable portion of the population grew up elsewhere:
Teeth that form in infancy, for example, like the first permanent molars, will reveal a person’s location as a newborn, while those that form in the early teens, like the third molars, will bear the chemical traces of their home in adolescence.
Armed with this technique, Slater’s team studied 133 teeth from 87 people, found in 13 different burial contexts throughout American Bottom.
The results showed that 38 of the teeth, about 29 percent, had strontium ratios that were outside the local range, indicating that those people had been born and raised elsewhere and migrated to Cahokia as adults.
Interestingly, the remains of those believed to have been sacrificial offerings are more likely to be those of locals than other remains.
The Cahokia mounds, which flourished between about 600 BCE to 1400 CE, constitute the largest and most complex pre-Columbian North American city north of Mexico. Artifacts found there suggest that it traded over an enormous area, from the Gulf of Mexico to the Great Lakes. And, as we are learning, it may have attracted people from an equally great range.
If you ever find yourself in downstate Illinois, it’s well worth a visit.
This year marks the centennial year of my dad’s birth. He was born above a saloon located at 14th and Clark in St. Louis, Missouri on October 10, 1914. Nowadays that’s a parking lot across the street from the ScottTrade Center but a century ago it was a gritty urban neighborhood right around the block from City Hall.
Over the course of the next year I plan on posting regularly about my dad and the times he grew up in. I write for multiple audiences here and one of them is my siblings and their kids. I think it’s important that I pass on what my dad told me. It might even prove interesting for a more general audience.
I don’t use recreational drugs. Never have. There are several reasons for that. For one thing, the only thing I really have going for me is my brain and I’ve never felt that putting that at risk was worth it. Additionally, my family tends to have what are referred to as idiosyncratic or paradoxical reactions to drugs. You know those warnings in fine print that you receive on the handouts that accompany prescription medicines these days? The ones that begin “In some rare cases ” That’s me. Example: one of my siblings was recently prescribed post-operative pain medication. It induced extreme pain.
All of that notwithstanding I’ve long felt that marijuana should be legalized or, at the very least, it should be legalized for medical purposes. However, findings like this make me wonder about the prudence of that course of action:
Young adults who used marijuana only recreationally showed significant abnormalities in two key brain regions that are important in emotion and motivation, scientists report. The study was a collaboration between Northwestern Medicine and Massachusetts General Hospital/Harvard Medical School.
This is the first study to show casual use of marijuana is related to major brain changes. It showed the degree of brain abnormalities in these regions is directly related to the number of joints a person smoked per week. The more joints a person smoked, the more abnormal the shape, volume and density of the brain regions.
“This study raises a strong challenge to the idea that casual marijuana use isn’t associated with bad consequences,” said corresponding and co-senior study author Hans Breiter, M.D. He is a professor of psychiatry and behavioral sciences at Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine and a psychiatrist at Northwestern Memorial Hospital.
“Some of these people only used marijuana to get high once or twice a week,” Breiter said. “People think a little recreational use shouldn’t cause a problem, if someone is doing OK with work or school. Our data directly says this is not the case.”
The study was small and local and, honestly, there could be other explanations for the results they found but it’s interesting.
Abnormal development in the areas of the brain they studied is associated with abnormal responses to learning, fear, aggression, and impulsivity, just to name a few. If there’s anything we need more of, it’s indifferent or unmotivated kids with learning difficulties.
As I see things, the present spirit of the times is moving in the direction of some sort of legalization of marijuana. We might want to think about some of the more longitudinal implications of that before getting too far down that road.
The graph above accompanies the very interesting post by Tom Liu at The Incidental Economist on how we can be confident that the PPACA hasn’t caused healthcare costs to fall which I recommend you read in full:
While reducing unnecessary utilization is one goal of ACA delivery system reforms, those reforms didn’t predate the signing of the law. For example, the Medicare Shared Savings Program and Pioneer ACO programs weren’t launched until 2012. And they are still finding their footing—of the 32 Pioneer ACOs (arguably best poised to achieve utilization reduction), only eight of them significantly slowed cost growth relative to their local markets in their first year. More dramatic value-based models such as Iora Health or Qliance, which can claim inpatient reductions of up to 41%, are only just beginning to achieve scale.
Something else must be causing the slowdown in utilization growth over the last decade.
What caught my eye in the graph above was how neatly it illustrates the point I’ve been making, the importance of not merely reducing the rate of increase of healthcare spending but actually reducing the spending. Note the labeling of the graph at left. Spending is divided into two components, a price component and a utilization component. The topline green line is the total increase in the rate of spending. That line has been above zero every single year for the last twenty years, i.e. real healthcare spending is rising monotonically. Actually, that’s been the case for the last forty years.
I would be remiss in not mentioning that to at least some degree the distinction between prices as a driver of spending an utilization as a driver of spending is specious. Physicians create utilization. An alternative interpretation to the last few years of that graph are that as the rate of increase in prices decline the rate of increase in utilization rose to maintain a more-or-less constant rate of increase.
Let’s do a thought experiment. Imagine a country in which healthcare spending, education, and defense spending account for a third of the economy and all of that spending is government spending. If spending in those three categories alone rise just 3% and general rate at which prices are increasing is 1%, those three categories account for 100% of the growth in the economy.
Now imagine that every dollar in those three sectors results in fewer people being employed than in any other sector of the economy. That’s a country in which fewer people will be able to find jobs every single year.
Now, there are two distinct strategies for addressing the obvious problem that presents. One is for those three sectors to start employing more people at lower wages than they’re accustomed to. The other is for the growth in those three sectors to be less than the average growth in the economy outside of those three sectors. In some years it might be a little more, in some a considerably less, but on average the growth would be less than the growth outside of those three sectors. That would be an economy in which more people would be employed each year, allowing for what’s quaintly known as “the natural increase”.
My thought experiment is over-simplified but IMO it’s a reasonable simulacrum of the actual economy. My assessment has been that it will be easier to contain spending in those three sectors than to change how they operate in more drastic ways, e.g. having much, much more of the actual work now being performed by physicians being performed by twice as many technicians and other practitioners who are being paid a third what today’s physicians are (for example). That’s why I think that healthcare spending must fall.
I am somewhat surprised to see Megan McArdle entering the lists of the conspiracy-minded. Here’s her reaction to the announcement that the Census Bureau is changing the questions it will ask in its regular survey so that we will never know confidently how many more people have received healthcare insurance as a consequence of the PPACA:
I’m speechless. Shocked. Stunned. Horrified. Befuddled. Aghast, appalled, thunderstruck, perplexed, baffled, bewildered and dumbfounded. It’s not that I am opposed to the changes: Everyone understands that the census reports probably overstate the true number of the uninsured, because the number they report is supposed to be “people who lacked insurance for the entire previous year,†but people tend to answer with their insurance status right now.
But why, dear God, oh, why, would you change it in the one year in the entire history of the republic that it is most important for policy makers, researchers and voters to be able to compare the number of uninsured to those in prior years? The answers would seem to range from “total incompetence on the part of every level of this administration†to something worse.
I think as good an explanation as any is that the good folks at the Census Bureau are merely justifying their jobs. If you never change anything in the surveys, why would you retain people who write surveys or figure out how to improve them? That the timing of the change is good for the administration is just a lagniappe.
Besides, as supporters of the PPACA have demonstrated time and again, they don’t really care about the practical impact of the legislation. It’s the idea of it they like.
Russia Today reports on a study from Princeton and Northwestern Universities on the relationship between majority views and policy in the United States and arrives at an interesting finding:
While “Americans do enjoy many features central to democratic governance, such as regular elections, freedom of speech and association,†the authors say the data implicate “the nearly total failure of ‘median voter’ and other Majoritarian Electoral Democracy theories [of America]. When the preferences of economic elites and the stands of organized interest groups are controlled for, the preferences of the average American appear to have only a minuscule, near-zero, statistically non-significant impact upon public policy.”
As will certainly be pointed out, we don’t have a democracy and weren’t intended to have a democracy. At the close of the Constitutional Convention of 1787, Benjamin Franklin is said to have been buttonholed by a passerby who asked him what form of government the convention had produced. “A republic if you can keep it” he is said to have replied.
Even in a representative democracy I would expect majority opinion to have more than a “near-zero, statistically non-significant impact upon public policy”. However, the finding does go some way towards explaining our immigration laws, trade laws, agricultural policy, and foreign policy. There is broad consensus in many areas of public policy that’s dramatically different from the policy that’s being followed.
This means that both Japan and China have an interest in seeing the United States face a binary choice between supporting Japan and stepping back from confrontation with China. Tokyo wants Washington to prove unambiguously that it will not sacrifice Japanese interests in order to avoid a rift with Beijing. Beijing wants to show Japan-and the rest of Asia-that America is no longer willing to defend their interests against China’s growing power.
Of course Washington wants to avoid that choice, and it seems to think it can. In Washington, they seem to assume that if shots are fired, China would back down rather than confront the United States militarily. If that’s true, the United States would not have to choose between fighting China and abandoning Japan.
The world needs to triple the energy it gets from renewables, nuclear reactors and power plants that use emissions-capture technology to avoid dangerous levels of global warming, United Nations scientists said.
Investments needed to keep climate change within safe limits would shave a fraction of a percent off annual global growth, the UN said yesterday in the third part of its most comprehensive study on warming. A delay in stemming rising greenhouse gases will cut chances to limit the global temperature increase, add to costs and lead to increasingly reliance on unproven technologies, they said.
Energy production, transportation, and cement production are the great producers of greenhouse gases. If people won’t accept curbs on transportation (they haven’t) and the level of investment required to build enough nuclear power plants, large scale windmills, and large scale solar isn’t imaginable (it isn’t), and we keep right on building roads, knocking down old buildings, and building new ones, I think you’re going to hear a lot more about ways to deal with the carbon that’s already been released than about releasing less.
Just a little reminder. The backend of Healthcare.gov is still presenting problems. The user-facing part of the site is, apparently, much improved, but, like an iceberg, that’s only a seventh of it.
The user experience may be better but to say that’s it’s working now is at best an exaggeration and at worst a lie. It still has a long way to go.