Whatever You’ve Heard Affirmative Action Remains a Legitimate Tool

I suppose the howls of outrage at the Supreme Court’s decision in Schuette v. Coalition to Defend Affirmative Action yesterday should have been expected. For a good plain English of the decision see here. I think that James Taranto’s summary of the four contrasting positions taken by members of the court is interesting.

My own view is that Justice Breyer has it pretty much right. In cases in which affirmative action is being taken neither by the voters nor state’s legislators nor the courts but by unelected school administrators the voters of the state have the power to reverse those administrators’ actions.

The editors of the New York Times take a somewhat different view:

Justice Anthony Kennedy, writing for a three-member plurality, sided with the voters, who he said had undertaken “a basic exercise of their democratic power” in approving the amendment. He cautioned that the ruling took no position on the constitutionality of race-conscious admissions policies themselves. “This case is not about how the debate about racial preferences should be resolved. It is about who may resolve it.”

Not so, Justice Sonia Sotomayor responded, in a stinging 58-page dissent. “Our Constitution places limits on what a majority of the people may do,” she wrote, such as when they pass laws that oppress minorities.

That’s what the affirmative action ban does, by altering the political process to single out race and sex as the only factors that may not be considered in university admissions.

While the decision expressly did not declare affirmative action unconstitutional, it may have dealt a severe blow to something called “political process doctrine” and that’s what I think the editors are alluding to. If the dissent had prevailed it would have meant that once affirmative action had been put in place for whatever reason, there would be no way to remove it except, possibly, by court order.

Intervening in a similarly predictably heated comment thread in a post on the decision, James Joyner remarks:

The lack of social mobility for poor and otherwise disadvantaged students, who are disproportionately black and Hispanic, is a real problem that should concern Americans of all races and political ideologies. I’m an opponent of state institutions giving preferential treatment on the basis of race alone for a variety of reasons, not least of which is that it’s increasingly anachronistic nearly seven decades after Brown vs. Board of Education and nearly half a century after the Civil Rights Act of 1965.

I don’t think it’s quite right that “we spend more money on the education of well off white kids.” Rather, we spend more money on the education of well off kids, who are disproportionately white. Nowadays, while race of course remains an issue, it’s quite possible that parental and community social class is a bigger issue in terms of children’s achievement. Indeed, while race per se is undeniably much less of a barrier to success than it was half a century—or, indeed, a quarter century—ago, we’re seeing a steady decline in social mobility. Increasingly, demography is destiny.

I would go farther than that. I think we should be able to devote the resources necessary to helping students both on the basis of family income and race. And we still can. Advocates for such intervention need to persuade their legislators or a majority the voters rather than just a few school administrators and trustees.

I would also add that higher education is a lousy place on which to focus our attention. We would be much better off concentrating resources on K-12.

While I would never claim that money is the sole solution to the problems of our public education system, I think it does make some difference. Consider the variations in per pupil spending here in Illinois. The lion’s share of funds for public education comes from local governments here in Illinois rather than the state (Illinois is 50th among the 50 states in the state’s contribution to public education) and most of those funds come from property tax revenues. Consequently, the value of property has an enormous influence on how much is available to fund public education. That means that per pupil public school spending is effectively proportional to family income.

Adjoining Evanston spends roughly 50% more per elementary school student than Chicago’s District 299 does. That means that Evanston can attract better teacher and administrators and afford to maintain its facilities better than Chicago can. That Chicago could offset Evanston’s spending by increasing its sales or property taxes is a blithe assertion that I do not believe stands up to scrutiny. Chicago already has the highest sales taxes in the state and raising Chicago’s property tax rate would be as likely to drive people and businesses out of Chicago as it would raise revenue.

What, then, should be done? The solution must come from the state and heretofore the state has refused to act.

Update

Ilya Shapiro summarizes the decision:

But really Schuette is a much easier case than the above description might indicate. Indeed, it’s no surprise that six justices found that a state constitutional provision prohibiting racial discrimination complies with the federal constitutional provision that prohibits state racial discrimination. To hold otherwise would be to torture the English language to the point where constitutional text is absolutely meaningless. The only surprise – or, rather, the lamentable pity – is that Justices Sonia Sotomayor and Ruth Bader Ginsburg somehow agreed with the lower court’s confused determination that the Constitution requires what it barely tolerates (racial preferences in university admissions).

30 comments

Joke of the Day

I received this joke from one of my fellow Watcher’s Council members, a Russian now living in Israel. A traveller has arrived in the United States.

U. S. Customs agent: Nationality?

Traveller: Russian

U. S. Customs agent: Occupation?

Traveller: No, just visiting.

4 comments

Things Change

The other day I watched a short subject from the 1940s on TCM that consisted largely of some sanitized history (with Craig Stevens who would later be TV’s Peter Gunn portraying Sephen Foster) and a sing-a-long of Stephen Foster songs. I suspect that the short was largely nostalgic to that audience of 70 years ago. I found the lyrics cringe-worthy.

I did learn one thing from the short: Foster probably earned a good deal of his money writing songs for minstrel shows (he was the first American to get rich writing popular songs). Many of his songs were written for and popularized by the Christy Minstrels, that most famous of all blackface groups, started in the 1840s by Edwin Pearce Christy.

In other words we’ve gone from something being the heart of mainstream popular culture 170 years ago to being nostalgic a century later to being horrid seventy years later.

0 comments

Asimov’s Predictions

You know, science fiction writer Isaac Asimov’s 50 year old predictions of the future have made out pretty darned well.

13 comments

Did the Bear Do It?

There’s an interesting post at Minyanville suggesting that Russian actions in response to U. S. sanctions may have produced a decline in the dollar:

I calculated the expected return on the yen for that week’s market movements. It was for a gain of 0.90%; the actual gain was 0.82%, well within reason. The dollar behaved much differently than expected; it declined 1.00% when it should have rallied close to 3.10%.

Why the discrepancy? One reason proffered is markets expected the Federal Reserve to reverse its tapering policy. That seems unlikely as that move would put its already wishy-washy reputation one step closer toward a complete lack of policy continuity. I think the real reason is a tad more sinister and even a little juicy for those into the cloak-and-dagger stuff.

Please recall a massive decline in custody holdings at the Federal Reserve at the start of the Ukrainian situation. Apparently someone in Moscow thought leaving Russian funds in the custody of the US central bank might be seen as a little careless among an unforgiving audience. What if the same thing happened with stocks as things started to heat up in eastern Ukraine? A motivated seller of US stocks liquidated, and instead of keeping the funds in greenbacks put them into another currency. This might explain why the dollar declined at a time when it should have increased.

It’s intriguing but I can’t say I’m convinced. You need more than motive and means to prove a crime.

1 comment

Risk, Rent, and Taxes

Of all of the thousands (maybe tens of thousands) of words I’ve read about income inequality in the aftermath of French economist Thomas Piketty’s visit to the United States, the article that resonated most with me has been Tyler Cowen’s review in Foreign Affairs of Dr. Piketty’s Capital in the Twenty-first Century. While acknowledging the significance of Dr. Piketty’s work:

Every now and then, the field of economics produces an important book; this is one of them. Thomas Piketty’s tome will put capitalist wealth back at the center of public debate, resurrect interest in the subject of wealth distribution, and revolutionize how people view the history of income inequality. On top of that, although the book’s prose (translated from the original French) might not qualify as scintillating, any educated person will be able to understand it — which sets the book apart from the vast majority of works by high-level economic theorists.

he finds it, as many commenters have, uneven. It, apparently, is better in vision than in policy prescriptions, in weaving a narrative that supports his views than fleshing out his ideas from a real world perspective.

Dr. Piketty, apparently, largely ignores the role of risk in capital returns. I think he can be forgiven for this because far too many of today’s risks aren’t risks at all. If you act with the reasonable expectation that the central government will step in to indemnify you against risks should your actions lose money, there is no risk.

Something that appears to have been ignored in the popular press is that Dr. Piketty’s concerns about income inequality aren’t focused solely on the ultra-rich, the Warren Buffetts or Bill Gateses, but also on petits rentiers, which includes most of the American professional class.

As I have emphasized here since the very origins of this blog, my greatest concern on this subject is how rent-seeking drives income inequality rather than on income inequality per se. Michael Jordan’s or Tiger Woods’s wealth do not concern me. The Kennedy family trust does. In a society as complex as ours with a government as pervasive as ours these rents take a vast number of forms—they encompass everything from royalty income to physicians’ wages to the subsidies received by bankers or GM executives and workers in the late recession. When you use the wealth you’ve gained through these rents to promote increases in your rents, as the late Sonny Bono manifestly did, it presents an assault on liberal democracy.

If your prescription for ending income inequality is, as Dr. Piketty’s, increased taxes on income and wealth, I challenge you to outline how this will work, recalling that when the highest marginal tax rate was over 90%, effective tax rates were little higher than they are now, i.e. marginal tax rates are virtually irrelevant to income inequality. Also, consider how many millionaires are sitting in the U. S. Congress. Does it actually seem likely to you that Congress will enact a tax on wealth? IMO a significant number of them are there to ensure that such a tax is never enacted into law.

I would be remiss in concluding this post without re-emphasizing that, at least as regards income inequality within the United States, reversing much of the income inequality that has come to pass over the period of the last forty years can be effected by controlling immigration, underwriting depositors rather than bankers, controlling healthcare costs, and emphasizing more jobs over other policy goals. It’s not your priorities that determine what you believe but your subpriorities.

19 comments

Lazear on Tax Reform

At the Wall Street Journal Edward Lazear proposes reforming the tax code to allow the immediate expensing of capital spending:

Allowing investment expenses to be fully and immediately deductible turns an income tax into a consumption tax, but the logic is subtle. All of an economy’s output is used to produce either current consumption or investment goods. If all income, which must equal output, is taxed, then both consumption and investment are taxed. But if we tax only the part of output that is not investment by allowing investment expenditures to be deductible, all that remains is consumption so only consumption is taxed.

There is no need for any complicated new tax laws or bureaucracies to make this change. Investments in plants, equipment, R&D and even human capital would be deductible from profits when paying taxes, and the deduction could be used now or against future or past tax liabilities.

The potential benefits of moving away from taxing investment to a consumption tax are well documented. A 2005 Tax Advisory Panel appointed by President George W. Bush estimated from Treasury data that moving to a consumption tax by removing taxes on investment would result in a 5%-7% increase in GDP. (Its scoring included lower and flatter individual and corporate rates, though expensing accounted for most of the gain.) A 2001 study in the American Economic Review by David Altig, Alan J. Auerbach and others estimates that GDP would rise more than 9% by moving to full expensing of investment spending (with a flat tax).

If recollection serves, that’s the rule in business-friendly countries, e.g. Switzerland, Hong Kong, Singapore (which also typically have much lower business income taxes). Business spending on financial instruments or real estate frequently cannot be expensed immediately.

One of the benefits of immediate expensing is that it provides fewer incentives for transferring capital overseas.

While I broadly support abolishing the business income tax completely or, as Dr Lazear proposes, changing how business income is calculated to incentivize capital spending, I think his proposal has almost no traction in Congress. Somehow the notion that taxing business income twice is fair (once when realized by the business, once as income by individuals) has caught on and has become a political shibboleth.

2 comments

Samuelson on Piketty

Robert Samuelson devotes his most recent column to Thomas Piketty, the French economist whose work on income inequality has become a cause célèbre among American progressives:

Agree or disagree with his views, Piketty’s project represents a prodigious research achievement. With other economists, he has constructed statistics tracing the distribution of income and wealth for many major countries back to the 1800s. The most obvious conclusion from the data is common-sensical: Even relatively egalitarian societies have huge disparities in economic fortune.

Dr. Piketty’s preferred solution seems to be taxation. My own view is that taxation is probably the easiest to enact but the least effective way of solving the problem, at least in the current state of American political policy.

Some people have always been more talented, hardworking, or just plain lucky than others. They haven’t always been able to corral such a large proportion of income and wealth. I don’t believe that the difference is either in the people or in the underlying economy but in the policies that have been put into place for which there are significant consensuses in both Congressional caucuses. Over the period of the last thirty or forty years a series of what are called “neoliberal” policies have given a significant advantage to areas that receive subsidies while stripping them from areas that don’t.

Another solution that progressives sometimes propose, stronger labor unions, is even less likely to succeed. That’s a cargo cult mentality, a form of the post hoc propter hoc fallacy. I believe that the underlying labor conditions, conditions of relatively tight labor markets and increasing marginal productivity of labor, made labor unions attractive and promoted the distribution of income and wealth. We don’t have those conditions any more.

Meanwhile, I think we need to recognize that if we keep doing what we’ve been doing, we’ll keep getting what we’ve been getting. The political class is more than happy with that.

9 comments

A Man’s Job

Today I read a comment to the effect that there were no longer any men’s jobs or women’s jobs. To my mind this is one of those remarks that sounds like it should be true but isn’t.

I think it depends a lot on how you define things. If you define a “man’s job” as one in which 2/3s or more of those in the workforce are men and a “woman’s job” as one in which 2/3s or more of those in the workforce are women, even after nearly a half century of the women’s movement many, many jobs remain dominated by one gender or the other.

Men’s jobs: physician (70%), lawyer(70%), engineer (90%), truckdriver (95%), construction trades (98%), computer programmer (80%), soldier (85%), architect (80%).

Women’s jobs: nurse (90%), kindergarten teacher (98%), social worker (80%), hairdresser (85%), speech pathologist (95%).

Those are round numbers—they might be a few percentage points off one way or another.

Here’s a biggie: 95% of Fortune 500 CEOs are men.

29 comments

The Stolen

Doris Pilkington Garimara, who wrote the book, Follow the Rabbit-Proof Fence which inspired the movie Rabbit-Proof Fence, has died:

When she was 4, Doris Pilkington Garimara was uprooted from her home in western Australia and sent to a camp for “half-caste” aboriginals, where she grew up believing she had been abandoned and forgotten by her mother.

Decades passed before she learned the full story – one that would not only answer painful questions about her past but help Australians understand one of the ugliest chapters in theirs.

Pilkington Garimara and her mother belonged to “the stolen generations”—the estimated 100,000 children of mixed aboriginal and white ancestry who by government edict were snatched from their homes and reared in desolate settlements. By separating them from their darker-skinned relatives, the policy aimed to assimilate them into white society.

The forced removals occurred through most of the last century, ending in the 1970s but kept hidden far longer, in part because those who had been the targets accepted what the government told them: that aboriginal people were dirty and evil.

The Australian aboriginal people were not alone. Native Americans in the United States had their children stolen as did Canadian Inuits.

I think it’s important to recognize that the officials and private citizens who engaged in these acts which we now recognize as heinous thought of themselves as enlightened and forward-thinking. They weren’t acting out of simple hatred for indigenous peoples but in all likelihood thought they were acting in the best interest of the children. People with the very best of intentions can be just bad as those with evil ones. Good intentions are not enough.

I recommend Rabbit-Proof Fence, streamable via NetFlix. It’s well-made, well-acted, and engaging and casts some light over a shameful period of history.

0 comments