Sweet Home Chicago

Speaking of re-locating, the Gallup Organization has produced a poll that I find disheartening:

PRINCETON, NJ — Every state has at least some residents who are looking for greener pastures, but nowhere is the desire to move more prevalent than in Illinois and Connecticut. In both of these states, about half of residents say that if given the chance to move to a different state, they would like to do so. Maryland is a close third, at 47%. By contrast, in Montana, Hawaii, and Maine, just 23% say they would like to relocate. Nearly as few — 24% — feel this way in Oregon, New Hampshire, and Texas.

This is hardly surprising. Illinois has the third highest unemployment rate among the states (only Nevada and Rhode Island are higher), a phlegmatic economy, is a fiscal basket case, manifest political corruption, and the lowest state contribution to education of any state.

Illinois is not a destination state like California or Florida or even North Carolina or New York. People come here to work:

Hog Butcher for the World,
Tool Maker, Stacker of Wheat,
Player with Railroads and the Nation’s Freight Handler;
Stormy, husky, brawling,
City of the Big Shoulders…

Carl Sandburg didn’t celebrate Chicago for the climate or for the sights but for working. Recent mayors have concentrated more on making Chicago a place where people like themselves would want to live. We need to make it a place where ordinary Chicagoans would want to live.

Things are not likely to get better in Illinois without some pretty drastic change. If people want change, they’ve got to change the people they want. We’ll get nowhere re-electing the same crooks year after year.

Meanwhile, people are discouraged and those who can will vote with their feet.

33 comments

The Boll Weevil

À propos of the observations I made the other day, I found this editorial on Toyota’s plan to re-locate its US headquarters from California to Texas interesting, saddening, and discouraging:

Toyota wanted out of California for many reasons: high taxes, steep operations costs and unpredictable state politics. The automaker reportedly had kicked the tires on several locations in Texas as well as in Denver, Atlanta and Charlotte, N.C. And Toyota’s not the only one racing for the exits. In recent years, more than 250 companies have bolted from California, and relocation experts in that state say Texas was their No. 1 destination.

“When you look at the whole package, it’s difficult to be a business here,” said Torrance Mayor Frank Scotto, whose city is the big job loser in Toyota’s move to North Texas.

Toyota has deep pockets and could expand anywhere on its own coin, but Texas made a strong case sealed with a handsome dowry. The benefit to North Texas comes from high-paying corporate jobs and the multiplier effect of new home purchases and countless other spending gains.

You can hardly blame Toyota for its decision but this kind of bidding war is at best a zero-sum game for the country. It’s good for Texans, bad for Californians, meanwhile producing disruption and upheaval.

Oh, de boll weevil am a little black bug,
Come from Mexico, dey say,
Come all de way to Texas,
Jus’ a-lookin’ foh a place to stay,
Jus’ a-lookin’ foh a home,
Jus’ a-lookin’ foh a home.

5 comments

Which Is Worse?

Scott Sumner has an interesting post about tax reform that’s worthy of your attention. The post also could serve as a sort of Socratic dialogue on which is worse, avarice or gluttony? Sadly, he combines the two but, as any good scholar of medieval philosophy could tell you, they’re different.

I think they’re both bad but that’s a subject for another post.

I did learn something that I did not know from the post. He quotes The Economist:

TO UNDERSTAND one of the gulfs separating the Anglo-Saxon world from continental Europe, consider Warren Buffett’s children. Omaha’s sage investor long ago said he would leave most of his fortune to charity, with more modest sums to his offspring. For Mr Buffett, leaving vast wealth to his children would be “anti-social” in a society that “aspires to be a meritocracy.”

In 26 out of 27 European Union countries, Mr Buffett’s plans would not just be shocking, but illegal. The exception is Britain, or rather England and Wales (Scotland has its own, centuries-old legal system, with a strong continental flavour). In continental Europe a big part of an estate (often around half) is reserved for the surviving children of the deceased and must be equally divided between them.

I wonder how many people will recognize the implications of that? Americans and Continental Europeans have very different assumptions about wealth, assumptions they themselves may not recognize, and, consequently, we need to consider European pronouncements on wealth as seen through that filter.

What’s true in France may not be true here and vice versa.

6 comments

GDP Report and Employment Sitrep Are, Unfortunately, Consistent

I was originally going to title this post “Good News”. Then I read the article and revised my opinion:

(Reuters) – U.S. job growth increased at its fastest pace in more than two years in April and the unemployment rate dived to a 5-1/2 year low of 6.3 percent, suggesting a sharp rebound in economic activity early in the second quarter.

Nonfarm payrolls surged 288,000 last month, the Labor Department said on Friday. That was the largest gain since January 2012 and beat Wall Street’s expectations for only a 210,000 increase.

but

The unemployment rate tumbled 0.4 percentage point, touching its lowest level since September 2008. The Labor Department attributed the decline to a drop in the number of unemployed people reentering the labor market as well as a fall in new entrants into the labor force.

The emphasis is mine. Don’t get me wrong. I rejoice in the 288,000 added to payrolls. If we kept that up every single month, those who’s who’ve been unemployed for so long could come back to work in just three or four years. If we kept that up every single month.

But the unemployment rate dropping because people aren’t even bothering to look isn’t good news.

When I read the article’s headline I wondered how a sharp April increase could be reconciled with the GDP figures we saw earlier in the week and now I know. They’re completely consistent and they’re not particularly encouraging. Better than nothing? Yes. But not nearly good enough.

11 comments

Rising Healthcare Costs Aren’t a Good Thing

There was one aspect of the report of flat GDP I posted on earlier that I’d intended to mention but somehow neglected to so I’ll mention it now. If healthcare costs hadn’t risen in the first quarter of 2014, GDP would have decreased.

That is a very, very bad thing. Spending more for the same quantity of goods or services is in no way indicative of economic strength. Mirabile dictu I’ve actually read things from people who claimed it was.

18 comments

Speaking of Self-Delusion

While we’re on the subject, Heather Wilhelm has a darned good explanation of my own impression about so much of the debate on income inequality in the United States:

Once you look past the patent silliness and First World problems of the almost-rich mentally scapegoating the already-rich, it becomes increasingly clear why income inequality has become the anxiety of choice for the upper-middle-class left. If you’re mad about your neighbor’s private jet, after all, it makes it a heck of a lot easier to ignore the poor kid from the wrong side of the tracks who was just denied access to a quality charter school—thanks, of course, to the charter-blocking policies of the politicians you voted (and perhaps raised funds) for.

The real income inequality isn’t among people in the United States at all. It’s between the people of the United States and rural farmers in most of the rest of the world. It will be much easier to take the prescriptions for ameliorating income inequality seriously when people start talking redistributing from the rich to the poor rather than from the rich to the “almost-rich” who will, of course, use the money on behalf of the poor.

28 comments

Ever Gone a Week Without a Rationalization?

At Slate John Dickerson has an interesting explanation for the emails that are being touted by some as a “smoking gun” in the Benghazi debacle:

Perhaps, but there is also evidence in the documents for another explanation. The administration was practicing garden-variety self-deception: Administration officials, who came into office on a wave of skepticism about the quality of CIA intelligence, believed what their intelligence agency told them and what was in the president’s best political interest to believe.

Is being willfully delusional and acting on the delusion exculpatory?

3 comments

Who Cares About GDP?

I didn’t comment yesterday on the BEA’s preliminary report on U. S. gross domestic product for the first quarter of 2014 which was flat. Here are Megan McArdle’s observations:

No, despite the caveats, the fact remains that we seem to be stuck. Six years after the financial crisis, we still haven’t entered anything that could really be called a “recovery.” A recovery would mean some sort of catch-up growth that reabsorbed stranded workers and capital. Instead, we’re barely limping forward, and the most cheerful thing we can say about any of it is that at least we’re no longer falling back.

The reason I didn’t comment is that I don’t much care about GDP. As far as I’m concerned real GDP could be flat for the next decade and I wouldn’t care as long as the economic indicators that I do care about are rising.

Those indicators are real median household income which has declined substantially since 2009 and shows little sign of recovering and job growth which is phlegmatic at best, morally reprehensible, and disastrous for those who’ve been unemployed for so long.

Touting GDP growth (not to mention a rising stock market) in the face of persistent long-term unemployment and declining real household income is an objective endorsement of increasing income inequality. Decrying income inequality on the one hand while hailing slow but steady growth in the economy on the other is incoherent. Cognitive dissonance.

7 comments

Punchline

Here’s the punchline of James Taranto’s most recent column in the Wall Street Journal:

John Kerry would be a great diplomat if only the Israelis and Palestinians could be replaced by holograms.

I seem to be in a minority in this view but I don’t think that diplomacy is an individual performance activity. Viewing it as such reduces the Department of State to people standing around waiting to hold the president’s or Secretary of State’s coats while they work.

My dissatisfaction with John Kerry’s approach to diplomacy is that he appears to view himself as the President of Foreign Policy, not a constitutional role. And I long ago complained that Mr. Kerry has the appearance of a diplomat without the temperament of one. I think that’s a typical Baby Boomer error. As Tom and Dick Smothers put it, “If you get an outfit, you can be a cowboy, too.”

3 comments

What to Do About Excessive CEO Pay?

Harold Meyerson describes a proposed California law:

The bill now moving through the California Senate doesn’t compel CEOs and their corporate boards to either raise their employees’ wages or cut their own. It merely presents them with a choice. Those who overpay themselves and underpay their employees can continue to do so but thereby subject their company to higher taxes. Or they can diminish the discrepancy in compensation and thereby lower their company’s taxes.

The proposed legislation wouldn’t exactly plunge CEOs into poverty. It would reduce, on a sliding scale, California’s corporate taxes — currently set at 8.84 percent of net income — for any company paying its chief executive less than 100 times the pay of its median worker, and raise them, also on a sliding scale, for any company paying its CEO more. (Under the terms of the Dodd-Frank financial reform act, the Securities and Exchange Commission is required to publish the CEO-median worker pay ratio for every publicly listed company. The SEC is expected to begin this practice this year.)

Other than some technicalities I don’t know that I have an objection to California’s proposed law. I doubt it will do much. As is the case with current law it would only apply to income generated within California so it’s possible that some companies might stop doing business in California.

That might not even be necessary. Just to take one example, Apple (headquartered in Cupertino) wouldn’t even need to close its many California stores. It could just sell them to franchisees and sell its products to the distributors (or the franchisees themselves) in any state that doesn’t have such a tax.

Companies that couldn’t engage in such a subterfuge but that are cash-rich enough could buy back their stock and become private.

I also note that the Dodds-Frank provision doesn’t require the companies to include wholly-owned subsidiaries in their calculations. That would suggest another strategy: offshore more of your workforce which I presume would be thought of as an unintended adverse secondary effect.

I think the real issues at stake here are poor corporate governance and the slack labor market created by globalization. When executive compensation becomes unmoored from company performance (my impression is that’s a factor mostly but not exclusively in the financial sector), it means that the companies’ boards for whatever reason are not doing their jobs. And when a worker’s competition isn’t the guy who lives next door but somebody who lives in India it would be expected that would put downward pressure on wages.

The interesting thing is that it hasn’t put downward pressure on executive pay. I would think that large companies could hire a highly-experienced Indian CEO who’d be willing to work for a fraction of what his U. S. equivalent would. For some reason that never seems to happen.

I’d be interested in hearing others’ reactions to the proposed law.

8 comments