Petri Dishes for Income Inequality

I found an interesting confluence of ideas between this op-ed at the Wall Street Journal on income inequality contrasting the experiences of Red States and Blue States and the article I mentioned previously on real-life economic experiments. The places with the greatest income inequality are Washington, DC, New York, and Connecticut. These are also not coincidentally the places where its citizens are most concerned about income inequality.

Here’s my modest proposal. DC and the two states can take strenuous measures to reduce income inequality. In five years we’ll come back and see how things have fared. Any predictions?

4 comments

Setting a High Minimum Wage

There’s a discussion at the New York Times over the effects of the setting too high a minimum wage. Two economists say that setting too high a minimum wage will slow the rate of job growth and prevent many young or unskilled workers from finding work. A lawyer and a venture capitalist say it would be beneficial.

Economist Arindrajit Dube muses that we’re conducting a real life experiment:

The good news is that the somewhat long ramp-up period in Seattle will provide us with an occasion to learn from this experiment and offer opportunities for course corrections. So we need to be open to evidence on what we see on the ground: if Cylons increasingly occupy check-out counters at the Space Needle while humans ring up the Big Macs in Tacoma and Portland, voters in the Emerald City would be well advised to recalibrate their wage standard. But if it turns out businesses can absorb this increase without a substantial reduction in less-skilled employment, then it’s the rest of the country – and dare I say the economics profession – that might need a rethink.

While I agree that more knowledge is necessary I think he errs in believing that course corrections are possible. I think that minimum wages operate as ratchets and once set are politically nearly impossible to revise downwards. You can only wait until inflation reduces the wage in real dollars for you, wreaking havoc with the local economy along the way.

My understanding is that the scholarship suggests that a moderate increase in the minimum wage doesn’t have much effect on employment or job creation but that the consensus among economists is that large increases in the minimum wage will in fact reduce both.

I think it’s possible that local conditions might warrant an increase in the minimum wage but that such increases might have consequences that reach well beyond the original locality. We’re seeing that right now. I can believe that a $15 minimum wage in Seattle where the unemployment rate is 5.3% can be absorbed by the local economy. Seattle’s local minimum wages incentivizes politicians in Chicago where the unemployment rate is 10.6% to push for our own $15 minimum wage and here it might well throw people out of work or make it harder for them to find work. Not to mention driving businesses on which the poor depend out of the city or even out of the state.

Chicago politicians can always deny responsibility on a “hoocoodanode” basis.

3 comments

The Myth of Not Leaving Soldiers Behind

In the wake of the prisoner exchange that resulted in the release of captured American soldier Bowe Bergdahl by the Taliban people from the president to generals to pundits. I wonder where this myth originated?

The reality is somewhat different. When the cease fire that brought a halt to the Korean War (it’s still not officially over) took place although the North Koreans released about 500 American prisoners the Pentagon believed that they continued to hold nearly a thousand more, as published by the New York Times in 1996.

Whether American prisoners remained in Viet Nam after the accords concluding the Viet Nam War were signed in 1973 is a matter of some controversy. The Pentagon and several Congressional investigations have insisted that none were but activists have accused the Pentagon and Congress of conducting investigations with directed findings. It’s possible that several hundred American prisoners were left behind in Viet Nam and never released. We can’t really be sure.

I think the truth of the matter is that insisting that we never leave soldiers behind is believed to be more conducive to maintaining morale, that the idea is more aspirational than reality, and that we can, do, and have left prisoners behind. The only way to assure otherwise is to insist on unconditional surrender by the enemy and be willing to back that up with action. That’s a strategy we haven’t followed for 70 years.

5 comments

Thinking About the Unthinkable

At The National Interest Harry White considers the circumstances would lead us to go to war with China:

The administration has hoped that Beijing will think that everything in Asia is important to America—from overlapping maritime claims with Vietnam to Japanese sovereignty. But from Beijing, it looks possible that nothing in Asia is that important to America, or at least not important enough to go to war with China over. Whether that’s accurate or not, it’s a thought that is slowly creeping into the minds of some of America’s allies too—and it has them worried.

There is a danger that this thinking at cross-purposes could precipitate a crisis, and that crisis could turn into a war. China might cross an actual American redline, which ironically, the White House won’t have articulated clearly enough to avoid antagonizing Beijing.

I strongly suspect that the Chinese believe that there are no circumstances under which we’d go to war with them. That is, perhaps, the most dangerous situation imaginable. Have a nice day!

22 comments

Telling Half the Story

As you might expect, the editors of the Wall Street Journal are vehemently opposed to the EPA’s recent ruling on emissions by coal-fueled power plants. In today’s editorial they take an interesting tack—that in this new policy the administration is stranding Democrats from “energy-producing states” in favor of “green liberals” from coastal states:

This will have far-reaching implications, especially for Democrats in energy-rich states and especially this year. Twenty years ago, Bill Clinton would never have dreamed of rolling out this EPA regulation five months before an election. Mr. Obama is willing to risk it now because his second term is winding down and he wants to put in place as a much of a legacy as he can. But he’s also gambling that money from green liberals like Mr. Steyer can help stave off the loss of the Senate in energy states.

What strikes me about the charts that accompany the editorial is that they only tell half the story and that the position of the coastal states can only be described as cognitive dissonance. Of course Washington, DC, Connecticut, Massachusetts, Delaware, and California don’t have as much “carbon intensity” as Wyoming, West Virginia, or Louisiana. DC and California import most of their energy, gas, and water. They also don’t depend on manufacturing to employ their workers or provide a tax base for the spending of their state and local governments. But their lifestyles would be impossible without those carbon-intense states. I wonder what the average commute distance in Los Angeles is compared with the average commute distance in Shreveport.

2 comments

The President Must Obey the Law

In my earlier post on the subject of the prisoner swap for Taliban prisoner Bowe Bergdahl, I said that I thought it was a difficult call and one I was glad I did not need to make. This morning Ruth Marcus:

Don’t count me among those who pronounce with certitude on the wisdom — or folly — of the Bergdahl deal. It was an agonizingly hard call, one that requires more knowledge than is publicly available about the dangerousness of the five Taliban officials and the United States’ ability to keep tabs on them once released.

and Kathleen Parker:

The United States does negotiate with terrorists; the president will circumvent laws as circumstances require; Republicans and Democrats will be summarily outraged as party affiliations seem to require.

We might also add that processes will be “truncated,” as President Obama described the exchange, and these are “hard choices,” as Hillary Clinton put it, cleverly employing the title of her new book.

Which is to say, war is tricky and we have no idea what we’re willing to do until the ball is in our court.

both writing in the Washington Post echo my thoughts. Ms. Marcus’s instinct is to oppose the swap; Ms. Parker’s to support it.

When I wrote I did not take notice of the law requiring that the president give Congress 30 days notice before releasing prisoners from Guantanamo. Although I’m still of mixed mind on the swap itself, I think that the president should have conformed to the law and notified Congress. That’s not a partisan position or even a political judgment. Both Congressional Democrats and Republicans have said much the same thing and the Democrats saying this are not merely those fighting tough re-election campaigns. Painting it as a purely partisan position is in fact the partisan and political position.

The president’s supporters have defended the president’s position using the same logic as used by the Bush Administration to condone torture and in some cases quoting from those statements. I think the Congress has the stronger legal position based on these two clauses in Article I, Section 8 of the U. S. Constitution. Among Congress’s enumerated powers are the powers:

11: To declare War, grant Letters of Marque and Reprisal, and make Rules concerning Captures on Land and Water;

and

14: To make Rules for the Government and Regulation of the land and naval Forces;

The Congress has acted under its enumerated powers. In violating the law, it is the president who has threatened the separation of powers. The key point here is that the president doesn’t just get to do whatever he wants. The president must obey the law and is bound by it just like the rest of us.

The Supreme Court has recently affirmed and re-affirmed that Congress cannot resort to the courts to compel the president to follow or enforce the law—impeachment is Congress’s only recourse. The president is coming far too close for my taste to giving Congressional Republicans the pretext they’ve sought for some time.

23 comments

The Price of Success

James Taranto makes a good point: if the cause of the lousy management we’ve had for the lasty decade or so at the federal level is structural problems in the federal government, viewing the federal government as the primary vehicle for effecting change smacks of Maslow’s Hammer:

If Klein is right to find fault with the structure of the federal government, then the federal government in its current form cannot be “the primary answer to the nation’s ills.” Fundamental restructuring of the federal government is another necessary condition for progressivism’s success.

To agree that these are necessary conditions is not to establish that they would be sufficient ones. But that’s an abstract point. If progressivism cannot succeed absent these two exceedingly unlikely contingencies, it is as well to say it cannot succeed. The problem is ideology, not just competence.

I think our problems are more complicated than that. Recent presidents haven’t been recruited from among army generals or successful private sector managers. They’ve been bureaucrats, apparatchiks, and career politicians without meaningful managerial experience. For more effective government we’d need to change the structure of the federal government, our political system, and just about everything else about our society. That’s so high a price I can’t imagine it happening.

So expect more incompetence and expect it good and hard.

8 comments

The Pushback

There’s been quite a bit of reaction to the EPA’s plan to reduce poewr plant emissions by fiat. Here are the editors of the Washington Post:

These numbers will be fought over — including by those who believe they do not fully represent the benefits. But the main point is that this plan is a down payment on a comprehensive climate plan, not the most efficient policy nor a suitably ambitious response to climate change. Assuming the proposal survives the inevitable legal onslaught, opponents will no doubt insist that the climate issue is dealt with. Global warming activists got their regulations, so why do any more?

A few reasons (there are many): The EPA’s new plan is a medium-term policy, but the country requires a long-run transformation in how it produces and consumes energy. Its implementation will depend heavily on who’s in the Oval Office; not much would happen in a Ted Cruz administration. The proposal applies only to the electricity sector, but emissions result from activities across the economy.

continuing by pitching a gradually rising carbon tax. The editors of the Wall Street Journal on the other hand point to the contradiction between environmental policy while complaining about rising income inequality:

The EPA claims to be targeting “polluters,” but the government is essentially creating an artificial scarcity in carbon energy. Scarcities mean higher prices, which will hit the poor far harder than they will the anticarbon crusaders who live in Pacific Heights. The lowest 10% of earners pay three times as much as a share of their income for electricity compared to the middle class. If you want more inequality, this is an ideal way to ensure it.

The EPA plan will also redistribute income from economically successful states to those that have already needlessly raised their energy costs. The New England and California cap-and-trade programs will get a boost, while the new rule punishes the regions that rely most on fossil fuels and manufacturing: the South, Ohio River Valley and mid-Atlantic. Think of it as a transfer from Austin to Sacramento.

It should also be mentioned that claims by bakery shop window-breakers notwithstanding manufacturing depends on cheap, plentiful energy. When you impose penalties on energy producers without viable alternatives (wind and solar won’t be viable substitutes for coal for the foreseeable future if ever) you are saying that you prefer reducing emissions to producing jobs that ordinary people can do. Fewer jobs will be created by more expensive energy than were created by coal.

For decades I supported a carbon tax, largely for geopolitical reasons. That was long before such a tax would have meant exporting our emissions to China where a) they’ll spread over here anyway and b) the problem becomes intractable due to China’s social, political, and legal structures. I’ve also become skeptical of the efficacy of a carbon tax for reasons somewhat along the lines the WSJ editors suggest.

Just assume that carbon emissions pose a problem. I don’t want this post to turn into another argument about climate change. Assume it. Carbon taxes are regressive. For them to be effective assumes that everyone’s lifestyle produces the same level of omissions or that emissions vary roughly linearly with income. If, on the other hand, emissions vary exponentially with income a carbon tax would make life increasingly tough for ordinary people but would do little or nothing about emissions. Billionaires fly to Europe on a regular basis and have multiple 25,000 square foot houses. Sales clerks generally don’t.

There are ways of dealing with that but they’d require broad political consensus, something lacking and that neither side seems to have any interest in fostering. And most especially it’s not something that can be done by fiat.

Meanwhile, here’s a modest proposal. Why don’t Bill Gates, Al Gore, and Barack Obama, just to name three, model the behavior they’d like to see in others? They’d have to live more like Warren Buffett. Quelle horreur! It would mean they couldn’t fly anywhere and they’d have to turn off the air conditioning but aren’t those small prices to pay to save the planet?

10 comments

Chicago’s Future

There’s an interesting post here on the repercussions of Seattle’s $15 an hour minimum wage. The idea of a $15 minimum wage is catching on in Chicago, too:

Supporters of a $15-an-hour minimum wage in Chicago said today that the time is right to introduce their plan to the City Council, despite moves from Mayor Rahm Emanuel and at the state level to go more slowly and possibly adopt smaller increases.

Speaking at a City Hall news conference prior to a council meeting, fast food worker Tanika Smith said she can’t make ends meet on her pay of $8.75 per hour. “My car note is $500 a month, my rent is about $500, food is going up, lights are going up,” she said.

The state minimum wage is currently $8.25 an hour.

Ald. Proco “Joe” Moreno, 1st, scoffed at the argument that a higher minimum wage would hurt business, saying the whole city would be better off if residents had more money to spend. “It’s not going to hurt business. It never has,” Moreno said. “It’s only raised those at the lower end.”

Clearly, it’s time to start hurling rocks through bakery shop windows. Think of all the jobs that will create for glaziers! If only they could figure out how to legislate a $7.75 an hour marginal product of labor, they’d really be on to something.

IMO if you favor a higher minimum wage, you should favor a higher national minimum wage, particularly if you live in a place like Chicago, whose metropolitan area borders two states, each of which has a lower minimum wage than Illinois’s current state minimum wage and a lot lower than $15 an hour. Otherwise we may be in for a future in which large areas of Chicago are not merely “food deserts” in the sense of no grocery stores that offer fresh fruits or vegetables but real food deserts in which there are neither grocery stores nor even fast food.

8 comments

Putting Words in His Mouth

Michael Weiss re-imagines the president’s speech at West Point. You might find it amusing. Here’s a sample:

To these critics, I would only pose a few simple questions. Can any nation on earth amass a hashtag campaign on Twitter faster than the United States of America? Has any nation in the history of the world held so many international conferences in Switzerland in so short a period of time? Does any one constitutional republic have a former leader so easy to mock and blame for all the problems that have ensued well after he has gone?

The answer, of course, is no.

Then again you might not.

2 comments