The Real Reason

When I read the results of this poll on the relationship between obesity and long-term unemployment (high blood pressure and high cholesterol are also positively correlated with long-term unemployment) my immediate reaction was to wonder whether obesity was not in fact a proxy for race. Consider this finding about those who are among the long-term unemployed from the Urban Institute:

…we see that blacks, relative to other groups, are disproportionately represented among long-term unemployed and discouraged workers. They make up 22.6 percent of the long-term unemployed, 10.5 percent of the employed, 25.9 percent of discouraged workers, and 15.0 percent of newly unemployed workers. Hispanics make up a somewhat smaller share of the long-term unemployed (19.0 percent), the employed (15.7 percent), and the discouraged (20.2 percent) than of the newly unemployed (23.1 percent).

There are all sorts of factors that are in reality proxies for race which confound findings of this sort. Zip code can be a proxy for race. Level of educational attainment can be a proxy for race.

10 comments

Will Hillary Face Opposition?

There’s one question that James Taranto’s column on Hillary Clinton brought to my mind. Will Sec. Clinton face serious opposition from the left flank and/or populist wing of her own party?

That’s a question. I don’t know the answer and I’d like your opinions.

Update

Every man a king! Is there a prospective Huey Long out there somewhere? I don’t see it but I’m really not attuned to what’s going on in states other than my own. And I don’t just mean Illinois, if you know what I mean.

6 comments

The Real Immigration Reform

Rather than going through Rupert Murdoch’s paean to comprehensive immigration reform in a point-by-point refutation, I’ll just make a few quick points. Not every immigrant is Rupert Murcdoch. While it might be true that 28% of businesses are started by immigrants, that doesn’t mean that 28% of immigrants start new businesses. The actual number is very, very small.

Google, eBay, Pfizer, and Home Depot aren’t headquartered in Eastern Europe or China because of our robust system of civil law and ambitious patent regime. I note that Mr. Murdoch doesn’t mention the many companies that were crowded out of the market by the companies he lists. I wonder who founded them? How many businesses have been shuttered because of News Corp.?

I agree with Mr. Murdoch that the H-1B visa program needs reform. I firmly support the idea that American businesses should have the workers they need. I’m just more skeptical than he that the workers aren’t already here and that the push for more H-1B visas are more a device for keeping wages low than for getting workers with necessary skills. That’s why I support a central clearing house for advertising jobs to be offered under H-1B programs and bounties paid whistle-blowers on paying sub-market wages.

Finally, there is one form of immigration reform that is vitally necessary. We need to mend our relationship with Mexico. It’s been nearly twenty years since I’ve heard much about serious bilateral negotiations with our neighbor to the south.

3 comments

Behold, the Power of Permanent Press

My dad wore two shirts a day. White, starched, cotton and linen blend shirts. My dad, at best rumpled-looking, felt it was essential to maintaining a professional appearance.

When I was very small my mother spent a lot of her time ironing my dad’s shirts (I don’t ever recall our household help doing any ironing). Later when we had a bit more money, my mom sent my dad’s shirt to the laundry. But that still meant trips to the laundry several times a week if not on a daily basis. On net it probably reduced my mom’s workload but just as importantly it changed the nature of the workload.

When permanent press became widely available and affordable in the mid-1950s, it changed her life.

4 comments

H = I + G

I suspect that this is something that will debated for decades. This study, of 3,137 of the 3,144 U. S. counties, certainly seems to have found that healthcare insurance premiums have risen sharply under the PPACA:

There are hundreds of aspects of Obamacare that people argue over. But there’s one question that matters above all others: does the Affordable Care Act live up to its name? Does it make health insurance less expensive? Last November, our team at the Manhattan Institute published a study indicating that Obamacare had increased the underlying cost of individually-purchased health insurance in the average state by 41 percent in 2014, relative to 2013.

[…]

Across the country, for men overall, individual-market premiums went up in 91 percent of all counties: 2,844 out of 3,137. For 27-year-old men, the average county faced 91 percent increases; for 40-year-old men, 60 percent; for 64-year-old men, 32 percent.

Women fared slightly better; their premiums “only” went up in 82 percent of all counties: 2,562 out of 3,137. That’s because Obamacare bars insurers from charging different rates to men and women; prior to Obamacare, only 11 states did so. Because women tend to consume more health care than men, the end result of the Obamacare regulation is that men fare somewhat worse.

I think there are several possible retorts to this study. You could take the position that it’s still early days and that at some point the PPACA will result in lower healthcare premiums. This might be thought of as “the Pony Hypothesis”. The trends for that don’t look particularly good. You could also point out that the study merely determines that healthcare insurance premiums have risen not that the PPACA caused insurance premiums to rise. It might be that premiums increased despite the PPACA rather than because of it.

It could also be maintained that since the study doesn’t not appear to be weighted by population but is strictly geographic that although prices increased for most areas they didn’t increase (or increased at a lower rate) for most policies. You can’t conclude that from the study but it might be the case. That will be the food for a different study, presumably one carried out by the legislation’s defenders.

The study does cast the number of insurers getting into the healthcare market in a different light. We may be seeing a gold rush incentivized by rising premiums and the mitigation of risk in the form of federal subsidies.

Whatever the case, it’s becoming increasingly difficult to claim that the PPACA is achieving one of its stated objectives, to reduce healthcare premium prices.

The equation that forms the title of this post just says that “healthcare spending is composed from the spending of individuals plus spending by governments”, something obvious stated in mathematicalese. Democrats have focused their attentions on the “I” component, the shrewd political strategy. If you reduce what people pay out of pocket by increasing government subsidies, from an experiential standpoint healthcare will cost less. Republicans on the other hand have tended to focus on the “G” component. That was the essence of the Ryan plan. It did nothing to reduce “H” (unless you assume that patient-induced over-consumption is the most significant driver of healthcare spending, something for which there is little evidence) while driving “G” down which inevitably meant that “I” would increase.

I have focused unfailingly on “H”. Healthcare insurance premiums are proportional to the cost of the underlying risk. As long as spending is increasing in real terms, healthcare insurance premiums will increase in real terms, too. Changing who writes the checks won’t change that.

3 comments

If You Build It, They Will Come

I have long thought, particularly when stuck in traffic, that the Federal Highway Act of 1956 AKA the Interstate Highway Defense Act might have been counter-productive. As it turns out, I may have been right:

As a kid, I used to ask my parents why they couldn’t just build more lanes on the freeway. Maybe transform them all into double-decker highways with cars zooming on the upper and lower levels. Except, as it turns out, that wouldn’t work. Because if there’s anything that traffic engineers have discovered in the last few decades it’s that you can’t build your way out of congestion. It’s the roads themselves that cause traffic.

The concept is called induced demand, which is economist-speak for when increasing the supply of something (like roads) makes people want that thing even more. Though some traffic engineers made note of this phenomenon at least as early as the 1960s, it is only in recent years that social scientists have collected enough data to show how this happens pretty much every time we build new roads. These findings imply that the ways we traditionally go about trying to mitigate jams are essentially fruitless, and that we’d all be spending a lot less time in traffic if we could just be a little more rational.

The point seems to be that marginal increases in the number and size of roads, slowly and over time, changes habits and preferences in such a way as to produce more traffic. The alternatives suggested include enormous over-capacity (a “100 lane highway”) or some sort of disincentive scheme like congestion pricing or raising parking fees.

10 comments

Willful Ignorance

Victoria Toensing makes an interesting point about Hillary Clinton’s assertions of innocence:

In her interview with ABC’s Diane Sawyer last week, Hillary Clinton said “I was not making security decisions” about Benghazi, claiming “it would be a mistake” for “a secretary of state” to “go through all 270 posts” and “decide what should be done.” And at a January 2013 Senate hearing, Mrs. Clinton said that security requests “did not come to me. I did not approve them. I did not deny them.”

Does the former secretary of state not know the law? By statute, she was required to make specific security decisions for defenseless consulates like Benghazi, and was not permitted to delegate them to anyone else.

I think that the Secretary was ignorant of the law is plausible. Keep in mind that just because she was a lawyer it doesn’t mean that she was a good lawyer. When she took the DC bar she was the only Ivy League grad to fail the first time around.

In her defense I suspect she was not ignorant of the law. I suspect she thought it didn’t apply to her.

6 comments

Let’s Put on a Show!

Because the Davos conference has completely fixed the global economy and the many conferences on the environment have stopped human-induced climate change, David Ignatius wants a conference on the situation in the Middle East:

Initially, such an action plan could probably do no more than establish cease-fire lines, aid refugees and empower Sunni moderates against the toxic power of the al-Qaeda offshoot known as the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria. The aim would be to exclude ISIS, not enfranchise it. Those goals are shared by all the regional and global powers. Russia and China (with their Chechen and Uighur Muslim populations) have as great an interest in stopping the super-violent extremists as does the United States. The aging monarchy in Saudi Arabia should want to roll back ISIS as much as Iran does.

We can’t know now whether the post-1919 borders will survive in this new order, or how the different ethnic minorities can be accommodated. The breakup of Yugoslavia shows that ethnic decentralization is possible, but also the potential cost in blood.

The discussions might start with a divisive issue that was on the agenda at Versailles: Should the Kurds have an independent state of their own, or can they be loosely integrated with Syria, Iraq, Turkey and Iran? Nobody knows the answer yet. That’s what crisis conferences are for.

One of my favorite wisecracks: a committee is a group of people, none of whom can do anything individually, who meet to agree that nothing can be done. If the Kurds want an independent state of their own, they can always take a page from the Israeli playbook: stake out a state, say you have a state, and defend it to the teeth against all comers. It might not make your neighbors happy but you’ll have a state of your own.

4 comments

Putting Down Markers

This is a good opportunity to put down some markers on what’s going on in Iraq.

  1. There is no ready replacement for Maliki.
  2. Maliki is working from a very familiar Middle Eastern playbook and one that should be expected from any leader operating in a tribal society who maintains his power by doling out favors.
  3. Consequently, any substitute for Maliki won’t do anything much different.
  4. ISIS doesn’t negotiate. They might delay but they won’t negotiate.
  5. They’ve been more effective at governing in Syria than has been suggested in the American media. They’ll probably do the same things in Iraq as they have in Syria.
1 comment

Not Overlearning

I strongly suspect that Ruth Marcus is misreading President Obama’s misreading of history:

On foreign policy, the signal episode of Obama’s overlearning the lessons of history is . . . pretty much the entirety of his foreign policy. It has been a reaction, understandable enough, to the adventurism of George W. Bush, primarily the ill-advised, ill-fated venture in Iraq.

Bush promised humility yet overreached; Obama vowed realism and yet underplayed the United States’ essential hand in world affairs. Hence the administration’s reluctance to intervene in Libya, the costly dillydallying over whether and how to help the rebels in Syria, the failure to push hard enough for a status of forces agreement that would have allowed U.S. troops to remain in Iraq.

The administration’s instinct to retreat and ignore festering problems has helped contribute to the cataclysmic result now playing out in Iraq. Yes, the original, far graver, sin was the decision to invade. The responsibility of the incumbent president is to deal with the mistakes he inherits.

I don’t think that the president has “overlearned” anything. He’s a specialist. I think his interest is limited to political history.

However important political history is, there is other history and I don’t think that President Obama believes that its lessons apply to him.

10 comments