The National Pastime

Today seems to be “National Pick on Dodd-Frank Day”. Perhaps it should be added to the list of federal holidays. The editors of Bloomberg get the ball rolling with the complaint that Dodd-Frank isn’t doing anything:

Four years after President Barack Obama signed the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act into law, polling suggests that most Americans think it hasn’t done enough to protect them from a repeat of the 2008 financial crisis, a disaster from which the global economy has yet to fully recover.

Unfortunately, they’re right.

while Peter Wallison whinges that it’s doing far too much:

When the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act took effect on July 21, 2010, it immediately caused a sharp partisan division. This staggeringly large legislation—2,300 pages—passed the House without a single Republican vote and received only three GOP votes in the Senate. Republicans saw the bill as ObamaCare for the financial system, a vast and unnecessary expansion of the regulatory state.

Four years later, Dodd-Frank’s pernicious effects have shown that the law’s critics were, if anything, too kind. Dodd-Frank has already overwhelmed the regulatory system, stifled the financial industry and impaired economic growth.

According to the law firm Davis, Polk & Wardell’s progress report, Dodd-Frank is severely taxing the regulatory agencies that are supposed to implement it. As of July 18, only 208 of the 398 regulations required by the act have been finalized, and more than 45% of congressional deadlines have been missed.

The effect on the economy has been worse. A 2013 Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas study showed that the GDP recovery from the recession that ended in 2009 has been the slowest on record, 11% below the average for recoveries since 1960.”

I don’t think that either opinion piece sees the big picture here. Dodd-Frank is clearly a jobs program. Full employment for federal bureaucrats. It’s an overwhelming success. Heckuva job.

That under Dodd-Frank we’ve seen a constant progression towards increasing centralization of the banking industry into the hands of an ever-shrinking few “too big to fail” banks does not seem to concern anyone. You can’t make an omelet without breaking eggs, can you?

18 comments

The Buck Stops Where?

At Fiscal Times David Patrick calls for letting Europe “do the heavy political lift” on dealing with Russia on the Ukraine:

“Days after the plane went down,” Liow said over the weekend, “the remains of 298 people lie uncovered. Citizens of 11 nations, none of whom are involved in the conflict in eastern Ukraine, cannot be laid to rest.”

These conditions at the crash site say it all now. The MH-17 tragedy transforms the Ukraine crisis into one that must be taken, decisively and immediately, out of the hands of its two belligerents, the Kiev government and the rebels who oppose them. This means international engagement of a seriousness not yet achieved.

Mr. Patrick does a pretty fair job of explaining some of the interests that various European countries have in pacifying the situation in the Ukraine. He doesn’t do nearly as good a job of explaining why they wouldn’t want to delegate that job to us. Or why we should be interested in doing the heavy lifting for them.

Let me summarize. We have no direct national interests in Ukraine. Russia does. We have an interest in not increasing tensions with Russia. We don’t do nearly as much trade with Russia as Europe does. Every move by us I have seen anyone propose would produce an escalation in the conflict rather than reducing tensions.

This entire crisis is a near-perfect example of the sort of thing where we should be able to depend on Germany, France, Italy, the Netherlands, etc. to take the lead because of their direct interests but can’t.

2 comments

Searching for an Answer

There’s an interesting article at Fiscal Times on the alternatives for punitive measures against Russia. Here are David Francis’s proposals:

  • Arm the Ukrainian military.
  • Strangle the Russian economy.
  • Extend NATO membership to Ukraine.

I think that each of those proposals is problematic in its own way and all fail by the standards I suggested yesterday. Is the present Ukrainian government really one we want to ally ourselves with? Germany in particular has shown few signs of any appetite for further economic sanctions against Russia. As I said yesterday, it’s not a crisis until Europe decides it’s a crisis.

Finally, the Ukraine is not a vital interest for us but it is a vital interest for Russia not only because of its substantial Russian population and historic ties but for its strategic importance. Do we really want to commit to defend the country? Does anybody believe that we would?

27 comments

James Garner, 1928-2014

Many years ago when television and I were much younger and television was testing its legs to see what genres were best-suited to the still-new medium, the Warner Brothers studio had a sort of repertory of westerns that played on ABC. Each was headed by a tall, good-looking, second- or third-tier contract player. Of these westerns the star of the most popular was a tall, impossibly handsome, easy-going Oklahoman. Now James Garner has died at the age of 86:

James Garner, a master of light comedy who shot to fame in the 1950s as the charming and dry-witted gambler on the hit TV western “Maverick” and later won an Emmy Award as the unconventional L.A. private eye on “The Rockford Files,” has died. He was 86.

Garner was found dead Saturday at his home in Brentwood, Los Angeles police officer Alonzo Iniquez told the Associated Press. Garner underwent quintuple bypass heart surgery in 1988 and suffered a stroke in 2008, but the cause of death was not immediately known.

Once described by Washington Post TV critic Tom Shales as having “embodied the crusty, sardonic and self-effacing strain of American masculinity” in his iconic roles as Maverick and Rockford, the Oklahoma-born Garner amassed more than 80 movie and TV-movie credits during his more than 50-year career.

After his stint on television’s Maverick, Garner went on to become a major motion picture star, appearing in a string of hit movies in the 1960s including The Children’s Hour, Boys’ Night Out, The Great Escape, and The Americanization of Emily. Many of the obituaries point to his talent for light comedy but it was as a dramatic actor that Garner had cut his teeth on stage and he excelled at it.

His motion picture career peaked with a pair of western spoofs, Support Your Local Sheriff and Support Your Local Gunfighter.

He returned to television to star in a modern day remake of Maverick, The Rockford Files.

His last role as a romantic lead was in 1985’s Murphy’s Romance. In it he played an elderly pharmacist courting Sally Fields’s spunky 40 year old ingenue. He received an Academy Award nomination for his performance in it. Murphy’s Romance remains one of my favorite pictures, one of the handful I could watch over and over again.

Garner never fit comfortably into the studio system. His relationships with the studios for which he worked were fractious. His parting with Warner Brothers was bitter; he sued Universal twice.

I think that the secret of James Garner’s success on both the big and small screens was that he always played himself and James Garner was always interesting and charming enough for us to want to watch.

4 comments

Spent Force

Gunmen of the “Islamic State” née ISIS (or ISIL) have defeated the Iraqi military and its Shi’ite militia allies at Tikrit:

RBIL, Iraq — Islamic State gunmen overran a former U.S. military base early Friday and killed or captured hundreds of Iraqi government troops who’d been trying to retake Saddam Hussein’s hometown of Tikrit, the worst military reversal Iraqi troops have suffered since the Islamist forces captured nearly half the country last month.

The defeat brought to an end a three-week campaign by the government in Baghdad to recapture Tikrit, which fell to the Islamic State on June 11. Military spokesmen earlier this week had confidently announced a final push to recapture the city.

Instead, Islamic State forces turned back the army’s thrust up the main highway Wednesday. Beginning late Thursday, the Islamist forces stormed Camp Speicher, a former U.S. military base named for a pilot who disappeared during the 1991 Persian Gulf War, and overwhelmed the troops there.

Bill Roggio adds:

The latest failed Tikrit offensive and the loss of Camp Speicher highlight the deteriorating condition of the Iraqi armed forces. The military has been forced to cobble together units since at least four of its 15 regular army divisions are no longer viable. The Long War Journal estimates that at least seven divisions have been rendered ineffective since the beginning of the year; see Threat Matrix report, US advisers give dark assessment of state of Iraqi military.

IMO this marks the end of the Iraqi military as a cohesive fighting force. I do not believe they will be able to oppose the “Islamic State” in its home Sunni-dominated areas of Iraq any further.

The question going forward is what the “Islamic State” will do next. My guess is that they’ll continue to consolidate their gains in western Iraq for a short period before moving on to Baghdad.

5 comments

Buying New Cookware

We finally broke down and bought new cookware.

When my wife and I were married, I had a set of Le Creuset enamel-coated cast iron cookware which I loved. My wife pronounced it too heavy to use (something she only does rarely anyway) and, shortly after we married, we purchased a set of Calphalon anodized aluminum cookware. It has served us well for nearly 30 years.

Over the years the anodized surfaces of our Calphalon has worn away and their bottoms are sprung. Some days I feel much the same myself.

I approached deciding what we should buy the way I approach most things: extensive research. I read every review, customer comment, or blog post on stainless steel cookware I could put my hands on and concluded on what we should buy based on that research. As it turns out our timing was good.

We decided to take advantage of a very attractive sale, redeemed a number of Williams-Sonoma gift cards I’d received from my mom (you might recall that my mom died several years ago so we’ve had these cards for quite a while), and I’ve called in several of the IOUs from my wife that I’d received over the years for new sets of cookware, and purchased a brand new set of All-Clad D5 stainless steel cookware, our first new cookware in almost 30 years. It is not your mother’s Farberware.

When we got it home and took it out of the box, my wife declared it too beautiful to use. It is genuinely beautiful with attractive lines and mirror-bright finishes.

Two days later I have used two of the pieces: the 8-inch frying pan and the 8 quart stockpot. Its heat diffusion is magnificent. It is substantial but easy to handle.

I have found I need to adjust my cooking. The temperatures I need to accomplish certain effects are different from my old Calphalon although not as low as All-Clad’s literature might lead you to expect. So far it seems to clean up beautifully.

They say it is dishwasher safe, something I haven’t had the courage to try out.

9 comments

But What Is the Right Response?

Judging by the many news articles, op-eds,and editorials, most urging action, the news of the day continues to be the Malaysian passenger jet shot down over the eastern Ukraine. The most likely explanation seems to be that it was shot down by trigger-happy pro-Russian separatists. As usual the opinionators are getting pretty far out in front of the known facts. What we know seems to be limited to the fact that the jet crashed. What we have pretty fair reason to suspect is that it was shot down and, if that’s the case, the most likely culprits are pro-Russian separatists, the surface to air missile used to bring the airliner down from an altitude of 33,000 feet was a weapon possessed both by the Ukrainian and Russian militaries, and it’s sophisticated weaponry, i.e. it requires a substantial amount of training to use.

We don’t absolutely know who was responsible and, importantly, we don’t know how they got their hands on the weapon.

Many of the opinion pieces make a sort of “no sparrow falls” assumption: that Vladimir Putin is responsible for anything that happens in Ukraine. This example from The Daily Beast is typical of the genre:

Russian President Vladimir Putin blamed the Ukrainian government for the crash, an absurd statement even by his own standards. “This tragedy would not have happened if there had been peace on that land, or in any case if military operations in southeastern Ukraine had not been renewed,” Putin said, the geopolitical equivalent of blaming the rape victim for her misfortune. The reason why there is no “peace” in Ukraine is because of the Russian government’s barely disguised strategy of funding and equipping a violent insurgency that has now gone on for months and taken hundreds of lives. Thursday’s horrific tragedy was the consequence of Russian war-mongering; if you give guns, missiles, training, and logistical support to a band of drunken thugs, it shouldn’t come as a surprise that something like this might happen.

While it’s possible that Pres. Putin is directly implicated in the transfer of the weapon used to whoever used it and specifically authorized the attack, we just don’t know. It seems like a stretch to me. I don’t see anything in his background or behavior to lead me to believe that he’d be that reckless.

The second common trope is that if we (or “the West”) were only tougher the airliner would never have been shot down. That, too, is exemplified in the article cited above:

And so the world’s shock at the catastrophe is misplaced. For too long, Moscow’s flagrant violations of Ukrainian sovereignty and destabilization of the European security order have been met by a tepid Western response.

Robert Beckhusen at Matthew Gault at WiB make a pretty good case that some kind of response is called for from the United States and the EU:

Shooting down a civilian airliner is an international crisis more serious than anything since Russia’s invasion of Crimea in February. Destroying a civilian airliner is a big deal.

Where before the war contained itself to eastern Ukraine, it’s now threatening the freedom of the skies which civil aviation and the world economy depends. The rebels are not just messing with Malaysia Airlines—they’re messing with world trade. Airlines are now avoiding Ukrainian airspace, as seen from this screen capture from flight-tracking Website Flightradar24.

I think we need to keep two things in mind. First, the Russians are the only ones in a position to end the conflict in the Ukraine. Second, the United States and Russia remain the only countries capable of destroying the world so, consequently, there are limits to how bad we should allow our bilateral relationship to become.

Consequently, I believe that our words and deeds should be measured according to two standards. Are we making it more or less likely that the Russians will allow the conflict in the Ukraine to end or bring it to an end? And second, are we gambling with nuclear war?

From a practical standpoint what can be done to Russia is pretty limited as long as the Europeans continue to pursue their lucrative trade in military hardware with the Russians. In just the last month the French, the Italians, and the Germans have all sold important military gear to the Russians. For them, it’s apparently business as usual.

2 comments

Where You Sit Is Where You Stand

For sheer schadenfreude it’s hard to beat this pick-up by Kimberley Strassel:

About the only thing Ms. Slaughter didn’t do in five hours was offer House Speaker John Boehner her litigation notes. For it seems to have slipped Ms. Slaughter’s mind—and the press’s attention—that a mere eight years ago she was a plaintiff in a lawsuit filed by congressional Democrats against George W. Bush. The year was 2006, just as Democrats were, uh, peaking in their campaign to take back the House.

Democrats were sore that they’d lost a fight over a budget bill that made cuts to Medicaid and student loans. They dredged up a technical mistake—a tiny difference between the House and Senate version of the bill. Michigan Democrat John Conyers, ranking member of the House Judiciary Committee, decided to (how did Ms. Slaughter put it?) file a lawsuit against the president brought by half of the Congress. He was joined as a plaintiff by nearly every other then-ranking Democratic member and titan in the House— Charles Rangel, John Dingell, George Miller, Collin Peterson, Bennie Thompson, Barney Frank, Pete Stark, James Oberstar and Ms. Slaughter herself.

How things have changed in just one administration! Some of the same people who were complaining about President Bush’s high-handed attitudes towards the law then are lambasting the Republicans for complaining about President Obama’s expansive view of what is “necessary and proper” now. And in much the same language:

In an April 2006 Huffington Post piece titled “Taking the President to Court,” Mr. Conyers explained that he was “alarmed by the erosion of our constitutional form of government,” and by a president who “shrugged” about “the law.” After “consulting with some of the foremost constitutional experts in the nation,” he had determined that there was “one group of people” who were “injured” by Mr. Bush’s lack of respect for “checks and balances”: Congress. So he was “going”—or as Ms. Slaughter might put it, “running”—”to court.”

I guess it looks different when the other guy is doing it.

16 comments

What Kind of Jobs Do They Want?

Miles White, CEO of Chicago-based Abbott Laboratories, explains corporate inversion, companies’ changing of national jurisdictions, frequently seeking tax relief:

First, inversion is legal. Period. It’s allowed in the tax code. The tax code even specifies the terms and conditions under which it may be done. Reference 26 U.S. Code Section 7874.

Inversion doesn’t change a company’s tax rate. A company pays the same tax rate in the U.S. after inversion as it does before inverting. A company also pays the same tax rates in foreign domiciles before and after inversion.

Inversion does not relieve any pre-existing tax burden. It does not reduce the tax that any company would ultimately have to pay on past earnings overseas that have been deferred under the U.S. tax system.

The tax law today views overseas earnings that have not been repatriated as part of the U.S. tax system, regardless of whether a company has inverted. Therefore, those past foreign earnings, if repatriated to the U.S., are still subject to full U.S. taxation.

What does change after inversion is a company’s access to its future foreign earnings generated outside of the U.S. tax system. Those future earnings may be used for any capital allocation purpose the company may have, including investment in the U.S., without the additional U.S. repatriation tax. Foreign taxes will have already been paid on those profits earned outside the U.S. It is the additional repatriation tax, imposed by high corporate tax rate in the U.S., that is not paid after inversion.

When a company changes its headquarters some portion of the jobs associated with corporate headquarters are inevitably lost.

For me that raises the question of what sort of jobs the Obama Administration actually wants? They clearly don’t want more corporate staff jobs. They don’t want more mining or logging or power plants or oil refining. They don’t want more heavy manufacturing. The tens of thousands of jobs for solar panel installers failed to materialize. We are so overbuilt in housing and infrastructure that larger numbers of new construction jobs are unlikely. States, their budgets pressed by tax revenues inadequate to pay their Medicaid bills and the pensions and benefits promised to past employees are reducing the number of present employees.

The economy isn’t like an army where you command and things happen but like farming. You prepare the soil, sow the seed, fertilize the crops, fend off predators and diseases. Nature (or God, if you prefer) produces the crops but the richness of the harvest can be influenced by the skill and effort you put into it.

It’s like the parable:

“Behold, a sower went out to sow. 4 And as he sowed, some seed fell by the wayside; and the birds came and devoured them. 5 Some fell on stony places, where they did not have much earth; and they immediately sprang up because they had no depth of earth. 6 But when the sun was up they were scorched, and because they had no root they withered away. 7 And some fell among thorns, and the thorns sprang up and choked them. 8 But others fell on good ground and yielded a crop: some a hundredfold, some sixty, some thirty. 9 He who has ears to hear, let him hear!”

We’ve been sowing among the thorns and on the stones for a long time. And yet, somehow, we’re surprised at the results.

8 comments

About That Malaysian Jet

I don’t really have a great deal to say about the Malaysian passenger jet that was shot down over the eastern Ukraine:

A surface-to-air missile struck a Malaysia Airlines plane carrying 298 people that went down Thursday in Ukraine near the Russian border, a U.S. official told ABC News.

The official said U.S. intelligence and analysis of the situation determined that it was a single missile that struck the Boeing 777-200 aircraft while at cruising altitude. It is unclear whether the missile was fired from inside Ukrainian or Russian territory and who fired it, the official added.

I can see only a few likely possibilities.

  1. It was shot down by Russian regulars operating within Ukraine.
  2. It was shot down by Russian regulars who’d removed their uniforms operating within Ukraine (a war crime).
  3. It was shot down by pro-Russian Ukrainian irregulars who’d received a Buk missile from the Russians.
  4. It was shot down by somebody who’d captured a Buk missile from somebody.

Whichever of these is the case it’s disturbing. Alternative C is particularly disturbing in its foolhardiness. I doubt that this event is a “game-changer” as some are claiming so much as a signal that events in Ukraine are out of anyone’s control.

That’s particularly distressing since the only power in a position to bring things under control is Russia.

29 comments