Realism Was Never Like This

There’s an article at The National Interest discussing an interesting question. Is Barack Obama a foreign policy realist?

If we take President Obama at his word that he is not a realist—and there are good reasons to do so—his administration’s long flirtation with foreign-policy realism and especially with the Left’s “progressive realists” raises two important questions. First, why were the president and his advisers comfortable with longtime and widely held perceptions that he was a realist? Second, what changed their minds?

Answering these questions with any certainty would require a front-row seat in the White House Emergency Public Relations Bunker that one can too easily imagine the administration building immediately beneath the Situation Room for its most important decision making. Still, it is not difficult to see how the image of foreign-policy realism could appeal to the president and his communications team—it has provided superficial intellectual and political legitimacy to Obama’s frequently expressed desire to concentrate on “nation building at home.” It likewise helped the administration to justify avoiding undue involvement in complex and time-consuming international problems, especially those inherited from former president George W. Bush, whose legacy the White House has publicly repudiated but quietly continued in many respects.

Want to get out of Iraq? Pivot to Asia instead—it’s more strategically important. Need to withdraw from Afghanistan? We’ve done all we can there. Hope to stay out of further wars in the Middle East? Negotiate with Iran and use Congress as an excuse to stay out of Syria. Americans frustrated with Bush’s expensive choices were understandably tempted.

I think it’s helpful to keep in mind that in international relations “realism” is a term of art that doesn’t mean what you might think it does if you don’t run in international relations circles—something along the lines of “not ideological”. I honestly don’t think we’ve had a foreign policy realist with major influence in policy-making here since Kissinger.

I’d certainly be interested in hearing the argument pro and con in comments.

Just for the record I do not consider myself a foreign policy realist. Pessimistic idealist.

21 comments

The Sacrifice

In one of the most outspoken arguments in favor substantial intervention by the U. S. in Iraq and Syria I’ve read to date, Richard Cohen writes:

I used to not believe in evil. When Ronald Reagan called the Soviet Union “the evil empire,” I thought it was a dandy phrase but also a confession of ignorance. The word itself connotes something or someone diabolical — bad for the sake of bad. The Soviet Union was bad, I conceded, but not for no reason. It was bad because it was insecure, occupying the flat, inviting, Eurasian plain, and because it had a different system of government that it dearly wanted to protect. Reagan had it right, though. The Soviet Union was evil.

Now we are facing a different type of evil. The Islamic State, in whose name Foley was beheaded, murders with abandon. It seems to love death the way the fascists once did. It is Sunni, so it massacres Shiites. It is radical Sunni, so it eliminates apostates. It is Muslim, so it kills Yazidis, a minority with a religion of its own, and takes as plunder their women as concubines. Men are shot in graves of their own making.

The Nazis are back — differently dressed, speaking a different language and murdering ostensibly for different reasons but actually for the same: intolerance, hatred, excitement and just because they can. The Islamic State’s behavior is beyond explication, not reacting as some suggest to the war in Iraq — although in time it will try to settle some scores with the United States — but murdering and torturing and enslaving because this is what it wants to do. It is both futile and tasteless to lay off blame on others — the West, the colonialists of old or the persistent Zionists — or to somehow find guilt in the actions of the rich or powerful because they are rich or powerful. You can blame the victim. You can even kill him.

If you follow and agree with his argument, I honestly don’t see how you could support half measures that failed to eliminate ISIS like modest bombings that just induce them to disperse and wait it out. I also don’t remember anyone ever having said, in reference to the Nazis in the 1940s, “The real solution is for the French to get their act together and oppose them.”

On the other hand even in the face of the atrocities that ISIS has committed, atrocities almost certain to be repeated in the near future and over and over again, I just can’t see Americans willing to accept the dreaded “boots on the ground” and, frankly, I honestly see no other way of assuring that ISIS is eliminated. And then what?

If I have a fundamental principle in areas of military intervention, it was Napoleon’s dictum: “If you set out to take Vienna, take Vienna.”

27 comments

The Cab Ride

After a rather slapdash morning which I may tell you about in full some other time I finally caught a cab to the client’s premises. It was a harrowing 45 minutes ride along tiny one lane roads with hedges on each side.

That gave me plenty of time to chat with the cab driver. He was an Englishman and had a running string of complaints very much along the lines of the complaints you might hear in the U. S., substituting Eastern Europeans and Asians for the low wage workers that are showing up here from other countries.

0 comments

Bath Views

This is a view looking down the street of the main shopping area. I caught it at just the right time—everybody is having dinner.

This is a picture of the brasserie where I had dinner tonight. I gather it’s part of a small but rather ritzy chain owned by a chap named Blanc. I had a sort of reimagining of classic fish and chips. It was a grilled halibut filet on a bad of mashed green peas with a few french fries and a remoulade sauce on the side. It was tasty but, honestly, nothing special.

It did, however, hit the spot. I found myself better able to form thoughts than since I’d arrived in the country. For reasons of time and energy nearly the only meal I’ve been eating is breakfast. It comes with my room and I do love full English breakfast.

Later.

2 comments

Speaking His Mind

While I making my way from Heathrow to Bath, my driver, an absolutely charming chap about whom I’ll write more later, blurted out his opinion of the murder of James Foley. His views were harsher than anything I’ve heard from Americans so far although, I suspect, not harsher than a lot of Americans are thinking but not saying.

8 comments

Sunday Night Bath

That’s pretty much the view looking out the door of my hotel in Bath, England. It’s the Francis Hotel if you’re interested.

My new gig has taken me to Bath where I’m planning on meeting with their customer and, perhaps, doing a bit of training. I will be here for a bit and while I am posting may be a bit sparser than is usual for me.

If you don’t know about it Bath is a small town in Somerset that has been renowned as a spa for millennia. The Romans built a beautiful baths here, some of which remains. Bath was sort of rediscovered in the 18th century and there was a lot of development then. Much of the construction here was built during that period. The obelisk in the picture at the top of this post was built in the early 1700s to honor the then Prince of Wales who, presumably, provided a lot of money for that 18th century development.

The hotel in which I’m staying appears to be a combination of an old residential hotel with new construction that was built over the ruins of the old buildings, destroyed by German bombs during the war.

I’ll keep you informed about my adventures.

5 comments

The Bargain

When Uwe “It’s the Prices, Stupid” Reinhardt opened his New York Times op-ed with this question:

Here’s a question I like to put on the final examination in my first-year economics course:

“Are undergraduate medical education in medical schools and subsequent residency training in teaching hospitals (called graduate medical education or GME) public goods that therefore should be publicly funded or at least receive substantial government subsidies?”

I was in the position of Arnold Horshack in the old TV show, Welcome Back, Kotter: I knew the answer and had my hand up in the air. But it’s a trick question. “Public good” is a term of art in economics and public policy theory. A good that is non-rivalrous and non-excludable is a private good. “Non-rivalrous” means that my usage of the good does not preclude your usage of the same good at the same time. An example of a non-rivalrous good, for example, is national defense. We may not benefit by it equally but we both benefit by it at the same time. “Non-excludable” means there’s no way to prevent my using the good without preventing your using it, too. National defense fits that qualification, too, which means that it is, by definition, a public good.

Medical education is obviously a private good and as Dr. Reinhardt notes:

Medical education and training represents human capital that is fully owned by the trainees. They can deploy it as they wish — on patient care, or even in the financial markets, where quite a few physicians now work. In principle, therefore, the owners of that valuable, purely private human capital should pay themselves for its production. That physicians serve society can be acknowledged, but so do many other professions whose education is not publicly funded. Just because privately owned human capital serves the public does not make it a public good.

The more subtle and interesting question is whether an educated medical profession is a public good? I think it is and that’s why regulation of the practice of medicine by local, state, and federal governments is a good idea.

Although physicians these days seem to regard the $80,000 or so per medical resident paid from the Medicare Trust Fund for each and every resident as a law of nature, it isn’t. It’s basically the bribe that was paid to the medical profession to secure its acquiescence to Medicaid in 1965. It’s a bit ironic that such bribery should have been needed since the medical profession has benefited so handsomely from Medicare. Since the passage of the program the wages of physicians have outstripped those of lawyers, accountants, architects, and engineers by far, to the point where the average physician earns a multiple of what the average lawyer earns rather than 10% plus or minus that they earned forty-five years ago.

The reality is that the subsidy has not increased the number of medical residents (that’s been capped) but rather has increased the wages of medical educators.

The smallest reform in our subsidization of medical education that we should implement is that we should limit the subsidy to the education of physicians who will mostly be providing primary care. Other specialties can more than pay their own way.

As to what I think should really be done, my views in the area of healthcare reform are so draconian I don’t even bother airing them.

8 comments

The Dog That Didn’t Bark

James Taranto muses over why the anti-war Left is so silent about our bombings in Iraq:

Is it different because this time the president is a Democrat and a reluctant warrior? The Post’s Aaron Blake notes that the poll found support for the strikes strongest among Republicans (61%), especially conservative Republicans (63%), while Democrats were right at the national average of 54%. Only a 49% plurality of independents back the intervention.

One imagines Democratic support would be lower, and Republican support perhaps higher, if a Republican were in the White House. But hard-left antiwar groups like the Answer Coalition (an acronym for Act Now to Stop War and End Racism), which organized that 2001 protest, are not loyal Democrats. They’ve protested, among other things, Obama’s use of drones to kill terrorists and his failure to empty Guantanamo Bay of al Qaeda detainees.

A look at the Answer homepage turns up nothing about the current Iraq intervention. Atop the page are two posters, one a law-enforcement parody–“WANTED: Officer Darren Wilson for the Murder of Mike Brown”–and one an ad for an Aug. 31 “National March in Detroit” to “END the SIEGE of GAZA NOW!”

Hence our hypothesis: The reason no one is protesting against the intervention in Iraq is because the usual suspects are distracted by agitations against Israel and the Ferguson, Mo., police.

I think it’s because there is no “anti-war Left” in the United States to speak of, at least not an organized one. Organization takes more than a few committed individuals. You’ve got to have institutions and with the exception of a few religious institutions there is very little institutional opposition to war here in the United States.

3 comments

What’s the Objective?

A propos of “do or not do”, the editors of the Washington Post are critical of the president’s plans with respect to Afghanistan:

“People have said, ‘Doesn’t this show that you should never take the troops out of Afghanistan?’ ” a White House official said this week, according to the New York Times. Mr. Obama’s response, according to this official: “He said, ‘No, it actually points to the imperative of having political accommodation. There’s a limit to what we can achieve absent a political process.’ ”

That’s true, of course. But what is the best way to promote political accommodation? Since Mr. Obama announced that he would pull all troops out of Afghanistan by the end of his second term, it’s not surprising that Afghan factions have begun looking for ways to hedge their bets and ensure their survival if order begins to break down. Two presidential candidates have each laid claim to the office, and Secretary of State John F. Kerry’s effort to broker a compromise is in danger. As The Post’s Pamela Constable reported Wednesday, “fears are growing that Afghanistan’s fragile transition process could collapse into violence.”

In the interests of clear thinking, I believe this would be a very good time for the president to re-articulate the reasons he believed that we should put more troops into Afghanistan in 2008 as well as his assessment of whether the goals he wanted to achieve have been accomplished there. Isn’t that how you determine what your policy should be? Figure out what you want to do and the means necessary for accomplishing that?

9 comments

We Have Always Been a Member of NATO

Anne Applebaum wants the members of NATO to start pulling their weight:

Certainly it is long past time for NATO to become more rigorous about its membership. Some Europeans don’t want to pay for their defense? Maybe those who want to be covered by Article 5, the alliance’s security guarantee, should now be obligated to pay. Perhaps those who contribute less than 1 percent of their national budget should be told that the guarantee no longer applies to them. Certainly there don’t need to be any NATO bases in countries that refuse to contribute. And a much higher percentage of their military spending should go toward funding the NATO budget, so that NATO, as an alliance, can afford to pay for important operations.

NATO also needs to become a lot clearer about its goals. Europe has two immediate security issues: the threat from Russia in the east and the threat from Islamic fundamentalism to the south. NATO therefore needs two command centers, each of which would take care of planning and intelligence for defense against those threats. The basing of troops and equipment needs to be rethought completely: If we were starting from scratch, nobody would put them where they are now. NATO needs to shut down unnecessary commands and legacy bases, and move on.

Something to keep in mind about NATO: the target military expenditure for NATO members is 2% of GDP. Among NATO members only the United States, the United Kingdom, France, and Turkey spend that much and, not coincidentally, those countries are the only NATO members able to project power beyond their own borders.

I don’t believe there’s any hope for Slovakia or Estonia’s spending more on their militaries. Why should they? They know we’ll defend them no matter what.

My own view is that we should be much more reluctant to intervene on behalf of other countries, particularly countries who won’t defend themselves, than we are and consider what purpose NATO actually serves these days. We may have our opportunity sooner than we might like. Despite our responsibility for the situation in Iraq, the “Pottery Barn rule”, etc. our European allies probably have more at stake than we do in what’s going on there. Given the issue, Security Council resolutions, and the stakes, this really seems like the right time to start putting together a joint effort for which NATO might serve as a starting point.

Just to reiterate my point of view for the umpteenth time, I don’t think our interests in Iraq warrant much intervention there but any intervention should be an intervention that achieves its objectives. Why put in any effort just for its own sake? Do or not do. There is no try.

3 comments