Who Are These People and Why Are They Saying Such Mean Things About Me?

It takes David Gergen several hundred words to get to the real points of his op-ed:

The people who have written the most searching books about his national security policies — Panetta, Gates, Hillary Clinton, and Vali Nasr — didn’t come into this administration as neophytes searching for the brass ring. Each of them had already won distinction for their years of public service.

Panetta and Gates had purposefully moved far away from Washington and wanted to stay away. They had to be persuaded to serve this time — and they did so mostly out of love of country. (As defense secretary, Panetta frequently flew to California for weekends just so he could be home again.)

Even if their books have had some sharp things to say, they thus deserve a reasoned hearing on the substance — not a flaying by people half their stature and with half their experience. (By the way, have you heard any White House aides thank Panetta lately for serving as the chief mastermind in the search for Osama Bin Laden?)

I think it’s pretty hard to hear the brouhahas over these insider “kiss and tell” books without taking away one of two conclusions. Either Bob Gates and Leon Panetta are writing mean, untrue things about the Obama Administration to sell books or the White House really does make its foreign policy decisions solely based on domestic political calculus. You be the judge.

16 comments

Expectations

One more remark on Aaron Miller’s op-ed. I’m not disappointed by Obama because my expectations weren’t that high.

I am, however, disappointed by Obama’s supporters. I think they’re far too willing to forgive him. We are undertaking one military adventure after the next because they’re afraid to criticize.

I think it’s because they possess the mens rea for racism and I’m disappointed about that.

2 comments

The Take on Obama

Aaron Miller of the Wilson Center’s take on President Obama is interesting and worth reading and I agree with much of it. However, I think I disagree with him on this critical observation:

Finally, on character, Obama has had a Jekyll and Hyde problem. Part pragmatist, part believer, but always capable of seeing all sides of an argument, the president has seemed too often at war with himself on how ambitious he wants to be, whether on climate change, tax reform or the size of the stimulus. And that personal conflict has made it too hard for him to make peace with his public. By nature, Obama is not a partisan, a populist or a revolutionary. Instead, he finds his comfort zone in conciliation and accommodation, and in the empirical world of rational policy analysis. Those can be useful qualities in many circumstances, but they won’t make you a transformative president.

I think there’s very little evidence for that other than resume and anyone who’s had a lot of resumes cross their desks knows that it ain’t necessarily so. On the contrary, I see President Obama as a man of very rigid and not particularly well-informed opinions who believes that his opinions should be heeded uncritically and has a very limited political repertoire and no relish for the ordinary things that politicians and presidents do.

As to Mr. Miller’s comparison with Bill Clinton:

Obama more likely has been closest to Bill Clinton, a comparison that historian David Greenberg took note of a year into his presidency. Both men were elected with similar numbers in the electoral college, though not in the popular vote. Both faced strong opposition from Republicans who imagined the president to be far more radical than he was, and both concentrated on the economy.

I think that is true only with respect to the circumstances in which the two men found themselves and not in actions or character. Clinton was and is a policy wonk. And he genuinely enjoys politics, something for which I see no evidence in President Obama.

1 comment

My Dad

One hundred years ago today, on October 10, 1914, my dad, Fred Joseph Louis Schuler, was born in a bedroom in a flat above a saloon at 14th and Clark in St. Louis, Missouri, a rugged neighborhood. The saloon was owned by his grandfather, Joe Schuler, and run by my grandparents.

Esther, my dad’s mother, my grandmother, was, to put it kindly, eccentric. She adopted every fad or quack idea. She was a disciple of Bernard McFadden, a Rosicrucian, and a Christian Scientist. She dressed my dad in Little Lord Fauntleroy outfits which, as you might imagine, were very popular in the gritty inner city neighborhood where they lived. My dad grew up tough with his fists clenched.

“Saloon” doesn’t really cover the place that my grandparents ran. Joe Schuler was politically connected and the real money in the place was in what would now be called a catering business. They had the contracts to feed the prisoners in the City Jail, the judges and other workers at the City Court, and the workers at the nearby City Hall. My dad had the job of using his little red wagon to transport the tin-covered plates of food from the saloon-restaurant to the jail, courts, even the City Morgue. Another early job was distributing half-pints of whiskey to voters on election day. Those were the days!

When he was 10 or 12 he was the batboy for the St. Louis Browns baseball team. I still have a signed team ball he received.

After an elaborate grade school graduation ceremony (my dad was the first in his family to graduate from grade school, high school, college, or grad school) my dad attended Roosevelt High School, at the time the best high school in the city, with other middle class and upper middle class kids. He graduated from high school at 16 and entered Washington University.

At Wash. U. my dad became editor of the college paper and something of a campus character. He created a bit of a stir with an editorial defending the rights of co-eds to smoke (more or less along the lines of “they have the right to make themselves as disgusting as they care to”). I’ll publish that some time. After becoming a member of Phi Beta Kappa and the president of the men’s academic honorary society he graduated with honors and entered Washington University’s law school, graduating three years later, also with highest honors.

After graduating from law school in 1937, my dad made a bold decision. He decided to take the last of the money he’d inherited from his grandfather and spend a year travelling Europe. He spent the full year 1937-1938 touring Europe and North Africa, filling journal after journal with details of his adventures and sending every scrap he’d written or collected home. I still have everything and I’ll get around to editing and, perhaps, publishing his journals one of these days.

He was in Munich on November 9 and 10, 1938. The bizarre and frightening events of those days (along with the note that he, along with all other Americans in Europe at the time, received from the State Department telling him to get the heck out—which I also have) convinced him it was time to return home.

When he returned the Great Depression of the 1930s was still ongoing and jobs were hard to come by. The first job he got was as editorial writer for the old St. Louis. It didn’t pay much. Shortly thereafter he got a job as an insurance claims adjuster.

After doing that for several years he finally got a job as an associate with one of the most prestigious law firms in St. Louis where he worked for the next five or so years until the firm collapsed in scandal. When it collapsed he was left with some of the clients he’d been working with so he decided to go into practice on his own. That, along with teaching law school at St. Louis University, kept body and soul together for him and his young wife, my mother.

Despite his most diligent efforts my dad did not go to war. He was 4F for his vision. After the war he got a call from the OSS, that which was to become the CIA, to go undercover to Europe but at that point he was married with a family (me) so he demurred.

Lest this post become too long I’ll skip to the end.

My dad excelled at just about everything he turned his hand to. He was a fine athlete, a good ball player, swimmer, and a champion tennis and handball player (he thought gloves were for sissies). He had a nice baritone voice. He was a superb scholar and a good, forward-thinking attorney. At the time of his death he was beginning to give workshops on computer law, decades before computers were to become consumer products. He was also kind, gentle, courageous, and adventurous. I am not half the man he was.

Every so often I run into someone whose life he touched and influenced and that influence is still felt today, all these years after his death at too-young an age. That’s the kind of man he was.

4 comments

What Will Work

Would anyone case to make a small wager on how long it will take those who support drastic changes to our economy to slow or end climate change to recalibrate their models and prescriptions to fit the data?

Just as a reminder I do believe in action. However, I believe in looking for technological remedies. Unless you can figure out how to persuade the Chinese Communist Party to change their ways, that’s what will work.

19 comments

The Limits of Limits

I’m glad that others besides myself in this case David Ignatius are making the point I did about limited war:

Here’s President Obama’s dilemma in a nutshell: He has proposed a strategy for dealing with the Islamic State that is, in the words of Harvard professor Graham Allison, “limited, patient, local and flexible.” This calibrated approach makes sense to Allison, one of America’s most experienced strategists, because it limits U.S. exposure in fighting an adversary that doesn’t immediately threaten America.

The problem is that military history, since the days of the Romans, tells us that limited war is rarely successful. Policymakers, when faced with a choice between going “all in” or doing nothing, usually choose a middle option of partial intervention. But that leads to stalemates and eventual retreats that drive our generals crazy. The warrior ethos says, “If you’re in it, win it.” The politician rounds the edges.

Sadly, I fear he’s more likely to draw the conclusion that, since limited war is rarely successful, we should practice unlimited war rather than limiting our waging of war to cases in which we can’t do cost-benefit analysis.

14 comments

We Haven’t Got Time

In his most recent column Fareed Zakaria draws an incorrect or at least incomplete conclusion from a correct observation. Here’s the observation:

There is a cancer of extremism within Islam today. A small minority of Muslims celebrates violence and intolerance and harbors deeply reactionary attitudes toward women and minorities. While some confront these extremists, not enough do so, and the protests are not loud enough. How many mass rallies have been held against the Islamic State (also known as ISIS) in the Arab world today?

His false conclusion is here:

That is not how Christianity moved from its centuries-long embrace of violence, crusades, inquisitions, witch-burning and intolerance to its modern state. On the contrary, intellectuals and theologians celebrated the elements of the religion that were tolerant, liberal and modern, and emphasized them, while giving devout Christians reasons to take pride in their faith. A similar approach — reform coupled with respect — will work with Islam over time.

It is false for two reasons. The first is that we simply don’t have time for Islam to work through its own internal contradictions. I could list a half dozen reasons why we don’t have the time but I’ll restrict my explanation to one reason: individual empowerment. Today’s technology acts as a force multiplier and potentially gives a single individual or even a small group of individuals the killing power of an army of the 6th, 13th, or 19th centuries AD. As a matter of simple self-defense we can’t allow people with as murderous intent as some Muslims possess to gain control of that sort of technology. Yes, innocents will be caught up in the struggle.

The second reason he’s wrong is that he’s swallowed a fiction made up by 19th century mostly Protestant historians hook, line, and sinker. The Enlightenment, what he’s referring to when he writes of “how Christianity moved from its centuries-long embrace of violence, etc.”, did not grow from the so-called Reformation. Protestantism began as a fundamentalist movement. The Enlightenment on the other hand grew from Italian Humanism which in turn was fostered by the most structured and hierarchical wing of Christianity.

In Islam that structuring principle is completely absent. There is no hierarchy. Anyone who can attract a following is an imam. Anyone who accepts the five pillars of Islam is as good a Muslim as any other.

Is there any reason to believe that something analogous to the Enlightenment can take hold in Islam as it did in Christianity? I don’t see the institutions, structures, and principles that would make that possible. Quite to the contrary I think that remaining decentralized and diverse is inherent in Islam. And as long as that decentralization and diversity exists there will continue to be “Islamic States”.

6 comments

The Century

Today is the centenary of my father’s birth. Had he lived he would have been 100 years old today.

I plan on writing a more extensive tribute to him later today but I didn’t want to let the morning go by without mentioning the occasion.

1 comment

The Game

Pat Lang is wargaming the situation with the “Islamic State”, Syria, Iraq, the U. S., etc. going on now and you might want to follow along or even participate.

The first move, “IS/Coalition War Game – Move 1, The Situation as of 7 October 2014”, is here.

The second move, “IS/Coalition War Game – Move 1b – Forecast of events until 5 November 2014”, is here. It closes tomorrow.

My guess as to what will happen between now and November 5 in the conflict is that we’ll continue bombing, IS will expand its territory a bit but mostly continue to consolidate its present holdings, the Arab states who’ve been participating in the bombing will begin to pull back, having reached the limits of their resources, and the Syrian government will continue to very, very slowly push back the rebels.

2 comments

Limited

Now that Leon Panetta’s book has revealed the inner workings of White House policymaking the demonization has begun but, more importantly, the crack in the dike is widening. Jonathan Alter remarks:

Panetta confirms what has been whispered about for years—that Obama shows “a frustrating reticence to engage his opponents and rally support for his cause.” The president often “relies on the logic of a law professor rather than the passion of a leader,” Panetta writes. In reflecting on the president’s habit of bitching privately about obstructionist Republicans without cleverly confronting them, he notes that Obama “avoids the battle, complains, and misses opportunities.”

Panetta is particularly concerned that Obama didn’t fight harder on the sequestration cuts that Panetta believes were harmful to national defense. But the criticism, now hardening into the conventional wisdom among Democrats, also applies to a variety of other issues, where the president had a habit of leading the Democratic troops into battle with a few speeches but not adopting the single piece of advice Oliver Wendell Holmes gave Franklin D. Roosevelt during his first week in office: “Form your battalion and fight.”

The arsenal of tools available to politicians is large. There’s dealmaking, logrolling, compromise, enlisting allies, cultivating friendships, threatening, shaming, cajoling, and persuasion. Sadly, the only device this president seems to be comfortable in employing is the blunt instrument of politics, power politics. It’s understandable for a politician who honed his craft in Chicago but it’s too limited a repertoire for the national scene, especially when you don’t have the votes for it.

7 comments