Snakes on a Plane

By the way, over the years I have been sneezed on, slobbered on, thrown up on, sweated on, and even bled on by fellow passengers on commercial airline flights. I have never personally had sexual relations with anyone on a commercial airline flight but I know people who have. Explain to me again how safe commercial airline flights are from a communicable disease standpoint.

I still don’t think there’s reason to panic but I do think we should recognize that public announcements are still getting far out in front of the known facts. To the best of my knowledge there aren’t any particularly good studies of disease transmission among the passengers of commercial airlines. One of the complications is that diseases have incubation periods and if you get sick three weeks after flying you might not attribute it to that guy who sneezed on your tray.

10 comments

Protocol

This story at the Daily Mail is surreal. Read it and weep.

It certainly makes you wonder how seriously the isolation protocols are being taken.

3 comments

Pushing Us Into Recession?

In an editorial broadly attacking public health institutions, the editors of the Wall Street Journal declaim:

An Ebola outbreak on the Eastern seaboard or some other densely populated region could well cost billions of dollars to contain and perhaps throw the economy into recession, akin to the 2009 SARS pandemic in China. The possibility is very remote, and Washington is marginally more accountable than Beijing. Then again, the CDC said domestic cases were improbable too.

They’re underestimating, probably by a factor of ten. As I pointed out yesterday spending billions to fight Ebola is already “baked in” to present policy. If that’s enough to push us into recession, recession here we come!

2 comments

The Elephant in the Room

The editors of the Washington Post urge “U. S. leadership” to boost world economic growth:

The list of measures that could boost growth in the short term is longer than you might think. Corporate tax reform, for example, has already been thoroughly discussed in the House and Senate, with relatively little daylight between the two parties. Several Democrats as well as the overwhelming majority of Republicans support the Keystone XL pipeline. Bipartisan coalitions in the Senate have drafted bills to reform housing finance and reauthorize federal highway programs. Postal reform, too, is teed up. All of these would be consistent with the IMF’s call for structural reform and greater infrastructure investment.

U.S. leadership internationally is also necessary to promote growth. Lest global trade stagnate, and economic reform in Japan stall, the Trans-Pacific Partnership trade agreement must be brought to a successful conclusion, aided by congressional approval of fast-track negotiating authority for the president. The Obama administration should keep urging Germany to reduce its trade surplus, which is a major factor inhibiting the growth potential of Europe’s debtor countries. And U.S. engagement can help resolve the crises in Ukraine and the Middle East, which the IMF identifies as aggravating factors in the global slowdown.

The ratio of wishful thinking to practical proposals in that list is very high. If you’re a resident of Illinois, you can hardly escape the reality that the Democrats’ present rhetoric relies almost exclusively on class warfare. It’s understandable. Their incumbents can’t run on records of solid accomplishment or reform. The implication is that Democrats can’t vote for anything that would smack of favoring corporations over the poor working stiff without injuring their own reelection bids.

And notice how conspicuously absent the word “China” is from their list. Although the “Trans-Pacific Partnership” is largely an anti-China measure.

The sad reality is that China, Germany, Japan, and South Korea just to name the largest economies in a very long list all need to consume more and export less if our economy or the world’s is to grow. Is U. S. leadership sufficient to accomplish that?

4 comments

It’s Nice to Dream

Since I was in college I’ve been reading reports of fusion reactors that were just around the corner. That was more years ago than I care to mention. Now just today I’m reading of two projects that should have prototypes working within a few years. First, from Aviation Week:

To understand the breakthroughs of the Lockheed concept, it is useful to know how fusion works and how methods for controlling the reaction have a fundamental impact on both the amount of energy produced and the scale of the reactor. Fusion fuel, made up of hydrogen isotopes deuterium and tritium, starts as a gas injected into an evacuated containment vessel. Energy is added, usually by radio-frequency heating, and the gas breaks into ions and electrons, forming plasma.

The superhot plasma is controlled by strong magnetic fields that prevent it from touching the sides of the vessel and, if the confinement is sufficiently constrained, the ions overcome their mutual repulsion, collide and fuse. The process creates helium-4, freeing neutrons that carry the released energy kinetically through the confining magnetic fields. These neutrons heat the reactor wall which, through conventional heat exchangers, can then be used to drive turbine generators.

Until now, the majority of fusion reactor systems have used a plasma control device called a tokamak, invented in the 1950s by physicists in the Soviet Union. The tokamak uses a magnetic field to hold the plasma in the shape of a torus, or ring, and maintains the reaction by inducing a current inside the plasma itself with a second set of electromagnets. The challenge with this approach is that the resulting energy generated is almost the same as the amount required to maintain the self-sustaining fusion reaction.

An advanced fusion reactor version, the International Thermonuclear Experimental Reactor (ITER), being built in Cadarache, France, is expected to generate 500 MW. However, plasma is not due to be generated until the late 2020s, and derivatives are not likely to be producing significant power until at least the 2040s.

The problem with tokamaks is that “they can only hold so much plasma, and we call that the beta limit,” McGuire says. Measured as the ratio of plasma pressure to the magnetic pressure, the beta limit of the average tokamak is low, or about “5% or so of the confining pressure,” he says. Comparing the torus to a bicycle tire, McGuire adds, “if they put too much in, eventually their confining tire will fail and burst—so to operate safely, they don’t go too close to that.” Aside from this inefficiency, the physics of the tokamak dictate huge dimensions and massive cost. The ITER, for example, will cost an estimated $50 billion and when complete will measure around 100 ft. high and weigh 23,000 tons.

The CFR will avoid these issues by tackling plasma confinement in a radically different way. Instead of constraining the plasma within tubular rings, a series of superconducting coils will generate a new magnetic-field geometry in which the plasma is held within the broader confines of the entire reaction chamber. Superconducting magnets within the coils will generate a magnetic field around the outer border of the chamber. “So for us, instead of a bike tire expanding into air, we have something more like a tube that expands into an ever-stronger wall,” McGuire says. The system is therefore regulated by a self-tuning feedback mechanism, whereby the farther out the plasma goes, the stronger the magnetic field pushes back to contain it. The CFR is expected to have a beta limit ratio of one. “We should be able to go to 100% or beyond,” he adds.

This crucial difference means that for the same size, the CFR generates more power than a tokamak by a factor of 10. This in turn means, for the same power output, the CFR can be 10 times smaller. The change in scale is a game-changer in terms of producibility and cost, explains McGuire. “It’s one of the reasons we think it is feasible for development and future economics,” he says. “Ten times smaller is the key. But on the physics side, it still has to work, and one of the reasons we think our physics will work is that we’ve been able to make an inherently stable configuration.” One of the main reasons for this stability is the positioning of the superconductor coils and shape of the magnetic field lines. “In our case, it is always in balance. So if you have less pressure, the plasma will be smaller and will always sit in this magnetic well,” he notes.

They’re talking about five years to prototype and ten to production.

And then there’s this in EETimes Europe:

Fusion reactors offer the possibility of unlimited green power, being based on the same principles that make the sun shine. Instead of fission reactors that produce massive amounts of radioactive waste that must be stored for thousands of years, fusion reactors produce only a small amount of much less dangerous nuclear waste that only has to be stored for 10 years. Fusion reactors also do not present the danger of a melt down. Sutherland’s and Jarboe’s low-cost fusion reactor design will be presented at the International Atomic Energy Agency’s Fusion Energy Conference in St. Petersburg, Russia on October 17, 2014.

The design, called a spheromak, began as a class project by professor Thomas Jarboe, but had not been proven a viable design until a prototype called the Dynomak was recently built by Jarboe and doctoral candidate Derek Sutherland, who had previously worked on reactor designs at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT).

The standard approach to fusion reactors today, exemplified by the joint Chinese, European Union, India, Japan, Korea, Russia, and US collaboration called the International Thermonuclear Experimental Reactor (ITER) in Saint-Paul-lès-Durance, France, is akin to using brute force compared to the more elegant Dynomak design invented at University of Washington.

“We eliminated the need for the expensive superconducting toroidal field coil set like the ITER in France requires, enabling us to make a much more compact reactor system that reduces the cost by a factor of 10 while increasing the output by a factor of five,” Sutherland told EE Times. “The spheromak design generates twisted magnetic fields which drive a current in the plasma — which is a really good conductor
— thereby confining and stabilizing the super-hot plasma in the reactor. A voltage transferred using induction generates these magnetic fields to achieve confinement and stability.”

There’s no estimate on how long it will take to build the next generation prototype or a production model.

I wouldn’t advise selling your stock in Peabody just yet. We’ve had reports like this for decades. But it’s certainly intriguing.

Imagine a fusion power generation plant cheaper to build than a coal-fired plant, which produces no greenhouse gases, and which doesn’t pose a radiation (or security) hazard. I think we’d probably learn pretty quickly whether environmentalists were interested in the environment or just opposed to technology.

9 comments

Are We There Yet?

At the Wall Street Journal which has been rattling a saber for war in the Middle East for some time, Mark Gunzinger and John Stillion suggest that by comparison with recent air campaigns we really aren’t doing much in our war against the Islamic State:

While it is still too early to proclaim the air campaign against Islamic State a failure, it may be instructive to compare it with other campaigns conducted by the U.S. military since the end of the Cold War that were deemed successes. For instance, during the 43-day Desert Storm air campaign against Saddam Hussein’s forces in 1991, coalition fighters and bombers flew 48,224 strike sorties. This translates to roughly 1,100 sorties a day. Twelve years later, the 31-day air campaign that helped free Iraq from Saddam’s government averaged more than 800 offensive sorties a day.

By contrast, over the past two months U.S. aircraft and a small number of partner forces have conducted 412 total strikes in Iraq and Syria—an average of seven strikes a day. With Islamic State in control of an area approaching 50,000 square miles, it is easy to see why this level of effort has not had much impact on its operations.

Of course, air operations during Desert Storm and Iraqi Freedom were each supported by a massive coalition force on the ground. Thus it may be more appropriate to compare current operations against Islamic State with the 78-day air campaign against Serbian forces and their proxies in 1999, or the 75-day air campaign in Afghanistan that was instrumental in forcing the Taliban out of power in 2001.

Both campaigns relied heavily on partner forces on the ground augmented by a small but significant number of U.S. troops. These air campaigns averaged 138 and 86 strike sorties a day respectively—orders of magnitude greater than the current tempo of operations against Islamic State.

Perhaps the small number of strikes in the air campaign against Islamic State is due to the lack of suitable ground targets. Yet representatives from the Pentagon have characterized forces fighting under Islamic State’s black banner as more of a conventional army than a highly dispersed, irregular force similar to today’s Taliban. Moreover, Islamic State fighters are using captured armored vehicles, artillery, mortars and other implements of modern land warfare to seize and hold terrain. These operations require a considerable amount of movement and resupply that can be detected by airborne surveillance.

This is not a second generation war. We cannot measure our progress on a path to victory by counting sorties or even by tallying how much enemy matériel or how many enemy production facilities we’ve destroyed. They don’t have production facilities, they have plenty of cash with more coming in every day, and they can buy all of the matériel they need.

How would we measure such progress? I’ve already provided one gauge: when more young Muslims are volunteering to fight IS than are volunteering to fight along side it. By that measure victory is very distant indeed.

What other yardsticks could we use? I would suggest:

  • When IS starts losing ground.
  • When Turkey allows us to use Incirlik Air Base.
  • When Turkey starts bombing IS rather than Kurds who are attempting to relieve the town of Kobane.
  • When the Iraqi army stands and fights rather than being routed at every encounter.
  • When IS withdraws from the Baghdad suburbs rather than pushing into them.
  • When there are fewer terrorist incidents in Baghdad.

At this point none of those measures is particularly encouraging. I honestly don’t know what the Obama Administration is talking about when they say that the campaign is going well unless they’re counting inputs rather than outputs, something I would have hoped we would have learned was futile in Viet Nam.

Contrarywise, we might consider actions we could use to determine that IS was winning. The most obvious is if they take Baghdad.

Any other suggestions for how we can tell whether IS is winning or losing?

6 comments

Outbreak

A second Texas healthcare worker who treated Thomas Eric Duncan, the man who died of Ebola last week in Dallas, has contracted the disease:

DALLAS — A second hospital worker who helped care for Ebola patient Thomas Duncan has tested positive for the disease, prompting local officials to warn Wednesday that more cases are “a real possibility.”

The unidentified health care worker, who was described as a woman who lived alone without pets, reported a fever Tuesday and was immediately isolated at Texas Health Presbyterian Hospital in Dallas.

At an early morning news conference, Dallas County Judge Clay Jenkins said he could not rule out more cases among 75 other hospital staffers who cared for Duncan and were being monitored by the CDC.

“We are preparing contingencies for more and that is a real possibility,” Jenkins said.

As I pointed out yesterday by the definition of disease outbreak used by both the World Health Organization and the Centers for Disease Control, this constitutes an outbreak of the disease here in the United States. If you disagree with that assertion, you’re not disagreeing with me. You’re disagreeing with the CDC and WHO and in order to prove your case you need to do two things. First, you must produce a recognized definition of disease outbreak that does not cover the situation in Dallas and, second, you must demonstrate that it does not cover the situation in Dallas and you must do so without resorting to sophistry.

I continue to believe there is no cause for panic but there’s plenty of cause for greater prudence and honesty.

Let’s do a little back-of-the-envelope calculation. There are about 5,000 hospitals in the U. S. If we train five people from each hospital in the correct protocols and procedures for treating Ebola, by my (again back-of-the-envelope) estimate it will cost $10,000 per person to train and equip them. Preparing the hospitals to isolate and treat the disease will probably cost (given the costs in healthcare) another $50,000 per hospital. That’s (5,000 X 5 X 10,000) + (5,000 X 50,000) or $500 million dollars. Let’s say a round billion. Remember, we still haven’t treated anybody yet.

I’ve seen widely varying estimates of daily ICU costs, anything from $1,000 a day to $20,000 a day. $1,000 a day is obviously not credible—the average doc earns more than that. Arguendo, let’s use the $10,000 a day figure and let’s use ICU costs as a gauge for treating an Ebola patient. The accounts I’ve read suggest that treating an Ebola patient takes from 2 to 4 weeks. Let’s use 30 days as a good, round number. 30 X 10000 = $300,000. That means that treating the two patients we already have will cost more than a half million. As you can see, the costs mount rapidly with more cases.

My point here is that because of the outrageously high cost of healthcare in the United States we have powerful incentives to avoid treating Ebola patients here and should be willing to go to substantial lengths to avoid it and hold the outbreak to its epicenter in West Africa. I don’t think that means we need to ban all travel to and from West Africa but it does mean we need to do more than wishful thinking and jollying people along.

22 comments

The Accounting

Jamsheed and Carol Choksy say that the financiers and supporters of the Islamic State should be “held accountable” for their actions:

Only the Muslim nations that ignited jihadism can now defuse it, working with moderate Iraqis and Syrians who are directly affected by it. There’s no need to defer to the feigned fury of the governments Biden rightly criticized. They are abettors, so let’s instead thrust them to the forefront of the confrontation against Islamic extremism.

These are bold words. Since the most active “abettors” of the Islamic State, e.g. Turkey, Saudi Arabia, Qatar, and the UAE, are also at least notionally our staunchest Muslim allies in the region, I wonder about the mechanics of how they might be held to account.

Also, how do you account for the deaths of thousands of innocents? What is the appropriate penalty?

I don’t believe that the atrocities of the Islamic State are inherent to Islam any more than Torquemada was inherent to Christianity. I do believe that these outbreaks of barbaric cruelty perpetrated by Muslims in the name of their religion will continue until more young Muslims volunteer to fight the Islamic State than volunteer to join it. That’s the real challenge for Muslims and where the real accounting should be.

8 comments

One Case

I see that Dr. Thomas Frieden, director of the Centers for Disease Control is walking back his cocksure remarks of Sunday:

DALLAS — As a 26-year-old Dallas nurse lay infected in the same hospital where she treated a dying Ebola patient last week, government officials on Monday said the first transmission of the disease in the United States had revealed systemic failures in preparation that must “substantially” change in coming days.

“We have to rethink the way we address Ebola infection control, because even a single infection is unacceptable,” Thomas Frieden, director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, said in a news conference.

Frieden did not detail precisely how the extensive, government-issued safety protocols in place at many facilities might need to change or in what ways hospitals need to ramp up training for front-line doctors or nurses.

At least that’s hewing closer to the known facts. I continue to wonder how he plans to implement a protocol that’s 100% effective, especially considering that we already have at least 100,000 deaths per year in the United States as a consequence of infections picked up in hospitals. The reports of casual violations of ordinary sanitation precautions in hospitals are legion.

The World Health Organization’s definition of a disease outbreak is “the occurrence of cases of disease in excess of what would normally be expected in a defined community, geographical area or season.” Despite what I suspect will be strenuous efforts to deny it single case in Dallas constitutes an outbreak of Ebola here in the United States and I strongly suspect that investigation will determine that it was preventable by something less than heroic measures.

As every twelve step program emphasizes the first step on the way to recovery is recognizing you have a problem.

22 comments

The Non-Apology

You might want to take a look at Cliff Asness’s non-apology for warning about the risks in the Fed’s policy of quantitative easing:

When you go out of your way to warn of a risk and after a suitable period that risk has not come to bear, at least where everyone, including you, expected it, you should admit some error, and I do. But there is a still a big difference between pointing out a risk and making a forecast (hence the half admission!). A big reason this risk hasn’t come to fruition is, while not as dangerous so far as we thought, it appears QE was only mostly useless. To the extent even that is only mostly true, where effects did show up, it actually caused rather a lot of inflation, but inflation that went straight into the pockets of those who needed it least and whom Paul wouldn’t swerve his car to avoid. That is, it inflated financial assets, benefited the rich, and enhanced inequality.

It’s worth reading if only for Mr. Asness’s citation of “an honest Paul Krugman” as an example of a counter-factual.

If you haven’t noticed, I’m a Keynesian in the sense that I believe that Keynes’s prescription was right in theory. However, as fellow St. Louisan Yogi Berra wisely noted in theory there is no difference between practice and theory but in practice there is. The reality is that politicians will never allow a Keynesian response fast enough or efficient enough to accomplish the putative policy goals. Somehow money will always be diverted to allies, contributors, and pet projects regardless of the economic implications.

I also feel that I should point out one of the gravest defects of the policy of quantitative easing: it tended to crowd out other policy responses. Sixty-four months have passed since the beginning of the recovery and it’s still phlegmatic and inadequate to bring people back to work who’ve been out-of-work for now more than five years. That’s nothing to crow about.

4 comments