Tribune Endorses Durbin

The editors of the Chicago Tribune explain how they had to struggle with their consciences to endorse the re-election of Dick Durbin to the Senate:

We often disagree with Durbin on issues. But we would rather have Illinois represented by a highly capable partisan than by a less capable partisan.

My misgivings about Durbin extend farther than those of the Trib editors. I don’t think that he’s been a particularly effective senator for Illinois. Even when they’ve risen to leadership roles in the Senate, senators aren’t elected to represent the whole country. They’re elected to represent their states and I do not see that Illinois has prospered through Sen. Durbin’s tenure or Senate leadership. Just look around you at the statistics. We lead the country in lost jobs, lost companies, and net outmigration. Although Illinois didn’t share in the huge run-up in home prices seen in California or Nevada, we haven’t shared in the housing price recovery, either.

In the final analysis a candidate for the Senate does not need to be the best of all possible candidates. Merely better than his or her opponent. This epitomizes the problem with the Republican Party ion Illinois:

In their primary, Republicans did have a promising candidate, political newcomer Doug Truax: West Point grad, former Army Ranger, owner of an Oak Brook firm helping employers address the costs of health care and retirement benefits. He had smart ideas for rescuing entitlement programs and reforming the tax code.

Republicans instead nominated Jim Oberweis, a business executive who in 2012 won an Illinois Senate seat after five unsuccessful runs for higher offices.

During that candidate debate with Durbin, Oberweis was every bit as partisan, but more evasive and not as prepared to delve into difficult issues such as immigration and federal finances. Oberweis’ campaign rests on stock GOP themes — less government, lower taxation — and that’s fine. But we have no faith he’d be a change agent in the Senate. When he finally got elected to something — the state Senate — he could have served a term and built a record. Instead, he quickly jumped into the next campaign, for the U.S. Senate.

They have an unerring instinct for snatching defeat from the jaws of victory. In a year in which events are breaking in favor of the Republicans they fail to nominate a decent candidate. I am thoroughly unimpressed with Jim Oberweis. Love his milk but hate his politics.

2 comments

Thinking About Ebola

At this stage in what may be a series of events of worldwide importance, I think it’s appropriate to consider a few alternative scenarios dispassionately. Before I begin it might be helpful to define a few terms: epidemic, endemic, and pandemic. If you know Greek, their meanings are obvious but classical educations have become rare.

We characterize a disease as “epidemic”, literally “among the people”, when there is a outbreak of an infectious disease in a large number of people over a short period of time. A disease is “endemic”, literally “in the people”, when it is maintained within a population at a more or less stable rate permanently. For example, chickenpox is endemic in the United States. A disease is said to be “pandemic”, literally “all of the people”, when there is global outbreak of a disease affecting a significant number of people.

Here are some scenarios I think are worth thinking about:

  • Worldwide Ebola pandemic
  • Ebola becomes endemic outside Africa
  • Ebola becomes endemic in sub-Saharan Africa
  • Ebola becomes endemic in West Africa
  • Ebola epidemic outside West Africa
  • Ebola epidemic in West Africa
  • Ebola outbreak outside West Africa

There are other possibilities that could be considered but that list hits the high spots. Now let’s put a little flesh on these scenarios and do a bit of speculating about their likelihoods.

Worldwide Ebola pandemic

I think this is extremely unlikely. I have no way of calculating the costs of this taking place but they would be vast. Half of the world’s population would die.

Ebola becomes endemic outside Africa

I think this is unlikely.

Ebola becomes endemic in sub-Saharan Africa

I think this is somewhat unlikely. If it takes place it will be a consequence of inaction in stemming the epidemic in West Africa, the weak economies and institutions in sub-Saharan Africa, and indifference on the part of the developed world. The costs of this scenario both in human and economic terms would be large.

Ebola becomes endemic in West Africa

This is a substantial and significant fear and the longer the epidemic in West Africa continues the more likely it becoming endemic will become. I think this is slightly likely.

Ebola epidemic outside West Africa

I think this is somewhat unlikely. If it does take place, it will be a consequence of allowing the epidemic in West Africa to continue and is most likely to take place in countries with weak economies and institutions.

Ebola epidemic in West Africa

Since there is already an ongoing epidemic in Guinea, Liberia, and Sierra Leone, this is now a certainty.

Ebola outbreak outside West Africa

Sadly, since there are has already been a small outbreak in the United States, this, too, is now a certainty. It should debunk the notion that an outbreak in the United States is impossible but interested parties are already trying to spin the truth away, a practice that I think increases the likelihood of future outbreaks rather than reducing their likelihood. IMO the outbreak was caused by reckless behavior on the part of professionals. We can only hope that the professionals will be chastened by the experience but I see no signs of that yet.

Note that these scenarios operate along several different planes, i.e. geographic extent, duration, number of cases, and cost. Also note that as the last-mentioned scenarios increase in likelihood the scenarios mentioned earlier become more likely, too. So, for example, if Ebola becomes endemic in West Africa, it will become harder (and more expensive) to prevent it from becoming endemic in sub-Saharan Africa more generally.

That’s why I think that we need to undertake a somewhat more muscular effort in Guinea, Liberia, and Sierra Leone that we presently have. As of this writing we have fewer than 1,000 troops there and they are insufficiently trained to deal with Ebola cases themselves.

They are better prepared to build hospitals but hospitals won’t staff and equip themselves. Not only the United States but France, the United Kingdom, Germany, and China should be making significant commitments of money, materiel, and people in West Africa.

The United States Navy has two hospital ships capable of treating 1,000 patients each and eight Wasp class amphibious assault vehicles capable of treating 600 patients each. These are, in effect, large mobile modern hospitals, fully staffed and equipt. Should some of these existing resources be deployed there? That’s a question. I’m not in the Navy and I don’t know the complications or issues involved.

3 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The link at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments

Images of the Past

Have you ever wondered about how a French aristocrat lived 70 years ago? Voici!

The auctioneer who walked into that was one lucky chap.

0 comments

There Are Other Choices Than Black or White

While I’m on the subject, can someone please explain to me why the only alternatives being presented are complete freedom of movement from West African countries and completely banning all travel between the United States and West African countries? I mean other than it’s a lot easier to beat a straw man than have a fully-fleshed legitimate discussion?

If we’re going to take the position as we appear to be now that the way to deal with Ebola within the United States is by flying a squad of experts into wherever a case springs up and then airlifting the patient to one of the handful of places in the country equipt to deal with it, doesn’t putting some effort into managing the number of cases likely to travel to this country from West Africa sound prudent? Not completely eliminate, reduce to zero, etc. but control?

11 comments

The Puzzle

If there’s one thing that baffles me about the present discourse on Ebola, it’s the effort to paint it as a partisan issue. Democrats are complaining that Republicans are turning Ebola into a partisan political issue even as they mendaciously claim that were it not for Republicans we’d be in a much better position for dealing with it.

In that light I’d appreciate an explanation of President Obama’s appointment of Democratic Party apparatchik Ron Klain as matrix manager for Ebola. I think that the complaints of some, including the editors of the Wall Street Journal, that he doesn’t have medical expertise is completely nonsensical. However, I think complaints that he’s neither a general nor even a manager are legitimate.

To the best of my ability to determine Mr. Klain is a lawyer and Democratic party apparatchik full stop. Should we interpret that as the president’s believing that the problems posed by Ebola are purely political?

Update

Ron Fournier’s take bolsters mine:

The choice makes sense if Obama’s main concern is a) the incompetence of his team, or; b) midterm politics. My strong hunch is it’s “b”. The Obama White House is not self-aware. It is nakedly political. The uneven response to Ebola threatens to be a toxic issue for Democrats, and the president is under pressure from his party’s desperate candidates to do something.

The problem with the White House strategy in my view is that the situation is not purely political, especially now that we’re talking about having 4,000 soldiers in the Ebola “hot zone”.

10 comments

Matrix Management

Matrix management is an organizational structure in which many of the workers have more than one direct manager. For example, if all engineers report to a director of engineering but also report to a project manager who does not report to the director of engineering, it’s an example of matrix management. If all accountants within an organization report to a director of finance but also report to, for example, a line manager it’s another example of matrix management.

It’s an idea that appears to have begun in the Pentagon during World War II but reached its full bloom at NASA in the 1960s and became a sort of fad among large corporations in the 60s and 70s. It’s largely fallen out of fashion now except in government.

The general problem with matrix management is managers. They can’t wrap their heads around the concept. Good management is scarce and precious. I have never seen an example of effective matrix management. Has anyone ever experienced effective matrix management? Give an example, outside of NASA or the Pentagon, of effective matrix management?

1 comment

The Sweeney

By the way how practical does the president’s plan for Ebola sweeneys (Cockney rhyming slang: “flying squad” = “Sweeney Todd”, shortened to sweeney) to deal with the cases that will occur here in the United States sound to you? To me it sounds as though he’s been advised of the time and expense of training doctors and nurses all over the country (which will run well into the billions) and tried to come up with a better, cheaper plan that could be put in place quickly. How much better would these sweeneys be?

How many of them would there be? How long would it take to train a team? If there aren’t many of these teams, what do you do when a member of one of the teams contracts Ebola? It seems to me that the plan can only work if the number of cases of Ebola in the U. S. is kept very small which in turn implies that you’re taking steps to limit the number of cases.

19 comments

Who’s Panicking?

I agree with just about every word of Eugene Robinson’s column about the need for candor from medical officials, especially the conclusion:

The thing is, Americans are anxious about Ebola but not panicked. This will change, however, unless experts speak more honestly about the nature of the threat.

That should include being frank about the limits of what they know. To my eye the greatest signs of panic are those coming from those medical officials who are so frantic to show that it’s not their fault. Or maybe it’s guilt—as though they’ve been caught with their hands in the cookie jar.

17 comments

Slouching Towards a Correction

In stock market parlance a “correction” is a decrease in the price of a stock or group of stocks of 10% or more. This week the Dow has been flirting with a correction so I think it might be a good time to consider Steve Forbes’s “five basic reasons stocks are falling”. They are

  • The U.S. Senate
  • Misbehavior by the Fed
  • The profit picture is getting blurry
  • World economies are a mess
  • The world security situation is worsening

I think an even more basic basic reason is that by what used to be the historic standards the relationship between stock prices and earning is incredibly out of whack. For 120 years the P/E ratio was around 15. Now it’s half again that.

Why? You can come up with any number of explanations but the implication of the (by historical standards) detachment of stock prices from the performance of the companies means that prices are unquestionably being buoyed by something else. If it’s “animal spirits”, I’d find an explanation of why the spirits of the stock market and those of entrepeneurs are so very far apart extremely interesting.

7 comments