Newt Gingrich has an op-ed in the Wall Street Journal in which he proposes that Congress should conduct a series of hearings. Here they are:
1. The current strength and growth rate of radical Islamists around the world. We need a detailed sense of the total picture. The scale of the threat from this nihilistic global movement, I suspect, will be stunning.
2. The country-by-country danger. Americans simply don’t realize how dire the situation is in specific areas. Boko Haram has killed thousands more people in Nigeria alone than Ebola has in all of Africa, according to data compiled by the Council on Foreign Relations and the Centers for Disease Control. One or more hearings should focus on each center of radical Islamism, including Somalia, Yemen, Syria, Afghanistan and Pakistan.
3. The role of the Muslim Brotherhood. The group is vital to the global radical Islamist movement, yet so little understood by Washington elites that it deserves its own set of hearings.
4. The primary sources of radical Islamist funding, especially Saudi Arabia, Qatar and Iran.
5. The Arab countries—including Egypt, Jordan, Morocco, Tunisia and Algeria—that have successfully contained and minimized radical Islamists. We must learn how this was accomplished and what aspects should be replicated.
6. Radicalization in mosques and on social media. How are young Muslims being drawn into terrorism? What can be done to counter a seductive message that has reached deep into Europe and the U.S. and inspired jihadists by the thousands to travel to the Middle East for terrorist training that can be exported back home?
7. The Islamist cyberthreat. The hacking of the U.S. Central Command’s social-media accounts this week apparently didn’t inflict serious damage, but the episode was evidence of a new front in the fight against terrorism.
and then conduct another hearing to review alternatives for “achieving victory”. He might think about a hearing to define victory first.
My objection to this process is the problem that has dogged our campaign against terrorism for the last fourteen years and can be summed up in two words: what then? You end the Taliban government in Afghanistan. What then? You bring down Saddam Hussein. What then? You bring down Moammar Qaddafi. What then? We removed the Taliban, Saddam Hussein, and Moammar Qaddafi. If anything there is more violent radical Islamist terrorism than there was fourteen years ago. The tactical moves we’ve engaged in have not resulted in strategic victory and I see little evidence that more of the same will have better results.
You kill one or one hundred or one thousand or one million violent radical Islamist terrorists. And that’s assuming you can distinguish among violent radical Islamist terrorists, non-violent radical Islamists, and garden variety Islamists (which probably includes a very high proportion of Muslims). What then?







