But perhaps the biggest difference between the two candidates — and the greatest current divide in the Democratic Party — is on economic matters. Emanuel has focused on bread-and-butter issues familiar to any successful mayor: cutting red tape and costs for small businesses, promoting tourism, attracting well-paying jobs. Garcia has cast his campaign in populist terms. His supporters call Emanuel, who used to work in investment banking, “Mayor 1%” and have embarked on a nationwide effort to defeat him.
Over the next six weeks, Chicago’s voters can show the nation — and the national party — that fiscally responsible government remains a priority for Democrats. That’s why this mayoral campaign has consequences not just for Chicago, but for the presidential race and debate over the next year and a half.
but I think they’re exaggerating the actual differences between the two candidates. In the final analysis they support the same things. At the end of the day Emanuel caved to the Chicago Teachers Union after alienating the people of Chicago, the CTU, and its president, Karen Lewis, in particular. To no good purpose. Mayor Emanuel didn’t even mention the billion dollar pension fund payment the city’s supposed to pay this year in his annual message. The deals that the mayor has cut with big businesses to come to Chicago have reduced tax money available to the city for years to come and hasn’t resulted in employment growth. Chicago’s job growth rate is .85%. That’s not enough to put people back to work. That’s not enough to bring people and money to Chicago and, importantly, the deals will inevitably have a cost to small businesses and individuals.
On Tuesday the majority of Chicago voters cast their ballots for “Anybody But Emanuel”. That wasn’t a battle for anything. It was a plebiscite over whether the incumbent is an obnoxious twit or not. The people have spoken.
One of the many amusing things my former business partner said that has stuck with me (in a reverse of the charaterization of Voltaire) was “I agree with what you say but I deny your right to say it.” I see that Secretary of State John Kerry’s remarks of the other day caused James Taranto’s hackles to rise as well as mine:
The Democratic news site TalkingPointsMemo reports on a hearing yesterday before the House Foreign Affairs Committee, where Kerry was “asked to address Netanyahu’s criticism of a hypothetical deal with Iran as a threat to Israel.†In response, he “slammed†Netanyahu—the verb is TPM’s—by calling his misgivings about an Iran deal “as wrongheaded as the prime minister’s backing of the Iraq War.â€
Is there anyone who has less right to criticize anyone on the basis of being wrong-headed about backing the Iraq War than John Kerry? Dick Cheney, maybe. All that would have been necessary to avoid the error of the Iraq War would have been for John Kerry, Hillary Clinton, and the other Democratic senators to oppose the AUMF or even filibuster it.
Every single sitting Democratic senator with presidential aspirations voted in favor of the Iraq War. They didn’t vote for the AUMF because they were mislead or lied to. They had the same intelligence information as the president, the same information as other foreign intelligence services, and they drew the same conclusions. It was the way the wind was blowing. When the wind shifted, so did their political views. They don’t have political convictions; they have postures.
Yesterday I heard and read a lot of commentary about net neutrality almost all of which was specious and had only a tangential relationship to the truth. What the ISPs want to do is something that hasn’t even been contemplated by the power company or the telephone company. I’ll trying making a correct analogy.
Imagine that your power company went to Frigidaire and GE and demanded that, unless they paid your power company a fee, they’d produce brownouts and intermittent power outages in every home that had a Frigidaire or GE refrigerator. Frigidaire and GE cough up and raise the prices of their refrigerators. BTW, this is one of the reasons we shouldn’t want the Internet of Things.
What I want is for consumers to get what they’ve contracted for and what they’re paying for. The ISPs shouldn’t be able to demand protection money from the Googles, Facebooks, and Netflixes of the world. What’s next, Vinnie the Leg Breaker? Cable companies and telephone companies merely getting into the ISP or content businesses are classic examples of the abuse of monopoly power. The Justice Department should be breaking up Comcast and Time-Warner.
I continue to be gobsmacked that alleged libertarians have allied with the ISPs, of which of the majors every single one has achieved its position through monopoly power, and against the upstarts. Every single business model argument I’ve ever heard can equally be made against GE and GM and I haven’t heard the same complaints about them.
That isn’t libertarianism. It isn’t even anarcho-capitalism. It’s corporatism and support of government monopolies. Everything is turning into its opposite.
If Obama has indeed decided that a strong Egypt is essential, he shouldn’t try to play both sides of the street. The Egyptian people, traumatized by four years of revolution and counterrevolution, need to know that the United States is truly an ally. Criticisms of human rights abuses should continue, but Washington should make clear that they come from a friendly nation that wants Egypt to succeed.
Contrary to what some of his supporters believe, I don’t think that President Obama is a foreign policy realist even though he plays one on TV. I think he’s a liberal interventionist who sometimes veers into being a transnational progressive. Throwing Mubarak under the bus was not the act of a realist. Our attitude towards Assad in Syria is not realpolitik. Neither is what we’ve been saying and doing with respect to Ukraine.
Realism does not mean basing your foreign policy moves on what will shore up your domestic political base. Sometimes it means doing things your supporters will hate because you must to further national interests and cleaning up the political fallout later.
Because the ideas at stake are potentially seductive only to Muslims, the ideological war today is really a struggle within Islam. It’s a cultural war that has to be waged by Muslims. If outsiders such as the United States want to play a role, they should listen to and support Muslims fighting the good fight. One such person is the king of Jordan, Abdullah II, whom I interviewed this week in Amman.
If you don’t believe me or Mr. Zakaria, perhaps Abdullah may convince you:
“It’s not a Western fight,†the king said to me. “This is a fight inside of Islam where everybody comes together against these outlaws.†He wants international support and involvement, of course, but is wary of Western troops. Jordan is on the front line of this battle, but other countries, from Iraq to Egypt, are finally joining in, and not just on the battlefield. This week, the head of Cairo’s Al-Azhar University, Sunni Islam’s most prestigious academy, denounced “extremist violent groups†that have “corrupt interpretations†of Islam.
The administration’s moves have been almost the diametric opposite of the correct ones. Instead of putting U. S. troops in harm’s way and conducting only marginally effective bombing runs while doing its best to convince American Muslims that they’re simply innocent bystanders to the conflict they should be treading a much more delicate, narrower line by letting the Muslim countries of the Middle East take point in the fight and encouraging Muslims all over the world including the United States to recognize that DAESH threatens everything they have and everything they want.
That’s a very difficult job and I’m glad I don’t have it.
There’s an intriguing post at RealClearWorld about the interrelationships of the Eurozone crisis, the Ukrainian crisis, and concerns about Iran’s getting nuclear weapons. Here’s the peroration:
Germany needs a deal with Russia to be able to manage an existential crisis for the eurozone; Russia needs a deal with the United States to limit U.S. encroachment on its sphere of influence; and the United States needs a deal with Iran to refocus its attention on Russia. No conflict is divorced from the other, though each may be of a different scale. Germany and Russia can find ways to settle their differences, as can Iran and the United States. But a prolonged eurozone crisis cannot be avoided, nor can a deep Russian mistrust of U.S. intentions for its periphery.
The author appears to believe that the common thread uniting the three “crises” is Russia. I think he’s missing the forest for the trees. For once the problem is not the United States. The connecting thread is Germany.
The opinion pages (physical and virtual) today are full of stories about governors, particularly Republican governors. One of the basic themes is the challenges posed in paying for present and past public employees.
In the past I’ve written here in support of the general principle of governors as potential presidential candidates. I’m ready to believe that the most pressing problem in many states is paying for past and present public employees. It’s certainly the case in the city of Chicago and the state of Illinois. It’s one of the (many) issues I have with Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel. Not only did he approve a whopping raise for Chicago teachers, already very well compensated and compensated beyond the city’s ability to pay, he has assiduously ignored the city’s single most pressing fiscal problem, the big balloon payment into the city’s public employee pension fund, hanging like a sword of Damocles over the city’s figurative head.
I don’t think the federal government’s most pressing problems are being caused by public employees or their unions. I think they’re caused by decades of bad fiscal, financial, trade, healthcare, economic, monetary, immigration, security, defense, and other policies. No one has had the guts even to start turning the ship around and its running aground.
Weeks after abandoning his proposed tax increase on college savings, President Obama is back with a plan to raise the cost of investing. On Monday the White House dusted off its proposal to limit retirement options that was hooted down in 2011 by a bipartisan coalition in Congress.
The White House says that many stock brokers are recommending products that generate fat commissions for themselves, rather than products that best serve their customers. It claims workers are particularly vulnerable to this “conflicted advice†when they roll over their 401(k) workplace savings into Individual Retirement Accounts.
Brokers are already heavily regulated by the Securities and Exchange Commission, which imposes myriad rules to prevent fraud, ensure that fees are disclosed and protect clients from “unsuitable†investments. But the President wants to require investors to use advisers who are even more heavily regulated. Specifically, he wants retirement savers seeking advice to use fiduciaries, who are legally bound to act in the client’s best interest.
That’s the most direct effect of taxation: it reduces private sector economic activity. Taxation and interest rates are the two main levers that the federal government and Federal Reserve, respectively, have to regulate private sector economic growth.
It seems to be “stick our noses into Illinois politics” day among the national punditry. George Will remarks on Illinois’s problems Gov. Rauner must address:
Rauner, 58, won his first elective office by promising to change Illinois’s political culture of one-party rule by entrenched politicians subservient to public-sector unions. This culture’s consequences include:
After more than a dozen credit-rating downgrades in five years, Illinois has the lowest rating among the states. Unfunded public employees’ pension liabilities are estimated, perhaps conservatively, at $111 billion, the nation’s largest such deficit as a percentage of state revenue. Currently, public pensions consume nearly 25 percent of general state revenues. The state owes vendors $6.4 billion in unpaid bills, and more than 1 million people have left Illinois for less dysfunctional states in the last 15 years. Debt per resident is about $24,989, compared with $7,094 in neighboring Indiana.
Left unmentioned in the column is that the fourteen years of Republican governors that preceded twelve years of Democratic governors weren’t distinguished by excellence in governing, either, and the previous Republican governor is presently serving a term in jail for corruption in office.
Rauner faces major obstacles in getting anything material accomplished. Democrats hold supermajorities in both houses of the Illinois legislature so it will largely be up to them. The best case scenario would seem to be to let the Republican governor take the heat for doing unpopular things that will need to be done if Illinois is not to founder.
At this point just leaving office without going to jail would be something of an accomplishment.