The Devil in the Details

I’ve told you the story of the mathematician, the lawyer, and the accountant before so you know how aware I am that given the impulse you can jigger the numbers to achieve any result you want. That’s the basic point of Alan Reynolds’s Wall Street Journal op-ed and it’s a reasonable one. However, in getting there he instantiates the very thing he’s complaining about.

I agree with him that the White House’s insistence that the average of the incomes of the lower 90% of income earners is a fair proxy for median income is a maddening one. It might be simpler just to say that normal distribution of income stops with the top 10% of income earners. I also think his determination that, if you use the same methodology as the White House does to find that median income is about the same now as it was 35 years ago, it was also the same 47 years ago is an interesting one. It certainly supports the point I’ve made here that our problems are not a result of differences of opinion between Republicans and Democrats so much as a remarkable agreement between Republicans and Democrats, both of which have followed the same lousy policies for the last half century.

However, I find the errors and elisions in his op-ed just as maddening. For example, he writes:

Are all those shopping malls, big box stores, car dealers and restaurants catering to only the top 10%? The question answers itself.

I have two problems with the remark. First, he’s ignoring the tremendous changes in real consumer prices over the last half century. Your phone bill is a fraction of what it would have been then and that’s changed your behavior. Your doctor’s bill is a lot higher.

Second, there are a lot fewer car dealers than there were a half century ago. For reasons not entirely clear to me the auto manufacturers have decided they’re better off with fewer customers rather than more (you aren’t the customer for auto manufacturers—auto dealers are). That means there are just about half as many much wealthier auto dealers serving twice as many customers as there were in 1970, a common pattern throughout the economy.

Here’s the story I would tell about the changes in the economy over the last half century. We’re importing a lot more of what we consume than we did 50 years ago. That plus government subsidies paid to people in the top 10% of income earners have resulted in a lot more money relative to the rest of us for the top income earners. We’ve also imported a lot of low skill and unskilled workers which has pushed the wages of the lowest and, increasingly, middle income workers down relative to what they might have been otherwise.

That has been offset to some degree by a drop in the prices of consumer goods, especially electronics. Your television today is bigger, better, and a lot cheaper than your television would have been in 1970.

Finally, a lot of income has been taken in the form of non-wage compensation and most of that has been in the form of healthcare insurance.

That’s the story of the last fifty years as I see it. I think it sticks to the observed facts better than either the White House’s version or Mr. Reynolds’s.

15 comments

Adventures in Moving

Illinois has the second greatest outmigration among the states:

Illinois’ net loss of 95,000 residents is so large that it defies belief, and speaks to the fact that Illinois has the worst job-creation rate in the Midwest in 2014, with food-stamp enrollment also hitting new record highs. Although Illinois has been a net loser of residents as far back as such data are recorded, never has the state lost so many people in one year.

Only New York lost more people to net migration, as the two states once again battled it out to be the nation’s largest exporter of talent. Meanwhile, states such as Texas, Florida, Arizona, Colorado and the Carolinas happily herded more of the nation’s talent pool across their borders.

Two of nation’s three largest moving companies, United Van Lines and Atlas Van Lines, corroborated the census data. Both moving companies show the rate of outbound traffic from Illinois spiked to new highs in 2014. Atlas and United respectively showed that Illinois ranked second and third-highest for the outbound rate nationally, with New York coming in last in for both moving companies.

The stunning data underscore an important point as power shifts to Governor-elect Bruce Rauner: Illinois cannot raise taxes on a population that is shrinking due to massive numbers of people leaving. We know the number one reason Illinoisans leave is for better job and business opportunities, according to Gallup.

And yet our state legislature remains committed to the ideas that higher tax and a higher cost of doing business in Illinois will solve Illinois’s problems.

4 comments

Just When You Thought…

Just when you thought it was safe to go back into the water, we learn there will be a Sharknado 3:

Syfy’s Sharknado 3 has elected a new president and vice president.

Mark Cuban and Ann Coulter have joined the growing list of guest stars for the third TV movie in the phenomenon, The Hollywood Reporter has learned. Launching in July, Sharknado 3 will be set in Washington, D.C., this time and, per Syfy, will “cause mass destruction in the nation’s capital” before it roars down the Eastern Seaboard.

Entrepreneur/Dallas Mavericks owner Cuban of Shark Tank will play the president, while conservative commentator/author Coulter will play the vp.

They join a rapidly growing list of guest stars set to cameo in the third film, including Bo Derek as May, the mother to star Tara Reid’s April; Jerry Springer, appearing as Mr. White, a manic tourist; ‘N Sync’s Chris Kirkpatrick as a pool lifeguard; and Chris Jericho, who will play Bruce, a roller-coaster ride operator.

What does Sharknado 3 have in common with the Congress? Both “cause mass destruction in the nation’s capital”.

Now I have four reasons not to watch it. Make that seven reasons.

The list of movies I need to avoid is growing rapidly.

Hat tip: memeorandum

1 comment

The Verdict on the Republicans’ Reform Plan

Three Senate Republicans have announced their plan to amend the Affordable Care Act if the Supreme Court decides it should be construed as the plaintiffs in King v. Burwell have proposed:

irst and most important: We would provide financial assistance to help Americans keep the coverage they picked for a transitional period. It would be unfair to allow families to lose their coverage, particularly in the middle of the year.

Most of these people have gone through the wringer to get this insurance. Millions lost their previous health-care plans because those plans didn’t meet Obamacare’s requirements; others no longer have access to the doctors or hospitals they were accustomed to; millions spent weeks trying to purchase insurance on the flawed Web site rolled out by the administration; and many have seen their out-of-pocket health costs or premiums skyrocket.

People do not deserve further disruption from this law.

Second, we will give states the freedom and flexibility to create better, more competitive health insurance markets offering more options and different choices. Republicans understand that what works in Utah is different from what works in Tennessee or Wyoming. We want to give states the time and flexibility to design health-care systems that work for them, not for the bureaucrats in Washington.

I presume that means that the Obama Administration’s power to determine what is acceptable healthcare insurance and what isn’t would be at an end.

I really have no strong feeling about their plan one way or another other than that it’s a patch on a patch. I don’t see that it fixes much and it leaves us just as much in need of healthcare reform as we have been for the last six years with even slimmer prospects for getting any.

2 comments

The Marginal Returns to Investment

As I thought more about John Tamny’s column that I remarked on earlier, it occurred to me that a good deal depended on the marginal returns to capital investment so I did a little research. As it turns out the prevailing wisdom is that the marginal returns, i.e. whether as more is invested the returns are proportionally more, less, or the same, of capital investment go down with scale. That’s basically plain old supply and demand. The question remains what’s really happening?

The answer to that, apparently, as is the case with so many economic questions, is that nobody knows for sure. We can make some inferences, however, based on things that we do know something about, e.g. savings and business investment. As it turns out those are nearing historic lows:

In contrast, investment in the U.S. has been decreasing as a share of GDP since the 1960s, and the decline has accelerated since the financial crisis of 2008 (see Figure 5). Investment was about 20 percent of GDP in the 1960s, fluctuated considerably thereafter with the business cycle, but declined for the most part after the 1980s, never exceeding 21 percent of GDP after 1984. With the financial crisis, investment dropped to 14 percent of GDP in 2009 and has only recovered to 15 percent of GDP as of 2011. Other OECD countries followed a similar trend though at higher levels of investment. The average OECD country now invests about 20 percent of GDP. China, on the other hand, has seen a huge increase in investment, starting from about 20 percent of GDP in the 1960s to 48 percent of GDP today.

In other words Americans are behaving as though the marginal returns to investment are going down so it’s not unreasonable to speculate that they are, in fact, going down.

The follow-up question is who cares whether the marginal returns are going up so long as the absolute amount of real investment goes up?

I’m throwing myself on the mercy of the court here. Are the marginal returns to capital investment going down? Does that matter with respect to the advances Mr. Tamny is talking about? Does it matter as long as the absolute level of real capital investment doesn’t decline? And, if you answered “no” to any of those questions, isn’t there some level of return at which investment stops?

4 comments

The Thing About Revolutions

If John Tamny is right about robots:

Robots will ultimately be the biggest job creators simply because aggressive automation will free us up to do new work by virtue of it erasing toil that was once essential. Lest we forget, there was a time in American history when just about everyone worked whether they wanted to or not — on farms — just to survive. Thank goodness technology destroyed lots of agricultural work that freed Americans up to pursue a wide range of vocations off the farm.

With their evolution as labor inputs, robots bring the promise of new forms of work that will have us marveling at labor we wasted in the past, and that will make past job destroyers like wind, water, the cotton gin, the car, the internet and the computer seem small by comparison. All the previously mentioned advances made lots of work redundant, but far from forcing us into breadlines, the destruction of certain forms of work occurred alongside the creation of totally new ways to earn a living. Robots promise a beautiful multiple of the same.

To understand why, we need to first remember that what is saved on labor redounds to increased capital availability for new ideas. Jobs aren’t finite; rather they’re the result of investment. For every Google, Amazon or Apple Inc. there are tens of thousands of failed entrepreneurial attempts to be like one of the aforementioned giants (all three are major employers), but in order for entrepreneurs to make big experimental leaps, they must first have the capital to do so. The profit-enhancing efficiencies that robots personify (even to their most ardent critics) foretell a massive surge of investment that will gift us with all sorts of new companies and technological advances that promise the invention of new kinds of work previously unimagined.

it will certainly throw a lot of people’s dystopian view of the future into a cocked hat. His view is a bit rosier than mine but he’s making essentially the same argument I’ve made over the last decade. The reason I say “rosier” hinges on one key word in his statement above: “ultimately”. In the near term it may be a lot more dystopian than any of us would like. I do feel impelled to mention that the reason that people went to work in factories in the 19th and 20th centuries wasn’t because they were forced to, either literally or because they were starving on their farms, any more than the Chinese are today. It was because they were seeking a way of life better and more prosperous than they could attain through subsistence farming.

The thing about revolutions is that the consequences of a dramatic departure from the past simply can’t be predicted. James Watt or Isaiah Wedgwood didn’t know what the Industrial Revolution would bring, Jefferson and Adams didn’t know what would come about after the American Revolution, and John Vincent Atanasoff had no idea of what computers would be doing now. IMO the results of all of these revolutions have been benign.

The past may not be that good a predictor of future developments. It is, however, all that we have.

6 comments

Who Killed Boris Nemtsov?

The editors of Bloomberg go to pretty great lengths to blame the murder of opposition leader Boris Yefimovich Nemtsov on Putin:

The thousands who marched in Moscow on Sunday in honor of the murdered opposition politician Boris Nemtsov did so because they recognize just how much has been lost with his death. Nemtsov had been brave enough to tell the truth in Russia under President Vladimir Putin.

The official response to his apparently professional murder on Friday, in the shadow of the Kremlin, has been distasteful. Government spokesmen have spun tales of conspiracy — involving Islamists or Nemtsov’s fellow opposition leaders — to distract from the most plausible explanation: that Putin and his obedient state news media have created an atmosphere of hatred that encouraged such violence.

without actually blaming it on Putin. My own view is that if Putin had wanted Nemtsov to be killed it would have happened much more quickly, more simply, and would not have been able to have been laid at Putin’s door even as much as it has. The word is that Nemtsov’s murder was a complicated operation involving at least fifteen people. I think if Putin had ordered it he would just have had a traffic accident.

I also have a visceral dislike of the formulation the editors are using: “Putin and his obedient state news media have created an atmosphere of hatred that encouraged such violence”. I emphatically do not blame President Obama for the murder of two police officers in New York by a nutbag (I recognize some do) but the same charge could be levied against the president. Using that tactic you can blame anybody for anything.

So, who killed Boris Nemtsov? I have no idea.

7 comments

Risk Assessment and Mitigation

Here’s the kernel of retired CIA official Robert Grenier’s op-ed opposing more strenuous involvement of the U. S. in Iraq or Syria:

Sadly, America has learned very little from the experience in Afghanistan. Just listen now to the impatient voices emanating from the right concerning the Islamic State. Our allies in Iraq, they say, are hopelessly ineffective, and our allies in Syria practically nonexistent. ISIS poses a clear threat to American security, they insist: If others will not, or cannot defeat it, we should not be afraid to step forward ourselves to crush it.

These sentiments play to the instincts of many Americans, and they must be resisted at all cost. If the United States were to take the lead in the ground war in Iraq and perhaps eventually in Syria by introducing conventional combat forces, we would feed into a radical Islamist narrative that pits the invading armies of the crusader against the committed defenders of Islam. In the process we would only strengthen the appeal and the morale of our enemies, while weakening and demoralizing our friends.

My own views, while consonant with Mr. Grenier’s, take a somewhat different tack. We need to identify our interests in the region, assess the risks, and evaluate the strategies for mitigating the risks. Our interests are not the same as France’s, Germany’s, Israel’s or the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia’s and treating their interests as our own would be a grievous error. They must act to secure their own interests and if they can’t or are unwilling to they aren’t really their interests at all.

2 comments

Their Own Facts

Here’s a fascinating little story illustrating the degree to which conservatives and progressives now have their own facts. The story begins with Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker’s assertion that Reagan’s handling of the air traffic controller’s strike was a significant foreign policy move. Phil Rucker of the Washington Post then scoffed at the idea. Here’s Kevin Drum’s affirmation of Mr. Rucker’s retort:

This morning, once again trying to show that fighting against Wisconsin labor unions is pretty much the same as fighting ISIS or communism, Scott Walker repeated his contention that Ronald Reagan’s early move to fire striking air traffic controllers was more than just an attack on organized labor. It was also a critical foreign policy decision. Here’s what he originally said last month on Morning Joe…

[…]

PolitiFact’s conclusion: “For a statement that is false and ridiculous, our rating is Pants on Fire.” But Walker shouldn’t feel too bad. After all, Reagan was also famous for making up facts and evidence that didn’t exist, so Walker is just taking after his hero.

PolitiFact in its conclusion relied heavily on the absence of confirming evidence from the Soviet end. However, the absence of evidence doesn’t prove anything one way or another. But, as you can see, Mr. Drum doesn’t see it that way.

Ed Driscoll, on the other hand, takes Gov. Walker’s statement very seriously quoting Steven Hayward, Paul Volcker, Peggy Noonan, and George Schultz. Those citations confirm what was being thought in the Reagan White House but not what actually happened. In the end for that we’re left to our own judgment.

What are the actual facts? That the air traffic controllers went out on strike and that President Reagan shut down the strike are facts. That the move had economic and foreign policy implications are reasonable speculations but those are judgment calls. Your view may differ. I think it probably had some foreign policy effect at the margins in the sense that a president’s actions are a seamless garment. Taking just one and extrapolating from it is an exaggeration to say the least. Consequently, I’m willing to give Scott Walker the benefit of the doubt here but just barely. He’s making a reasonable supposition about the facts and treating it as itself a fact which is an error. Phil Rucker and Kevin Drum are treating the absence of contradicting evidence as evidence of contradiction which is an even bigger error.

But what’s really clear is that they now have their own facts and where they stand depends on where they sit.

10 comments

The Trend

Let’s see. Here are the World Health Organization’s numbers for the number of new cases of Ebola in Guinea, Liberia, and Sierra Leone since the beginning of the year:

Week ending New cases
Jan 11 525
Jan 18 438
JJan 25 368
Feb 1 403
Feb 8 399
Feb 15 359
Feb 22 476

What in the world are the editors of Bloomberg talking about?

In late January, the World Health Organization said that for the first time in seven months there were fewer than 100 new confirmed cases of Ebola in a week in the hardest hit countries: Liberia, Sierra Leone and Guinea. Even if the epidemic ends, it will continue to inflict pain. More than 23,000 people have been infected since December 2013, according to the official count. About 9,600 have died, leaving behind an estimated 30,000 orphans. More will perish, given a fatality rate of 70 percent in this outbreak. The economic disruption caused by Ebola cost the three countries more than half a billion dollars in 2014, almost five percent of their combined GDPs, according to the World Bank. Aversion to medical facilities has wrecked malaria-control efforts, raising concerns about a malaria surge. Coping even with mundane medical needs is a challenge given the 490 health-care workers killed by Ebola so far. With better medical systems, Nigeria, Senegal and Mali contained Ebola when it spread there, and the Democratic Republic of Congo controlled an outbreak of a different strain of the virus. Two medical workers in the U.S. and one in Spain were infected after caring for people who had contracted Ebola in Africa; all three recovered.

Do you see a trend there? If there is one, the only interpretation I can is that Ebola has become endemic in West Africa. What a happy thought.

Basically, there are three ways an epidemic can end. Everyone can have died. No new cases may emerge. Or the disease becomes endemic which certainly looks like what has happened in this instance.

They also appear to have missed the news that Ebola may have a limited ability to be transmitted through the air. Other than that the article is correct.

8 comments