Are We Really At Full Employment?

What struck me about Robert Samuelson’s most recent column:

First, let’s admit that we don’t really know where “full employment” is. Economists define it as the “natural rate” of unemployment: the rate when tight labor markets begin to generate higher wage inflation. The Fed’s estimates of today’s “natural” rate range between 5 percent and 5.2 percent unemployment. At 5.5 percent, we seem close.

But suppose the natural rate is nearer to 4 percent. If so, we’re not so close. Despite the label, the natural rate isn’t natural. It reflects laws (say, the minimum wage), institutions (unions) and worker behavior. At any time, the natural rate is an educated guess based on past relationships that could be outdated.

The “Great Recession” might have reduced the natural rate. If workers worry more about job security — as seems likely — companies can pay less to keep them at their present jobs. Similarly, some economists argue that there are millions of labor dropouts who are not counted as unemployed but who would accept a job if it were available. Both these behavioral changes would depress the natural rate. But there’s no consensus among economists.

was that I wondered what he has against more jobs? Do you believe we are nearing full employment? Me, neither. I think he’s been staring at the BLS employment situation reports too long.

The 5.5% unemployment rate that he’s citing doesn’t include a laundry list of people including those who’ve given up looking for jobs and those whose unemployment benefits have run out. It does include hundreds of thousands of jobs that may not even exist, products of the birth-death ratio the Bureau of Labor Statistics uses to adjust the establishment employment figures. Note that the household employment stats have diverged from the establishment survey for quite a while now.

If the labor force utililzation rate today were what it was back in 2007, the unemployment rate would be closer to 10% than to 5%. Although Baby Boomers retiring may explain a portion of of that, it doesn’t explain most of it. Let’s keep our eye on the ball. This economy still needs to put a lot more people back to work.

4 comments

How to Persuade Me About the Importance and Value of an Iranian Nuclear Agreement

Over my years in the political blogosphere I have learned that I differ in many ways from most of the denizens of this demimonde. Among these are that I listen to everybody’s points of view and that, in fact, although I can’t be browbeaten I can be persuaded. I’ve made no secret of my skepticism of the value of a negotiated agreement on nuclear development but I wouldn’t be true to myself and my principles if I didn’t entertain the possibility that I was wrong.

What would it take to persuade me that an agreement reached under the framework that has been announced by the Obama Administration (which differs somewhat from the framework as outlined either by the EU or Iran) would be a good thing? Basically, I think you’d need to provide compelling evidence of two things. First, you’d need to persuade me that Iran is a threat to us. I mean something very specific by that not just that they don’t like us. I mean an imminent threat to the American people or our property. I don’t mean a threat to Germany, Israel, or the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. I mean to us.

Second, you’ve need to convince me that despite their history of lies and concealment the Iranian regime can be trusted to be fully forthcoming about the extent of their nuclear development and will allow unrestricted international inspection of all of its nuclear development facilities whether we know about them now or whether they even exist now.

Failing those two things I’ll remain unconvinced.

Update

I just heard a radio interview with a former IAEA nuclear inspector who expressed the opinion that Iran was the least cooperative and most deceitful country the IAEA had ever tried to inspect.

26 comments

What Could Possibly Go Wrong? (Iran Edition)

Dan Drezner outlines how the deal with Iran could “fall apart”. He lists five ways:

  • Disagreement over the sanctions timetable. I think there’s more than a timetable that’s still undecided. What has been promulgated is a framework for an agreement rather than an agreement and, judging from the published sources, there does not appear to be agreement among the parties about the framework let alone its timing.
  • Each side sabotages the other with its domestic sales pitch. The statement of the framework published by the White House was much longer and more detailed than those put forth by the EU or Iran. And note the reports of rejoicing in Tehran. It certainly appears that somebody is overselling something.
  • The regional situation melts down further. Or, said another way, circumstances change.
  • The Sunni Arab states remain unconvinced. This is a point made by Walter Russell Mead. The P5+1 organizational structure left out some important stakeholders, namely the Gulf States and Israel. Like it or not they have veto power over any agreement.
  • Scott Walker (R) is elected president. I take that as an instance of synecdoche. If anything in the final agreement requires action by the U. S. that will require approval from the Senate and I sincerely doubt that will be forthcoming.
30 comments

The Farmer’s View of California’s Water Problems

I rarely read Victor Davis Hanson’s stuff. I have issues with some of his ideas. He has the specialist’s problem: while knowledgeable within his field there are odd lacunae within his knowledge. For example, I find his views on the American Revolution, American Civil War, and Russia skewed, to say the least.

However, I know that he grew up on a farm in central California and comes from a farming family so, when I saw he had a piece in City Journal, I thought he probably had a point-of-view different from the one being expressed in most major news outlets and that was worth considering.

Here’s the kernel of his post:

We do know two things. First, Brown and other Democratic leaders will never concede that their own opposition in the 1970s (when California had about half its present population) to the completion of state and federal water projects, along with their more recent allowance of massive water diversions for fish and river enhancement, left no margin for error in a state now home to 40 million people. Second, the mandated restrictions will bring home another truth as lawns die, pools empty, and boutique gardens shrivel in the coastal corridor from La Jolla to Berkeley: the very idea of a 20-million-person corridor along the narrow, scenic Pacific Ocean and adjoining foothills is just as unnatural as “big” agriculture’s Westside farming. The weather, climate, lifestyle, views, and culture of coastal living may all be spectacular, but the arid Los Angeles and San Francisco Bay-area megalopolises must rely on massive water transfers from the Sierra Nevada, Northern California, or out-of-state sources to support their unnatural ecosystems.

Now that no more reservoir water remains to divert to the Pacific Ocean, the exasperated Left is damning “corporate” agriculture (“Big Ag”) for “wasting” water on things like hundreds of thousands of acres of almonds and non-wine grapes. But the truth is that corporate giants like “Big Apple,” “Big Google,” and “Big Facebook” assume that their multimillion-person landscapes sit atop an aquifer. They don’t—at least, not one large enough to service their growing populations. Our California ancestors understood this; they saw, after the 1906 earthquake, that the dry hills of San Francisco and the adjoining peninsula could never rebuild without grabbing all the water possible from the distant Hetch Hetchy watershed. I have never met a Bay Area environmentalist or Silicon Valley grandee who didn’t drink or shower with water imported from a far distant water project.

He takes what I think of as a stewardship view. California cannot simultaneously be home to 40 million people which includes the jobs that sustain those people and remain in a wild state. California must either constrain its population or pay for new water development projects, something that will become increasingly difficult as its surrounding states scramble after the West’s scarce water resources.

0 comments

Found

When I got out of my car after parking in the grocery store lot, I spotted a cellphone on the ground. I examined it and, strangely, it had a message and a signature written on it. The message was “Look at the flowers” and I couldn’t make out the signature.

I figured someone would miss it and I couldn’t just leave it there so I trotted into the store and got into line at the customer service desk where two women with strong accents (different accents) were arguing with each other. When I got up to the desk, I turned in the phone and explained the situation.

As I turned to walk away, a young girl (keep in mind that any female below the age of forty looks like a young girl to me) in a state of distress came up to the desk, spied the phone in the customer service representative’s hand, and said “That’s my phone! That’s my phone! It has an autograph from someone in The Walking Dead on it!” She was able to repeat the message and easily unlocked the phone. She thanked the customer service representative who pointed to me. So she thanked me.

On reflection I think the autograph was probably Melissa MacBride’s. Didn’t she say the line “Look at the flowers” to a young girl in one of the episodes?

2 comments

The American Civil War in Missouri

There’s a good article here on the extent and effects of the Civil War in Missouri. If they think of it at all when most Americans think of the Civil War they think of Atlanta or Gettysburg, Pennsylvania or the many battles fought in Virginia. They don’t think of Missouri but the southern half of the state experienced a lot of war. As the author of the article points out what went on in Missouri sounds a lot like what’s happening in Iraq today.

There were multiple Civil War battlefields within walking distance of my home when I was a kid and for a while when she was a kid my mom lived right across the street from one. Several of my great-great-grandfathers fought for the Union in the war. It wasn’t just the defeated Confederacy that suffered during the aftermath of the war. Even the victors suffered adverse economic effects. The real victors were the cowards and war profiteers among whose number are counted some of the greatest fortunes in the U. S. today.

0 comments

Much Ado About Not Too Much

I guess it’s impossible to avoid the news of the day so I’ll comment on it. The Obama Administration has its framework agreement with Iran on Iran’s nuclear development program. Le Monde has a good backgrounder on the history of the negotiations, laced with healthy dollops of cynicism and skepticism (or it may be that things just sound more cynical and skeptical in French). For an outline of the terms of the framework agreement Russia Today’s “The Nuclear Deal for Dummies” appears to be a pretty good explanation. Here’s how The Guardian characterizes it:

Iran has promised to make drastic cuts to its nuclear programme in return for the gradual lifting of sanctions as part of a historic breakthrough in Lausanne that could end a 13-year nuclear standoff.

The “political understanding”, announced on Thursday night in the Swiss city’s technical university, followed 18 months of intensive bargaining, culminating in an eight-day period of near-continuous talks that went on long into the night, and on the last night continued all the way through until dawn.
In a joint statement, the European Union’s foreign policy chief, Federica Mogherini, and the Iranian foreign minister, Mohammad Javad Zarif, hailed what they called a “decisive step” after more than a decade of work.

Speaking afterwards, Zarif said the accord showed “our programme is exclusively peaceful, has always been and always will remain exclusively peaceful”, while not hindering the country’s pursuit of atomic energy for civilian purposes.

There does not appear to be a complete meeting of minds on what’s actually in the framework agreement. Iran’s chief negotiator has said that the Obama Administration is misrepresenting what was agreed upon. His interpretation is that the EU will completely lift its sanctions as soon as the IAEA completes its preliminary certification of Iran’s nuclear development program.

David Ignatius says that there’s a substantial amount of spin control on all sides and that’s probably about right. The prevailing wisdom appears to be that the framework agreement is about as good as it gets.

The editors of the Washington Post are skeptical:

The agreement is based on a theoretical benchmark: that Iran would need at least a year to produce fissile material sufficient for a weapon, compared with two months or less now. It remains to be seen whether the limits on enrichment and Iran’s stockpile will be judged by independent experts as sufficient to meet that standard.

while the editors of the Wall Street Journal are even more so:

The general outline of the accord includes some useful limits on Iran, if it chooses to abide by them. Tehran will be allowed to operate a little more than 5,000 of its first-generation centrifuges at its Natanz facility, and only there. It will not enrich uranium above civilian-grade levels for at least 15 years, though it will retain some of its unnecessary current stockpile.

Even better, the reactor at Arak will be retooled to render it incapable of producing weapons-grade plutonium. The underground nuclear facility at Fordo will remain open but be converted into a “nuclear, physics, technology, research center,” with no fissile material present and centrifuges under monitoring by the International Atomic Energy Agency.

All this would be somewhat reassuring if the U.S. were negotiating a nuclear deal with Holland or Costa Rica—that is, a law-abiding state with no history of cheating on nuclear agreements. But that’s not Iran.

Consider the Additional Protocol, a 1997 addendum to the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty that was meant to expand the IAEA’s ability to detect and monitor clandestine nuclear activities. Iran signed the Additional Protocol in December 2003, about the time Saddam Hussein was pulled from his spider hole. The signature meant nothing: By September 2005 the IAEA reported that Iran wasn’t meeting its commitments, and Iran abandoned the pretense of compliance by February 2006.

Now Iran has promised to sign the Protocol again. But as former IAEA deputy director Olli Heinonen observed in a recent paper for the Iran Task Force, “contrary to what is commonly observed, the AP does not provide the IAEA with unfettered access.” Mr. Heinonen adds that the agency “needs ‘go anywhere, anytime’ access to sites, material, equipment, persons, and documents.”

The framework lacks this crucial “anywhere, anytime” provision, even as Mr. Obama calls its inspections the most intrusive ever. Instead it says the “IAEA will have regular access to all of Iran’s nuclear facilities.” Does that mean inspectors have to schedule an appointment? With how much notice? The obvious way to evade inspections is to start a new and secret facility that isn’t part of the accord. This is exactly what Iran did with the operations at Fordo.

You be the judge of whether the negotiations have been successful. Back in 2012 here’s what the president said about negotiations:

The deal we’ll accept [ed. with Iran] is that they end their nuclear program and abide by the U.N. resolutions that have been in place.

Those resolutions called for Iran to suspend its enrichment. In the framework agreement Iran gives up very little. They’ll keep all of their centrifuges. They’ll reduce the number they’re operating to just over 5,000. They continue enriching uranium. They’ll retain all of their stockpiles of nuclear fuel. In exchange Russia, China, and the EU will drop their sanctions. The United States will do nothing, well within its core competency, and that doesn’t require the president to seek approval from Congress which he wouldn’t get anyway.

To me this sounds very much like accepting the inevitable and calling it a breakthrough. The Russians and Chinese were already chafing under the sanctions and sending signals they were going to abandon them. The Chinese in particular are eager to get even deeper into the Iranian oil industry. The Europeans don’t want to lose their market share and, if the Russians and Chinese abandon sanctions, so would the Europeans.

29 comments

California’s Water Conservation Measures

In response to California’s drought, the state’s governor has announced unprecedented measures to mitigate the problem:

Gov. Jerry Brown on Wednesday ordered sweeping and unprecedented measures to save water in California. A survey that day found the snowpack, which supplies a third of the state’s water, almost completely vanished.

“We’re in a new era; the idea of your nice little green grass getting water every day, that’s going to be a thing of the past,” Brown said, standing on a brown field that would normally be covered in snow that melts its way into taps.

The governor’s order calls for cities and towns to cut water use by 25 percent, but many Californians like Whitman aren’t seeing a difference in their day-to-day routines or a hit to their wallets because of the drought.

[…]

He signed an executive order ordering officials to impose statewide mandatory water restrictions and expand programs intended to reshape how Californians use water.

Cemeteries, golf courses and business headquarters must significantly cut back on watering their large landscapes. Local governments will tear out 50 million square feet of lawns for drought-tolerant plants. And customers will get money for replacing old water-sucking appliances with efficient ones under a temporary rebate program.
These initiatives tie back to a central goal of reducing urban water use by 25 percent compared with 2013 levels, the year before Brown declared a drought emergency. In January 2014, he asked Californians to cut water use by 20 percent, but he said they haven’t come halfway to meeting that target, prompting stronger action.
That includes directing local agencies to charge for high water use, such as extra fees for the highest water consumption. Water officials vowed to crack down on waste and illegal water diversions, acknowledging spotty enforcement of existing rules limiting outdoor water use.
The order also prohibits new homes and developments from using drinkable water for irrigation if the structures lack water-efficient drip systems. In addition, the watering of decorative grasses on public street medians is banned.

There are two steps I don’t see in Gov. Brown’s list that will need to be taken at some point or another. The first has to do with agricultural use but that will need to be taken cautiously. The state will need to start charging farmers more for water—enough to incentivize conservation but not enough to put the farmers out of business.

The other step that needs to be taken has to do with zoning and restrictions on permits for new construction. That’s going to be traumatic. California’s business model has relied on more people and more houses for over a century. That needs to come to an end. The land has a finite carrying capacity.

It would have been nice if Gov. Brown had taken more of these steps the last time he was governor thirty years ago. His voluntary conservation plan showed that he understood the problem and taking these steps thirty years ago might have prevented some of the problems they have now. Still, I think the measures he’s announced have shown considerable courage.

3 comments

What We Can’t Afford

I found this post at Personal Finance Cheatsheet quite distressing:

Though there is some debate over the exact income a middle class household brings in, we do have an idea of who the middle class are — most working class people. Today’s bourgeoisie is composed of laborers and skilled workers, white collar and blue collar workers, many of whom face financial challenges. Bill Maher reminded us a few months back that 50 years ago, the largest employer was General Motors, where workers earned an equivalent of $50 per hour (in today’s money). Today, the largest employer — Walmart — pays around $8 per hour.

The middle class has certainly changed. We’ve ranked a list of things the middle class can no longer really afford. We’re not talking about lavish luxuries, like private jets and yachts. The items on this list are a bit more basic, and some of them are even necessities. The ranking of this list is based on affordability and necessity. Therefore, items that are necessity ranked higher, as did items that a larger percentage of people have trouble paying for.

Here’s their list of things that middle income people can “no longer really afford”:

  1. Vacations
  2. New vehicles
  3. Paying off debt
  4. Emergency savings
  5. Retirement savings
  6. Medical care
  7. Dental care

I can provide at least anecdotal evidence for the last item on the list. My dentist clients have been complaining since 2008 that they hadn’t seen anything like what’s happened to their businesses in their entire working lives. People are just not getting dental care. Since dental problems can be contributing factors to all sorts of other health problems, e.g. heart problems, that’s not prudent. It also provides a little support for a point I’ve made repeatedly here. People don’t distinguish between necessary healthcare and unnecessary healthcare. When they economize on healthcare, they may well choose wrong with serious implications down the road.

I have several observations. GM employees earn about what they did fifty years ago, maybe a bit more, and I suspect that the typical GM employee can afford all of the things on that list. There are just a lot fewer of them than there were 50 years ago.

There’s a big difference between a retail sales clerk and a GM hourly worker. Do we really think that sales clerks at Walmart should be able to afford middle class lifestyles?

Finally, I don’t recall that ordinary middle class people did all of the things in their list 50 years ago. 70 years ago my family which could reasonably have been considered middle class (although we lived in a working class neighborhood) didn’t. We always paid off debt, had a little emergency savings, and got medical and dental care. We had no retirement savings, didn’t take a vacation every year, and generally bought used cars. I think a little more research into how ordinary middle income people actually lived 50 years ago would be in order before making any generalizations.

All of that having been said, I don’t think the United States can be the sort of country we expect it to be if the typical job is retail sales clerk and we continue to import large numbers of workers from other countries who’d be happy to work for a less-than-middle-income wage. My preference would be a lot fewer retail sales clerks and a few more people working in the factories that make the gadgets that we use instead of having so many retail sales clerks. I seem to be in the minority in that view.

7 comments

Dear Mr. Gable

As I write this I have The Broadway Melody of 1938 on as background music and I’ve just heard Judy Garland’s rendition of the old Al Jolson number “You Made Me Love You”, preserved in the video above. Contrary to popular opinion it wasn’t “Over the Rainbow” that made Judy Garland a star it was this song and I thought I’d pass on how it came to be.

As it works out MGM threw a party for Clark Gable’s 35th birthday. The party took place on February 1, 1936. The composer and arranger and, importantly, Judy Garland’s mentor at MGM, Roger Eden, wrote the “Dear Mr. Gable” lyrics for Judy Garland to perform at the party. It knocked the studio execs’ socks off. They knew they had something and inserted “You Made Me Love You” with the “Dear Mr. Gable” lyrics into The Broadway Melody of 1938. The public adored it and Judy Garland became a star.

Now I happen to think that Judy Garland was one of the very best interpreters of 20th century American popular song but something that isn’t appreciated is that when you get right down to it she was a Jolson imitator, probably the last. Popular singers of that day were imitating Bing Crosby. Other young performers Judy Garland’s age would soon be imitating Frank Sinatra, who got his start as a Crosby imitator.

At any rate watch and listen to the video and revel in a seminal performance by a great performer.

0 comments