Riots and Morality (Updated)

In all of the commentary on Ferguson, Missouri and now Baltimore, Maryland there’s something missing. When Person A injures Person B as a protest over the actions of Person C, it is immoral. Person A is treating Person B as an object rather than a person. A means to an end rather than an end. The riots going on in Baltimore are both illegal and immoral and commenters on the events should avoid trying to justify it.

If the people of Baltimore have objections against the Baltimore police that cannot be addressed through ordinary government channels, they might be storming the police stations or bombing city hall. When instead they are robbing convenience stores or looting appliance stores, attempts to justify their actions are misplaced.

Update

The president strikes what I think is essentially the right tone in commenting on the riots in Baltimore:

Washington (CNN)President Barack Obama on Tuesday condemned the “criminals and thugs who tore up” the city of Baltimore on Monday night, after rioting and looting paralyzed the city and overwhelmed local officials.

The sustained outbreak of violence followed the funeral for Freddie Gray, the 25-year-old man who died after he was arrested more than two weeks ago. Cars were set on fire, stores were destroyed, and six officers were seriously injured. It was the first time Obama has commented on the turmoil in Baltimore that has followed Gray’s death.

“There’s no excuse for the kind of violence that we saw yesterday. It is counterproductive,” Obama said at a press conference from the White House. “When individuals get crowbars and start prying open doors to loot, they’re not protesting. They’re not making a statement. They’re stealing. When they burn down a building, they’re committing arson. And they’re destroying and undermining businesses and opportunities in their own communities. That robs jobs and opportunity from people in that area.”

Those who make excuses for the rioters and looters or conjoin the issues of the riots and police misconduct shouldn’t mislead themselves. They aren’t holding up the progressive side. They’re holding up the anarchist-hooliganism side.

16 comments

When Is a Partnership Not a Partnership?

There are times when your advocacy for something ties you up in such knots that you ignore the facts of the case in pursuit of your advocacy. I think that’s the case with the Washington Post editorial in support of the incipient Trans-Pacific Partnership agreement. After remarking on the benefit of trade they write:

In any case, the world’s biggest alleged currency manipulator, China, is not a party to the agreement.

That’s incorrect, both formally and practically. Formally, the United States continues to have a “One China policy”. That means that as a matter of policy the U. S. believes there is only one China, not a mainland China and Taiwan. Since Taiwan is a party to the negotiations, as a matter of policy China is a party to it.

However, practically it’s false as well. As a consequence of the way so many Taiwanese companies operate when you do business with them you’re doing business with China. That’s a problem with the agreement that hasn’t been mentioned. China is the elephant in the room. Any agreement that includes Japan and Taiwan but doesn’t include mainland China will give the mainland the benefits of the agreement without demanding it change its policies. That seems like a basic problem to me.

There’s also a logical problem with editors’ criticisms. Although they object to opposing an agreement when we don’t know the terms to it, they don’t recognize that it’s equally problematic to support the agreement. It’s no more illegitimate to critique in advance than it is to advocate in advance.

I don’t oppose a trade agreement in principle, a position the editors attribute to unnamed progressives. Unlike the editors I recognize that the TPP is not a free trade pact but a managed trade one, we need to negotiate a deal in which trade is managed in our favor, and in the U. S.’s typical haste to embrace neoliberal policies I’m not confident that’s the case. I’d rather see tariffs that protect ordinary American workers at the expense of a little GDP than managed trade in the form of the TPP that increases GDP at the expense of ordinary workers.

2 comments

The Wind (1928)

Last night my wife and I watched the 1928 silent The Wind on TCM. If it’s not the last important silent movie, it’s darned close—The Jazz Singer opened just a few weeks before The Wind did. It is a serious and even disturbing look at a woman who moves from Virginia to West Texas and slowly loses her mind under the privations of the harsh environment. Although it’s not on any of the commercial streaming services, it’s readily available online.

It stars Lillian Gish, one of the most beautiful women ever to appear in the movies, and a remarkably courageous and inventive actress. She’s the only person I know of to have appeared in movies in eight different decades.

It occurred to me that there’s a documentary crying out to be made about four different women: Mary Pickford, Lillian Gish, Ida Lupino, and Lucille Ball. Mary Pickford was the first woman to own her own motion picture studio (she, Charlie Chaplin, and Douglas Fairbanks started United Artists). Lillian Gish did it all. Not only was she a foundational movie actress and one of the most affecting, she wrote, directed, and produced movies during the period in which the language of film was being invented. In addition to being a fine actress, as a director Ida Lupino put women on the map. Lucille Ball took charge of her own career, made a prophetic move to television, retained 80% ownership of the earliest episodes of her influential program I Love Lucy, and, with husband Desi Arnaz, founded what was to become the second largest production company in the U. S., Desilu.

1 comment

The Best Baseball Movies

Despite the snow flurry last week spring is here in Chicago and the baseball season has begun in earnest. In recognition of that I’ve been thinking about baseball movies. Baseball movies have actually been made in three different centuries—in 1898 one of the early Edison pictures was a baseball movie and it’s about what you’d expect: two guys playing baseball. After that the earliest baseball picture I know about wasn’t until 1928 but I’d be surprised if there hadn’t been more silent baseball pictures.

There are enough baseball pictures that there are actually two distinct genres: baseball movies and baseball comedies. I’ll list them separately. Here are what I think are the best baseball movies.

The Pride of the Yankees

This film biography of Lou Gehrig based on the book by Paul Gallico is quoted so frequently it has a life of it own. One of the best baseball movies with multiple great performances by Gary Cooper, Teresa Wright, Walter Brennan, and Dan Duryea. It’s also an historic record with appearances by a number of Gehrig’s teammates including Babe Ruth (about whom there have been at least three film biographies).

The Stratton Story

The late 40s and early 50s had a spate of baseball pictures and this biopic of Monty Stratton, who lost his leg in a hunting accident but returned to major league baseball is one of the best. It features performances by Jimmy Stewart and June Allyson who despite their Mutt and Jeff quality were something of a screen couple during the period.

Fear Strikes Out

This biopic of Jimmy Piersall is not just a baseball movie but features one of the relatively few serious treatments of mental illness in an American movie and a fine performance by Anthony Perkins which should convince you that he could do more than play a serial killer.

Bang the Drum Slowly

Sort of a baseball Brian’s Song. Solid performances by Michael Moriarty and Robert De Niro.

The Natural

For my money the best of all baseball movies. I’m a sucker for mythic themes and this picture has plenty of them. It’s helped along considerably by Robert Redford’s natural athleticism and a fabulous supporting cast.

Eight Men Out

Baseball pictures don’t get a lot better than this one about the 1919 Black Sox scandal.

Field of Dreams

This baseball fantasy is a favorite of mine. Kevin Costner does a solid job, I could listen to James Earl Jones read the phone book, and Burt Lancaster in a small supporting role lends gravitas and heart. “If you build it, they will come.”

A League of Their Own

This long-overdue albeit fictionalized account of the All American Girls Baseball League features good performances by just about everybody in the cast including Geena Davis, Tom Hanks, Lori Petty, and Madonna.

Moneyball

This picture about the modern business of baseball features one of Brad Pitt’s best performances as Billy Beane.

42

An affecting account of Jackie Robinson’s breaking the color barrier in major league baseball.

And here’s a list of some of the best baseball comedies.

Alibi Ike

There haven’t been many athletes better than Joe E. Brown in the movies and he’s good in this picture about a baseball player with ready excuses for everything.

It Happens Every Spring

Screwball comedy meets baseball in this picture about a chemist who invents a substance that repels wood, puts it on a baseball, and becomes a pitching phenom. Features Ray Milland.

Angels in the Outfield (1951)

There’s a reason this baseball fantasy is beloved. Funny and touching it wouldn’t be the same without Paul Douglas as a baseball manager who, in a reverse of Faust, makes a deal with the angels for a winning season. Probably Bruce Bennett’s best supporting performance. Sex appeal provided by Janet Leigh.

The Bad News Bears (1976)

It’s hard to beat Walter Matthau’s turn as a washed-up and alcoholic minor league baseball coach who takes a job coaching a little league team of misfits. Frequently imitated, never beaten.

Bull Durham

This picture is as much a baseball satire as it is a romantic comedy. Superb performances by Kevin Costner as a nearly finished minor league catcher, Susan Sarandon as a baseball groupie, and Tim Robbins as a young pitcher on his way to the majors. It may well be the best baseball comedy.

Major League

Uproarious baseball farce with a trivial romantic subplot. Bob Uecker’s color commentary is hysterical.

Any other suggestions? What are your favorite baseball movies?

15 comments

Point/Counter-Point

On welfare reform, point by Max Sawicky, posting from Kevin Drum’s place:

The 1996 welfare reform looked good in the late ’90s, but that was when the whole labor market looked really, really good. Since 2000, not so much. Poverty rates, for instance, have consistently gone up since then. People have not been empowered to pull themselves up by their bootstraps. Looking to Tyler for enlightenment on anti-poverty programs is like taking Driver’s Ed from Vin Diesel.

Counter-point from Megan McArdle at Bloomberg:

Was welfare reform a good idea?

In the past few years, I’ve started to hear a common complaint from leftish policy wonks about the welfare reforms of 1996. Maybe it was a good idea in the booming labor market of the 1990s, they say. But after the dot-com bubble burst in the early 2000s, things went south, and what looked like a good idea at the time has turned out to be a recipe for misery. Max Sawicky referenced that argument Friday at Mother Jones in a post on labor force participation.

Yet if you look at the poverty figures, I don’t think they tell that story.

My view is that there’s no substitute for robust economic growth. Whether you’re a Democrat, Republican, libertarian, or socialist you should be unhappy with what’s going on now, what we’re doing now, and what our responses have been.

1 comment

The Kurds and the Armenian Genocide

In the wake of Pope Francis’s remarks about the Armenian genocide by the Turks, there has been quite a bit of criticism of the present Turkish government and its continuing official rejection of the very idea of the genocide, preferring to think of it as the outcome of a civil war which is ridiculous. If it was a civil war, it was a war in which only one of the sides was armed.

The Kurds, who are known to have taken part in the killings of Armenians, are under no such illusions as illustrated by this article at International Business Times:

During the 1915 genocide, some Kurdish tribes were also exploited and encouraged by the Turkish Ottoman regime to attack the deportation caravans of Armenians.

However, it should be noted that there were many cases where Kurds refused to attack the Armenians and rescued them from certain death.

Today, 100 years after the genocide, Kurds in Turkey still do not have any political authority in their own lands. But they do recognise the Armenian genocide, commemorate the victims and call on the Turkish government to apologise to Armenian people.

One of them is Selahattin Demirtas, the Kurdish co-chairperson of the Peoples’ Democratic Party (HDP), who said in televised comments that “without hesitation, I recognise the Armenian Genocide.

“Both during my deputyship and before that – when I was a human rights lawyer – my stance toward this issue has never changed.

“Just because some people have covered up such a tragic historical incident by saying that ‘the official history [of the Ottoman Empire and Turkey] is not like that’, I will not bow to it,” said Demirtas. “Whatever happened should be acknowledged.”

When asked whether Kurds also had a role in the genocide, Demirtas responded: “Everybody including the Kurds did. But the political authority was the Ottoman regime led by Talaat Pasha, and Djemal Pasha. Whoever gave the orders, carried out the project and made the decisions [regarding the Armenian Genocide] – that is, the ideology of the government of Union and Progress – should be brought to account before history.”

The word “genocide” was apparently coined in 1944 to describe the murders of the Jews by the Nazis in Germany and elsewhere. I think too little has been written of the role of creating an ethnically-based national identify in such mass murders. That was obviously the case with the murder of Jews referred to as “the Holocaust” but the murder of Armenians by the Turks is inextricably entangled with the rise of Turkish nationalism as well.

I don’t know how far this particular sort of genocide and “ethnic cleansing” goes back. Possibly forever. I can certainly hear echoes of them in the persecution of the Breton in France during the French Revolution and since, the earlier persecution of the Huguenots, the persecution of Jews in Europe from the 13th century onwards, the persecution of the Irish by the English, the expulsion of Jews from North Africa and the countries of the Middle East, and even the treatment of the American Indians here.

8 comments

Gallipoli and the Turks

This week we and the British and to an even greater extent the Australians have been commemorating the centenary of the Gallipoli campaign, an eight month long campaign of World War I considered a great national victory by the Turks and the national baptism of fire by the Australians and New Zealanders. The campaign began one hundred years ago yesterday on April 25, 1915. In the course of the campaign there were a quarter million casualties on the Allied side alone, nearly 60,000 killed by enemy fire, with even more dying of disease.

I only became aware of it recently but on September 23, 1915 a young Australian reporter, Keith Murdoch, father of Rupert, after spending four days crawling through the trenches, scrambling over the countryside, speaking with soldiers, and generally surveying the campaign wrote a 25 page typewritten letter to Andrew Fisher, the Australian Prime Minister, that is considered influential if not instrumental in bringing the disastrous campaign to an end. You can read the letter here at the Australian National Library and I think it should be mandatory reading, not only for its clear reporting but for its rhetorical excellence. Here is its most famous passage, its peroration:

I hope I have not made the picture too gloomy. I have great faith still in the Englishman. And, as I have said, the enemy is having his own troubles too. But this unfortunate expedition has never been given a chance. It required large bodies of seasoned troops. It required a great leader. It required self-sacrifice on the part of the staff as well as that sacrifice so wonderfully and liberally made on the part of the soldiers. It has had none of these things. Its troops have been second class, because untried before their awful battles and privations of the peninsula. And behind it is a gross selfishness and complacency on the part of the staff.

In the commemorations too little has been written about the Turks’ experience of the campaign. They suffered as many or more casualties as the Allies did, both by enemy fire and disease. Just as the Australians attributed their high casualty rate to the recklessness and indifference to their lives of the general staff so too did the Turks attribute their even higher casualty rate to the recklessness and indifference to their lives of the German officers that commanded them.

Here is what Keith Murdoch wrote of the Turks in his letter:

The Turks by the way are as generous in their praise of our men as the British and French are. Certainly the Turks are positively afraid of our men, and one of their trenches–that opposite Quinn’s Post–is such a place of fear, owing to the indomitable way our snipers and bomb-throwers have got their men down, that Turks will not go into it unless they are made corporals. So say our Intelligence Officers. I saw many strange and remarkable instances of the humanity and courage of the Turks. Certainly his trenches are better than anything we can do, and he makes them remarkably quickly.

A young Turkish officer of the campaign, Mustafa Kemal, later called “Atatürk”, rose to prominence in the campaign for his gallant and courageous leadership. He is best known now for having founded something of a rarity among majority Muslim countries, a secularist state. Nineteen years after the campaign in 1934 he wrote this in tribute to the Aussies and New Zealanders killed in it:

Those heroes that shed their blood and lost their lives … You are now lying in the soil of a friendly country. Therefore rest in peace. There is no difference between the Johnnies and the Mehmets to us where they lie side by side here in this country of ours … You, the mothers who sent their sons from faraway countries, wipe away your tears; your sons are now lying in our bosom and are in peace. After having lost their lives on this land they have become our sons as well.

2 comments

Peak Radicalization

I hesitated to get involved with this story but I finally caved in. This morning I stumbled across this story about the newly elected mayor of Kinloch being barred by the city’s police from taking office on the grounds of vote fraud.

Kinloch is a small, poor, almost exclusively black suburb of St. Louis, north of the city not far from Ferguson which has become infamous lately. Kinloch once had a population of about 10,000 but in the 1980s St. Louis began purchasing plots of land for noise abatement reasons (Kinloch isn’t far from the airport) and by the 2010 census its population had fallen below 300.

The article describes Kinloch as once having been “thriving”. I suppose that depends on your operative definition. It was once more populous but it has been poor for as long as I can recall.

What really caught my attention was the comments to the article which included complaints that the newly elected mayor was being prevented from taking office due to racism. That is nonsense. Yes, the new mayor was black but the old mayor was black, too. I don’t know for sure but I seriously doubt that Kinloch has had anything but black mayors for the last half century and the same is true of police chiefs. Kinloch’s population has been 95% or more black for as long as I can recall.

My point here is that not every bad thing that happens to a black person is caused by racism. Assertions of racism in this particular case points to a level of radicalization with respect to race that assumes the level of farce.

2 comments

Chasing Rainbows

Mort Zuckerman opens his Wall Street Journal op-ed on President Obama’s agreement with Iran with two lines from the popular song “I’m Always Chasing Rainbows” and remarks:

The vaudeville song by Harry Carroll and Joseph McCarthy, popularized by Judy Garland and Barbra Streisand, is all too appropriate to this moment, as we consider the implications of a nuclear Iran and the prospect of mushroom clouds over the Middle East.

The song was popularized in 1918 by Charlie Harrison (his version is above) back when a “hit song” meant you sold a lot of sheet music with your picture on it and before Judy Garland was born. The melody is adapted from Chopin’s Fantaisie-Impromptu composed in 1834 and published in 1855. It’s been popular ever since, one of Chopin’s most popular works. The popular song has a new revival about once a generation. It’s been covered hundreds of times.

In his op-ed Mr. Zuckerman lists the reasons he’s skeptical about the agreement but IMO there only needs to be one: the only vote in Iran that means anything is that of the Grand Ayatollah Ali Khamenei and, judging by his public statements, an agreement that would meet with his approval is not one that should meet with U. S. approval. Contrary to Sec. Kerry’s claims if Khamenei answers to any constituency it is a handful of ayatollahs with very different views and objectives from those of an American politician.

As I’ve said from the announcement of the “framework agreement”, it certainly appears that President Obama is desperate for a deal and I think the Grand Ayatollah has that impression, too.

16 comments

Economic Ignorance

I knew that I couldn’t in good conscience vote for George McGovern when I was treated to the spectacle of seeing his chief economic advisor, John Kenneth Galbraith, being compelled to apologize shamefacedly for the candidate’s extraordinary economic ignorance. The editors of the Wall Street Journal find themselves somewhat in that position in critiquing the position of Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker on legal immigration:

In a radio interview Monday with Glenn Beck, Mr. Walker said “the next President and the next Congress need to make decisions about a legal immigration system that’s based on, first and foremost, on protecting American workers and American wages.” He went on to say, “I’ve talked to folks, I’ve talked to Senator Sessions and others out there.” At the “forefront of our discussion going foward,” he says, must be what legal immigration is “doing for American workers looking for jobs” and what it “is doing to wages.”

By all means let’s have that discussion on jobs and wages. Because Mr. Walker seems to be taking his cue from Senate hearings Mr. Sessions held recently to spread a whopper: that Americans with degrees in STEM subjects (science, technology, engineering and math) can’t get jobs because foreigners are stealing them.

Mr. Sessions is the Senate’s leading crusader against any immigration, legal and illegal, and his latest targets are H-1B visas for skilled workers. Practically speaking, these visas are the only way U.S. companies can bring foreign talent to work in America, and more are going to STEM specialists.

The Senator calls claims of a skilled-worker shortage a “hoax.” But the numbers suggest otherwise: The U.S. Citizen and Immigration Services announced last week that it received a record 233,000 requests from American business for the 85,000 H-1B visas available.

The WSJ editors are displaying a bit of economic ignorance of their own. There’s more than one reason that the number of requests for H-1B visas might be so large. It might be, as the editors suggest, that the workers are simply not available. Or it might be that the wage being offered for the workers is below the market clearing price. The editors present no evidence for their position; they merely assume it. I would submit that anyone who has ever worked for a company that requested H-1B visas could testify as to how frequently they’re used as a way of reducing wages. The employers aren’t short of workers; they’re chaffering down wages.

In the technology sector in particular it has been demonstrated so frequently that the industry leaders, e.g. Microsoft, Oracle, etc., are using H-1B visas in just that way that it requires no additional proof.

One bit of evidence that might be produced for the WSJ’s position is if median wages in the U. S. were rising (and median wages equalled average wages or nearly so). That isn’t the case so I think we should be skeptical of the claim.

The editors also say this:

As for jobs overall, in 2010 the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco concluded “there is no evidence that immigrants crowd out U.S.-born workers in either the short or long run.” It also found that the long run effect on the income of Americans is small but positive.

which is a bit of lying with statistics. There’s more than one way that could be true, for example it might mean that the incomes of top managers were rising even as the incomes of ordinary workers were falling.

I want American employers to be able to get all of the skilled workers they need and I’ve produced my strategy for doing that any number of times. Remove any limits for the number of H-1B visas that will be available. Create a central clearing house for jobs for which employers wish to obtain H-1B visas. Let the employers pre-commit to hiring any applicant that meets the qualifications stated in their application. If the employer fails to hire a qualified applicant or if the wage being offered for the position can be demonstrated to fall below the prevailing market wage, deny that employer any H-1B visas for a period of five years. Let all of this be handled administratively rather than going through the courts.

3 comments