Where Else But Economics?

I don’t cite the New York Post as a source very often. I doubt I’ve done so more than four times in the last decade including this time. But John Crudele’s analysis of the recent employment situation report is so apt I really feel I must:

First off, a gain of 223,000 jobs is just OK, not great. And that figure included a guesstimate — before seasonal adjustments — that 213,000 jobs were created by newly formed companies that Labor can’t prove really exist. Without that assumption, which comes from something called the birth/death model, the April jobs report would have been worse than March.

Do any of those 213,000 phantom jobs really exist? Considering the fact that bankruptcies soared during the first three months of this year and that this trend probably continued into April, you have to wonder if Labor should have been subtracting jobs for the “death” part of the birth/death model, instead of adding them for newborn companies.

Labor reduces the assumptions for these jobs in May and June, so its thumb won’t be pressed as hard on the scale in the short term.
March’s job growth was revised lower, from 126,000 jobs to 85,000.

It was reasonable to expect a big rebound in April after the March disappointment, but that didn’t happen.

The March/April average of 154,000 jobs — even with the phantom birth/death jobs added in — is a big dropoff from the pace of employment growth last year.

Only a few parts of the economy showed job growth: Construction was up 45,000 jobs; health care, 45,200; restaurants, 26,000; and professional and business services, 62,000. The manufacturing sector of the economy showed very little improvement.

I’ll start out with the last part of that first. I consider job growth in healthcare a failure rather than a success for the simple reason that at least sixty cents out of every dollar spent on healthcare comes from government subsidies. Medicare, Medicaid, and the 1,001 other ways that healthcare is subsidized. Not only can we not have a healthy economy on the basis of subsidies, most of the money spent on healthcare goes to the highest income earners in the sector. That’s true in most sectors but it’s particularly true in healthcare—that’s obvious from the large number of highly compensated professionals in the sector and the low wages paid to the people who empty bedpans, sweep up the halls, and take care of the elderly. It’s a contributing factor to income inequality just as the growth of the finance sector is. Depending more on healthcare jobs is a Bad Thing. It’s the cat and rat farm I’ve written about here before.

Second, how many of those “professional and business service” jobs were temps without benefits? And how many are paid below the prevailing wages for those jobs? My guess would be most of them. That means that wages are being pushed down.

Finally, do you think that the estimated 26,000 people newly employed by restaurants were anything but minimum wage employees? What’s actually happening in our economy is two things. People coming into the labor market for the first time are getting jobs with low wages (regardless of their educational levels) and the longterm unemployed are staying that way. That is no success and painting it as such is a cruel fantasy.

Going back to the top of that quote. The “establishment survey” is not a survey. It is a sample to which various fudge factors are added. How large are the fudge factors? If of 223,000 jobs reported as having been created 213,000 are a result of the fudge factor, that means that 95% of the reported jobs are extrapolated, interpolated, and otherwise made up.

Where other than in economics is that high a fudge factor not laughed out of the building? If engineers applied fudge factors of that magnitude, every appliance in your home would be melting down or exploding on a regular basis, a lot more bridges and buildings would be falling down, and you’d need to dig yourself a shelter to avoid the airplanes falling out of the sky. At least I would—I’m on the O’Hare flight path. A rocket sent to re-supply the space station would be as likely to hit Paris as it was to reach its objective.

Is it any wonder that the economy melts down or explodes on a regular basis?

6 comments

The One Sentence Summary

I think I can summarize David Stockman’s lengthy and interesting post in one sentence, just eight words: why the heck is the stock market rising? I’ll also answer it. It’s the only game in town. Or, said another way, blame the Fed.

0 comments

Handicapping the Electoral College

Larry Sabato has an interesting analysis of the prospects for the electoral college in the 2016 election. Here’s his bottom line:

Basically, that if a party wins both Colorado and Virginia, it will win the White House. Both states have hewn closely to the national electoral average for the past two presidential elections, and they are formerly reliable Republican states that have moved in a Democratic direction. The chances of one of them providing the decisive 270th electoral vote to the winner, as Colorado did in 2012 (with Virginia right behind as just a shade more Republican), are high.

The only thing I’d add is that I think the odds are very high that the general election will have a very low turnout. Under those circumstances anything can happen. Remember, Illinois just elected a Republican governor.

1 comment

What’s a Fella to Do?

The editors of the Wall Street Journal are not happy about the Illinois Supreme Court decision I posted on yesterday which found that the Illinois legislature’s 2013 law aimed at reducing the state’s public pension liability was unconstitutional. They declaim:

All of this means that Illinois and its municipalities may soon have little choice but to raise taxes or restructure debts to pay for pensions. Chicago, whose credit rating is two notches above junk, faces a $20 billion unfunded liability for pensions and $1.1 billion balloon payment next year. Unions (and perhaps investors) were counting on a state bailout, but now they will probably beg Washington for a rescue.

Actually, there are any number of other strategies the state could use. We could amend our constitution, a move that is already under way. Not only is that iffy it will be time-consuming.

We could reduce state payrolls. That can be done in two ways: by cutting the pay of state employees and reducing their number. Both could be tried. Cutting the pay and budgets of state legislators would be a good start. Minimum wage is the floor so, presumably, the legislature might suddenly cultivate a vital interest in raising the state’s minimum wage.

The state, counties, and municipalities could try renegotiating their contracts with their employees’ unions to fit the straitjacket the Illinois Supreme Court has measured for them.

The legislature could enact a graduated state income tax. We could return our Medicaid system to its pre-2000 configuration—then-Gov. Rod Blagojevich was a significant force behind trimming the state’s contribution to its employee pension fund in order to expand its Medicaid system.

The alternatives are almost limitless. More than likely, however, they’ll just raise taxes. The evidence that they can realize enough revenue that way to fill the budget gaps without economizing in other ways is slim to non-existent.

Let’s not lose sight of the reality that it’s the state legislature that got us into this fix. It’s a legislature whose members have overwhelmingly just been re-elected. While we’re amending the constitution, we might consider granting the electorate the power to recall any elected official in the state and broadening the initiative.

0 comments

Harry Truman Explains…

…the results in the recent British elections:

If it’s a choice between a genuine Republican, and a Republican in Democratic clothing, the people will choose the genuine article, every time…

Now assume that Liberal Democrats are British voters who will not vote for Labour. Once the Lib-Dems had made common cause with the Conservatives it left former Lib-Dem voters no reason not to vote Tory.

I think some assumptions had been made about Liberal Democrats swinging over to Labour but that, obviously, was not the case.

With most of Labour’s voters in Scotland swinging over to the Scottish National Party and Scotland having been a stronghold for Labour it goes a long way towards explaining the results.

I’ve heard some absurd explications of Britain’s politics trying to analogize between their parties and ours. It’s a futile exercise. Political orientation does not translate well. The Tories are Tories; they’re not Republicans. Labour is Labour not Democrats.

Here in the United States we have the Republican Party which used to be a catch-all party turning center-right moving right and the Democratic Party which used to be a catch-all party turning center to center-left party and moving left. The fastest growing group in the U. S. is independents who no longer have a comfortable home in either party.

2 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The announcement post at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments

Illinois Supreme Court Strikes Down Pension Reform

The Illinois Supreme Court has ruled unanimously that the pension reform legislation enacted by the legislature back in December of 2013 is unconstitutional:

Illinois’ supreme court has overturned the state’s 2013 pension reform law, which reduced pension costs and increased retirement ages, according to a copy of the decision, sending the state’s bonds lower.

The state has the worst-funded pension system and the lowest credit ratings of all 50 states and has contended that pension costs are making it difficult to fund services such as healthcare and public safety.

“There are no winners today,” said Ty Fahner, president of the Civic Committee of The Commercial Club of Chicago. “If there’s any good news, it’s that Chicago and Illinois are resilient, and we’ve responded to great challenges before.”

Illinois’ reform law, enacted in December 2013, reduces and suspends cost-of-living increases for pensions, raises retirement ages and limits salaries on which pensions are based.

which is exactly what I’ve been predicting all along. The question was never whether there was any wiggle room in the state’s constitution. The question has always been was the Illinois Supreme Court willing to carry water for our cowardly and feckless legislature. We now have our answer: they aren’t.

The ball is now in the legislature’s court. The elections are now safely behind them so they have some breathing room. Circumstances are much more difficult for the legislature now than they were back in late 2013. Now they know when the state’s constitution says “shall not decrease” and “enforceable” that’s exactly what it means. The state’s credit rating is worse than it was in 2013. And there’s a Republican governor, elected at least in part because he could be expected to oppose making the income tax increase, notionally imposed to put the state’s fiscal house in order. Whatever is done now will require a supermajority unless it’s something that fits into Gov. Rauner’s plans. His hand has just become stronger.

Update

At Crain’s Greg Hinz points out that the court’s decision is a blow to Mayor Emanuel’s and Gov. Rauner’s strategies, too:

Emanuel last year negotiated reductions in benefits with unions covering about half of city workers and is working with police and firefighters for further changes. But the language of today’s decision appears to allow no exception for “negotiated” reductions in benefits. Rather, the benefits are owed, as in any contract.

Rauner, in turn, has proposed shifting all current workers into a new system with reduced benefits. But the court decision suggests that a worker is entitled to accrue benefits at the old rate until he or she leaves the payroll.

The language of the justices’ ruling suggests that they could hoss trade with the unions, trading, for example, improved benefits of other kinds for pension reductions, but could not simply reduce benefits to something they’d be comfortable paying for.

2 comments

The Law and Morality

I want to go on record as defending Pam Geller’s right to do and say offensive, obnoxious, and hateful things unconditionally. I think it’s wrong of her to say them because I think that setting out to offend someone or hurt their feelings deliberately is immoral. However, that’s her right and should remain so.

I also want to condemn those who are blaming her for the two stupid Islamist terrorists who drew their guns on an armed Texas police officer and were shot dead where they stood. Those who are to blame are the two terrorists and anyone who supported them.

I’m seeing too many signs of a sadly authoritarian streak in American thought. On the one hand there is the law where force is used in upholding it. On the other is morality where no force is used. Something may be bad but still be legal. All bad conduct should not be made illegal. Doing so nullifies the very idea of rights.

6 comments

If You Torture the Data Long Enough, They Will Submit

It certainly looks as though the Obama Administration is declassify Malaysia as being among the countries with the worst track record in human trafficking:

If the State Department does take Malaysia out of Tier 3 status in the next human trafficking report, it will be hard-pressed to make the case that decision is based on merit. Last year, when Malaysia was downgraded from Tier 2, the department said the country was rife with systematic exploitation of foreign workers through abusive work conditions, de facto indentured servitude, and rampant sex trafficking.

In fact, Malaysia’s downgrade to Tier 3 should have come two years earlier, but the State Department granted it waivers in 2012 and 2013. The Malaysian government promised to address the problem in those two years, but did not, the department found. Last year, the Malaysians actually decreased their anti-trafficking enforcement efforts. U.S. Ambassador to Malaysia Joe Yun said publicly just last month that the Malaysian government had to do more if it wanted to lose its Tier 3 status.

Obama administration officials often argue that a smart foreign policy is achieved when the government properly balances American interests and American values. One argument holds that huge trade deals can pull nations such as Malaysia out of poverty and could benefit workers there immensely, so shouldn’t be held up by isolated human rights issues.

because unless they do their Trans-Pacific Partnership trade agreement is dead. When your standards are that instrumental, are they really standards at all?

1 comment

Divining Their Meaning

U. S. Sen. Elizabeth Warren and New York Mayor Bill De Blasio have taken to the opinion page Washington Post’s to lay out what they characterize as a “bold” plan to revitalize the American Dream (whatever that means). Here are their proposals:

  • Increase the minimum wage.
  • Equal pay for equal work.
  • Paid family leave.
  • Control costs and allow borrowers to refinance educational loans at lower rates.
  • Universal pre-K.
  • More medical and scientific research.
  • Spend more on “roads, bridges, rail, water, power and broadband”.
  • Strengthen and expand Social Security.
  • Reform trade policy (details unspecified).
  • Remove unspecified tax breaks for businesses and ensure that “millionaires and billionaires pay their fair share”.

which seems a lot more like a list of Democratic nostrums for the last 50 years than it does a “bold” plan. To my bloodshot eye that anodyne list wouldn’t have been bold in 1965 let alone in 2015. No red necktie wearers here.

You’ll notice a long list of people who are completely left out of their plan. People who don’t already have a job. People who can’t or won’t graduate from college.

I could propose a bolder list right off the top of my head. I won’t claim that any of these will be effective in reviving the American Dream or even that I agree with them but at least they’re bold:

  • A guaranteed minimum wage job for any American that wants one.
  • Abandoning Davis-Bacon requirements in federal infrastructure spending bills.
  • Universal college education at no charge to the students or their families (just as we have universal high school education now).
  • Ban selling Treasury bonds to foreign governments, sovereign wealth funds, or similar institutions.
  • Greatly increase the number of work visas available to Mexicans.
  • Strong workplace enforcement of immigration laws based on a national biometric ID.
  • Impose tariffs on goods and services from countries that don’t have health, safety, labor, and environmental laws at least as strict as ours (or who don’t enforce the laws they have).

So go bold! Let’s hear some bold plans for revitalizing the American Dream.

12 comments