Things to Come

There was an interesting observation made in my post yesterday reacting to Sean Trende’s observations about the state of the Republican Party to the effect of a prediction that Midwestern and Southern states would experience a sharp out-migration while, presumably, those on the East and West Coasts would see in-migration. If I misinterpreted that comment I apologize in advance.

The graphic above, courtesy of Governing.com, (which I suspect will play hob with my format but you can’t have everything) depicts in-migration and out-migration by state in 2011. That’s the most recent I could find. If the commenter’s prediction is coming true, it isn’t exactly coming true yet. As you can see Midwestern states are experiencing out-migration and the leader of the pack is Illinois, the most Democratic state in the Midwest. Southern states are experiencing in-migration with the most in-migration being seen in the very Republican state of Texas. The most populous East and West Coast states, New York and California, respectively, are experiencing substantial out-migration.

I do not believe that the more-or-less current patterns reflect what the commenter was implying—that Republicans would drive people out of their states. That doesn’t appear to be happening. Indeed, if you can make a simple generalization based on statistics it would be the opposite.

Before I close I want to caution against too simple an interpretation. The statistics say nothing about just who is migrating. It could be that Democrats and Republicans are equally likely to leave their home states in search of greener pastures, it might be that Republicans are more likely to leave, or it could be that Democrats are. Texas could become more Republican rather than less or vice versa. Ditto for California. It depends.

And it all depends on whether you believe in the persistence theory. I tend not to but would be more predisposed to think about equilibria. It might be that Americans are seeking some sort of equilibrium and when that is reached the present trends will slow or even reverse. It can all be summed up in two words: it’s complicated.

27 comments

Is the Republican Party a Party in Decline?

Sean Trende and David Byler attempt an empirical examination of the question and conclude:

Overall, this gives the Republicans an index score of 33.8. This is the Republican Party’s best showing in the index since 1928, and marks only the third time that the party has been above 15 in the index since the end of World War II.

It’s an interesting article that you might want to take a glance at. As far as the White House goes the only poll that matters is the one conducted on the first Tuesday of November, 2016 and no index of party strength will change.

That having been said, I believe that Democrats would do well to call a moratorium on dismissing the Republicans as the party of the past or a spent force and pay more attention to the here and now. It’s a failing that progressives frequently have. Training their eyes firmly on the horizon may result in mistaken judgments about the present.

8 comments

Please, Sir, I Want Some More

I think there a clear lesson in Matthew Ladner’s bill of indictment against the public schools:

The unacknowledged elephant in the room- the inescapable fact that the poor have been the primary victims of the failure of the public school system to produce a decent return on investment for the massive increase in public K-12 spending. Several generations of Americans have attended public schools increasingly generously funded and staffed over the decades, and always at globally enviable levels. I’m at a loss to imagine how anyone can blame inter-generational poverty on under investment in public education when such investment can only be described as both substantial and increasing for many decades.

and it is not that we should spend a lot more on them. We spend more on every basis—per capita or overall—than any other country in the world. Just as with our healthcare system we are not receiving value for the money we spend. We are not under-investing. They are under-delivering.

The lesson is that we deserve more from our public education system. The poor deserve more. Everyone deserves more.

12 comments

Structural Problems With the Economy

At the New York Times Tyler Cowen points out something that should be obvious to all but the most tenaciously partisan—the problems with the U. S. economy aren’t ordinary cyclical problems any more:

It is hard to avoid the feeling that our current economic problems are more than just a cyclical downturn. We know that the economy has gone through some bad times. But what exactly are we experiencing?

One relatively optimistic view is that observed deficiencies — like slow growth in real wages and the overall economy, persistently low interest rates and low levels of labor participation — are merely temporary. In this view, these problems will dwindle after manageable problems like high levels of public or household debt have been reduced.

Another commonly heard view is that we made the mistake of letting the last recession linger too long, allowing some of its features to became entrenched. That analysis suggests that if we correct past policy errors, whatever they may have been, an underlying normality will re-emerge.

Both of those proposals—the deficiencies are temporary and they’ve the consequence of mishandling the late recession—are nonsense. We’ve had most of the problems for decades. Just as a thin wash of colored pigment will bring up even small hills and valleys on a white-painted surface, so the late recession has highlighted the problems we’ve been struggling with since the George H. W. Bush Administration (at least). New businesses are not being created at the rate they used to. New jobs are not being created at the rate they used to. Economic surplus overwhelmingly goes to producers. The gains from trade accrue to the wealthiest as do increases in income and wealth.

If you’ve been reading this blog for a while you might have some ideas on how that might have happened but if you’re just passing by, that might come to you as a bolt from the blue.

Over at OTB the very first comment on Doug’s post on this same article takes time out to pat President Obama on the back (something he hardly needs help with). If you believe that federal stimulus ended recession in 2009 or prevented a second recession from starting in that year, you necessarily believe that the measures taken during the George W. Bush Administration did the trick. Money did not begin being disbursed under the “stimulus package”, the America Recovery and Reinvestment Act, until later. What, then, did the ARRA accomplish?

I think it’s been sufficiently documented that it didn’t do much, at least not the “infrastructure spending” component of it. For one thing, as the president has acknowledged, there’s no such thing as a “shovel-ready project”. Secondly, most of the projects had already been approved at the state and local level. There wasn’t a great deal of stimulus provided. They just moved money from one pocket to another.

We need serious changes to our economy. That’s the long and the short of it. We import too much of what we consume. The businesses that have the cash (or credit) to invest are not sufficiently motivated to invest in the domestic economy. The labor market is too slack. Change those and you might see a recovery worthy of the name but I wouldn’t get my hopes up.

17 comments

Checking Illinois’s Options

Matthew Dietrich quotes Reboot Illinois’s take on the state’s options in dealing with its public pension problem. The strategies he lists are:

  • Raise taxes.
  • Amend the state’s constitution.
  • Dicker with the unions.

Illinois didn’t do much about its public pension problem the last time it raised taxes. There’s a time-inconsistency problem in assuming that it will do so this time around. Besides, the last time they double taxes without doubling revenue. That’s very, very bad. It means it’s a strategy with a shelf life and I strongly suspect they’d raise even less if they tried it again.

Amending the state’s constitution takes time we just don’t have. At least two years. It’s like the old prayer: Lord, send a cure! The disease is already here.

As to bargaining with the unions, at least here in Chicago (where the problems are probably the worst) the public employees’ unions have shown no willingness to hoss-trade. I’m not sure what the state or Chicago has to offer them anyway.

As I’ve said before and will no doubt say again if solving the problem were quick, painless, and easy we would’ve already solved it. It’s going to be long, painful, and difficult. The best approach is to agree on shared sacrifice with everyone joining hands and jumping together. I see no signs of that yet.

3 comments

The Con Argument Buried in the Pro Argument

In the middle of an editorial in favor of the Trans-Pacific Partnership Agreement, the managed trade pact with eleven Pacific Rim countries, the editors of the Wall Street Journal have managed to make a pretty good case against it:

The U.S. has trade pacts with 20 markets around the world, and those markets account for 47% of U.S. goods exports, according to the U.S. International Trade Administration. U.S. goods exports to trade-pact countries rose 64% from 2009 to 2014, far more rapidly than the 45% growth with the rest of the world.

Exports have increased by 415% with Chile (trade pact in 2004); 378% with Mexico (1994); 111% with Canada (1994); 90% with Australia (2005); 84% with Singapore (2004); 74% with Central America (2006); 61% with Peru (2009); 42% with Colombia (2012) and 26% with Panama (2012) since the respective trade deals took effect.

or, in other words, we already have bilateral “free trade” agreements with countries accounting for most of the trade we have with the countries of the TPP. How, specifically, does the TPP benefit us, given the presence of those agreements?

With the exception of Japan. Before rendering judgment on the agreement, I’d like to know the details. I cannot believe that Japan will surrender its agricultural subsidies, quotas, etc. (or that we will surrender ours).

The arguments in favor of the agreement nearly all surround Ricardo’s teachings about free trade. Nothing that Ricardo ever wrote supports the idea that trade cannot be managed to benefit one trading partner at the expense of the other. Whatever emerges from the agreement we can be confident that it won’t be free trade. Free trade would require us to abandon not only our agricultural subsidies but our intellectual property laws and occupational licensing. Does anyone really believe that will happen?

What the agreement will do is pick winners and losers. So, the devil, as they say, is in the details and the details are being kept under lock and key.

0 comments

Summary

The biggest foreign policy story of the day is the Trans-Pacific Partnership agreement. The biggest stories in world events are the story of Ramadi, capitol of Iraq’s Anbar province, falling to the Islamist terrorist organization DAESH and the ongoing war between Saudi Arabia and Houthi forces in Yemen. The biggest political story of the day is the ongoing revelations of corruption surrounding the activities of the allegedly charitable Clinton Foundation which, as well as anyone can tell, exists primary to raise money, create an empire, and support the Clintons’ lifestyle. The media story of George Stephanopoulous’s serial failures of journalistic ethics can be subsumed under that.

I think the most important domestic story of the day has got to be the phlegmatic U. S. economy. A whole phalanx of other domestic stories from public employee pension crises as far as the eye can see to riots in Baltimore and even problems with the police in community after community can be laid at the feet of economic growth inadequate to bring prosperity to all Americans rather than just a few.

How am I doing?

17 comments

Gambling and Inequality

I can see I’m not nearly as libertarian as Scott Sumner is. In a recent post he makes the interesting and non-obvious observation that as presently operated state lotteries are a very regressive form of tax:

Today I’ll focus on another policy shift that would reduce inequality—sharply cutting the tax on lottery tickets, which now absorbs roughly 40% of all money gambled in state lotteries. Here are some points worth considering:

This floored me: Americans in the 43 states where lotteries are legal spent $70 billion on lotto games in 2014.
Seventy billion? I thought. No, that’s impossible. That’s more than $230 for every man, woman, and child in those states–or $300 for each adult.

But it’s true: According to the North American Association of State and Provincial Lotteries, lotteries took in $70.1 billion in sales in the 2014 fiscal year. That’s more than Americans in all 50 states spent on sports tickets, books, video games, movie tickets, and recorded music sales. . . .

Lotteries set aside about 40 percent of their ticket sales as state revenue that often goes to schools. Then, winners of more than $600 are subject to 45 percent windfall taxes on their good fortune. “The house” is winning, even when it’s losing.

But it’s the poor who are really losing. The poorest third of households buy half of all lotto tickets, according to a Duke University study in the 1980s, in part because lotteries are advertised most aggressively in poorer neighborhoods.

Basically, lotteries are a very inefficient transfer from low income earners to other low income earners. I would think that we would want to encourage transfers from higher income earners to lower income earners but apparently not.

I’m not sure that analysis is complete. I think you’d need to factor in the income effects of the state spending the lottery revenues support. Since the state spending goes overwhelmingly to support the income of people in the professional class who earn between $60,000 and $300,000, I think that lotteries are probably an even more regressive form of taxation.

But that’s true about gambling more generally. In places where gambling is legalized most of the money is spent by people in the lower third of income earner who, except in a very small number of places, live locally. The proceeds go either to national gambling operators (like Donald Trump) who don’t live where the gambling is going on or to the state where it has the same economic effects as state-sponsored lotteries. There’s a transfer from the localities in which gambling takes place to other localities.

I also want to remark on his aversion to banning lotteries:

Some misguided people want to help the poor by banning state lotteries. But that would make things even worse. Buyers would have to rely on the black market, or drive all the way to New Hampshire or Rhode Island to buy their tickets. The solution is simple, cut the state’s take from 40% to 10%, and make up the lost revenue through higher sales and property taxes, where the burden is shared more fairly across all of society.

I’m not so sure about his point about sales and property taxes is correct but I think his observation about black markets is even worse. I believe it’s based on the frequent untrue assertion usually phrased as “Prohibition didn’t work”. That is only true if you think that the purpose of Prohibition was to eliminate the consumption of alcohol. It wasn’t. The Volstead Act had provisions that allowed people to make beer and wine for their own use. Its purpose was to reduce alcohol abuse and it was quite effective in doing that. The rate of alcohol abuse declined sharply when Prohibition was enacted and did not recover to its previous high rate.

While I agree with him that it’s obvious that ending state-sponsored lotteries wouldn’t eliminate lotteries, I’m skeptical that it wouldn’t reduce the rate at which people spend money on lottery tickets. He hasn’t proved it. He’s just claimed it.

5 comments

What Will the Run-On Effects of the PPACA Be?

I’m going to have to re-read Casey B. Mulligan’s post at City Journal about the economic consequences of the PPACA. I may disagree with his conclusions. I think it’s inescapably true that the PPACA will tend to push total compensation down for the reasons that Dr. Mulligan outlines in his post. But what will the other run-on effects be? I think it may tend to improve economic efficiency.

As a higher proportion of total compensation is paid in the form of wages rather than non-wage compensation, the advantage that non-wage compensation confers on some employers at the expense of others will tend to be eroded and economic efficiency will increase. Some of that efficiency may be captured by employees in the form of wages rather than employers in the form of profits. We can always dream, can’t we?

There was one thing that caught my eye:

The law defines a large employer as one with at least 50 full-time-equivalent employees in the calendar year prior to the one in which it failed to provide coverage.

I wish that the federal government in all its wonderful variety of forms would settle on a definition of “large business” that matches any sane intuitive definition of “large business”. Let’s do a little back of the envelope calculation. We’ll use round numbers to make things easier. If you multiply a median wage of $50,000 by 50, you get $2.5 million. Add 30% for non-wage compensation and it boosts your employment costs to $3.4 million. What to you want to use to estimate non-payroll expenses? You know, everything other than payroll costs? Two times? Three times? Let’s use two times or non-payroll expenses of $3.4 million. That gives us total expenses of $6.8 million. If your operating margin is 8% (something a lot of business would kill for) that gives you about $7.5 million. That’s a small business by the definition used in just about every state. If the non-payroll expenses are ten times payroll costs (unthinkable as far as I’m concerned), it would give you (assuming our unrealistic profits) of right around $38 million. That’s a medium sized business by just about any reckoning. Just a little perspective.

At any rate, read the whole thing. It might give you a little different perspective on the PPACA.

3 comments

Why Did ABC Hire George Stephanopoulos?

I wanted to remark on the recent story that’s hit the news, that previous Clinton Administration functionary and present ABC new anchor George Stephanopoulos has contributed substantial sums to the Clinton Foundation or one of its large web of organization and foundations. I’ll repeat what I’ve been saying for years.

It was unseemly at the very least for ABC News to hire George Stephanopoulous in the first place. There might have been some argument for hiring him as a consultant but hiring him as an anchor is teetering on the brink of a breach of journalistic ethics already. Allowing him to interview the Clintons or former administration officials steps over that brink. Ethics has required him to recuse himself from interviewing them all along.

The question I think we need to be asking ourselves is why did ABC hire Mr. Stephanopoulos in the first place? I think it’s undoubtedly to allow him to perform exactly these sorts of activities. They wanted his contacts.

Being an honest, decent political correspondent is hard enough to begin with without allowing political apparatchiki to saunter into the top jobs in the field. You’ve got to build knowledge, contacts, and a reputation for fairness over a period of years. It’s that much more difficult when the top jobs go to people who are partisan operatives.

More than a half century ago Ike warned prophetically about a military industrial complex that threatened democracy in America. Now we’re faced with a media non-profit complex that poses a very similar threat. It’s no accident. There has been a deliberate Gramscian “long march” and Mr. Stephanopolous’s ongoing breaches of ethics illustrate just how effective it has been.

17 comments