There was an interesting observation made in my post yesterday reacting to Sean Trende’s observations about the state of the Republican Party to the effect of a prediction that Midwestern and Southern states would experience a sharp out-migration while, presumably, those on the East and West Coasts would see in-migration. If I misinterpreted that comment I apologize in advance.
The graphic above, courtesy of Governing.com, (which I suspect will play hob with my format but you can’t have everything) depicts in-migration and out-migration by state in 2011. That’s the most recent I could find. If the commenter’s prediction is coming true, it isn’t exactly coming true yet. As you can see Midwestern states are experiencing out-migration and the leader of the pack is Illinois, the most Democratic state in the Midwest. Southern states are experiencing in-migration with the most in-migration being seen in the very Republican state of Texas. The most populous East and West Coast states, New York and California, respectively, are experiencing substantial out-migration.
I do not believe that the more-or-less current patterns reflect what the commenter was implying—that Republicans would drive people out of their states. That doesn’t appear to be happening. Indeed, if you can make a simple generalization based on statistics it would be the opposite.
Before I close I want to caution against too simple an interpretation. The statistics say nothing about just who is migrating. It could be that Democrats and Republicans are equally likely to leave their home states in search of greener pastures, it might be that Republicans are more likely to leave, or it could be that Democrats are. Texas could become more Republican rather than less or vice versa. Ditto for California. It depends.
And it all depends on whether you believe in the persistence theory. I tend not to but would be more predisposed to think about equilibria. It might be that Americans are seeking some sort of equilibrium and when that is reached the present trends will slow or even reverse. It can all be summed up in two words: it’s complicated.






