Why Does Obama Want the TPP?

In his musings on why the president is pushing so hard for his Trans-Pacific Partnership agreement, it takes William Finnegan quite a few column inches before he lurches uncontrollably on to the most likely answer: the president very badly wants a foreign policy legacy and the remainder of his attempts at securing a victory in that area haven’t been working out too well.

The question I’ve asked in the past is a little different. We already have bilateral “free trade” agreements with countries representing most of the GDP and most of the trade in the countries of the TPP other than Japan. Is Japan really likely to, for example, open its agricultural markets to us in any reasonable way.

Supporters of the agreement have been unable to mount any defenses of it other than the most anodyne of generic defenses of free trade for an important reason: they’ve been sworn to secrecy.

Once again, this agreement is not a free trade agreement. You can write a free trade agreement on the back of a napkin and agree to it over dinner. The length of the negotiations alone tells you it’s a managed trade agreement and such agreements are only good for us conditioned on the specific terms and the specific terms are secret.

It’s all very mysterious.

8 comments

The First Step on the Road to Recovery Is Recognizing That You Have a Problem—Middle East Edition

While reading George Friedman’s lengthy disquisition at RealClearWorld on the events of the last twenty or so years resulting in, in his words, “fragmentation”, a number of questions occurred to me.

Why is it better for us to try to sustain late 19th and early 20th century policies than it was for us to try to sustain late 19th and early 20th century French policies?

How does sustaining Britain’s policies help us?

How does supporting the present foreign policy objectives of the former colonial powers help us?

Is Iran a force that encourages stability in the Middle East?

Is the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia still a force that encourages stability in the Middle East?

Is it possible for us to secure israel’s foreign policy objectives for them? Is it desireable?

Are our objectives of the 1970s in the Middle East still our objectives today? If not, what are our objectives today?

10 comments

Taken Aback

I was taken aback by this statement from Stephen Schwarzman in the opening of his Wall Street Journal op-ed:

After the financial crisis, a focus on safety and soundness was good medicine for the financial system. New bank liquidity and capital policies, among other initiatives, strengthened a debilitated patient. The banking system is now stronger, with more liquid assets and better underwriting standards.

Despite good intentions, however, politicians and regulators constructed an expansive and untested regulatory framework that will have unintended consequences for liquidity in our financial system. Taken together, these regulatory changes may well fuel the next financial crisis as well as slow U.S. economic growth.

The problem with U. S. banks was never one of liquidity but of solvency and that’s the big question now. Are the big banks solvent? Or do they still hold a lot of worthless paper which, if they were compelled to get rid of, would reveal just how insolvent they are? If they are solvent, Fed policy is even harder to understand than it is.

The balance of the op-ed is an attack on Dodd-Frank and bank regulation more generally. I’d have a lot more sympathy with that point of view if the big banks didn’t have a certainty founded on experience that there isn’t much they could do that they won’t be indemnified against.

2 comments

The Fading Vote

There’s a good illustration of the point I’ve been making about the problems that low voter turnout may pose for Hillary Clinton in this account at the Washington Post of the plight of the black voters of Jacksonville, Florida:

While supporting Obama became a cause for many here rather than a typical campaign, Clinton faces a higher bar in making a case that she, too, can be a transformative figure.

Her campaign is planning to build on the multiethnic coalition that turned out to support Obama. Running to be the first female president, Clinton will also try to generate Obama-like enthusiasm among new voters — those who were too young to turn out for Obama or have not previously been engaged with politics.

Yet as her allies prepare to register voters and expand the black electorate, her candidacy presents residents here with a question: If Obama’s presidency didn’t do more to help African Americans, then how could hers?

As long as the Democratic Party is confident it can depend on their votes, it will have other priorities.

1 comment

The Incredible Shrinking State

Illinois’s cities are shrinking:

Out of Illinois’ largest 27 cities, 17 shrank in population and 10 grew from 2013 to 2014.

New data from the U.S. Census Bureau shine a light on the annual growth and decline of cities across America. The Census Bureau looked at all 746 American cities with a population of more than 50,000 people, and projected their annual population changes. Unfortunately for the Land of Lincoln, the majority of Illinois cities are shrinking and come in near the bottom of the national rankings.

Only Naperville and Elgin ranked in the top 50 percent nationally for growth. The other 25 Illinois cities were clustered near the bottom of the pile, with Rockford ranking 737 out of 746 U.S. cities and Decatur ranking 744 out of 746.

The article is accompanied by a chart documenting the growth statistics of Illinois’s cities with greater than 50,000 population.

It might be that people are moving from the cities into the surrounding areas. Suburbanization isn’t just for megalopolises. But, since Illinois’s has substantial net outmigration it isn’t much of a stretch to think that people are just pulling up stakes and leaving.

When the population of a city or a state shrinks so does its tax base. Unfortunately, city budgets don’t shrink automatically to accommodate the loss of revenue. Which gets you to where a lot of Illinois cities are to day. Immigration might help if all of the new immigrants were on the books so to speak and they produced net for the cities, counties, or the state. It takes a pretty healthy income for a family of four with a mom and dad and a couple of school age kids to produce net revenue.

1 comment

Since They Don’t Match the Theory, the Data Must Be Wrong

I’m commenting on this post at NewtonBlog because it ties in so neatly with a few things I’ve written lately. Ross Pomeroy reports on a Mayo Clinic study on why nutrition and diet studies are so lousy:

Every five years, the Dietary Guidelines Advisory Committee, composed of nutrition and health experts from around the country, convenes to review the latest scientific and medical literature. From their learned dissection, they form the dietary guidelines.

But according to a new editorial published in Mayo Clinic Proceedings, much of the science they review is fundamentally flawed. Unlike experiments in the hard sciences of chemistry, physics, and biology, which rely on direct observational evidence, most diet studies are based on self-reported data. Study subjects are examined for height, weight, and health, then are questioned about what they eat. Their dietary choices are subsequently linked to health outcomes — cancer, mortality, heart disease, etc.

That’s a poor way of doing science, says Edward Archer, a research fellow with the Nutrition Obesity Research Center at the University of Alabama, and lead author of the report.

“The assumption that human memory can provide accurate or precise reproductions of past ingestive behavior is indisputably false,” he and his co-authors write.

Two of the largest studies on nutritional intake in the United States, the CDC’s NHANES and “What We Eat,” are based on asking subjects to recall precisely what and how much they usually eat.

But despite all of the steps that NHANES examiners take to aid recall, such as limiting the recall period to the previous 24 hours and even offering subjects measuring guides to help them report accurate data, the information received is wildly inaccurate. An analysis conducted by Archer in 2013 found that most of the 60,000+ NHANES subjects report eating a lower amount of calories than they would physiologically need to survive, let alone to put on all the weight that Americans have in the past few decades.

Please note a few things. First, testimony is lousy evidence. I agree with that. However, the conclusion about that should not be that, since people’s self-reported “dietary choices” don’t conform to the simple thermodynamics theory of diet (calories in minus calories expended through exercise equals net weight gain or loss), people must be lying. The conclusion should be that better studies are needed, ones that don’t rely on self-reporting. It’s possible, even likely that the simple thermodynamics theory is wrong. For example, if the simple thermodynamics explains 100% of weight loss or gain, how do you explain the frequently observed weight loss after fecal transplant?

1 comment

Battlespace Preparation

Michael Mandel of the Progressive Policy Institute questions President Obama’s embrace of the Base Erosion and Profit Shifting Project, an OECD initiative:

As they are being developed, the BEPS rules — mainly written at the headquarters of the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, in Paris — will not be likely to generate more tax revenues for the United States. Instead, the BEPS rules, as written, will encourage American companies to quickly move high-paying jobs such as those of research scientists and software developers to Europe to take advantage of lower tax rates.

In other words, unless Congress acts quickly to reform the ossified American corporate tax system, the BEPS rules have the potential to turn into an enormous job-and-revenue grab by Europe, and an enormous loss of jobs and revenues by the United States.

How does this work? The BEPS rules would do two things. First, they would close the most egregious international tax loopholes. Most multinationals would end up paying more taxes to someone, somewhere. That’s good.

But the project also changes the international tax rules by forcing companies to pay corporate taxes according to the location of the economic activity and value creation generating their profits. At first blush, that would seem to benefit the United States, home to much of the world’s innovation and many innovative companies. Certainly the Obama administration seems to think so, because it continues to support the BEPS effort.

But the administration’s support is rooted in political anti-corporate rhetoric rather than cold hard analysis.

Note that the Progressive Policy Institute is an outgrowth of the now-defunct Democratic Leadership Council, the Bill Clinton-led “New Democratic” caucus within the Democratic Party.

That BEPS is not in the U. S. interest seems obvious but I’d be interested in seeing the counter-argument. My interpretation of this blue-on-blue attack is that it’s battlespace preparation and that if you think the Obama Administration was corporatist, you ain’t seen nothin’ yet.

There’s also an obvious strategy for mitigating any risks presented by BEPS: the U. S. should bring its corporate income tax into line with international standards. I don’t, however, see anything about that in Mr. Mandel’s op-ed.

3 comments

Restraint

I agree with the Bloomberg editors that we should show restraint in the aftermath of the hacking of the Office of Personnel Management’s information:

Applying big-data tools to such a vast trove might yield insights into U.S. intelligence and military strategy, expose a revealing web of government relationships, or find unexpected correlations that Chinese analysts could exploit. In short: This is bad. The U.S. would be within its rights to respond aggressively.

It shouldn’t.

Restraint, though unsatisfying, is the prudent response.

I disagree, however, on what a restrained response would be. Nuking Beijing would show a lack of restraint. Mitigating the risks posed by Chinese hacking by, for example, blocking Chinese sites from access to the United States entirely would not be. There are 1,001 measured, restrained moves that are exquisitely painful and punishing to the Chinese government that we can and should make.

IMO the editors at Bloomberg make a mistake we’ve seen a lot of lately—claiming that any response is an over-reaction. Here’s another example. Invading Iraq was a mistake but it wasn’t an over-reaction. If anything, it was an under-reaction. We really need to learn to distinguish between restraint and passivity.

To repurpose another phrase I’ve heard a lot of lately we cannot value a good relationship with the Chinese more than they value a good relationship with us and, pretty clearly, they don’t value that relationship nearly enough. Friends don’t hack into other friends’ computers.

1 comment

Brokedown Machine

For the last ten years here at The Glittering Eye I’ve been making the point that societies are machines, tools which have been created by trial and error and found to be working (more or less), and arise out of the fabric of the societies themselves. What is considered desireable and acceptable here in the United States would be intolerable in, say, the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, and vice versa. This point comes up most frequently when somebody points out how well a strategy works in the Netherlands, Denmark, or Luxembourg and why don’t we do that here? The Scandinavian model is darned hard to transplant out of Scandinavia. Political consensus is really much easier when so many of the people in the society belong to the same ethnic group, are members of the same social class, and belong to the same religion. In the instance, for example, of Sweden that would be Lutheranism. 90% of Swedes are Lutherans, at least historically.

Now via Megan McArdle Dan Drezner makes a different argument for why we can’t import the social strategies that work elsewhere into the U. S. and expect them to work:

Every year these rankings come out, and the same cycle repeats. American columnists rend their garments about how life is better in Scandinavia, and the United States needs to do better. Chinese commentators say nothing and silently fume at Norwegian thriving. Expatriates carp that things aren’t that great in Scandinavia.

[Actual Scandinavians are way too polite to brag about any of this, but you know that, in the comfort of their own homes, they nibble on their lutefisk and chuckle at how the Scandinavian film version of “The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo” is so superior to the Hollywood version.]

Enough. Here’s a crazy thought: What if life is better in these small countries because of the United States?

That sounds jingoistic of me, I know. But I’m not the one making this argument. Daron Acemoglu, James Robinson, and Thierry Verdier are the ones making this argument. You can read the full paper (pdf), or read their precis in VoxEU.

In essence, they argue that everyone benefits from technological innovation, and that technological innovation is more likely to thrive in an economy where “incentives for workers and entrepreneurs results in greater inequality and greater poverty.” This is the cut-throat capitalist model. The other option is to create an economy with generous social protections and safety nets. They dub this the “cuddly capitalist” model.

I think the question the rest of the world should be thinking right now is what if they’re killing the goose that laid the golden eggs? What if the United States actually becomes more like Sweden? And along with that transformation comes slower growth, slower job creation, fewer imports, and less ability or willingness to allow other countries to be free riders on our defense spending, healthcare spending, and consumer spending?

The prospect that should concern us is that we’re not likely to become more like Sweden, France, or Singapore. It’s a lot more likely we’ll become more like Mexico or Brazil.

11 comments

Simplify!

Imagine the perfect financial regulatory agency. Such an agency could only continue to be perfect if nothing ever changed or if it could always anticipate every possible move by people wishing to exploit the deficiencies in the regulatory system instantaneously and it would allocate capital where it was needed without friction and instantaneously. Now read David Dayen’s remarks on “rationalizing” financial regulation:

The truth is that, regardless of what you think of the Dodd-Frank reform law, the financial regulatory system we have is incredibly unintelligently designed. Overlapping responsibilities, an alphabet soup of agencies zealously guarding their jurisdictions and a lack of a clear hierarchy has created such a morass that major problems can easily fall through the gaps. Think of the worst organizational chart you can imagine — like the one for Initech, the fictional company from Office Space, where Peter Gibbons has eight different bosses — and make it a little worse, and that’s what our financial regulatory apparatus looks like. Nobody would start from scratch and design oversight this way.

[…]

This process of rationalization has some key features:

• The Financial Stability Oversight Council (FSOC) would get new independence as a super-regulator with broad oversight authority of the entire system. The Office of Financial Research would similarly get shifted out of the Treasury Department and have its own data collection mandate.

• A new Prudential Supervisory Agency (PSA) would be responsible for the supervisory authority now stretched across five different federal agencies, examining banks, systemically important financial institutions (SIFIs), investment dealers, money market funds and more.

• The Federal Reserve would do rulemaking, but the PSA could propose regulations for them to approve. It would also have some oversight authority in concert with the FSOC.

• The Federal Deposit Insurance Commission would focus on deposit insurance and orderly liquidation of failed firms and get out of the primary supervision business.

• The Office of the Comptroller of the Currency, which currently regulates nationally chartered banks, would be eliminated.

• The SEC and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission would be combined into one regulator with responsibility for investor protection and capital market conduct.

Some random observations about Mr. Dayen’s preferred “rationalization”. It would be most effective the first day it opened its door and would deteriorate over time. How do I know that? We’ve been studying bureaucracies for the last 150 years and one of the things we know about them is that over time they stray from their notional mandate and devote increasingly more time, attention, and resources to organizational purposes. Note, too, that in the world Mr. Dayen envisions regulators are never coopted by the institutions they’re supposed to be regulating (“regulatory capture”) but always devote themselves unswervingly to their mandates. Regulatory capture of financial regulatory agencies is so obvious as to hardly require additional proof.

I’ve quoted the testimony around here before on the sources of the financial crisis. It wasn’t that no one had the authority to rein in the excesses or that the structure of regulation was too complicated. It was that the agencies with the mandates and authority didn’t bother to do their jobs.

In actuality there is a perfect financial regulatory agency along the lines I described in the opening paragraph of this post. It’s called “the market”. Like Christianity or communism the market is not a case of having been tried and found wanting but of having been found difficult and not tried. We do not presently have a market system and have not for at least the last century. We have a hybrid system and it’s not working very well.

What will inevitably happen with any regulatory agency, agencies, or structure is that their every move will be matched by the cleverest people in the world who have every incentive to do so to wring a buck out of the nooks and crannies of the system. More complicated even more adaptive structures can’t hope to match that. The only possible opposing force to an emerging phenomenon is another emerging phenomenon.

7 comments