The Tragedy of Robert E. Lee

As explained by Aristotle among the defining factors in tragedy is the character (ethos) of the hero. The hero must be a great and good man whose downfall (hamartia) comes through an error produced by what has been called a “tragic flaw”, usually pride (hubris).

If any individual in American history cries out to have his story portrayed in art as a tragedy, it must be Robert E. Lee. That he was a great and a good man can hardly be doubted. Kinsman of George Washington, at the top of his class at West Point, brilliant general and scholar. He was by all accounts a gentleman in every sense of the word. His downfall also rose from a tragic flaw, placing his state above his country.

Bourgeois country that we are we do not produce great tragedies. Our art is more predisposed to comedy, e.g. Huckleberry Finn, the greatest of American novels, or melodrama, e.g. Gone With the Wind, the Civil War epic that laid the groundwork for so many that have followed. There have been some gallant attempts at producing a genuine tragedy that is legitimately American. The closest is probably Arthur Miller’s play Death of a Salesman but Theodore Dreiser’s An American Tragedy and F. Scott Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby also clearly have aspirations in that direction. They’re all melodramas.

In terms of artistry and returning to the American Civil War, I would commend to your attention Stephen Vincent Benet’s novel length narrative poem, John Brown’s Body. Here’s a snippet:

There were three stout pillars that held up all
The weight and tradition of Wingate Hall.
One was Cudjo and one was you
And the third was the mistress, Mary Lou.
Mary Lou Wingate, as slightly made
And as hard to break as a rapier-blade.
Bristol’s daughter and Wingate’s bride,
Never well since the last child died
But staring at pain with courteous eyes.
When the pain outwits it, the body dies,
Meanwhile the body bears the pain.
She loved her hands and they made her vain,
The tiny hands of her generation
That gathered the reins of the whole plantation;
The velvet sheathing the steel demurely
In the trained, light grip that holds so surely.

[…]

Let us look at her now, let us see her plain,
She will never be quite like this again.
Her house is rocking under the blast
And she hears it tremble, and still stands fast,
But this is the last, this is the last.
The last of the wine and the white corn meal,
The last high fiddle singing the reel,
The last of the silk with the Paris label,
The last blood-thoroughbred safe in the stable
—Yellow corn meal and a jackass colt,
A door that swings on a broken bolt,
Brittle old letters spotted with tears
And a wound that rankles for fifty years—
This is the last of Wingate Hall,
The last bright August before the Fall,
Death has been near, and Death has passed,
But this is the last, this is the last.

I think it’s a beautiful, evocative work and I have substantial chunks of it committed to memory (including the passage above) but it, too, is a melodrama.

Yesterday Pat Lang leapt to the defense of Gen. Lee, his fellow Virginian:

I just heard Eleanor Clift the “liberal” journalist call Lee a traitor on MSNBC. IMO that description only applies to him and the rest of them if the notion prevails that the right of secession did not exist.

That was decided in blood 150 years ago. There is no right of secession.

In one of the most cold-blooded of acts of vengeance that I can recall in American history the victors in the American Civil War took Lee’s beautiful family estate, Arlington, and turned it into a cemetery for Union dead.

25 comments

The Terrorist Attacks Last Week

Nearly lost in the domestic news of last week were several foreign affairs stories that should have received greater attention. There were significant terrorist attacks in France, Tunisia, and Kuwait on a company, tourists, and a Shi’ite mosque, respectively. Patrick Bahzad provides an excellent outline and analysis of the attack in France, better than anything I’ve read in the professional media:

At approximately 10 a.m. this morning, a van entered an chemical production site in the suburbs of Lyons, in south-eastern France. Contrary to what was said in previous reports, the van didn’t crash the security gate, but had proper clearance to enter the premises, a facility registered on the so-called “Seveso List” (a list of sites producing hazardous dioxin-like compounds).

Are the connecting links among these attacks? They all appear to have been perpetrated by Sunni Muslim radicals. The French and Tunisian attacks were not only calculated to maximize terror but to attack the economic life of the countries as well.

Perhaps the message in these three attacks is that an organized mass attack is not necessary to create havoc. It doesn’t take the Third Reich or the Imperial Japanese Army any more. All it takes is a few highly motivated individuals with guns, knives, and trucks. I doubt that efforts at banning guns, knives, and trucks will prove successful.

15 comments

Echoes of History

One of the things that made my ears prick up about the horrific murders in Charleston was when I heard the name of one of the victims, the man whom President Obama eulogized yesterday: Pinckney. I wonder how many people are aware that Pinckney is an old South Carolinian name? Charles Cotesworth Pinckney fought in the Revolutionary War, ultimately rising to the rank of general, was a strong supporter of Washington, and was one of South Carolina’s delegates to the Constitutional Convention.

And he owned slaves. Pinckney Island Plantation was one of his holdings and I have little doubt that the ancestors of the black South Carolina Pinckneys were owned by Gen. Pinckney.

I also wonder if President Obama knows that the song that he intoned as he finished his eulogy, Amazing Grace, was written by a reformed slave trader?

As William Faulkner said, the past is never dead. It’s not even past.

2 comments

In Re: Obergefell

In their editorial on the Supreme Court’s decision in Obergefell v. Hodges after lengthy throat-clearing they finally arrive at my view:

Justice Kennedy writes that expanding the definition of marriage to include gay couples would “pose no risk of harm to themselves or third parties.” We hope he’s right in practice, and that if he’s wrong he’ll protect the liberty rights of those who disagree with him.

Update

Sasha Volokh has what I think is a good post which makes the observation I made when the Massachusetts case that got this whole snowball rolling was decided:

An equal protection holding based on fundamental interests means that if marriage exists, there can’t be unreasonable discrimination, but you could still abolish marriage altogether — which seems correct to me.

The point is that good law and good policy point in the same direction here. If there is a liberty interest in marriage, the key to the Court’s arguments, then the better policy decision is to require that the states abolish civil marriage.

15 comments

Casualties

There are some obvious candidates for what would be casualties if Greece exits the euro, most obviously Greece and the German, Dutch, and Luxembourger banks that extended too much credit to the Greek government. Mohammed El-Erian points out that another, less obvious casualty would be the International Monetary Fund:

All sides are working hard to prevent Greece from defaulting on its debt obligations to the International Monetary Fund — and with good reason: Such an outcome would have dire consequences not only for Greece and Europe but also for the international monetary system.

The problem with his op-ed is that he’s saying it as though it would be a bad thing. The IMF is not a monetary sovereign. It’s dependent on big countries that are for its backstop ability. In other words it’s only nominally the “lender of last resort”. The big monetary sovereigns are. The unelected, unanswerable, and irresponsible IMF allows big countries to behave recklessly while insulating them from the political consequences of their folly.

0 comments

What We Don’t Eat

There’s a fun article at Smithsonian on foods that used to be popular in the United States but aren’t any more. These include roasted beaver tail, perry, and syllabub.

The three basic factors seem to be cost, a long-term trend away from foods whose sources are too obvious, and marketing. For example, there’s no particular reason that hard cider has made a comeback in recent years while perry, also known as pear cider or “baby cham”, hasn’t.

4 comments

The Decision in King v. Burwell

As you undoubtedly know by now, the Supreme Court has ruled in favor of the defendant in King v. Burwell, the suit challenging subsidies paid to people insured under the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act who live in states that did not set up exchanges. You’ll undoubtedly hear bickering back and forth but the PPACA is definitely the law of the land and early statements from the Congressional Republican leadership suggest that they accept that.

The good news in the Court’s decision is obvious: millions of people won’t lose their subsidies. The bad news is less obvious. One bit of bad news is that the Court has again taken it on itself to reward the Pelosi-Reid Congress for slovenly work. Don’t be surprised if at some point SCOTUS is forced to throw the Congress a brushback pitch. It can’t allow itself to become Congress’s whipping boy.

From my point of view the worst piece of news in the decision is that the lesson the Congress will learn from this is to minimize its paper trail.

Supporters of the PPACA including the Obama Administration are understandably elated at the outcome. The president’s signature piece of legislation is secure and will survive through the end of his presidency and likely beyond. I’ve already seen claims that the Court rejected a flimsy, frivolous attack on the PPACA. That’s a mistaken view that Chief Justice Roberts expressly rejected in his decision, characterizing the plaintiff’s case as a strong one. Another obvious outcome: the decision was made at least as much on policy grounds as it was on legal ones.

14 comments

Other Than That, Mrs. Lincoln

Does anybody else find this study as obnoxious as I do?

The New America Foundation found that twice as many people have died in attacks by right-wing groups in America than by Muslim extremists since 9/11.

First off, it’s incredibly fatuous. When you drill down into the study itself you’re left with a somewhat different conclusion. If you exclude the largest terrorist attack not merely in U. S. history but in the history of the world, you’re left with fewer than a hundred deaths via terrorism in the U. S. over a period of 15 years. From that I draw two conclusions. First, that in a country of more than 300 million people a few nutcases will inevitably kill some people an claim political motives for it. No foreseeable law, enforcement, or anything else will stop that. It’s a combination of sheer numbers and personal empowerment.

Also by the logic of the red shoes it tells you that concern about mass terrorist attacks, particularly mass terrorist attacks with state backing, are a legitimate concern. Who are today’s candidates for such state sponsorship? Saudi Arabia, Iran, and Pakistan. It’s just not Russia’s style. And China’s anti-U. S. actions are targeted at gain rather than terror.

13 comments

There Are No Presidential Candidates

I’m getting tired of writing about the security breach at at the Office of Personnel Management. I just finished reading the Wall Street Journal editors’ take:

While little noticed, the IRS admitted this spring it was also the subject of a Russian hack, in which thieves grabbed 100,000 tax returns and requested 15,000 fraudulent refunds. Officials have figured out that the hackers used names and Social Security data to pretend to be the taxpayers and break through weak IRS cyber-barriers. As Wisconsin Senator Ron Johnson has noted, the Health and Human Services Department and Social Security Administration use the same weak security wall to guard ObamaCare files and retirement information. Yet the Administration is hardly rushing to fix the problem.

Way back in March 2014, OPM knew that Chinese hackers had accessed its system without having downloaded files. So the agency was on notice as a target. It nonetheless failed to stop the two subsequent successful breaches. If this were a private federal contractor that had lost sensitive data, the Justice Department might be contemplating indictments.

Yet OPM director Katherine Archuleta and chief information officer Donna Seymour are still on the job. Mr. Obama has defended Ms. Archuleta, and the Administration is trying to change the subject by faulting Congress for not passing a cybersecurity bill. But that legislation concerns information sharing between business and government. It has nothing to do with OPM and the Administration’s failure to protect itself from cyber attack.

which illustrates not just rank incompetence but outright indifference to the nuts and bolts of running the government.

When Barack Obama first ran for the presidency in 2008, he was something of a cipher. At this point there are a few things we can say about him with some confidence. He’s got his eyes firmly on the history books. He has complete confidence in his own abilities and opinions. And he has almost complete indifference verging on disdain for either the process of managing the federal government or for ordinary politics.

Which brings us around to the field of those running for the presidency. We don’t need another Barack Obama at this point. Despite their large number there are few substantial candidates. I can only see three. First there’s Jeb Bush against whose candidacy I have grave reservations on republican grounds. Then there’s Rick Perry who strikes me as a charming, handsome numbskull. Finally, there’s Carly Fiorina who has an asterisk next to her name because of her ouster from HP.

On the Democratic side there’s bupkis. Hillary Clinton is neither an effective politician nor a manager. She’s basically Barack Obama in a pants suit. Bernie Sanders might be a politician but he’s no manager. Anybody else is hanging back.

Bring me giants!

12 comments

Do the Math

Jonah Bennett wonders why the U. S. Navy is paying Microsoft $9 million to support its Windows XP systems:

The Navy plans to eventually transfer away from outdated software, but in the meantime, the service is willing to spend more than $9 million dollars to maintain Windows XP on 100,000 workstations.What do you think?

Transition efforts to a new operating system kicked off in 2013, but two years wasn’t long enough to complete the process, leading the Space and Naval Warfare Systems Command to sign a contract with Microsoft to the tune of $9,149,000 dollars to keep old operating systems alive, The Hill reports. Adm. Jonathan W. Greenert issued a directive called “Windows XP Eradication Efforts” last year, detailing best practices for weaning the Navy off the platform.What do you think?

Over time, the contract may expand to $30.8 million dollars, which would stretch the lifespan of the XP systems up until 2017, even though Microsoft considers the product obsolete. The contract also includes support for Office 2003, Exchange 2003 and Windows Server 2003.

It’s easy to understand if you do the math. The old XP workstations will almost undoubtedly not support Windows 7 let alone something more recent. Even if it’s possible upgrading them will probably cost about the same as a new system. 100,000 systems X an average of $400 per system is $40 million. Even if the eventual cost of the contract is $30 million they’re still saving money.

6 comments