Chicago, desperate for revenue, has decided to push its power to impose transaction and amusement taxes about as far as they will go, wants to tax Chicagoans’ use of NetFlix, Spotify, and even online reference services used by businesses like YCharts:
Chicagoans who pay to stream movies and music from services like Netflix and Spotify will now need to fork over an additional 9 percent for the privilege, as will Chicago businesses that pay to use everything from real estate to court databases online, under a decision the city quietly made recently to expand its taxing power.
The added costs are the result of a ruling by the city Finance Department that extends the reach of ordinances governing two types of taxes — the city amusement tax and the city personal property lease transaction tax — to cover many products streamed to businesses and residents alike.
My offhand guess is that the city’s move has two problems: jurisdiction and vagueness. I can see the argument for taxing local services just as local theaters are taxed but it’s a lot harder for me to see how the city has any authority over services provided by companies that don’t have a physical Chicago presence. Additionally, everything on the Internet is arguably a service. How can you tax NetFlix and Hulu but not Youtube? Isn’t a search engine a service? Why wouldn’t the tax apply to Google or Microsoft as well? Because the services are “free”? They’re not free to their customers, the businesses that pay for search priority.
If this law holds up at all, I wouldn’t be a bit surprised if the city ends up paying more in legal fees that it can realize in revenues.






