It Takes Two to Tango

There isn’t a word today in Robert Samuelson’s column today on how Greece, Italy, Portugal, and Spain can escape high levels of debt without Germany abandoning its mercantilist policies:

The lopsided Greek vote — 61 percent to 39 percent — to reject a rescue package from the country’s creditors has cast the impasse into a high-stakes drama over the future of Europe. Greece itself is teetering on the edge of economic collapse. Its banks are virtually insolvent, limiting depositors to meager daily withdrawals of 60 euros ($66). European leaders have given Greece a five-day ultimatum (until Sunday) to reach agreement with lenders. If no agreement emerges, a chaotic situation will get worse. The government will exhaust its skimpy supply of euros and be forced to pay either in scrip (possibly including promises — not reliable — to convert the scrip into euros) or in a national currency, the drachma.

Germany is too large an economy to be as dependent as it is on exports. It should be spending euros in Greece or Italy rather than extracting them from Greece and Italy.

Germany did not recover after World War II solely by pulling itself up by its bootstraps. It needs to remember that.

1 comment

The Euro and the EU

In a column that consists largely of a “what can you expect from the wogs?” attitude towards Greece’s economic problems, George Will has a substantive remark on the EU:

The E.U. exists to require nations to “pool” their sovereignties in unelected, unaccountable bureaucracies. The retrograde point of the E.U. is to leech from national parliaments powers that were hard-won over many centuries of struggle. National governments rendered unserious by the E.U. are apt to regress to adolescence, as with Syriza’s referendum — a tantrum masquerading as governance.

Seventy years after the guns fell silent, the drive to turn “Europe” from a geographic into a political expression lacks the excuse of preventing continental convulsions caused by nationalistic militarisms. Now, the drive for “ever closer union” — which means ever-more attenuated democracy — is fueled by the traditional socialist (and, in the United States, the progressive) goal of expanding the reach of a mandarin class of supposed experts in social rationality.

or, in other words, the European Union is a move towards a “United States of Europe” except without the democracy. Sadly, increasingly the United States of America is a United States except without the democracy.

The form of government to which we once aspired is hard. Among other things it requires forbearance, always in short supply.

1 comment

Solving or Prolonging the Crisis?

China’s stock market crash is now in its third week. In an attempt at stemming panic the Chinese government has provided money and an “offer” to financial companies to buy more stock. As of this writing there are few signs of the bottom:

HONG KONG—Contagion from the plunge in Chinese stocks spread Wednesday in a sign investors within China and overseas are losing confidence in Beijing’s ability to stem the slide in the country’s equity markets and manage its economic reforms.

Shares listed on the country’s main Shanghai market dropped 5.9%, deepening a slump that has seen the market fall by nearly a third since mid-June.

The gloom is no longer confined to stocks. The yield on China’s benchmark government bonds rose sharply, while investors unloaded billions worth of dollar-denominated debt issued by Chinese companies. China’s currency, the yuan, fell to a four-month low in offshore markets, while a global selloff in commodities continued, with oil down in early Asian trading and metals such as copper trading close to six-year lows.

The malaise in China stocks is spreading outward largely because Chinese policy makers have put their credibility at stake in a series of attempts to shore up the market that so far have borne little fruit. Unlike the global financial crisis of 2008, when panic spread through world markets as the complex links between major financial institutions unraveled, investors are taking fright from the fall in Chinese stocks because it has exposed Beijing’s limitations in the face of market forces.

I’m far from an expert on the Chinese stock market but I can’t help but wonder whether the Chinese authorities are solving the problem, trying to soften the landing, or whether their efforts are actually and perversely prolonging it? Is this the beginning of the Big Correction for the Chinese economy as a whole or is it just a bump on the road to an ever more prosperous and economically powerful China?

Update

Yves Smith has a good post on China’s stock market tumble. It really looks bad and she’s about as much in the dark as I am.

3 comments

The Policy Implications of Mexican Immigration

There’s an interesting post at RealClearPolicy reflecting on the prospects for “upward mobility” among Hispanic immigrants:

The desire to increase social mobility has taken center stage in recent years, as lower-skill workers and their families struggle to join the middle class. A recent New York Times poll found that only 35 percent of Americans agree that “everyone has a fair chance to get ahead in the long run.” The explanations for insufficient mobility are many and varied, with some analysts citing technological changes that disproportionately benefit high-skill workers, while others point to cultural differences that tend to pass advantages (or disadvantages) to the next generation.

But whatever the root causes of class stratification, the political class tends to ignore a major policy that worsens the problem — namely, the mass immigration of low-skill workers.

The brief summary of the post is that what seems to be the case is that the recent immigrants and their children don’t pick up the best practices and traits of the majority population, e.g. higher levels of educational attainment, but do pick up some bad practices and traits, e.g. lower rates of employment and higher rates of incarceration. Let me articulate that more clearly: based on the statistics presented in the post second and third generation Mexican-Americans have lower rates of lower rates of educational attainment, higher rates of unemployment, and higher rates of incarceration than non-Hispanic whites do and higher rates of unemployment and higher rates of incarceration than first generation Mexican immigrants do. I wish those claims were normed for family income. Absent that it’s less than clear what those results might be attributed to.

At one level the results don’t concern me particularly since they might be completely consistent with the findings on the adoption of English as a primary language. The most commonly quoted study on the subject has convinced me that the claim that the children of Mexican immigrants, their children, etc. never learn English is a canard. I’ve cited the study around here before and I don’t feel like looking it up again.

Although the study did find, as advocates note, that Mexican-Americans ultimately do adopt English as their primary language, I can only presume they don’t read the complete study since it also found that Mexican-Americans become primary English a generation or so later than other immigrant groups. The pattern usually cited is that many immigrants never become primary English but their children are frequently true bilinguals while their grandchildren are often English-only (unless they studied the language their grandparents spoke in the Old Country in school, also commonplace). For example, I don’t know if my great-great-grandfather Schuler ever fully adopted English but I do know that my great-grandfather Schuler spoke both English and German while my grandfather spoke only a few words of German, presumably stuff he learned around the house. My dad spoke German fluently but that was because he studied it in school.

What I’m suggesting is that Mexican-Americans might have higher levels of educational attainment, higher levels of employment, and lower rates of incarceration by the fourth or fifth generation. I also don’t think there’s anything particularly extraordinary about Mexican-Americans slower rate of English acquisition. There are about as many Mexican-Americans now as there are Americans of German descent (17%). If the U. S. shared a 2,000 mile land border with Germany, I suspect that the rate of adoption of English by German-speaking Americans would be slowed as well.

I’d take more solace in all of this if the job and income prospects for people with high school educations or even four year college degrees were better. Sadly, the group with the greatest job and employment gains have been those with post-graduate degrees. It’s a Red Queen world out there: you’ve got to run twice as fast to stay in the same place.

All of this is by way of saying that if we’re going to come up with sane immigration, education, and anti-poverty policies, we should be considering the realities of our situation with a steelier eye. I doubt that we will which means our policies will become increasingly detached from reality over time.

2 comments

Minds Changing on the Drachma

It doesn’t seem like all that long ago that Greece’s abandoning the euro in favor of a return to its own currency was an extreme, farfetched idea. Now it’s apparently the prevailing wisdom or at least prevailing wisdom adjacent. David Ignatius, the high priest of the prevailing Washington wisdom muses over the prospects for Greece’s return to the drachma:

WASHINGTON — The Greek financial nightmare is a reminder of why countries benefit from having their own currencies. In the old days, a flexible drachma could have been devalued to boost exports and economic growth. But today’s euro trades at a single exchange rate that may suit some of its member nations but not others. For Greece, it has become the equivalent of a straitjacket.

So why doesn’t Greece drop the euro and restore its freedom of maneuver? A cheap drachma would boost exports and tourism — and it might be the easiest means of post-crisis financial adjustment. But separating from the eurozone would mean rewriting thousands of contracts and deals. And it could put Greece in a monetary free fall, perhaps forcing Athens to look east for support to Moscow, Riyadh or even Tehran.

and

As Greece is discovering, it’s difficult for small, ailing economies to threaten big, strong ones. Greece’s implicit threat over the last three years has been a “Grexit” — a Greek withdrawal from the euro that could undermine European solidarity and increase pressure on other weak eurozone members. But it seems that the leaders of Germany and other strong eurozone economies are more worried about another kind of contagion — the demand for concessions from Portugal, Spain, Italy and other debtor nations that might ensue if Greece’s confrontational tactics were seen as succeeding.

Greece and its creditors need the monetary equivalent of a divorce lawyer who can help reckon the costs and benefits of a breakup. Restoring the drachma would give Greece more flexibility, but at the price of much greater vulnerability. For the eurozone, a Grexit would signal that the promise of monetary union was conditional — and unreliable. Bad divorces happen when each side is too angry for rational decision-making.

Greece’s problem is that it really doesn’t have much choice. When you combine the inefficiency and inadequate capitalization of the Greek economy with the efficiency, size, and mercantilist policies of Germany you get exactly what the Greeks have gotten. Inexpensive, high quality German goods bought with borrowed money, the need to pay back the loans, and no practical way of doing it.

Now, in the absence of debt forgiveness that would require a change in the political winds from Germany, Greece has the Hobson’s choice between a perennially deteriorating economy with declining standard of living and a return to the drachma.

11 comments

Not Precisely Without Precedent

As we unwind from the Fourth of July festivities, I didn’t want to let the occasion slip by without drawing some attention to the Plakkaat van Verlatinghe of 1581, an important source and inspiration for the Declaration of Independence. It’s reproduced here with copious annotations.

0 comments

Explaining Chicago’s Fiscal Problems

As it turns out it’s darned hard to determine the rate of economic growth in the City of Chicago. It’s easy enough to determine for the Chicago metropolitan area but not the city as such. However, there’s one thing that is pretty easy to research that I think is a pretty fair proxy for economic growth: city revenues.

Here’s a graph of Chicago’s revenues derived from the city’s own analysis of its fiscal position:

My interpretation of that is that Chicago’s revenues have been flat since 2007. If you exclude “Proceeds and Transfers In”, the city’s revenues have increased about 3% since 2007 or, said another way, dollar revenues are nearly flat while real revenues have actually decreased. Most revenue classes have declined since 2007. A few, e.g. non-tax revenue which includes various fees the city collects like parking fines, penalties for traffic tickets, license fees, and so on, have increased sharply, as anyone who lives in the city could tell you. That’s what all those red light cameras were for.

You can click on over to the whole report but I’ll save you the trouble. The good news is that the city’s expenses have been flat since 2007, too.

The really bad news: even with flat expenses flat revenues leaves nothing to pay extraordinary expenses like the big payment the city owed its pension fund, mostly the result of not having paid anything into it over a period of 15 years.

Just about anything you can do to increase revenues will be regressive and have an adverse impact on the city’s economic growth, something it can hardly afford. Consequently, I think the real solution is for the city to roll wages back, a view that doesn’t exactly make me popular around here. What makes me think that is in the early Aughts during the housing boom, city employees got a big raise. Although revenues were as high after 2007 as they’d been expected to be, expenses remained just as high as they were expected to be. The difference has to be made up somewhere.

1 comment

Trende’s Argument Not Convincing

Sean Trende presents an argument for why the Supreme Court’s decision in Obergefell v. Hodges legalizing same sex marriage is unlikely to lead to the legalization of polygamy, the abolition of age of consent laws, or any of the other things that lawsuits have already been filed to secure:

Melissa Etheridge came out in 1993. Ellen DeGeneres came out in 1997. A slew of celebrities followed: The “Queer Eye for the Straight Guy” folk, Anderson Cooper, Portia de Rossi, Suze Orman, Neil Patrick Harris, just to name a few off the top of my head. These celebrities didn’t comport with the preconceived notions of what a gay person “ought” to look or act like for many Americans. This “de-otherizing” of gays, I think, was one of the keys to public acceptance of homosexuality resuming its upward march in the 1990s.

There have been attempts to create a similar conception of polygamists, most famously with the popular show “Sister Wives.” But even they are associated with a religious group that most Americans are unlikely to associate with. Scandals such as the one involving Warren Jeffs have only reinforced the idea that polygamy is something that “others” do.

Perhaps celebrities will begin to take on multiple spouses in the next few decades. If that happens – if Brad Pitt had been happy to stay with Jennifer Aniston but just wanted to add Angelina Jolie to the club – things could change. But for now, it seems unlikely that a spate of relatable polygamists will emerge into the mainstream culture in the next few years. That remains a crucial distinction.

I remain unconvinced. I think there may be something akin to the “Feiler Faster Thesis” at work. The greater the social change the greater the push to even greater social change, arrived at with even less ability to adapt to it.

Forty years between the the same sex marriage court case and turning it into a right. Could be forty months for the next major social change. That’s probably the greatest problem with Justice Kennedy’s opinion. Basing his decision on an imagined “dignity of marriage” argument opens a door for a lot of other things that was closed before. I mean, you’ve to be pretty nasty to be against dignity, right?

8 comments

A Brief Sketch of Greek History

…over a period covering the last half millennium or so.

In 1458 the Ottoman Empire captured Greece and ruled it until 1832 when the (more or less) modern Greek state was created.

During the period of Ottoman rule, the Turks imposed heavy taxes and travel restrictions on the Greeks. They imposed property and trade taxes. They imposed the jizya, the “poll tax”, as they did on all other non-Muslims who did not pay the zakat. They forbade travel on horseback. The Turks took a lot out of Greece and put nothing in.

In 1832 following the Greek war of independence a German prince (Otto of Bavaria) came to rule as king of the Greeks. For most of the next 135 years the Greeks were ruled by mostly German kings. The first of these kings to be born in Greece, Constantine, didn’t assume the job until well into the 20th century and he was strongly pro-German. That’s why the Greeks were neutral during World War I.

In 1967 a military dictatorship took over and ran the country until 1974 when the present Greek state began.

Greece adopted the euro in 2001. While I think there’s a reasonable argument that the Greeks could have made better use of the last 40 years, the last 40 years isn’t Greece’s only problem. Greece has been systematically looted, misruled, and mismanaged, mostly by despotic governments over the period of the last half millennium. Changing the repercussions of that won’t happen over night.

0 comments

Where’s the Beef?

I’m not even going to bother to link to the Washington Post editorial in which the editors say that the Chinese have gone a step too far in breaching the Office of Personnel Management and gaining access to millions of employment records of federal personnel, followed by a) a demand for retaliation and b) establish the prerequisite that any retaliation not threaten the relationship between the two countries or our economic interests.

There is no relationship. Or at least it’s not what you think/hope it is. Poindexter, that cute girl is only showing interest in you so you’ll write her English paper. She’ll never let you take her to the prom.

IMO they just have generalized angst over the breach. They don’t really want anything to be done about it. Otherwise they’d make specific suggestions.

I’ve already made my suggestions.

0 comments