Remarkable Forebearance

In my opinion the judge hearing the case over the release of Sec. Clinton’s emails:

A source familiar with what was produced told POLITICO the bulk of what was turned over were news clips forwarded to staff from an outside vendor, which ran between 125 and 150 pages worth of stories each day. The source said those went to both Reines’ official and personal email accounts, leading to boxes upon boxes.

During Leon’s court hearing — part of an ongoing lawsuit filed by the AP that charges the agency with failing to respond to FOIA requests — the State Department often underscored that it does not have a complete record yet of Clinton’s top staff.

During the hearing, Leon grilled the department for failing to respond to the news wire’s requests, vowing to issue a court order to force it to hand over documents more quickly.

The AP had requested documents relating to Abedin’s quasi-government employment status that allowed her to advise Clinton but also work in the private sector. It also asked for Clinton’s schedules, appointments and call logs, among other items.

Leon, a George W. Bush appointee, said he couldn’t understand why State couldn’t simply hand over nearly 5,000 pages of documents relating to Clinton’s schedule.

Hackett explained that although he has 60 full-time staffers working FOIA requests, they handle only paperwork. The actual reviews of emails and memos by which they are approved for public release, are done by a mere 40 former Foreign Services officers — all of whom work part-time.

The judge was flabbergasted: “Is Congress aware that people who do all [State] FOIA requests are part-timers?”

When Hackett suggested the system works well enough, the judge said that’s a “matter of perception.”

is exhibiting remarkable forebearance. If I were in his shoes, I’d already have thrown John Hackett in the clink for contempt with the clear understanding that he’d stay there until all of the documents requested were in hand and that his successor would become his cellmate in a week if the task had not already been accomplished.

It’s like the old story of the mule who could tap dance. A Missouri farmer once claimed he had a mule who could tap dance. A talent scout came all the way to see the remarkable site. The farmer said to the mule, “Dance, mule!”. Nothing. The mule just stood there, chewing his cud. “Dance, mule!” Nothing. The exasperated farmer grabbed a two-by-four and whapped the mule in the middle of his forehead with it as hard as he could and, sure enough, the mule began to tap dance. The talent scout was astonished. “But what’s with the two-by-four?”, he asked? “Wal, first I had to git his attention”, the farmer replied.

Of course, I’ve never been known for a judicial temperament.

19 comments

It’s a Small World After All

My own personal idea of Hell is to be trapped on the Disney ride featuring the earworm of this post’s title for eternity. I came very close to experiencing that firsthand, something I may have mentioned in an earlier post. Howsomever, when I read Robert Samuelson’s most recent column I was predisposed to dislike it practically from its first sentence:

To understand the economy, you have to resort to psychology. Throughout the recovery, forecasters — including those at the Federal Reserve and the International Monetary Fund — have repeatedly overestimated the economy’s strength. They’ve predicted faster economic growth than has occurred.

While I agree with Mr. Samuelson that economics is a social science in which psychology plays an important role, unlike physics or chemistry, I don’t think you can explain the underperformance of the U. S. economy solely on the basis of malaise, as he seems to want to do.

The balance of his column consists largely of citing opinion polls citing the opinions of people around the world about their domestic policy. Oddly, Mr. Samuelson alludes to the variation, i.e. that local differences affect local opinions of the economy, but refuses to run with it. Riddle me this: if a declining U. S. public opinion of the economy explains the U. S. economy, how does a rising Chinese opinion of the Chinese economy explain the slowing growth of the Chinese economy? Or the collapse of the Chinese stock market since the start of the year?

Let me propose an alternative explanation for the failure of predictions. The worthies he cites as failing to predict the slower growth we’ve actually experienced because they’re strongly predisposed to believe certain standard models of the economy and those models have lost their predictive power, largely on the basis of globalization.

I’m skeptical that anyone can predict the behavior of the U. S. economy at all but even more skeptical that you can even get the directionality right without taking into account the economies of China, Japan, Germany, the UK, Brazil, and Australia (just to name a few major players).

Does anyone know of scholarship attempting to model the global economy? I know of good models of the U. S. economy but I haven’t checked back with them lately to see how well they’ve been doing, prediction-wise.

I also feel impelled to point out that the tools to regulate the world economy are completely lacking. We’ve adopted a global economy which will remain regulated at the local level to the extent it’s regulated at all. My prediction is hold on to your hats, we’re in for a bumpy ride.

5 comments

Brokedown Engine

I have severely mixed feelings about Clive Crooks’s latest column at Bloomberg, at its core elaborate apologetics for two decades (at least) of bad policy. After redefining the problem several times he arrives at the conclusion that maybe wages haven’t lagged productivity that much after all:

For decades after 1970 — contrary to one popular account — labor incomes grew roughly in line with productivity. Over the long haul, far from being irrelevant to well-being, growth in productivity goes far to deciding how poor or prosperous ordinary Americans will be.

However, at the end of his analysis there’s still a gap of about 10% between the increase in productivity and wages.

I think that one of the explanations behind what’s happened over the last 30 years or so is the enormous growth of the financial, healthcare, and education sectors, all of which have had great run-ups in wages, none of which employ a vast number of Americans, and none of which, arguably, have seen much in the way of increases in productivity. Certainly nothing commensurate with the degree to which the increase in wages in those sector have outstripped wage growth in other sectors of the economy.

I guess I shouldn’t be too concerned. Quietly and surreptitiously all of those sectors are or will be disrupted. I won’t be surprised if the 21st century equivalent of manning the barricades isn’t fighting against the holding action defending obsolete business models.

2 comments

Nostalgia Economics

Please, please tell me that we’re not going to need to sit through another fifteen months of political candidates giving their visions for the future which, oddly, to me look mired in the past.

The Republicans are pretty clearly stuck in the 1980s. To all appearances they only know one song: tax cuts. IMO the argument for tax cuts at the federal level was much stronger in 1980 than it is today. That there isn’t a national consensus in favor of tax reform is a scandal and an outrage but I’m afraid that whatever shape reform takes and all of the dust has settled there won’t be much in the way of a tax cut. The federal government just has too many obligations, those are going to remain obligations regardless of which party holds the Congress and the White House, and, given the consensus over the kind of budgeting we do, that means that not only a certain amount of revenue but an increasing amount of revenue is required. Protestations to the contrary notwithstanding no Republican president has ever submitted a budget calling for the abolition of any federal department. Although there are differing priorities between the two parties over how to spend money, a dramatic decrease in the size of the federal government just isn’t in the cards.

Democrats should take no solace in their own politicians. You can’t listen to Hillary Clinton’s views on the economy without realizing that she’s hopelessly mired in the 1950s when the Fordist compromise, the grand agreement among Big Government, Big Business, and Big Labor, was at its peak. Big Business is now global and Big Labor is now irrelevant in the private sector.

I do have one question for Sec. Clinton about her recent profit-sharing proposal. If it’s such a good idea, why haven’t the trade unions representing the workers at large, publicly-held companies been clamoring for a greater equity stake in the companies they’re working for? Why don’t they hold significant chunks of their pension funds in the form of the stock in those companies?

The economic conditions of today aren’t those of 1980 or 1950 (or, pace Bernie Sanders, the 1930s). The challenges we face today are those of globalization, disruption, and the vast proportion economy in finance, healthcare, and education, none of which employ enough people to propel either a Fordist or a Reaganite recovery in the economy.

Are the present and future so bleak that they can only stand talking about the past?

8 comments

Why Do They Talk That Way?

It isn’t very often that speech pathology stories make it onto the opinion pages but recently I’ve seen any number of op-eds and news reports on two subjects: vocal fry and “uptalk”. Here’s a satirical take from the WP opinion page.

“Vocal fry” is a low, vibrating or buzzing quality in the voice, particularly at the end of sentences. It can be aggravated by vocal abuse—shouting, singing incorrectly, smoking. It may be behavioral—sometimes it may even have become fashionable. The research that I’ve read suggests that pitching one’s voice in the wrong register is a major cause. Many women pitch their voices below their natural register, producing vocal fry. It is extremely common in Hollywood actresses. Men can get it too, sometimes by pitching their voices too high.

“Uptalk” is clearly social in nature. It is the tendency for young women today to end every sentence with a rising inflection. It’s taken as lack of confidence but I suspect it’s largely just imitative and habitual. Today’s analog to “Valleyspeak”.

I’m mostly amused by the entire suggestion. In 30 years you’ll be able to identify women of a certain age by their uptalk which is probably not the effect they’re going for.

5 comments

Crash Test Dummies

As I said yesterday, the Chinese stock markets aren’t finding a bottom expressly because of the actions of the Chinese authorities to prop them up. The editors of the Wall Street Journal remark:

International institutional investors have expressed skepticism about the Chinese stock market in recent days for this reason. MSCI Inc. punted on a decision to include mainland Chinese shares in its Emerging Markets Index in June, and the government’s response to the crash means it is unlikely to happen soon.

The botched intervention could even threaten the reputation of China’s pre-eminent financial center, Hong Kong. Through the Hong Kong-Shanghai Stock Connect system, stocks listed in one market can be traded on the other. Through the recent carnage, Hong Kong trading of Chinese companies remained more stable, perhaps because the scheme is so new that few mainland shares are held there. But in some future crisis, might Beijing freeze the positions of investors in Hong Kong to stem outflows?

Such questions have to be worrying Beijing’s many competent technocrats, who clearly weren’t calling the shots in recent weeks. The policy wheels turn slowly in Beijing, but the past 35 years have shown that after a few failures the Communist Party tends to come around to needed economic reforms. Here’s hoping that Party Secretary Xi Jinping and his colleagues are realizing the futility of propping up stock prices.

Today Chinese officials have already pledged to buy stock to keep prices up. It’s practically a license to steal.

Update

More from Ambrose Evans-Pritchard:

China consumes 50pc of global coal, 43pc of industrial metals and 23pc of grains, according to World Bank data.

Brazil, Russia, South Africa and a string of commodity states face a double-barrelled stress test. The Chinese are freezing imports just as the US Federal Reserve drains worldwide dollar liquidity and prepares to raise rates, calling time on emerging markets that have together borrowed $4.5 trillion in US currency.
The Brazilian real fell to a 12-year low of 3.38 against the dollar on Monday. The South Africa rand hit a record low of 12.69. The Russian rouble flirted with the danger line of 60. It was the same story across much of the emerging market nexus.

“One by one the dominoes are starting to fall,” said Societe Generale.

10 comments

What Makes Hillary’s Email Server a Scandal

Ruth Marcus scoffs at the kerfuffle over Hillary Clinton’s emails:

The latest controversy over Hillary Clinton’s e-mails — the allegation that classified information was improperly transmitted on her private e-mail server — is, or should be, a non-scandal.

Clinton has only herself to blame for a lot of the e-mail mess. She should have behaved like other government officials and used an official account, however cumbersome the multiple-device consequences might have been.

[…]

Nonetheless, the classification kerfuffle is a non-scandal blown out of proportion by a toxic combination of sloppy reporting, official miscommunication and partisan positioning.

Ms. Marcus mischaracterizes the affair. In a sample of 40 emails the IG found that 10% contained classified information. The odds favor there being a lot more and each of those emails containing classified information is a serious infraction.

Every single email held back by Sec. Clinton or her staff for any reason whatever constitutes a violation of regulations. And multiple individuals have worked together to accomplish that mess which makes it a conspiracy to break laws and regulations, itself a serious infraction.

The question Ms. Marcus should be asking herself is whether we should have classified information or a Freedom of Information Act. If we should and if anyone should be prosecuted for releasing classified information or not preserving an official record, then everyone should and especially Secretaries of State who violate those laws and regulations.

That’s what makes it a real scandal.

13 comments

Yellow Dog Democrats

The term “yellow dog Democrats” refers to an old Southern wisecrack about voters who would “vote for a yaller dog if it ran on the Democratic ticket”. It was first applied to Democrats around the turn of the last century (it had previously been applied to Republicans) and was popularized a quarter century later. What I think that Michael Gerson doesn’t appreciate:

One of the lively debates among conservatives over the past several months has been: Is Clinton a strong candidate or a weak one? I have been on the “strong” side. She is knowledgeable, tough, experienced and certainly imaginable as president. She has almost managed the remarkable achievement of clearing the Democratic field through a perception of her own inevitability and a reputation for remembering disloyalty.

But arguments on the “weak” side are getting stronger. Since her video announcement in April, perceptions of Clinton’s character and leadership have worsened — which is not really the purpose of a campaign. Her vulnerability on the populist left — Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) is supported by a majority of white Democratic liberals — has shifted Clinton’s candidacy decisively to the left. And the candidate looks as comfortable in this overcorrection as Mitt Romney did in his “severely conservative” phase.

is that most Democrats are yellow dog Democrats who wouldn’t vote for a Republican because they’re convinced that Republicans are evil. They’re abetted in that belief by a compliant press and undisciplined Republican candidates always ready to produce a sound bite to confirm the belief and Democrats are just shy of an outright electoral college majority.

That’s Hillary Clinton’s greatest strength as a candidate but it’s a strength that any Democratic presidential candidates will possess.

Which brings us to another expression. Hillary Clinton’s support is a mile wide and an inch deep, somewhat like the candidate herself. The question isn’t whether Democrats will vote “Hillary Clinton” but whether they’ll turn out in sufficient numbers to push her over the line in the few “swing states” they need to carry to make her president in November 2016.

Drip, drip, drip.

7 comments

Unforeseen Secondary Effects

Speaking of excessive risk-taking, Mark Thoma wants the financial industry to bear more of the costs for economic downturns:

I believe that far too much of the cost of the financial meltdown was imposed on working class households and far too little on the industry itself. Is there a way to change this? Can we shift more of the cost of financial meltdowns to the financial industry? Yes we can, and one way to do this is to implement a financial transactions tax.

I think that Dr. Thoma must have attended the same economics classes I did. He almost always thinks in terms of behavior modification via tax. I don’t think his tax will have the consequences he thinks they will. More likely the opposite.

After all, imagine that you were Goldman-Sachs, that the financial transaction tax had reduced your margins, but that you knew with a confidence based on experience that the federal government in one of its myriad forms would underwrite your losses. Wouldn’t that predispose you to making riskier investments rather than less risky ones?

We don’t need additional taxes or even additional laws to “shift more of the cost of financial meltdowns to the financial industry”. Enforcing the laws we have would be enough.

7 comments

What Goes Up…

The Chinese stock markets have plunged another 8.5%:

China’s stocks tumbled, with the benchmark index falling the most since February 2007, amid concern a three-week rally sparked by unprecedented government intervention is unsustainable.

The Shanghai Composite Index plunged 8.5 percent to 3,725.56 at the close, with 75 stocks dropping for each one that rose. PetroChina Co., long considered a target of state-linked market support funds, tumbled by a record 9.6 percent. The rout dented investor confidence from Hong Kong to Taiwan and Indonesia, helping send the MSCI Emerging Markets Index to a two-year low.

Monday’s retreat shattered the sense of calm that had fallen over mainland markets last week and raised questions over the viability of government efforts to prop up share prices as the economy slows. China’s industrial profits fell 0.3 percent in June from a year earlier, the statistics bureau reported on Monday. The International Monetary Fund has urged China to eventually unwind its support measures, according to a person familiar with the matter.

Now that the Chinese government has shown the “investors” that they’re willing to underwrite their losses, I wonder how the government could ever have thought their strategy might work. It hasn’t so far and there’s no bottom in sight.

No wonder they’re buying real estate in the U. S. and gold.

0 comments