Measuring Income Inequality

I have severely mixed feelings about Francis Menton’s post at City Journal. He starts off well enough, pointing out the seeming paradox that the 25 Congressional districts with the greatest levels of income inequality within them all elect Democratic congressmen and have for some time. I think that stands to reason. There’s particular appeal in redistributionist rhetoric in places where the problems are walking right down the street alongside you.

And it also stands to reason that the redistributionist rhetoric never quite seems to become more than rhetorical or, if it does, the effects are never quite what their advocates have assumed. That’s always the case. Good intentions are not enough. You’ve got to have things like a grounded understanding of human nature and human behavior and an eye firmly on results rather than just intentions or, worse, opinion polls.

Which is how I interpret this:

Could it be that progressive policies intended to reduce income inequality actually cause it to increase? Quite likely, yes. The reason has to do with the effect of these policies on the low end of the income distribution. The government doesn’t count the distribution of in-kind benefits as income—and means-tested handouts create incentives for recipients to keep their measured incomes low. Further, where higher minimum wages—another progressive agenda item—cause higher unemployment, we see even more zero-income earners. Having lots of low-earners or zero-earners doesn’t help reduce inequality. Meanwhile, at the high end of the income distribution, taking money from high earners through higher marginal tax rates is not counted in official statistics as a cut in income—which means that income inequality again doesn’t shrink.

I also agree with his point that income inequality should be calculated using after tax income that takes into account both taxes paid and benefits received, either in the form of transfer payments or any of the myriad forms of subsidies. You can’t calculate income inequality in New York City without accounting for the effects of rent control, just to take one example.

But what then? My intuition clearly differs from Mr. Menton’s. I gather that he either thinks there isn’t a problem or that there’s nothing that can or should be done about it in a sort “the poor we shall always have with us” sort of way.

My intuition is that the net result of all of this is a great increase in income inequality between the 90% of income earners and the top 90 to 99.9%-ers. I don’t think it’s an unavoidable accident that Chicago’s police officers, firefighters, teachers, etc. are the highest-paid in the country. Or that physicians becoming wealthy as a side effect of the enactment of Medicare was because they’re so smart and hard-working. I think that those are the rules of the game.

4 comments

What If?

What if we’re calculating productivity, GDP, inflation, wages, and unemployment all wrong? That’s James Pethokoukis’s question in this post:

It’s a puzzle for which Goldman Sachs has a simple answer: We are measuring productivity wrong, and therefore we are measuring GDP wrong. A metric devised for America’s 1930s “steel-and-wheat” economy, in the words of economic historian Joel Mokyr, doesn’t work so well for a rapidly growing digital economy. In a recent report, Goldman economist Jan Hatzius and Kris Dawsey note that prices of tech hardware — adjusted for quality improvements — have fallen a lot faster than those for software. This suggests software isn’t improving much.

But Goldman thinks this gap is a “statistical mirage” reflecting the “amorphous” nature of software improvements. Hatzius and Dawsey ask: “How much better are the inventory management systems that retail companies contract out or develop for their own account compared with those of 20 years ago? How much better is Grand Theft Auto V than Grand Theft Auto IV? And how much more value do we now derive from our internet connection compared with a decade ago?”

As the Goldman economists reckon, then, U.S. inflation is lower than we think due to sharply falling, “quality adjusted” IT hardware and software prices — and thus real economic growth and productivity are higher. GDP growth might actually be close to 3 percent right now, which would be more in sync with what’s happening in labor markets and the tech sector. Oh, and it also means real incomes are growing faster than we think, which is why the economists are “skeptical of confident pronouncements” that American living standards aren’t improving as fast as they used to. By the way, new analysis by the Peterson Institute suggests worker incomes have pretty much been keeping up with productivity gains. So perhaps more good news for the 99 percent.

Okay, I’ll bite. What if? Show me the numbers. Don’t just ask hypothetical questions.

In my measly view from here on the ground rather than soaring above at 50,000 feet I see a heckuva lot of unemployment, even more underemployment, burgeoning black markets in practically everything, and an economy that, at least at the local level, is barely holding on by the skin of its teeth. Are we all being sold a bill of goods by a constantly nay-saying press?

But I’m willing to listen to Dr. Pethokoukis’s thoughts. Where’s the evidence?

3 comments

I’m Shocked, Shocked

Jeff Cox, writing at CNBC is alarmed at the results of the Fed’s monetary policies:

The central bank printed $4.5 trillion and all we got was a lousy 0.2 percent wage increase.

While that sounds like a T-shirt for policy geeks that one might buy at the shore, it actually pretty accurately describes the plight of the average American worker. After years of easing never seen before in global central banking history, the Federal Reserve’s efforts have amounted to little when it comes to stimulating “good” inflation, particularly in terms of wage increases.

The employment cost index, an otherwise secondary data point that suddenly has taken on more importance, painted a bleak picture for workers in its latest update Friday.

On a quarterly basis, it showed wages and salaries increasing just 0.2 percent, believed to be the lowest three-month move ever for a data set that goes back to 1982. That translated to a 2 percent annualized gain in compensation costs, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics.

What’s more, the scant growth went mostly to government workers, who saw a 0.6 percent increase, while the private sector was flat. On a 12-month basis, private worker compensation rose just 1.9 percent, which actually was a slight decrease from the 2.0 percent at the same time in 2014. Wages and salaries alone grew 2.1 percent, which actually was an increase from the 1.8 percent a year ago.

He shouldn’t be. As Barry Ritholz explains, the Fed’s policy is doing exactly what it was intended to do:

You probably learned the phrase “moral hazard” during the financial crisis. In short, what it means is that the bailouts rescued leveraged, reckless speculators from the results of their unwise professional folly and gave them an incentive to do it all over again. They were and the intended rescuees.

Do you think I am exaggerating? Consider the U.S. bailout in its manifold forms, from TARP to ZIRP to QE. How many bondholders suffered losses from their poor investment decisions? With the exception of holders of Lehman Brothers’ debt and a handful of banks that weren’t deemed too big to fail, just about every other bondholder was made whole, 100 cents on the dollar.

Thanks to rescue plans such as the Trouble Asset Relief Program, holders of bonds from a diverse assortment of failed and failing companies suffered literally no losses. American International Group? Zero losses. Government sponsored entities Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac? Zero losses. Banking giants Citigroup and Bank of America? Zero losses. Morgan Stanley, Merrill Lynch, Goldman Sachs, Bear Stearns? Zero losses.

The Federal Deposit Insurance Corp.’s actions were rare exceptions to this rule: Its bailouts actually benefitted consumers — savings and checking account holders. When banks such as Indy Mac, Wachovia, Washington Mutual went belly up, the FDIC arranged a shotgun marriages. WaMu went to JPMorgan Chase, Wachovia went to Wells Fargo, Indy Mac went to OneWest Bank.

Once it was certain the account holders were made whole, whatever assets were left went to the most senior creditors — typically bond holders. (Equity holders usually get wiped out). In Washington Mutual’s case, bond owners received between 20 and 28 cents on the dollar. Other FDIC resolutions yielded similar amounts.

Even the Federal Reserve’s zero interest rate policy (ZIRP), in place for so long that there hasn’t been a rate increase in more than nine years, is there to help rescued banks. For years after the financial crisis, their balance sheets remain festooned with so many bad mortgages and soured loans that an early increase in rates would have put those portfolios at huge risk. Now that prices have mostly returned to pre-crisis levels, it is considered safe to increase the fed funds rates, which we all know will have a significant impact on mortgage rates. With foreclosures down tremendously from their peak, the banks can tolerate interest increases. Despite plenty of evidence that the economy could have absorbed interest rates increases almost two year ago — the economy met the Fed’s own parameters at that time — bank mortgage portfolios were still shaky, and not in shape to deal with rate increases. More losses that could have compromised the banking industry’s health were likely.

As I always have, I think that way back in 2007, the U. S. should have done what Sweden did in its banking crisis: nationalized the banks. Liquidate them in an orderly fashion. Let the bankers of insolvent banks go broke or incarcerate them, as appropriate. I don’t doubt that there would have been a period of substantial disruption. It could have been managed as Bill Black has explained over and over again. We’re a big, rich, powerful country and we have lots of ingenuity. Our economy would have returned to something resembling normal much more quickly. The costs would have been borne by people whose profession it is to know better. Instead we’ve provided those same people with every incentive to do it all over again and they’re enormously richer now than they were then. It’s everybody else who’s bearing the costs.

I don’t honestly see how anyone can coherently think that income inequality is a problem and that we’ve done the right things with out banking system over the period of the last eight years.

7 comments

Okay, I’m Convinced

It looks as though Ebola has not become endemic in West Africa. It was a close call. We really need to respond better the next time and there will be a next time.

2 comments

The Fox Butterfield Report

Here’s another one:

WASHINGTON — U.S. consumer sentiment slipped this month but remains at healthy levels, the University of Michigan said Friday.

Michigan’s index of consumer sentiment fell to 93.1 in July from 96.1 the previous month.

Richard Curtin, chief economist for the survey, blamed the drop on the “disappointing pace of economic growth.”

Let’s see. Wages grow at the slowest rate since Reagan was president. Consumer sentiment declines. Could these things possibly be related?

1 comment

Your Economics Quiz

Snap quiz. When the supply of labor goes down to the demand for labor, all other things being equal do you expect the price of labor to increase, decrease, or remain the same?

Okay now read this:

U.S. labor costs in the second quarter recorded their smallest increase in 33 years amid tepid gains in the private sector, but it likely was a temporary setback against the backdrop of diminishing labor market slack.

The unexpectedly smaller rise reported by the Labor Department on Friday will probably not dampen speculation that the Federal Reserve is set to raise interest rates later this year. The U.S. labor market is fast approaching full employment.

The Employment Cost Index, the broadest measure of labor costs, edged up 0.2 percent, the Labor Department said. That was the smallest gain since the series started in the second quarter of 1982 and followed a 0.7 percent rise in the first quarter.

“This data has periodically proved to be very lumpy and the sharp deceleration is inconsistent with other measures of wage inflation that are trending higher, not falling off a cliff,” said Eric Green, chief economist at TD Securities in New York.

Economists polled by Reuters had forecast the employment cost index, which is widely viewed by policymakers and economists as one of the better measures of labor market slack, rising 0.6 percent in the second quarter.

15 comments

Don’t Worry—Be Happy!

That’s Drew Altman’s message about the increase in the rate of increase in healthcare costs:

Rather like a broken record, I have been warning for years that historically low rates of increase in health-care spending would not last. Now it’s time for a different warning: The higher rates of growth now expected are moderate and should be seen in context. Media outlets–especially headline writers–should take care not to dramatize them.

The chart above shows why. Whatever the wishful thinking, the slowed rates of 2008 to 2013 did not represent a watershed period when we had some secret formula for controlling growth in health spending; they were an aberration. Spending grew by an average annual per capita rate of 3.1% during that period, compared with much higher rates in the past and a projected 4.9% average growth rate for 2014 to 2024. But the projected 2014-24 growth rate is moderate by historical standards, and a bounce back to the higher growth rates of the past is unlikely given the many changes in the marketplace and in public programs aimed at restraining costs and producing greater value per health-care dollar. The increases in premiums that employers and most Americans pay for group coverage are likely to remain moderate for the immediate future.

The “moderate increases” he’s talking about are between three and four times the rate of increase in costs in the rest of the economy and three to four times the rate of increase in wages outside the healthcare sector.

At the risk of becoming a broken record myself, healthcare’s privileged position in being as highly subsidized as it is (to the tune of something between 50% and 75% of all healthcare spending coming from government in one way or another) makes it something of a sure thing. That siphons away investment that might go to sectors that employ more people per dollar income and might actually raise wages for the 90% of Americans who aren’t seeing much in the wage of wage increases. Its high degree of subsidization creates a built-in thirst for ever higher taxes, something that also threatens economic activity.

9 comments

Up, Up, Up and Away!

Remember those decreases in the rate of increase in healthcare spending? Looks like those have come to an end:

After several years of historically low, sub-4 percent growth, national health spending is now expected to rise at 5.5 percent in 2014—the highest its been since 2007—actuaries at the federal government’s Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) reported yesterday. The report further projects that growth will increase slightly, on average, over the next decade, to 5.8 percent. The authors write that the latest growth estimate “primarily reflects” the effects of the health law’s major coverage expansions, as well as renewed economic growth and an aging population. Of these factors, Obamacare is the most significant, at least for the moment. The accelerated growth in 2014, the authors write, was “mostly driven by health insurance coverage expansions under the ACA, as 8.4 million Americans are anticipated to have gained insurance coverage primarily through Medicaid or the new health insurance Marketplaces.”

Whether the slowing rate of increase has always been hotly contended. Fans of the PPACA have been quick to credit the slowing to the law, however tenuous the relationship might be. Offhand I’m guessing they won’t be as quick to accept responsibility for a return to more rapidly rising costs.

My position remains as it has been for decades: healthcare costs rising faster than the non-healthcare rate of inflation is harmful to the economy and unsustainable. The healthcare reform we need is, as it has been, reform that will bring the rate of increase to an affordable pace. Getting more people to carry insurance does not appear, as some of the proponents claims, to reduce that rate of itself. A lot more work will be needed but as long as the PPACA sucks all the air out of the healthcare reform room we’re unlikely to see much movement in the right direction.

0 comments

Taking Aim at the TPP

WikiLeaks has made a new dump of secret documents:

TOKYO — The WikiLeaks website published documents Friday that it says show the U.S. government spied on Japanese officials and companies.

The documents include what appear to be five U.S. National Security Agency reports, four of which are marked top-secret, that provide intelligence on Japanese positions on international trade and climate change. They date from 2007 to 2009.

A notation on one of the top-secret reports on climate change before the 2008 G-8 summit is marked for sharing with Australia, Canada, Great Britain and New Zealand, according to WikiLeaks. It’s not clear if it was actually shared.

The organization also posted what it says is an NSA list of 35 Japanese targets for telephone intercepts including the Japanese Cabinet office, Bank of Japan officials, Finance and Trade Ministry numbers, the natural gas division at Mitsubishi, and the petroleum division at Mitsui.

It appears to me that the organization’s target in these leaks is Japanese public opinion with an eye to sabotaging the Trans-Pacific Partnership negotiations.

The TPP negotiations are coming down to the short strokes and, as is usual in negotiations of this sort, the issues left until last are frequently the thorniest. As I’ve mentioned before we already have free trade agreements with most of the substantial economies in the negotiations—except Japan.

I’ll be interested in seeing how these leaks play in Japan. Things are increasingly tense in Japan these days. The economy has become wobbly again and the tensions between Japan and China are rising.

I’d still like to know what we will actually get from Japan in the TPP agreements. I’m not opposed to them but I am skeptical. A majority of Americans support the TPP, at least in principle, while most Japanese share my skepticism. I doubt that the new leaks will help.

1 comment

No Growth

The editors of the Wall Street Journal point out the dog in the manger in the BEA’s latest report on U. S. GDP—we have entered a period of slow or no growth:

The news, which most Americans have long felt in slow-growing wages, is that the worst expansion in 70 years has been even weaker than we thought.

The gnomes at the Bureau of Economic Analysis ran the numbers based on new data and analytical methods and downgraded the recovery since 2011 nearly across the board. From 2011 through 2014, the economy grew at a paltry annual rate of 2%, down from the previous estimate of 2.3%. This means the overall U.S. economy is smaller—with GDP slashed by $105 billion in 2013 and $71 billion in 2014 to $17.35 trillion.

Those numbers are abstractions, but another way to put it is that national income, corporate profits and personal income were all revised down. From 2011 through 2014, the average annual growth of real disposable personal income was slashed to 1.5% from 1.8%. That’s a giant cut in the standard of living.

They also have their preferred strategies for increasing growth:

Freeze and roll back stifling regulation. Reform the tax code to unleash investment and raise wages. Modernize America’s creaky 20th-century public institutions, including health care, and K-12 and higher education. Welcome the world’s most talented immigrants to our shores. And restore monetary policy to its appropriate job of maintaining price stability.

They point out something worthwhile. Nearly 50% of the present economy and most of the growth is in just three sectors: finance, healthcare, and education. That’s a good part of our problem. All three are heavily subsidized which in turn means that their growth has a demand for ever-greater subsidies “baked in”. They also don’t employ 50% of workers which means that they’re engines for income inequality.

Additionally, a grave problem is that neither political party has any coherent plan for fostering growth. But they have fantasies aplenty.

5 comments