I have severely mixed feelings about Francis Menton’s post at City Journal. He starts off well enough, pointing out the seeming paradox that the 25 Congressional districts with the greatest levels of income inequality within them all elect Democratic congressmen and have for some time. I think that stands to reason. There’s particular appeal in redistributionist rhetoric in places where the problems are walking right down the street alongside you.
And it also stands to reason that the redistributionist rhetoric never quite seems to become more than rhetorical or, if it does, the effects are never quite what their advocates have assumed. That’s always the case. Good intentions are not enough. You’ve got to have things like a grounded understanding of human nature and human behavior and an eye firmly on results rather than just intentions or, worse, opinion polls.
Which is how I interpret this:
Could it be that progressive policies intended to reduce income inequality actually cause it to increase? Quite likely, yes. The reason has to do with the effect of these policies on the low end of the income distribution. The government doesn’t count the distribution of in-kind benefits as income—and means-tested handouts create incentives for recipients to keep their measured incomes low. Further, where higher minimum wages—another progressive agenda item—cause higher unemployment, we see even more zero-income earners. Having lots of low-earners or zero-earners doesn’t help reduce inequality. Meanwhile, at the high end of the income distribution, taking money from high earners through higher marginal tax rates is not counted in official statistics as a cut in income—which means that income inequality again doesn’t shrink.
I also agree with his point that income inequality should be calculated using after tax income that takes into account both taxes paid and benefits received, either in the form of transfer payments or any of the myriad forms of subsidies. You can’t calculate income inequality in New York City without accounting for the effects of rent control, just to take one example.
But what then? My intuition clearly differs from Mr. Menton’s. I gather that he either thinks there isn’t a problem or that there’s nothing that can or should be done about it in a sort “the poor we shall always have with us” sort of way.
My intuition is that the net result of all of this is a great increase in income inequality between the 90% of income earners and the top 90 to 99.9%-ers. I don’t think it’s an unavoidable accident that Chicago’s police officers, firefighters, teachers, etc. are the highest-paid in the country. Or that physicians becoming wealthy as a side effect of the enactment of Medicare was because they’re so smart and hard-working. I think that those are the rules of the game.






