Soltas On Income and Productivity

Ever since the lastest figures showing an increase in labor productivity and the subsequent battlespace preparation articles came out I’ve been waiting for a riposte. It has arrived in the form of this post from Evan Soltas. His rejoinder, essentially, is that when viewed properly compensation actually has kept pace with increases in productivity. Here’s the meat of his post:

Between 1987 and 2013, changes in sector-level labor productivity explain almost all of the changes in sector-level hourly labor compensation. And almost all of those productivity increases were paid as compensation to labor.

If you really want to know, 74 percent of the variance in the change between 1987 and 2013 in sector-level log hourly labor compensation is explained by changes in log labor productivity over the same period. A one-percentage point increase in productivity generated a 0.81-percentage-point increase in compensation. I’ve used 1987 and 2013 because this data was collected starting in 1987 and much of the data is still missing for 2014. As always, you can find my cleaned dataset here for your own analysis.

I have some problems with his analysis. For example, this:

If workers aren’t compensated for their productivity, it seems, they’ll switch firms or industries.

That process has been impeded for the last 30 years by all sorts of things including two-income households, slow job growth, increasing specialization, and the rise of credentialism. It might be that under circumstances of perfect elasticity there would have been considerably more job-hopping.

At any rate it’s an interesting post.

0 comments

Realism Sets In

I think that the editors of the Washington Post may have taken the wrong conclusion from the study the article describes when they gave it this headline: “Millennials have low opinion of themselves, compared to boomers”. Here’s the section that caught my eye:

Millennials are also more likely to give themselves low rankings in categories such as patriotism, responsibility, willingness to sacrifice, religiousness, morality, self-reliance, compassion and political activism. Fully 59 percent say “self-absorbed” is an apt description of their bunch.

But, hey, they’re young.

Boomers, however, tend to have relatively healthy self-regard, giving themselves better scores in patriotism, responsibility and so on. Only the silent generation — those born between 1928 and 1945, who are between 70 and 87 years old – gave themselves an even bigger pat on the back.

Wouldn’t a more descriptive caption be “Baby Boomers have inflated view of themselves, compared to Millennials”? But I guess that would be a “dog bites man” story.

0 comments

Is It Hatred?

The United States is not a signatory to the 1951 Refugee Convention. Germany and Sweden are. While I agree with the NYT op-ed writer that riots and burning the habitations of refugees in Germany villages are signs of hate, I don’t agree that the “Dublin mechanism”, which makes a practical distinction between refugees, who under the Convention are owed shelter and care, and economic migrants who aren’t. When a migrant arrives in Greece from Turkey, as European law reckons it, they may claim refugee status. They must present themselves to local authorities, have their names, countries of origin, fingerprints, and justification of their refugee status taken. When, in full knowledge of the law, they make their away across five countries, shopping for the best economic conditions and benefit packages, thinking of the migrants as refugees begins to strain credulity.

As an offhand guess I’d say that something like a third of humanity can qualify for refugee status. Certainly the populations of many Middle Eastern sub-Saharan African countries can. Is not wanting to pay for the upkeep of the migrants, who in many cases reject your language, culture, habit, religion, and liberal values hatred? Or is it just being mugged by reality?

5 comments

What Can You Tell From Real Per Capita GDP?

Real-GDP-per-capita-masked

Here’s a little puzzle for you. Can you match the countries with their per capita GDPs? The countries illustrated in the graph are Australia, Canada, Euro area, Japan, New Zealand, U. S., and U. K. Click on the graphic for the answer.

3 comments

Explaining China to Americans

This morning the editors of the Wall Street Journal came very close to explicating a good theory of China for an American audience:

China’s laws forbids storing explosive chemicals within one kilometer of residences. Regulations on how dangerous chemicals should be stored were also violated. Chinese state media reported that the owners of the warehouse, now under arrest, admitted using ties to government officials to skirt the law. Such corruption is a major contributing factor to China’s poor safety record.

The Tianjin disaster also exposes a major fault line in Chinese society. A growing middle class largely signed on to the Communist Party’s post-1989 social contract: You don’t question our power, and we will make you prosperous and secure.

For more than two decades the Party has largely kept its side of the bargain. But an economic slowdown and the costs of official corruption could shake its legitimacy. As people become more prosperous, they value more highly the benefits that come from an accountable political system.

By contrast, China’s state capitalist system can’t root out corruption and other abuses of official power, no matter how hard President Xi Jinping tries. That’s because the central tenet that can’t be questioned is that the Communist Party is above the law.

but, sadly, they fell short of the mark. China does not have a robust system of civil law. In the final analysis it doesn’t matter what the laws say—those are just for the rubes. Corruption is not an aberration of the system; it is the system. What the heck good is party power if you can’t throw money the way of your friends and family?

Another thing they missed which you can hardly avoid realizing. You only need to listen to the survivors of the explosions: nothing happens that the authorities didn’t intend. I don’t believe that’s the case but it’s obvious that the Chinese people believe it. It was an obvious takeaway from the market crashes they’ve sustained. There was interview after interview with poor sods who’d lost their life savings who said “Why did the government do this to me?”

0 comments

Mad About Hillary

I think it was George Santayana who characterized fanaticism as redoubling your efforts when you’d lost sight of your goal and nowhere is that truer than in the contest over who will become the next president. Conor Friedersdorf explains why Hillary Clinton has never made much sense as a Democratic presidential candidate:

As Hillary Clinton loses ground to Bernie Sanders in Iowa, where her lead shrinks by the day, it’s worth noticing that she has never made particular sense as the Democratic Party’s nominee. She may be more electable than her social-democratic rival from Vermont, but plenty of Democrats are better positioned to represent the center-left coalition. Why have they let the former secretary of state keep them out of the race? If Clinton makes it to the general election, I understand why most Democrats will support her. She shares their views on issues as varied as preserving Obamacare, abortion rights, extending legal status to undocumented workers, strengthening labor unions, and imposing a carbon tax to slow climate change.

But most Democrats hold similar positions on those issues. So why are Democrats supporting her in a primary bid? She’s awful on other issues they’ve deemed hugely important.

Maybe it’s just the pursuit of power for its own sake. It will be interesting to see how Sec. Clinton continues to wrap herself in her husband’s legacy while repudiating his policies. Interesting in a grim sort of way, I mean.

5 comments

Arguing About the Minimum Wage

Once upon a time evidence actually meant, you know, evidence, something material and factual you could point to. Nowadays that notion is just too quaint, a relic of a bygone day. When I read this post on new evidence on the effects of increasing the minimum wage, I was excited about the prospect of additional, you know, evidence. Sadly, I was disappointed.

It’s a good enough article and reasonably interesting but it actually is a survey of various sources of additional analysis. I guess we’ll just have to wait for actual evidence.

1 comment

I Understood There Was to Be No Math

Noah Smith makes a really good point which, coincidentally is something I’ve been complaining about for a long time—despite its pretensions economics just isn’t very mathematical:

A lot of people complain about the math in economics. Economists tend to quietly dismiss such complaints as the sour-grapes protests of literary types who lack the talent or training to hack their way through systems of equations. But it isn’t just the mathematically illiterate who grouse. New York University economist Paul Romer — hardly a lightweight when it comes to equations — recently complained about how economists use math as a tool of rhetoric instead of a tool to understand the world.

Personally, I think that what’s odd about econ isn’t that it uses lots of math — it’s the way it uses math. In most applied math disciplines — computational biology, fluid dynamics, quantitative finance — mathematical theories are always tied to the evidence. If a theory hasn’t been tested, it’s treated as pure conjecture.

It’s not very surprising. Expressing ideas in mathematical symbols isn’t all there is to math. I don’t recall seeing any econ majors or grad students in the higher level math courses when I was in college and those are the guys who would be running the departments now.

11 comments

This Time Is Always Different

At Bloomberg Justin Fox ruminates over whether the incipient global slowdown actually is different:

He presents several different pieces of evidence:

  • Flat global trading volumes
  • The slowdown may be accelerating
  • Population growth is slowing
  • The transition to a services economy
  • Peak light vehicle sales (at least in the U. S.)
  • Declining per capita energy production (at least in the developed world)

I don’t find any of those convincing, each for a different reason but the only one I’ll expand on is the transition from goods to services. First, in the U. S. the demand for goods is still increasing. If you don’t believe me, go over to the St. Louis Fed’s FRED site and chart it out yourself. Real durable goods plus non-durable goods continues to increase (whether per capita or overall). That’s an effective refutation. Despite the claim I’ve read here and there that all earthly wants have been satisfied, people somehow still keep wanting more. And if it’s true here it’s got to be true in China and India (where most of the world’s poor people live).

I also don’t see why if we didn’t want more stuff that still couldn’t translate into growth increasing indefinitely.

What I really think Mr. Fox is seeing is laziness. We’ve come to rely too heavily on credit, the sugar high of economy development. The U. S. is overextended and we haven’t saved enough over the last half dozen years to fill the void and now China is about tapped out, too.

Nobody really has any idea of China’s credit problems. Its banking system is too opaque.

0 comments

The Internet of Silly Things

If you’re interested in an Internet-connected cup, fork, toothbrush or pacifier you might want to check this article out. As it turned out the Internet-connected toilet mentioned in the article was hackable with predictable results.

That’s the problem I have with the Internet of Things. I strongly suspect it will be inherently insecure.

0 comments