Heresy

Megan McArdle engages in heresy:

What if nature, with its infinite disregard for our wishes, simply declined to deliver the raw talent for women to ever gain equal representation at the top of many fields?

I would add that men are disproportionately represented both among those with very low IQs and those with very high IQs. Women are more like at or near normal than men. Also (completely anecdotally) it seems to me that women are better at meticulous, repetitive tasks than men. Relatively few men find knitting an appealing hobby.

2 comments

Sense and Nonsense

I think there’s a lot of sense in Jared Bernstein’s analysis of the latest unemployment situation report which lowered the unemployment rate to 5.1%. Here’s the peroration:

We’re clearly not at full employment so, especially given the absence of price and wage pressures, the correct answer is to hold for now. Either 5.1% is an inaccurate estimate of the “natural rate”—which is actually lower than that—or the reported jobless rate is biased down by some of the factors noted above.

Either way, for a data-driven Fed, it’s the same answer. For a Fed driven by other stuff—emotions, ennui, nervousness (“let’s just raise the damn thing already and break the suspense!”), nightmares from the late 1970s, or whatever…well, that’s a different story.

However, I wish Dr. Bernstein (his PhD is in Social Welfare) would keep in mind that it’s not as though our present interest rates aren’t harming anyone. The ultra-low interest rates are killing the insurance industry and pension funds. Those are already causing political upheaval and taxes to soar. Here in Chicago they’re talking about boosting real estate taxes by the largest amount in city history to a truly confiscatory level to pay the pensions of Chicago’s retired public employees. Higher real estate taxes will put some of the poorest Chicagoans out on the street. If the insurance industry collapses it will create substantial economic and social dislocation.

Under the Taylor Rule interest rates should already have been raised. I just don’t know whom to believe.

6 comments

Government Property

Something caught my eye in James Taranto’s Best of the Web column from yesterday about a CNN interview with Hillary Clinton’s press secretary. Here it is:

This column has been noting for some time that the “55,000 pages” Mrs. Clinton initially turned over to the State Department were not actual emails but printouts of their content—lacking metadata and not electronically searchable.

Here’s my question for someone more knowledgeable than I. Is the metadata that was attached to emails sent from the private server maintained by Sec. Clinton in which Sec. Clinton was carrying on official business government property or not? Last time I checked destruction of federal government property was a felony (18 U.S.C. § 1361).

3 comments

These Foolish Things

I don’t always agree with conservative economist Thomas Sowell but I found this WSJ interview with him interesting. Here’s a snippet:

What about Ta-Nehisi Coates, the black writer whose new book, a raw letter to his son about race relations in the U.S., is stirring public intellectuals? I read Mr. Sowell a line from Mr. Coates’s 15,000-word cover story for the Atlantic calling for reparations for slavery: “In America there is a strange and powerful belief that if you stab a black person 10 times, the bleeding stops and the healing begins the moment the assailant drops the knife.”

“Ah . . . yes,” Mr. Sowell sighs, as if recognizing a familiar tune. “What amazes me is not that there are assertions like this, but that there is no interest in checking those assertions against any evidence,” he says. “One of the things I try to do in the book is to distinguish between what might be the legacy of slavery, and what’s the legacy of the welfare state. If you look at the first 100 years after slavery, black communities were a lot safer. People were a lot more decent. But then you look 30 years after the 1960s revolution, and you see this palpable retrogression—of which I think the key one is the growth of the single-parent family.”

Mr. Sowell says he cannot remember ever hearing a gunshot when he was growing up in Harlem, and he used to sleep on the fire escape to beat the summer heat. He cites changes in black enrollment at New York City’s highly competitive Stuyvesant High School, which he attended. “In 2012, blacks were 1.2% of the students at Stuyvesant,” he says. “Thirty-three years earlier, they were 12%.”

Here’s the point: Does anyone believe that racism and the legacy of slavery are stronger today than in the 1970s—or for that matter in 1945, when Mr. Sowell enrolled at Stuyvesant? “It’s not a question of the disproportion between blacks and whites, or Asians, but the disproportion between blacks of today and blacks of the previous generation,” he says. “And that’s what’s scary.”

He offers another statistic: “For every year from 1994 to the present, black married couples have had a poverty rate in single digits,” Mr. Sowell says. “Those people who have not followed the culture—the ghetto culture—are doing fine.”

I think the takeaway here is that good intentions are not enough. The policies you support really need to effect the changes you want them to without their unwanted secondary effects overwhelming their intended effects.

9 comments

Top-Notch Performances in Top Grade Movies

This morning my wife and I were chatting about which American actors and actresses have given top-notch performances in top grade movies for five consecutive decades. The list is amazingly small and mostly from the studio era. Among actors there were

Henry Fonda (1930s-1980s)
Burt Lancaster (1940s-1980s)
Fredric March1 (1920s-1960s)
Paul Newman (1950s-1990s)
James Stewart (1930s-1970s)
John Wayne (1930s-1970s)

and among actresses there were

Ingrid Bergman2 (1930s-1970s)
Joan Crawford (1920s-1960s)
Bette Davis3 (1930s-1980s)
Katharine Hepburn (1930s-1980s)
Meryl Streep (1970s-2010s and counting)
Joanne Woodward4 (1950s-1990s)

Lillian Gish, astonishingly, gave outstanding performances in every decade from the nineteen teens to the 1980s except the 1930s so she doesn’t make the list. Jimmy Cagney made no movies in the 1970s. Tom Hanks may make the club yet—his first top-notch performance was in the 1980s. Whether Susan Sarandon makes the list or not depends on what you think of the performances she turned in during the 2000s (I don’t think any of them were top-notch).

Have we missed anybody? The criteria again are a) top-notch performances; b) top grade movies; c) five consecutive decades.

1I’m giving Fredric March the benefit of the doubt here. Jealousy, an early sound effort, is no longer extant but by all accounts it was a fine movie and March’s performance was excellent.
2Depending on whether you consider her an American actress or not.
3Depending on what you think of Death on the Nile and her performance in it.
4Depending on what you think of The Glass Menagerie.

7 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The announcement post at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments

What Did I Do to Deserve This?

Picture it. After four years of a Donald Trump presidency, Kim Kardashian becomes First Lady. It’s a sign of the end times!

I know that democracy is the system of government in which the people know what they want and and deserve to get it—good and hard. But nobody deserves this.

16 comments

Welcome to Bizarro World

Does this New York Times headline bother you as much as it does me? Here’s the headline: “Exodus of Syrians Highlights Political Failure of the West”. And here’s the supporting squib:

“The migrant crisis in Europe is essentially self-inflicted,” said Lina Khatib, a research associate at the University of London and until recently the head of the Carnegie Middle East Center in Beirut. “Had European countries sought serious solutions to political conflicts like the one in Syria, and dedicated enough time and resources to humanitarian assistance abroad, Europe would not be in this position today.”

Got it? Nobody in the Middle East is ever responsible for anything. How patronizing can you possibly be?

Quite to the contrary I think the flood of refugees highlights the extraordinary political and economic success of the West while the desire of so many people in the Middle East to flee highlights their abject political and economic failure.

Meanwhile, Russia appears to be expanding its military commitment to Syria:

The numbers are small, but Moscow may be looking at its own version of mission creep in the treacherous Middle East.
The end of summer. It means back-to-school shopping, tearfully ended beach-borne romances, Labor Day barbecues—and, it would seem, the increased likelihood of new Russian adventurism. As if Moscow weren’t satisfied with the game in Ukraine, the last month has seen a flurry of reports about its ever-expanding military involvement in Syria.

One report has even alleged that Russian pilots are gearing up to fly missions alongside the Syrian air force, dropping bombs not just on ISIS but on anti-Assad rebels who may or may not be aligned with the United States or its regional allies.

There have been several good posts on this subject at Pat Lang’s place. The Russians aren’t that nuts about Assad but they’re really unwilling to lose their last remaining ally in the Middle East. Call it the “post-Qaddafi syndrome”. And Assad was never going to leave power peaceably. Dictators of his stripe never have retirement plans.

8 comments

Hillary Clinton Looks Better

when seen in the rear view mirror than she does when looming ahead. At least that’s what I take away from her most recent favorable/unfavorable ratings from Gallup:

WASHINGTON, D.C. — Dogged by continued scrutiny of her email practices as secretary of state, Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton’s favorability with the American public has sunk to one of its lowest levels in Gallup’s 23-year trend. Currently, 41% of U.S. adults say they have a favorable opinion of the Democratic front-runner, while 51% hold an unfavorable view.

The graph attached to the post is interesting. She hasn’t had this low a favorable rating since 1993.

3 comments

Measuring the Dollars and Cents Worth of College

After a dozen or so paragraphs of throat-clearing John Cassidy finally gets to the point:

During the past decade or so, however, a number of things have happened that don’t easily mesh with that theory. If college graduates remain in short supply, their wages should still be rising. But they aren’t. In 2001, according to the Economic Policy Institute*, a liberal think tank in Washington, workers with undergraduate degrees (but not graduate degrees) earned, on average, $30.05 an hour; last year, they earned $29.55 an hour. Other sources show even more dramatic falls. “Between 2001 and 2013, the average wage of workers with a bachelor’s degree declined 10.3 percent, and the average wage of those with an associate’s degree declined 11.1 percent,” the New York Fed reported in its study. Wages have been falling most steeply of all among newly minted college graduates. And jobless rates have been rising. In 2007, 5.5 per cent of college graduates under the age of twenty-five were out of work. Today, the figure is close to nine per cent. If getting a bachelor’s degree is meant to guarantee entry to an arena in which jobs are plentiful and wages rise steadily, the education system has been failing for some time.

And, while college graduates are still doing a lot better than nongraduates, some studies show that the earnings gap has stopped growing. The figures need careful parsing. If you lump college graduates in with people with advanced degrees, the picture looks brighter. But almost all the recent gains have gone to folks with graduate degrees. “The four-year-degree premium has remained flat over the past decade,” the Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland reported. And one of the main reasons it went up in the first place wasn’t that college graduates were enjoying significantly higher wages. It was that the earnings of nongraduates were falling.

My view, as should be clear by now, is that the signalling effect of a college degree has been the most important factor in the college pay differential and the influx of so many college graduates over the period of the last thirty years has resulted in that effect becoming increasingly attenuated. Now it’s on to post-graduate degrees and when that no longer serves a signalling function it will be post docs. As Mr. Cassidy points out, in an arms race the only ones who really benefit are the arms dealers.

0 comments