Reacting to Tragedy

I wanted to say a few words on President Obama’s reaction to the shootings in Oregon yesterday. I view them more as a cri de coeur than as a policy prescription. I can understand how those who are radicalized with respect to gun ownership could have seen them as an attack.

As far as policies go, based on what we know now from published accounts, what could have prevented the deaths from happening? Just off the top of my head I can think of three or four, none of them constitutional. It makes me wonder what President Obama meant by “commonsense reforms”?

Much as I hate to credit it, the only prescription I’ve seen that would meet constitutional muster and might have prevented the tragedy is the one from the Second Amendment absolutists: open carry.

In conclusion I’m glad I’m not faced with being expected to respond to every news story as President Obama is. Sometimes just being sad and having no other opinion is about all I can come up with.

13 comments

Kimberley Strassel’s Checklist

Hot on the heels of my Q&A on Hillary Clinton’s emails, Kimberley Strassel has a closely related post. Here’s a snippet:

All you really need to know at this point is this: Pretty much every claim Mrs. Clinton made at her initial March news conference, and since then, is false. In the spirit of keeping it simple, here’s the Complete Busy Person’s Guide to the Clinton Email Scandal. Stick it on the fridge.

It’s much more negative than mine was.

I honestly don’t see how a fair-minded person could contend that there is absolutely no scandal here.

4 comments

Another Precinct Heard From

And the editors of the Wall Street Journal are on the same page as David Ignatius:

Mr. Obama could make Mr. Putin pay a price if he reversed his Middle East policy and revived American leadership. In Syria the U.S. could set up a no-fly zone to create a haven for refugees against Islamic State and Mr. Assad’s barrel bombs. He could say U.S. planes will fly wherever they want, and if one is attacked the U.S. will respond in kind.

In Iraq the U.S. could directly arm the Kurds. And the U.S. could rev up the campaign against Islamic State from more than 11 or so strike sorties a day. This would show a new commitment that might convince the Sunni Arabs that the U.S. is finally serious about defeating the caliphate.

By now we know Mr. Obama will do none of this. He wants America out of the Middle East, so he will gradually find a way to accommodate Russia’s presence in the Middle East and Mr. Putin’s demands. U.S. allies in the region will get the message and make their accommodations with Russia and Iran. The next President will inherit a bigger terror threat and diminished U.S. influence, if not worse.

Does that sound like a call to war to you? It does to me. The reason that Putin has moved fighters into the Syrian theater is because he has anticipated the possibility of a U. S.-created “no-fly zone”. It’s an unambiguous message to the U. S. to do no such thing. Arming the Kurds is a very good way of provoking our notional allies, the Turks. In support of whom in Syria? Al Qaeda? DAESH? I think the Kurds have been very much over-sold in this country but that’s a subject for another post.

Has everyone lost their ever-loving minds?

2 comments

Everything In One Sentence

I wanted to take note of a single sentence in David Ignatius’s Washington Post column on Russia’s increasing involvement in Syria:

Putin embodies a kind of muscular diplomacy the United States disdained over the past three years of halfhearted attempts to train and equip the Syrian opposition. Obama’s failure to develop a coherent strategy left the field open for Putin.

because it illustrates everything that’s wrong with the Washington prevailing wisdom, of which Mr. Ignatius is the haruspex. There are several assumptions bundled into the sentence, first, that there is a coherent interventionist policy for the U. S. in Syria. It also assumes something else: that Russia has entered the lists in Syria solely because of a vacuum produced by U. S. inaction. Neither of those is true.

The first is not true because the choice in Syria is between the Assad government and radical Islamists. However much the Administration might wish there were liberal democrats in Syria just waiting for their opportunity to form a a government there isn’t one. There’s the more-or-less secularist Alawite government of Assad and his regime, there’s Al Qaeda and groups affiliated with them, and there’s DAESH and groups affiliated with them. That’s it. All are bad choices, inconsistent with American interests or values but, sadly, the Assad government is probably the best of the lot. Given how awful that regime is that’s not something any American president is likely to admit.

But as we have seen in Iraq DAESH would be even worse. Iraq was ethnically and religiously diverse with Arabs, Kurds, Chaldeans, Assyrians, Muslims, Christians, and Yezidis, just to name a few of the many groups that have called the country “home”. DAESH is changing that in the areas it controls. No one other than Sunni Arabs is safe in those areas and those are only safe as long as they adhere to a particularly harsh and antiquated form of Islam.

And do I really need to remind anyone that Al Qaeda was responsible for the most deadly terrorist attack on U. S. soil in history? I see no circumstances under which supporting Al Qaeda is in our interests.

But the second is even more absurd. Syria is in Russia’s neighborhood. Sevastopol is about 750 miles from Damascus—roughly the distance between New York City and Atlanta. The travel time is 33 hours overland. Russia is much more threatened by violent radical Islamism than we are. It has about three times as many Muslims as we do and some are very radicalized. Indeed, the Boston Marathon bombers were Chechens and there are many Chechens fighting the Assad government in Syria. They have good reason to believe that what happens in Syria won’t stay in Syria.

Far from needing a more muscular or interventionist policy in Syria, the U. S. needs a less interventionist policy in Syria. We shouldn’t be supporting radical Islamists under any circumstances. Actual U. S> military intervention means risking a direct confrontation between the United States and Russia. Do I really need to remind anyone that Russia is the only country other than the United States able to bring life on earth to an end? Direct confrontation with Russia would be foolhardy in the extreme.

The best thing we can do right now in Syria is maintain a low profile.

4 comments

Lead, Follow, etc.

Meanwhile, the editors of The Economist are upset with President Obama:

TO HEAR Vladimir Putin, Russia has become the leader of a new global war on terrorism. By contrast Barack Obama seems wearier by the day with the wars in the Muslim world that America has been fighting for more than a decade. On September 30th Russian jets went into action to support Bashar al-Assad’s beleaguered troops. It is setting up an intelligence-sharing network with Iraq and Iran. The Russian Orthodox church talks of holy war. Mr Putin’s claim to be fighting Islamic State (IS) is questionable at best. The evidence of Russia’s first day of bombing is that it attacked other Sunni rebels, including some supported by America. Even if this is little more than political theatre, Russia is making its biggest move in the Middle East, hitherto America’s domain, since the Soviet Union was evicted in the 1970s.

In Afghanistan, meanwhile, America’s campaign against the Taliban has suffered a blow. On September 28th Taliban rebels captured the northern town of Kunduz—the first provincial capital to fall to them since they were evicted from power in 2001. Afghan troops retook the centre three days later. But even if they establish full control, the attack was a humiliation.

Both Kunduz and Russia’s bombing are symptoms of the same phenomenon: the vacuum created by Barack Obama’s attempt to stand back from the wars of the Muslim world.

Syria is in Russia’s backyard not ours. They are more at risk from violent radical Islamists than we are. They have vital interests at stake and we are, inexplicably, assisting Al Qaeda.

As George Patton said, lead, follow, or get the hell out of the way. We should pick one. We’re trying for “all of the above”.

8 comments

The Options in Afghanistan

I am astonished that after fifteen years the editors of the New York Times have not realized the truth about Afghanistan:

One cannot help but feel horror and déjà vu as the battle over the northern Afghan city of Kunduz unfolds. On Monday, the Taliban seized the city, the first provincial capital to fall to the militants since they were routed by the United States in the war after September 2001.

On Wednesday, American warplanes were back conducting airstrikes, while Special Operations Forces were on the ground helping the Afghan government’s struggling security forces reclaim Kunduz. But Afghan troops were blocked by the Taliban from even reaching the besieged city, while the security of the nearby capital of Baghlan Province appeared under threat.

Afghanistan will never be able to defend itself. There will always be a hazard of violent radical Islamists taking over provincial capitols or the whole country for that matter. That was true in 2002 and it’s true now.

It has a GDP of about $20 billion, a population of about 30 million and, consequently, a per capita GDP of around $670. That’s half that of Pakistan, a very poor country, and 15% of that in Iran. Its border is around 3,500 miles long. With an army of 200,000 that’s about six soldier per mile. It can’t even afford the military it has let alone a larger one.

Its literacy rate is so low it can’t staff an officer corps let alone non-coms.

None of these things are new. They were true when we invaded; they’ll be true if we remain in Afghanistan for another 20 years. In 2001 our workable alternatives were:

  1. Let Afghanistan be Afghanistan, complete with training camps for Al Qaeda or, today, DAESH. Bomb the training camps every once in a while so they know we’re still looking.
  2. Invade the country and be prepared to stay indefinitely. Invading the country, replacing its government with one more to our liking, training our replacements, and then boogying out has always been a fantasy.
  3. Bomb the country until there’s nothing worth blowing up. If something worth blowing up shows up, bomb that, too.

Doing nothing and #3 were both politically impossible in 2001 and #2 has always been politically impossible. We only had one workable alternative and we didn’t take it. Now we’ve wasted hundreds of billions (or trillions) of dollars, thousands of lives, and 15 years.

4 comments

Why Healthcare Reform Is Hard

Back in the mists of the distant past, 2009 to be exact, I posted endlessly on how important healthcare reform was and why getting it right the first time was crucial. Charles Lane’s latest column illustrates some of the reasons that I think that. In the article he complains about Hillary Clinton’s latest proposal to abandon the tax on “Cadillac plans”:

The tax, set to take effect in 2018, is a key component of President Obama’s health-care plan and its most effective means of controlling health-care costs. Without it, Obamacare becomes one more entitlement program facing ever-rising health-care costs that the country will eventually be unable to afford. Ms. Clinton said she would find ways to make up the revenue the tax would generate, but that would not repair the principal damage. She also would have to find alternate ways to control health-care costs, and that seems unlikely. As the Huffington Post’s Jonathan Cohn wrote , “The Congressional Budget Office made it clear that, without something like the Cadillac tax, the health care law was unlikely to reduce health care spending.”

To understand why, you have to understand that health benefits are a form of employee compensation that the federal government doesn’t tax: The government subsidizes employer-provided health insurance, in other words, but not wages. This encourages firms to compensate people in health plans instead of in dollars, and the resulting distortion tends to irrationally push up health-care spending.

IMO the best way to explain Sec. Clinton’s proposal is that it’s constituent service. The two groups most likely to be subject to the tax are people in the top decile of income earners and union members, both groups Sec. Clinton needs to secure the nomination let alone the presidency.

The history of healthcare reform in the United States is one of fits and starts. About once a generation we’ll engage in major healthcare reform. The process is so painful, frustrating, and unsatisfying that it takes about a generation to recover. The model of continuous improvement (one of the underlying assumptions of the PPACA) has not been our experience and runs counter to the preferences of the Congress let alone the people.

What we have is Cheshire Cat policy. Little by little everything disappears until nothing is left but the smile. Dump the taxes, mandates, and penalties. Keep the subsidies.

The real problem is that what we need is not marginal, incremental reform but basic structural reform, something nobody wants to do.

4 comments

If the World Goes Into Recession, Will We?

Robert Samuelson considers whether a recession in the “emerging economices” will push the United States into recession, too:

“We’ve had a huge plunge in emerging-market growth,” says Nariman Behravesh, chief economist for the consulting firm IHS. By IHS’s estimates, economic growth in these countries has dropped by about half, from 7.4 percent in 2010 to 3.8 percent in 2015. Some countries have simply lost speed; China declined from 10 percent in 2010 to less than 7 percent this year, according to many estimates. Other countries have suffered recessions. Brazil’s economy, which grew more than 7 percent in 2010, is expected to shrink 3 percent this year.

As a result, prices of raw materials — conspicuously, oil — have dropped sharply. Some global industries have surplus production capacity, and emerging-market imports are well below expectations. The fallout has already affected the U.S. economy. Caterpillar recently announced as many as 10,000 layoffs through 2018, because demand for the company’s earth-moving equipment — heavily used in mining operations — has been soft. And the Federal Reserve recently cited global uncertainty as one reason for not increasing U.S. interest rates.

Still, many economists doubt that the emerging-market debacle will squash the U.S. recovery. “The U.S. consumer and the housing market are big driving forces,” says Behravesh. U.S. exports to emerging-market countries are only about 4 percent of the economy (gross domestic product). Any loss of exports can be overwhelmed by higher consumer spending, which is nearly 70 percent of GDP. And Behravesh thinks consumer spending will remain solid for many reasons: strong job growth (around 200,000 a month); low interest rates (households’ interest payments as a share of disposable income are the lowest since the mid-1980s); and low gasoline prices.

It has been 76 months since the end of the last recession. The longest expansions of the post-war period have been the expansion that ended in December 1969 (106 months), the expansion that ended in July 1990 (92 months), the expansion that ended in March 2001 (120 months), and this one. All of those expansions were significantly more robust than this one has been by nearly every metric and most expansions have been much shorter.

I think the smart money would bet on a recession sooner rather than later. If the Republicans are very, very lucky, it will begin soon. If they’re very, very unlucky, a Republican will be elected president in 2016 and a recession will start in 2017.

12 comments

Russia Begins Air Strikes

The BBC is reporting that Russian planes have begun to carry out air strikes against opponents of the Syrian government:

Russia has begun carrying out air strikes in Syria against opponents of President Bashar al-Assad.

The strikes reportedly hit rebel-controlled areas of Homs and Hama provinces, causing casualties.
The US says it was informed an hour before they took place.

Russian defence officials say aircraft targeted the Islamic State group, but an unnamed US official told Reuters that so far they did not appear to be targeting IS-held territory.

Reportedly the Russians have also cautioned the U. S. against flying within Syrian air space. If we’re not very, very careful, this could be the way that World War III begins.

The Russians have been asked for their assistance by the Syrian government. By what authority is the U. S. bombing targets in northern Syria?

Update

That’s the spirit:

The United States said it would continue to lead coalition airstrikes against Islamic State targets in Syria, ignoring Russia’s request for U.S. aircraft to avoid Syrian airspace as Russia began conducting bombing there Wednesday.

U.S. State Department spokesman John Kirby said a Russian official in Baghdad had given U.S. Embassy personnel notice earlier in the morning of the planned strikes in Syria against Islamic State targets.

“The U.S.-led coalition will continue to fly missions over Iraq and Syria as planned and in support of our international mission to degrade and destroy ISIL,” Kirby said, using an acronym for the Islamic State group.

Don’t let those Russkis push us around! If we shot down one of their planes (purely by accident of course) or they shot down one of ours, it would be all in good fun, wouldn’t it? Wouldn’t it.

13 comments

Too Soon Old, Too Late Smart

Here’s a bit of not unexpected but nonetheless distressing news from Deutsche-Welle:

There are no official statistics, but aid organizations, social workers and volunteers note that ethnic, social, cultural and religious tensions are on the rise in Germany’s overcrowded refugee shelters.

Separating refugees according to religion is now being mentioned as an interim solution to help alleviate the problems.

Who could possibly have predicted it? This is the quote that caught my eye:

Overcrowding isn’t the main issue anyway, Jacob argued – it’s merely the trigger: “People bring with them the conflicts that exist in their native countries, Christians and Muslims, Kurds and extremists, Shiites and Sunnis – they don’t leave them behind at the border.” These conflicts erupt when the refugees – often traumatized – are forced to live close together, he added.

Another question raised in the article: how does Germany accept Muslims without accepting Islamists? I’ll answer it for them: they can’t.

4 comments