Voting and the Technological Treadmill

My main reaction to this Washington Post editorial on the sorry state of voting machines in the United States is that I wonder where the editors think the money for this expense will come from? Speaking for my city and state, there isn’t enough money to pay for the commitments we’ve already made let alone for buying new voting machines every ten years.

For most of the history of this country written ballots were the norm. Our romance with the voting machine didn’t really catch fire until the introduction of the Votomatic in 1965. The demand for going to something other than punched card voting was sparked by the debacle of the 2000 presidential election (“dangling chads”, anyone?).

However, there’s an unforeseen problem. A Votomatic machine could be maintained indefinitely—that’s the nature of electro-mechanical devices. As long as the parts are available and you replace the part every so often, you can keep them running. Today’s fully electronic, computerized voting machines are based on what I think of as “ephemeral technology”. There’s a sort of planned obsolescence. They’re dependent on components that will stop being made sooner rather than later so their life expectancy is a lot shorter than the old electro-mechanicals. In using fully electronic, computerized voting machines, state and local boards of election have mounted the technological treadmill that’s familiar to just about any business owner.

I honestly don’t know how any jurisdiction that doesn’t print its own money can expect to stay on that technological treadmill for their voting machines.

Some states have adopted Internet voting. I’m pretty sure I know how that would work out in Chicago. Not only would the dead never leave the voting rolls, they’d all have cellphones.

0 comments

Right On What?

Indefatigable in their advocacy for World War III, the editors of the Washington Post commend Hillary Clinton for disagreeing with the Obama Administration on the Syria policy she helped to craft:

What of Mr. Obama’s claim that proposals like Ms. Clinton’s are “mumbo jumbo” and “half-baked”? It’s worth considering the recent congressional testimony of retired Gen. David Petraeus, who like Ms. Clinton first advanced his ideas from inside the administration. The creation of enclaves in Syria “protected by coalition air power,” he said, was not only feasible but also essential to the political solution Mr. Obama says he is seeking for Syria.

“If there is to be any hope of a political settlement, a certain military and security context is required — and that context will not materialize on its own,” Mr. Petraeus said. “We and our partners need to facilitate it.” What’s needed is the creation of a formidable moderate Sunni force that can act as a counter both to the Islamic State and to the Syrian regime of Bashar al-Assad. That in return requires territory that is safe from aerial attacks.

Unicorns. More unicorns! We must have unicorns. The most moderate state in Syria that can reasonably be foreseen in Syria will be ruled by Bashar al-Assad and/or his Alawite regime. Why are we supporting the more extreme, anti-modern, and illiberal opposition?

Unless I’m mistaken “coalition” referred to consists of France and the U. S. with, maybe, a little tacit assistance from Turkey. France’s ability to continue operations over a protracted period is limited. IMO we should just be suitably grateful for the Russians’ help rather than working against them.

The Russians in the air and the Syria Army on the ground should be a formidable enough combination to rid Syria of jihadi extremists. And by “jihadi extremists” I mean all of them. I suspect the Russians are willing to let Allah do the sorting.

3 comments

Explaining the Low Real Interest Rates

In a lengthy Washington Post op-ed Lawrence Summers gives a good college try to explaining low real interest rates:

●First, increases in inequality — the share of income going to capital and corporate retained earnings — raise the propensity to save.

●Second, an expectation that growth will slow due to a smaller labor force growth and slower productivity growth reduces investment and boosts the incentives to save.

●Third, increased friction in financial intermediation caused by more extensive regulation and increased uncertainty discourages investment.

●Fourth, reductions in the price of capital goods and in the quantity of physical capital needed to operate a business — think of Facebook having more than five times the market value of General Motors.

If there is an increased propensity to save, I wonder how it’s being manifest? The St. Louis Federal Reserve doesn’t report it:

Maybe Dr. Summers sees saving somewhere else.

I’d buy the third one. That we have more extensive regulation and increased uncertainty is obvious. I wonder how you’d go about quantifying those?

His fourth explanation is particularly interesting. Doesn’t that also militate against his proposals for infrastructure spending to spur economic growth? I.e. there just isn’t as much multiplier as there used to be.

And in this paragraph he makes an argument I’ve been making here for years:

What is needed now is something equivalent but on a global scale — a signal that the authorities recognize that secular stagnation, and its spread to the world, is the dominant risk we face. After last Friday’s dismal U.S. jobs report, the Fed must recognize what should already have been clear: that the risks to the U.S. economy are two-sided. Rates will be increased only if there are clear and direct signs of inflation or of financial euphoria breaking out. The Fed must also state its readiness to help prevent global financial fragility from leading to a global recession.

The way I have usually phrased it is that the tools that were effective in nudging the domestic economy just aren’t as effective under globalization. Here’s something “on a global scale”: how about China and Germany abandon their mercantilist policies? If the two of them started importing a couple of hundred billion more, that would probably have some real impact.

Indeed, I think we’re likely to see phlegmatic growth here as long as China, Germany, and Japan maintain mercantilist policies. “Beggar thy neighbor” policies are dandy until you’ve actually beggared your neighbor. Then they’re problematic.

5 comments

She Was For It Before She Was Against It

Well, that was quick. Contrary to Ruth Marcus’s prediction which I commented on earlier, Hillary Clinton has come out against the Trans-Pacific Partnership agreement with alacrity:

Just days after the U.S. and 11 nations released a monumental trade deal that still faces a fight in Congress, Hillary Clinton says she does not support the Trans-Pacific Partnership. Speaking with Judy Woodruff Wednesday, the Democratic presidential candidate said that as of today, given what she knows of the deal, it does not meet her bar for creating jobs, raising wages for Americans and advancing national security.

Speaking at Cornell College in Mount Vernon, Iowa, as part of a two-day swing through the leadoff caucus state, Clinton said that she’s worried “about currency manipulation not being part of the agreement” and that “pharmaceutical companies may have gotten more benefits and patients fewer.”

“As of today, I am not in favor of what I have learned about it,” Clinton said, later adding, “I don’t believe it’s going to meet the high bar I have set.”

If you recall Ms. Marcus made two predictions: that Hillary Clinton would drag her decision out but that she would ultimately oppose the deal. She got the opposition to the deal right but the timing wrong.

Presumably, Sec. Clinton has a better notion of what’s in the agreement than you, I, or the average senator hanging around the street corner. Her opposition is going to make it much easier for Democrats to vote against it. Who are they going to aggravate? The sitting president or (possibly) the next president? I won’t go quite as far as to say that she’s driven a nail into the TPP’s coffin but it’s the next thing to it. I suspect that if it passes at all it will be on the basis of Republican votes. The question now is just how committed corporatist Republicans are to the deal.

What to do, what to do? Approve the deal on its merits (whatever they are) or give the president a poke in the eye? Maybe the Congressional leadership can figure out a way to do both.

11 comments

The First Last Step

Iran’s Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei has forbidden further talks with the United States. So much for the idea that the arms deal negotiated by the Obama Administration with Iran was the first of many steps that would lead to a normalization of relations with the Islamic Republic.

Maybe he’s just kidding. Playing hard to get.

0 comments

What Does Harvard’s Admissions Department Select For?

Guess who beat Harvard? Members of the Bard’s Prison Initiative presently incarcerated at the New York Eastern Correctional Facility beat the Harvard College Debating Union team in an intercollegiate debating competition. The author of the article explains the victory in two ways. First, the prisoners weren’t stupid:

But it’s also worth pointing out the fallacy of our underlying assumptions about such a match-up — the first (and most pernicious) being that if a definitive link between criminality and below-average intelligence exists, nobody has found it.

and, second, the prisoners worked very hard.

I think there’s another fallacy at work here: that we can assume that Harvard’s team were smart and skilled because they’re attending Harvard. I think that we can assume that the Harvard students possess whatever qualities Harvard’s admissions department are selecting for. What are those qualities? We can’t be sure because Harvard doesn’t publicize its admission’s department’s criteria.

The Harvard students were probably smart enough and were no doubt skilled debaters. I doubt that they possessed acumen, something handy in a debate and the prisoners apparently had it. IMO the primary criteria that Harvard selects for are future potential earning power and connections, neither of which are particularly helpful in a debate.

The prisoners have beaten University of Vermont and West Point, too, although West Point won a rematch.

15 comments

Not Every Award Is Deserved

With the Nobel Prize Award announcements in full swing, here’s an amusing post from RealClearScience on the awards that have been bestowed for discoveries that were later disproven.

0 comments

Her Calculation on the TPP Agreement

Hillary Clinton hasn’t given her opinion of the Trans-Pacific Partnership agreement yet. Although she supported it while Secretary of State that’s no guarantee she’ll support it now. The one thing I think we should agree on is that wherever she eventually lands on it, it will be calculated. Ruth Marcus makes a prediction:

History suggests she will duck. And also that, after much hemming and hawing on Clinton’s part; after pundits like me pouncing on her evasiveness and inconsistency; after incessant pounding from interest groups and activists, Clinton will end up opposing the deal.

That would be the worst of all worlds — which is, all too often, exactly where Clinton finds herself.

Ms. Marcus herself is an enthusiastic supporter of the agreement. I might be, too, if I knew what was in it. I won’t support a trade agreement for the sake of a trade agreement or because the president supports it. I’ll make my evaluation on the merits which illustrates why I’m not a politician.

0 comments

Herding Cats

When asked if he were a member of an organized political party, Will Rogers responded no, he was a Democrat. Some things never change. The goings on surrounding the Republican contest for presidential nominee and even Speaker of the House have revealed multiple fissures within the Republican caucus so it’s easy to forget the large number of factions within the Democratic Party. Recently, in describing those factions to a Republican friend I identified three: progressives, the group I call “machine Democrats” or, occasionally, “party Democrats”, and reformers. To be sure there are overlaps among these groups but there are differences as well.

In a post of City Journal, Fred Siegel muses over the divisions within the Democratic Party that may make it difficult for the party to hold the White House in 2016:

The Democrats have ongoing strengths. The party has shown considerable unity even in the face of landslide losses in the 2014 midterms. On a wide variety of issues, however, the Democratic base finds itself at odds with the country’s so-called “swing” voters. This poses a problem for Democrats in 2016. On issues as varied as crime, environmentalism, late-term abortion, illegal immigration, free trade, and the Iran nuclear deal, serious splits exist among self-identified Democrats. The base’s leftward shift on these issues has party moderates shaking their heads.

The Democrats are deeply dependent on black votes. “African-American voters,” explains The Cook Political Report, “accounted for Obama’s entire margin of victory in seven states: Florida, Maryland, Michigan, Nevada, Ohio, Pennsylvania and Virginia. Without these states’ 112 electoral votes, Obama would have lost decisively.” With Obama on the ballot, black voter participation exceeded white voter participation in 2012. The great fear among Democratic Party operatives in 2016 is that African-Americans will stay home.

There are similar issues with organized labor, environmentalists, and Jews, just to name three of the components of what is thought of as the “Democratic base”.

As I’ve said before if Hillary Clinton is the Democrats’ candidate, the election may as well be held today—she has nearly 100% name recognition and just about everyone has already made of their minds about her. The great question is turnout. What the Republicans need to be wary about is nominating a candidate that mobilizes the Democratic base more than he or she does their own.

0 comments

Emanuel’s Tax Plan

If you’re at all curious about the sizeable property tax hike (the largest in the city’s history) that Mayor Emanuel hopes to us to avoid restructuring the way Chicago’s government operates, here’s a pretty fair summary from Rich Miller:

We have a whole lot of nothing going on these days. For instance, a minor fuss was made recently at the Statehouse when a city of Chicago honcho showed up to testify about Mayor Rahm Emanuel’s property tax proposal without having actual written legislation to talk about.

But, in reality, that thing ain’t going anywhere.

So far, the governor is opposed to the plan, which would exempt homeowners with houses appraised at $250,000 or less from Emanuel’s massive property tax hike. The main burden would fall on commercial property owners and Rauner has said their opposition is valid and that everyone’s property taxes should be capped at current levels—despite Chicago’s horrific fiscal problems.

As long as Rauner remains opposed, it’s highly unlikely that the House could pass such a bill. The House Democrats have not yet convinced the Republicans to break with their party’s governor on anything, and they’re surely not going to do so over a vote for Chicago, and it’s doubtful that all Downstate and suburban Democrats will go along without some relief for their own taxpayers.

The city is simply going to have to find another way to solve its problem unless and until the governor and the legislative leaders work things out. Which may be never at the rate they’re going.

The city doesn’t have the authority to impose the tax without a by your leave from the state. And the Democrats in the state legislature don’t love either Chicago or Rahm Emanuel enough to fall on their swords to save it or him.

0 comments