Getting There

I think that John Kasich is right on the policy but wrong on the politics:

If we want to get serious about economic growth, we need less government and more “us.” We need to take our money, power and influence from Washington and bring it back to the states and communities where we live. That is the federalism the Founding Fathers intended for us, and in the first 100 days of my administration, I will seek votes in Congress to restore it.

As the punchline of the old joke has it, “you cahn’t get they-ah from he-ah”. Centralizing money and power in Washington lowers the transaction cost for those who want their views to prevail regardless of their merits. Centralization provides superior opportunities for graft.

A dispirited public thoroughly discouraged with government rather than attentive to local government is so much better for that.

1 comment

Baby Steps in Syria Policy

What I’m afraid that David Ignatius, the haruspex of the DC prevailing wisdom, does not yet understand:

U.S. military commanders are now recommending a “Syria first” strategy that relies on the Kurdish fighters and a smaller Arab force to move gradually toward the Islamic State’s capital of Raqqa, just 25 miles south of the Kurds’ forward positions. The decisive battle for Raqqa could come in the spring. The stalemated campaign in Iraq and other parts of Syria probably would be left for later.

is that the Kurds in Syria have no interest in advancing on Raqqa. They’re fighting to defend their homes not for a free Syria.

Oh, well. Baby steps. Perhaps by the time that spring rolls around the Syrian, Russian, Iranian, and apparently Cuban forces now engaged in an offensive to consolidate the areas in the northwest of Syria and return them to government control will have unseated DAESH from Raqqa.

Perhaps the prevailing Washington wisdom will eventually come, as some have to the realization that there was never a workable path to a free Syria and that the available choices have always been the Assad regime or radical Islamists. We should not be supporting radical Islamists. Better to support no one.

2 comments

Why Does the “Drone Campaign” Exist?

You know, as the facts on the “drone campaign” being waged in Afghanistan, Pakistan, Yemen, Somalia, and other places by the Obama Administration dribble out, I think they’re going to substantiate the position I’ve taken here and eviscerate the administration’s articulated position.

IMO the use of drones for targeted killings has been immoral and ineffectual. Not merely a crime but a mistake.

For most of its supporters the administration’s policies are not defended because they’re defensible but because they’re the administration’s policies.

1 comment

Running Against Your Own Record

What this Wall Street Journal editorial highlights is just how difficult it’s going to be for Democrats to avoid running against Barack Obama’s record:

Look past the pro forma Republican bashing, and Tuesday’s message is stark: After nearly seven years of Barack Obama in the White House, America’s working families are struggling in an economy with fewer good jobs, stagnant paychecks, growing inequality and a system that rewards billionaires while hard-working Average Joes are left behind.

And this is the Democratic talking point. If Republicans want to make the case against Obamanomics, they can start by quoting Democrats.

That Hillary Clinton isn’t being driven from the stage by disgruntled Democrats is a token of a) just how mindlessly partisan we’ve become and b) just how mindless full stop the Republicans have become.

There comes a point at which a president owns the decisions he or, perhaps someday, she has made. For me with respect to Barack Obama that point was about five years ago. He chose to withdraw from Iraq, to remove Qaddafi in Libya, and to increase the operational tempo in Afghanistan. He’s choosing to leave troops in Afghanistan. George W. Bush didn’t force him to do it. He chose to turn his attention away from the economy and towards healthcare insurance. George W. Bush didn’t force him to do it.

13 comments

The Rectifying of Names, Part IV

Let’s start this post by trying to define “meaning”, a daunting task since thousands of volumes have probably been written on the subject over the last 400 years. Think of a word as being like a bag and its meaning as the contents of the bag. If you overfill it, the bag will burst and become useless.

I think that some confusion has arisen over what the words “objective reality” mean. If you can see it, hear it, smell it, taste it, or kick it, it’s objective reality. In general for us and in most cases, whether it’s red, loud, rank, sweet, or hard are subjective. There are things (like gravity) that don’t fit into the definition but they’re real, too. If you don’t believe me, jump off your front porch. You’ll come to the same conclusion. Yes, I’m over-simplifying.

How you feel about something, however strongly that might be is not “objective reality” Neither are my, your, or anybody else’s motives. They’re real enough all right but they’re completely subjective. Thinking of them as objective is like over-filling the bag.

You can quibble about all sorts of things like the imperfection of our senses or of language or about how our experiences of reality are mediated by our interpretations of reality but it’s pretty difficult to avoid over-filling the bag that way. Pretty soon you end up denying the possibility of communication and that flies in the face of our everyday experience. You might find that philosophically satisfying but it’s just not how we live our lives. When you’re run over by a car while crossing the street, you’re just as dead however imperfect our senses or language are. And if we’re going to communicate we need to limit the “objective reality” bag to things that are, well, objective and real.

So, if you start a sentence with an invocation of objective reality and then launch into a diatribe on somebody’s motives or virtue, tread carefully. Your views might be real but they’re not objective.

0 comments

Am I Blue?

Since its focus this week was on Chicago and the failure of its “Blue Model”, as Walter Russell Mead has characterized the Fordist pattern of social organization under which a co-op of a few large companies, large labor unions, and the guiding hand of centralized government planning, fueled by debt and taxation, controls the working of society and the economy, I didn’t want to let George Will’s latest column go by without comment. Mr. Will remarks:

During the past 84 years, the growth of the public sector has been mostly driven by the alliance between elected politicians and public-sector unions. This has made Chicago emblematic of the coast-to-coast crisis of what Walter Russell Mead has labeled the “blue model” of municipal and state governance.

It is not Emanuel’s fault that Chicago’s three largest employers, after the federal government, are the public school system, the city government and Cook County’s government. Although Emanuel is a product of the Chicago politics that made Barack Obama, the crisis brought on by such politics now requires Emanuel to take many measures to make Chicago an exception to the nation’s economic lethargy under Obama.

There is one thing that is definitely Rahm Emanuel’s fault. When he took office in 2011, Chicago’s bond credit rating was A3. During his tenure it has inexorably dropped until it’s not given junk status. That is costing the city money. If he took the steps he’s taking now four years ago, it would have saved the city millions in interest payments. His call—his fault.

He’s certain to be rewarded by his banker cronies. It’s the citizens of Chicago who’ll pay the costs.

The video above is the incomparable Ethel Waters who introduced the standard, “Am I Blue?” in 1929. This is the hit record she made back then, nearly 90 years ago. That’s just about the last time that Chicago had a Republican mayor.

4 comments

The Prospects for the PPACA

Well, one thing’s for sure. From this Wall Street Journal editorial we can reasonably infer that the editors of the WSJ don’t care much for the PPACA. If you can take their figures at face value, the PPACA’s prospects don’t look particularly good:

As Exhibit A, note that participation on the federal and state insurance exchanges is badly trailing the original projections and declining over time. About 11.7 million people joined ObamaCare during the open sign-up period last year. But enrollment this summer slipped 15% to 9.9 million with “effectuated” coverage, meaning enrollees who were up to date on their nominal share of the premium after subsidies.

and I concur with their observation that it will be difficult for the PPACA to reach the CBO’s projected goals:

Some churn is inevitable, but the Congressional Budget Office estimated two years ago that some 13 million would participate in 2015, and its most recent revision in March of this year still pegged the figure at 11 million. The CBO nonetheless now projects ObamaCare will more than double in size in 2016 to 21 million, and such a growth spurt is probably necessary to stabilize the insurance markets.

especially considering that as of this year funds for outreach are drying up. IMO that was one of the many defects in the PPACA’s architecture. A reasonable assumption is that you get the low-hanging fruit first, i.e. it will be increasingly difficult to get higher participation over time. Releasing most of the money ear-marked for encouraging people to sign up for healthcare insurance in the earliest years of the plan may have goosed the initial numbers a bit but at best it was a qualified success. Now what? If spending hundreds of millions trying to talk reluctant people into enrolling didn’t accomplish the task, how successful will spending less be?

But this is actually pretty distressing:

In a new working paper, Wharton economists Mark Pauly, Adam Levine and Scott Harrington estimate how much better or worse off the non-poor uninsured are under ObamaCare. They measure the cost of the plans, the benefits of consuming pre-paid medical care and out-of-pocket payments without obtaining coverage. They conclude that, “even under the most optimistic assumptions,” half of the formerly uninsured take on both a higher financial burden and lower welfare, and on net “average welfare for the uninsured population would be estimated to decline after the ACA if all members of that population obtained coverage.”

In other words, ObamaCare harms the people it is supposed to help.

The editorial continues by cataloguing the failures of the insurance co-ops.

As I’ve been saying since before 2009, the challenge we face is in decreasing what we spend for healthcare while maintaining a reasonable level of public health. The prospects for doing that using the strategies of the PPACA were dubious enough. The prospects for accomplishing that task with the notionally market-based reforms as, for example, in Jeb Bush’s recently outlined replacement plan are non-existent.

Supporters of the PPACA have contended that the plan was the first step in reforming our healthcare system. I have believed that history will record it as a well-intended misstep.

5 comments

What Are You Trying to Accomplish?

This post at ThinkProgress on making a carbon tax progressive very nearly had me convinced. I commend it to your attention, particularly for the eye-catching graphic near the bottom of the post illustrating the effects of the alternatives they consider. If I had more time, I’d sample it.

As I mulled their proposals over, it occurred to me that they’re relying on a trompe l’oeil. The reason that suspension of the payroll tax isn’t as effective as their preferred alternative (writing a monthly check to everyone) is that the poorest don’t pay FICA because they don’t have jobs. In addition cash incomes don’t tell the whole story. When you take benefits into account, it tips the scale towards eliminating FICA a bit except for two groups: people under 25 who aren’t head of household and people with no fixed abodes. Their preferred program will have difficulty reaching the latter group.

There’s another, more basic problem with their proposal. What are they trying to accomplish? Presumably, a carbon tax would be intended to reduce carbon emissions. It only will accomplish that if it influences behavior and it will only influence behavior if the burden of the tax is allowed to fall on someone.

I agree with this claim from the post:

The wealthiest Americans contribute the most to carbon pollution, and yet the poor suffer the brunt of the impacts. Low-income families are more likely to live near crowded highways and dirty power plants, and they are also the least equipped to deal with loss and damage from severe weather or shocks to the food system.

but I don’t think that the author of the post realizes just how much the “wealthiest Americans contribute”. If my calculations are correct, emissions increase geometrically with income rather than linearly. In other words somebody with twice the median income doesn’t just contribute twice as much. He or she may contribute four times as much. Or ten times as much. My WAG is that the top 10% of income earners are probably responsible for 80% of the carbon emissions that aren’t borne by all of us corporately (e.g. how do you account for the military’s carbon emissions?). Just as an example a single flight from Los Angeles to Paris in a private jet emits more carbon than the average American does in a year. That’s not something the lowest quintile of income earners does at all but it’s something that the top .1% of income earners does frequently.

The political reality is that we’re not going to impose a carbon tax that’s draconian enough to influence Bill Gates’s behavior. Or your doctor’s or a vice president at GE’s. If we impose a carbon tax at all, its burden will fall mostly on the lowest 90% of income earners. And if we remove the burden from the lowest 20% of income earners, we reduce the effect of such a tax to the point that it’s having very little if any effect other than the income effects. That’s the sort of result that makes some people question whether progressives are trying to solve problems, e.g. carbon emissions, or trying to create a client class.

I think the bottom line is that while it’s theoretically possible to make a carbon tax progressive if it is to have much effect it shouldn’t be. Which is how I’ve arrived at my opinion which is that we’re better off finding ways to remove the carbon from the atmosphere than we are at relying on pseudo-market strategies for which the unforeseen and unwanted secondary effects outweigh the intended effects.

6 comments

Our Not-So-Excellent Libyan Adventure

Here’s a sobering assessment of Libya after the overthrow of Qaddafi: “Life under Gadhafi was much better than it is now.”

8 comments

Is This the Beginning of the End?

You know, I think that Will Hutton may have a point. We may really be coming to the end of the Mad Tea Party:

The emergence of a global banking system means central banks are much less able to monitor and control what is going on. And because few countries now limit capital flows, in part because they want access to potential credit, cash generated out of nothing can be lent in countries where the economic prospects look superficially good. This provokes floods of credit, rather like the movements of refugees.

The false boom that follows seems to justify the lending. Property prices rise. Companies and households grow overconfident about their prospects and borrow freely. Economies surge well above their trend growth rates and all seems well until something – a collapse in property or commodity prices – unravels the whole process. The money floods out as quickly as it flooded in, leaving bust banks and governments desperately picking up the pieces.

The collapse of the real estate bubble in the United States was followed by a similar crisis in the United Kingdom was followed by a similar crisis in the European Union which has finally spread to China and the other major “emerging economies”.

China’s banks are, in effect, bust: few of the vast loans they have made can ever be repaid, so they cannot now lend at the rate needed to sustain China’s once super-high but illusory growth rates. China’s real growth is now below that of the Mao years: the economic crisis will spawn a crisis of legitimacy for the deeply corrupt communist party. Commodity prices have crashed.

Money is flooding out of the EMEs, leaving overborrowed companies, indebted households and stricken banks, but EMEs do not have institutions such as the Federal Reserve or European Central Bank to knock up rescue packages. Yet these nations now account for more than half of global GDP. Small wonder the IMF is worried.

but “inventive responses” by which Mr. Hutton means more aggressive international banks and even greater fiscal stimulus won’t be sufficient. They can’t be. The stagnant economies of the United States and Europe and the floundering Chinese economy are simply too large.

In the final analysis and in the long term economic growth can’t be based on credit. That is after all what Keynes taught. His strategy was strictly a short term proposition in which aggregate demand was made to meet aggregate production. No excess aggregate production no stimulus. A growing economy must be based on increased production. You cannot base a healthy economy on trading hats.

14 comments